Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992 IV
And from there we are off on the steamroller to equations 16 & 17, which Mozina has elevated to the status of holy mantra in the struggle against the dark side of plasma physics, the evil Darth-Priest (may the lines-of-force be with you) and his "magnetic reconnection magic". Never mind that Mozina cannot read mathematics (he actually does not know or understand the implications of either equation), cannot read English (the authors explicitly say that the currents and monopoles are simultaneous, not one changed into the other), and cannot read physics (there is no magnetic reconnection in this paper).
You've said that twice now Tim, but RECONNECTION appears on page one {...} Why is the word RECONNECTION mention SEVERAL TIMES in the paper Tim?
Oh my, now I feel properly chastised. Why didn't I think of that? Why oh why didn't I actually read the paper and save myself the incredible embarrassment of being one-upped by
Mozina over something as obvious as the word "reconnection"? Time for me to "reassess" my campaign and ... hey ... waitaminnit ... Look what I found ...
Reference
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992
{...}
Do you see "magnetic reconnection" on that list? Which of those section titles suggests that magnetic reconnection occurs in that section?
Indeed, can you even find magnetic reconnection anywhere in the paper?
Yes, and here they all are:
Page 535 (Introduction, lower right):
"
Reconnection therefore allows a general force-free field to relax to a constant-alpha field (
Taylor, 1986;
Berger, 1984)"
Page 536 (Introduction, middle left):
"Observations show that flares occur sometimes in bipolar regions which have S-shaped polarity inversion lines. Because these regions are bipolar, the classical picture of current sheet formation, with
reconnection taking place at separatrix surfaces, cannot be used because the field topology is that of a simple arcade.
Page 536 (Introduction, lower left):
"On a smaller spatial scale, magnetic fields are observed to be concentrated at supergranular boundaries in small knots of magnetic field. To study the process of
reconnection observed there (
Martin 1990), it may be very useful to have a simple representation of the magnetic field which retains its main features"
Page 540 (Conclusion, middle right):
"The study of three-dimensional field topology with observed photospheric boundary conditions was initiated by
Gorbachev & Somov (1988), who model the observed field as a potential field created by four charges placed below the photosphere. The model supposes the
reconnection is taking place at the separator. The location of chromospheric flare ribbons computed from this model compares well with observations, giving support for this kind of modelling."
That's a complete list of all instances of the word "reconnection" in the paper. The infamous equations 16 & 17 are on page 539, right at the beginning of section 3. So where is the connection between equations 16 & 17 & magnetic reconnection? There isn't one.
Whew. That was a close call. Good thing I thought of that a long time before
Mozina did. That list now includes enough context, as it did when I originally posted it, to answer the questioning "why".
... and the ENTIRE PAPER is related to the flare events!
Well "
duh" on me, huh? That's obvious from the title of the paper: "
The properties of sources and sinks of a linear force free field". I mean, who wouldn't read that and know right off the bat that this is a paper about flare events! And just read the abstract:
Reference
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992
{...}
Here is the abstract:
"In a highly conducting plasma, the magnetic field topology determines where, for example, current sheets can form, which is of great importance as a potential coronal heating source. With the classical extrapolation of a continuous weak photospheric field, the determination of topology is in general a difficult challenge. Because of the concentration of the photospheric field at intense flux tubes in supergranulation boundaries a more realistic field representation may be a description in terms of magnetic singularities located just below the photosphere.
In this paper we analyze in detail the generalization to linear force-free fields of the standard multipole expansion for singular potential fields. Solutions are presented in spherical coordinates with the constraint that all singularities are located in the half-space z is less than 0 below the solar photospheric plane (z = 0). A great variety of solutions is shown to exist depending on two continuous and one discrete parameter. The properties of monopole and dipole solutions in particular are discussed and it is shown that isolated magnetic charges exist only in the potential limit and not in a linear force-free field."
How could anyone read that abstract and not see how obvious it is that the
entire paper is "related to flare events"? Well, OK, maybe not. But maybe it's not "the entire paper". Maybe there is a section in the paper devoted to flare events?
Reference
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992
{...}
Look at the section headings:
1 Introduction
2 Multipole expansion of a linear force-free field
2.1 Introduction
2.2 Solutions with a Toroidal/Poloidal representation
2.3 Direct solution in the case with cylindrical symmetry
2.4 General properties
3 Study of the particular case l = 0
3.1 Singularity along the negative z-Axis
3.2 Field lines
3.3 Is a single magnetic charge possible in a linear force-free field?
4 Conclusion
5 Appendix: The Chiu and Hilton Green's function
Well, OK, maybe not. So, really now, how much of "
the entire paper" is about flare events? Two of the examples of the use of the word "reconnection" include flare events.
