Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Follow this line...

Let's follow you as you run from my question about the LIGHT sources of 171A ORIGINAL images! What are they GM?

It has been concluded

By whom? A guy that isn't sure he even owns a book on the topic of plasma physics?

I refuse to discuss any RD images with you until you CORRECTLY identify and CORRECTLY describe the light sources of original images, and you CORRECTLY explain the horizon line color of an iron ion composite image!

You never cited any source when you claimed to have written and you spoke for the SDO team when you claimed that the green COLOR of the horizon was due to a MISALIGNMENT of RGB images. You wouldn't be committing FRAUD would you? Who *SPECIFICALLY* did you talk to at SDO that told you that the green color was related to MISALIGNMENT of the images?
 
Last edited:
Not all atoms in the solar atmosphere are fully ionized. There are some NON ionized particles that WILL be ionized during the process. Likewise some ions exist in the atmosphere BEFORE lightning occurs.
The atmosphere is not a conductor, the solar atmosphere is. That's all that really matters.

You're again hiding behind an equivocation fallacy that equates "dialectric breakdown' as a REQUIREMENT for a discharge when no such requirement exists. An electrical discharge can occur in a solid and NEVER ionized that solid! You're literally CHANGING the definition of electrical discharge to suit yourselves, not in the way Dungey uses the term or the way Peratt uses the term.
Nope. It is you who has been equivocating.

Dungey used the term "electrical discharge" in the same "process" of reconnection that occurs in solar flares. You don't like it. You don't want to deal with it. You therefore make up excuses to NOT deal with it.
He may have used that term. But it bares no relation to the lightning-like discharges which is what most people mean when they talk about electrical discharges.
 
Get me a published, peer reviewed paper that describes their interactions in a vacuum in terms of 'reconnection' rather than 'attraction/repulsion/flux changes'. That will NEVER happen. :(

Get me a published, peer-reviewed paper that describes how the Sun is an oblate spheroid rather than flat. That will never happen too.
 
The atmosphere is not a conductor,

Boloney. PARTS of the atmosphere are already ionized BEFORE the full breakdown occurs!

the solar atmosphere is. That's all that really matters.

That wasn't all that mattered to Birkeland, Bruce or Dungey, so why should it matter to me?

Nope. It is you who has been equivocating.

Not me. My terms and beliefs are consistent with Dungey's use of terms, Peratt's definition of a discharge *IN* plasma, and WIKI's description of RECONNECTION!

He may have used that term. But it bares no relation to the lightning-like discharges which is what most people mean when they talk about electrical discharges.

It does bear a relation. It's called MASSIVE CURRENTS! The notion they are 'unrelated' and "bear no resemblance" is false. They BOTH emit gamma rays. They BOTH emit x-rays. They BOTH generate neutron capture signatures *IN PLASMA*.

This whole conversation is surreal.
 
Let's follow you as you run from my question about the LIGHT sources of 171A ORIGINAL images! What are they GM?
What source of light is there other than the Sun?

30 seconds on NASA's site reveal two pieces of information that, by themselves, completely invalidate your claims about seeing deep into the interior of the Sun and about solid features on the surface.

1. The instrument is called the Transition Region and Coronal Explorer
2. The filter used for those images captures a temperature passband of 160,000 to 200,000,000 Kelvin

http://trace.lmsal.com/Project/Instrument/inspass.htm

Why do you ignore these simple facts? Why do you make claims that are so utterly divorced from reality?
 
Last edited:
My terms and beliefs are consistent with Dungey's use of terms,
...
I visited my university library. I looked up that paper. I downloaded it using my university access. I posted Dungey's definition of "electrical disharge" from that paper in this very thread. It has been quoted to you multiple times. You completely deny his definition yet you continue to cite him as support for yours.

This is profoundly dishonest of you. Stop it.
 
Boloney. PARTS of the atmosphere are already ionized BEFORE the full breakdown occurs!
It is still a dielectric.

That wasn't all that mattered to Birkeland, Bruce or Dungey, so why should it matter to me?
That's what differentiates a medium that can give rise to (lightning-like) electrical discharges and one that can't. If you're talking about some other idea of electrical discharge then your objections of earlier are clearly misplaced.

Not me. My terms and beliefs are consistent with Dungey's use of terms, Peratt's definition of a discharge *IN* plasma, and WIKI's description of RECONNECTION!
Nope. It is clearly you has been equivocating. You were telling us all how everybody else had it wrong by saying that electrical discharges couldn't happen in a conductor. But other people (or at least me) were talking about lightning-like discharges. Which trivially cannot happen in a conductor.

It does bear a relation. It's called MASSIVE CURRENTS! The notion they are 'unrelated' and "bear no resemblance" is false. They BOTH emit gamma rays. They BOTH emit x-rays. They BOTH generate neutron capture signatures *IN PLASMA*.
The process is completely different. This is really trivial. The aspects of a lightning strike are determined by the dielectric medium. If there is no dielectric medium present then any similarity with lightning is coincidental.

This whole conversation is surreal.
Every conversation with you is surreal Michael.
 
Let's follow you as you run from my question about the LIGHT sources