Occupy Wall Street better defend its identity

Status
Not open for further replies.
You can't suddenly cry crocodile tears for 21 wait-staff affected by a short-term issue when you've been passionate defending the ideas that caused a recession which impacted everyone at that pay-scale in the long-term.

I have seen no such "passionate defense" of the causes of recession from Grizzly Bear. What are you referring to?
 
Not sure if this has been posted yet, and if it has been I apologize, but here's some more footage of the UC Davis protest that's being called "What really happened" by the video's uploader, who was there and took the footage:



"If you let them go we will let you leave."

"If you let them go we will continue to protest peacefully."

This was chanted to the police after protesters surrounded them.
 
Last edited:
I can't stand watching those rich white folks with their bellies full yelling like mad people.
 
What is it that you are not getting here? If I have an inalienable right to free speech then my boss can't tell me what I can or cannot say on my own free time. You can't have it both ways. Make up your mind. By your logic the inalienable right to life means the govt can't kill me but my boss can.
The way you seem to view your free speech rights, if I start spamming pointless topics on these forums, and then Randi bans me for obvious reasons, then Randi's in the wrong because I have the right to free speech. Obviously, that isn't true.
 
Anybody catch the retards on Facebook that were giving youtube lessons on how to escape the plastic ties the cops use instead of handcuffs?

Nice.
 
Yes he can, because your inalienable right to free speech has nothing at all to do with your boss.
One more time. By your logic my boss can kill me because my inalienable right to life has nothing to do with my boss, right?

You keep saying you get it, and then you demonstrate that you don't.
You keep demonstrating your inconsistency. According to you I have an *inalienable right to free speech except when I don't.

So tell me WC, what does "inalienable" mean if my boss can take it away? Can he take my life? Or is that a different kind of "inalienable"? Are you special pleading?

in·al·ien·a·ble

Adjective: Unable to be taken away from or given away by the possessor: "inalienable human rights".
 
Not sure if this has been posted yet, and if it has been I apologize, but here's some more footage of the UC Davis protest that's being called "What really happened" by the video's uploader, who was there and took the footage:



"If you let them go we will let you leave."

"If you let them go we will continue to protest peacefully."

This was chanted to the police after protesters surrounded them.
Please to explain how that justifies spraying people with pepper spray who are seated?
 
The way you seem to view your free speech rights, if I start spamming pointless topics on these forums, and then Randi bans me for obvious reasons, then Randi's in the wrong because I have the right to free speech. Obviously, that isn't true.
But that's a straw man. I'll cut you some slack because you might not have been in on the conversation.

  1. No one at JREF can tell me what to do or say when I'm not posting on JREF
  2. My boss CAN tell me what I can do or say when I'm not at work.
Do you see the difference?
 
Last edited:
But that's a straw man. I'll cut you some slack because you might not have been in on the conversation.

  1. No one at JREF can tell me to do or say when I'm not posting on JREF
  2. My boss CAN tell me what I can do or say when I'm not at work.
Do you see the difference?

No, actually, your boss cannot tell you what to say or not say when you're not at work. All your boss can do is give you your job or take it away.

And JREF could, if it wanted to, ban you from posting here based on what you said elsewhere. That is essentially no different from what your boss can do.

Do you see the difference yet between banning speech and making other things conditional on your speech?
 
So tell me WC, what does "inalienable" mean if my boss can take it away?

But your boss can't take away your right to speech. All he can take away is your job, which you don't have an inalienable right to.
 
Please to explain how that justifies spraying people with pepper spray who are seated?
Already been extensively debated and explained. Bottom line, they were chained together and pepper spray was the best way to separate them without causing injury in order to arrest them. A procedure that has been verified by law enforcement experts as the proper approach.
 
Already been extensively debated and explained. Bottom line, they were chained together and pepper spray was the best way to separate them without causing injury in order to arrest them. A procedure that has been verified by law enforcement experts as the proper approach.
You mean you've already made assertions and refused to listen to facts that don't fit your preconceived bias.

Law enforcement calls on Calif. AG to investigate UC Davis pepper spray incident

The Yolo County District Attorney’s Office and Sheriff’s Department are calling on the California attorney general to investigate police use of pepper spray on peaceful protesters at UC Davis, officials said today.