Reference
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992
{...}
Page 536 (Introduction, middle left):
"Observations show that
flares occur sometimes in bipolar regions which have S-shaped polarity inversion lines. Because these regions are bipolar, the classical picture of current sheet formation, with reconnection taking place at separatrix surfaces, cannot be used because the field topology is that of a simple arcade.
{...}
Page 540 (Conclusion, middle right):
"The study of three-dimensional field topology with observed photospheric boundary conditions was initiated by
Gorbachev & Somov (1988), who model the observed field as a potential field created by four charges placed below the photosphere. The model supposes the reconnection is taking place at the separator.
The location of chromospheric flare ribbons computed from this model compares well with observations, giving support for this kind of modelling."
We are a bit short of "
the entire paper", so can we find "flare events" anywhere else. Yes, in the first two paragraphs of the introduction ...
Magnetic fields are the cause of most of the structure and activity in the Sun's atmosphere. They channel both mass flow and thermal flux; they store energy that is rapidly converted to electromagnetic, kinetic and thermal energy in solar eruptions; they provide the heating that leads to such a high coronal temperature. Thus an understanding of coronal magnetic fields is fundamental for understanding coronal physics
But, except in the particular case of prominences, the magnetic field can only be measured at the photospheric level. Extrapolation to the overlying levels needs a knowledge of the appropriate magnetic laws. However, the MHD equations are to complex that many simplifications are made. A quasi-static evolution is often assumed, arguing that MHD waves travel across the magnetic structure in a shorter time than the global evolution time (driven by photospheric motions).
By now any objective reader should understand that
Mozina exaggerates when he says ...
... and the ENTIRE PAPER is related to the flare events!
In fact, the entire paper is about modeling the magnetic field in unobservable regions. If we read farther into the introduction, we can find the real motivation for considering monopole fields at all ...
Observations show that flares occur sometimes in bipolar regions which have S-shaped polarity inversion lines. Because these regions are bipolar, the classical picture of current sheet formation, with reconnection taking place at separatrix surfaces, cannot be used because the topology is that of a simple magnetic arcade. On the other hand flux concentrations represent individual physical identities which have different flux linkage. Using a linear force-free field extrapolation procedure, we need to introduce an arbitrary boundary between flux of the same polarity, in order to reflect the complex topology provided by their history. To emphasize this distinct identity of each flux concentration it is useful to model them by the field of magnetic charges located below the photosphere. The flux linkage is determined by the two magnetic charges at the footpoints of a given field line. Such a procedure has been successfully used by Gorbachev & Somov (1988), with a potential field, to compute the intersection of the separatrices with the photosphere and to compare them with flare ribbon locations. A magnetic charge representation models efficiently the complex topology of a bipolar region formed by adding several flux concentrations. It has also the advantage of giving an easily computed magnetic field, an important practical aspect when one wants to determine separatrix surfaces.
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992, introduction, page 536.
Outside of the introduction, "flare events" do not appear again until the conclusion section of the paper. Here we find the closest thing to a connection between the monopole fields and reconnection or flare events:
In two-dimensional modeling of solar flares, X points are the locations of energy released by magnetic reconnection. In three dimensions the X point is generalized into a line, called a separator, which is the intersection of two surfaces called separatrices. As in two dimensions, the presence and shape of the separator is of primary importance to flare physics as well as coronal heating. The study of three-dimensional field topology with observed photospheric boundary conditions was initiated by Gorbachev & Somov (1988), who model the observed field as a potential field created by four charges placed below the photosphere. The model supposes the reconnection is taking place at the separator. The location of chromospheric flare ribbons computed from this model compares well with observations, giving support for this kind of modelling.
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992, conclusions, page 540.
By now we are in a position to arrive at some reliable conclusions. Foremost among them is this:
There is absolutely no direct connection between the monopole fields in this paper and the physical process of magnetic reconnection. The monopoles are placed in all cases
below the photosphere, and exist for no other purpose than the recreate the observed field topology in the photosphere, from which the field topology above the photosphere can be extrapolated. The monopoles do not take part in any reconnection process. They are not in fact necessary at all, and exist only to make the topology of the magnetic field easier to compute. Any claim to the contrary from
Mozina is obviously false.
What DO you think they're talking about in section 3.1 while using a MONOPOLE DEVICE to create 'magnetic charge' in equation 17?
What I think, or what you think, are not so relevant as what they authors say they were thinking when they wrote the paper. So let us start with that.
In section 2 we first consider solutions that are singular below the photospheric plane (z=0) using a toriodal/poloidal representation. We show that it generalizes the multipolar expansion of a potential field, except, surprisingly, for the case of a magnetic charge which cannot be expressed in this representation. The field of a monopole charge is then found by solving directly the force-free equation. It cannot have a charge distribution located in only one point. For example, the solution discovered has a line of magnetic charges located on the vertical axis below the singularity at the origin. We demonstrate, in section 3, that such behavior is general: an isolated magnetic charge cannot exist alone in a force-free field. The behavior of the magnetic field lines is then analysed for the simplest configurations: monopole and dipole configurations and their nonsingular counterparts.
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992, introduction, page 536.
Equations 16 & 17 are found in section 3.1 ("study of the particular case l=0"), part of section 3 as referenced above. The case l=0 is the monopole component of the multipole expansion, and it is the results of the analysis referenced above, to find the monopole configurations along the vertical axis. These monopoles are all located below the photosphere, also as directly indicated above. While they lie below the photosphere, reconnection is assumed to be taking place at the separator above the photosphere, no where near the monopoles. That's what I think they are talking about.
I'm starting to think you never actual READ the paper
Curiously, I came to precisely the same conclusion about you a long time ago. So far, I see no reason to alter my previous conclusion.
but you WILL stop claiming that Priest's source/sink paper is NOT related to "reconnection". It's ALL ABOUT IT.
By now the part where you say "
It's ALL ABOUT IT" is an obvious fairy tale unworthy of any further consideration. As for the part about me, I can't stop doing something I never started doing in the first place ...
Tim Thompson;7782115
said:
Reference
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992
{...}
Furthermore, neither equation 16 nor equation 17 has a thing to do with magnetic reconnection.
{...}
Which of those section titles suggests that magnetic reconnection occurs in that section?
Indeed, can you even find magnetic reconnection anywhere in the paper?
{...}
So where is the connection between equations 16 & 17 & magnetic reconnection? There isn't one.
Absolute crap. There is absolutely no connection of any kind, not in any way, between monopoles and magnetic field line reconnection. All of your references to "equations 16 & 17" are irrelevant horse droppings. All of your attempts to link magnetic reconnection to monopoles have failed miserably. You are embarrassing yourself.
It's not a fact, and you are "full of prunes", as my dear old grandmother used to say. Monopoles are gloriously irrelevant.
I never said that the paper was not related to magnetic reconnection. What I did say was that you can't find magnetic reconnection happening in the paper, and that happens to be a true fact. The authors talk about the location of the magnetic reconnection process, the places where it would be happening, in order to give proper context to their own work. However, you will not find the actual process of magnetic reconnection in that paper, not a single equation where magnetic reconnection is actually happening in the equation. Furthermore, I also claim that neither equation 16 nor 17 nor both together have anything to do with magnetic reconnection, and at least in any direct sense, that too is a true fact. Those two equations only describe the distant sources that generate the magnetic field topology. Only in that indirect sense could one claim that they have anything to do with magnetic reconnection. But that would be a slippery concept, since both equations could simply be replaced, in particular the monopole equation 17 could be ditched altogether, and there would be no affect on the magnetic reconnection process as long as the modeled topology of the magnetic field is not seriously altered.
Finally:
Reference
Dèmoulin & Priest, 1992
{...}
Furthermore, these equations, and this paper, are vastly overblown and exaggerated by Mozina. This trick of using magnetic charges appears in only a few papers, and they are all early in the process of describing the physics of magnetic reconnection. Its sole purpose is to play a role in multipole expansions of the magnetic field. But superior methods soon arrived and this methodology of using magnetic charges, which was even then esoteric & obscure, disappeared altogether, never to be seen again. It does not appear in any text book on plasma physics, field modeling, or magnetic reconnection that I have seen. That's why I said I didn't want to talk about this, because it is irrelevant.
irrelevant.
The current state of the physics of magnetic field modeling and magnetic reconnection does not involve any of this at all.
Now go back and look at the introduction, where we find, as I have already quoted, "
But, except in the particular case of prominences, the magnetic field can only be measured at the photospheric level. Extrapolation to the overlying levels needs a knowledge of the appropriate magnetic laws." It's all really about using the monopoles, placed below the photosphere, to model an unobservable field above the photosphere, by extrapolation from the photospheric magnetic field. Now remember me saying "
It does not appear in any text book on plasma physics, field modeling, or magnetic reconnection that I have seen." How can all of this be so critical to the physical process of magnetic reconnection if nobody ever did it again? It's not critical, it's not important, it's not even involved at all. The main reason is that we can now routinely observe & measure the magnetic fields that were previously unmeasurable. So the trick is no longer necessary; we don't need to model fields that we can measure, data and real fields can be used instead. Aside from that, we also have far better modeling tools available today, not to mention far faster & more capable computers.
This all leads to the obvious final conclusion, as I stated above: "
Furthermore, these equations, and this paper, are vastly overblown and exaggerated by Mozina."