In a letter sent to California Attorney General Kamala Harris Tuesday, Yolo County District Attorney Jeff W. Reisig and Sheriff Ed Prieto wrote:
You might want to contact the Yolo County District Attorney’s Office and Sheriff’s Department. Obviously you know more about the law than they do.

Oh wait...

UC Davis police break law with pepper spray

But while there are still some today who defend the use of pepper spray on nonviolent protesters, what occurred at UC Davis couldn’t be further from legal. According to a January 2002 ruling in the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, Headwaters Forest Defense v. County of Humboldt found that “officers’ use of pepper spray on activists’ eyes and faces during peaceful … protests” that consisted of them locking arms via machine “constituted an excessive use of force.” The Court noted that before 2002, pepper spray use was “limited to controlling hostile or violent subjects” and had never been seen in use against nonviolent protesters.
You are flat out wrong. But I'm guessing the facts don't count, right?
 
You mean you've already made assertions and refused to listen to facts that don't fit your preconceived bias.
I've made assertions and backed them up with citations from experts. You?

You might want to contact the Yolo County District Attorney’s Office and Sheriff’s Department. Obviously you know more about the law than they do.
Did you even bother reading your quote? They are INVESTIGATING. If they conclude the officers broke the law or established police procedures, I'll gladly admit my reliance on the other experts was wrong.

You are flat out wrong. But I'm guessing the facts don't count, right?
Your support is flat out weak. An opinion piece by an engineering student. Really? That's your argument?
 
Man bashed by Occutards for holding up a sign they didn't like;

Friday night assault: We checked into the SPD report of a man holding a "Occupy Somewhere Else" sign who told police he was assaulted outside the Occupy Seattle camp Friday night prior to the building takeover and SWAT raid a few blocks away. Though the man declined medical attention, he was, according to police,*hit hard enough to break his glasses. The man told police he was standing outside the camp with his sign -- the full text read "Occupy Somewhere Else, Not My School" -- when a group approached him. One man told the sign-holder "I don't like your sign," the victim said, and punched him in the face three times. The victim told police he attempted to follow the group of men and women -- all described as white and having dreadlocks -- into the camp as he called 911 but that one of the group attempted to sic his pit bull on the man. The victim told police Occupiers then blocked him and said they would not let him enter SCCC's plaza. Police arrived but could not find anybody matching the suspect descriptions at the scene.

http://capitolhillseattle.com/2011/...sts-camp-status-occupy-somewhere-else-assault

This is what Tardocracy looks like.
 
I've made assertions and backed them up with citations from experts. You?
I gave links...
Did you even bother reading your quote? They are INVESTIGATING. If they conclude the officers broke the law or established police procedures, I'll gladly admit my reliance on the other experts was wrong.
Woah, hold on there buckaroo, you are claiming there IS NOTHING to investigate, remember? Let me refresh your memory.

A procedure that has been verified by law enforcement experts as the proper approach.
If you are right there is zero reason for the DA and sheriff to ask for an investigation. Had you asked for me to wait for the investigation then I wouldn't have posted this link.

But then...

Your support is flat out weak. An opinion piece by an engineering student. Really? That's your argument?
THAT'S YOUR REBUTTAL? Seriously? You couldn't bother to look up the case law?



We concluded in our prior opinion that, viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the protestors, a rational juror could conclude that the use of pepper spray against the protestors constituted excessive force and that Lewis and Philip were liable for the protestors' unconstitutional injury.
 
Please to explain how that justifies spraying people with pepper spray who are seated?

I'm not sure why you want me to justify something that, to you, is unjustifiable?

Do you agree/disagree that the protesters were breaking the law by refusing to take their tents down?
 
I'm not sure why you want me to justify something that, to you, is unjustifiable?
I can have my mind changed. In any event that's a non sequitur.

Do you agree/disagree that the protesters were breaking the law by refusing to take their tents down?
I agree they were breaking the law. That DOESN'T justify excessive use of force (see Find Law link above).
 
You might want to contact the Yolo County District Attorney’s Office and Sheriff’s Department. Obviously you know more about the law than they do.

Do you believe protesters threatening cops, after encircling them, constitutes as a peaceful assembly?

Or, please explain away these lines:

U.C. Davis Protesters said:
If you let them go we will continue to protest peacefully.

If you let them go we will let you leave.
 
Anything is justified when you break the law...

Right IDB?

Do you agree/disagree that the protesters were breaking the law by refusing to take their tents down?

protest1h.jpg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom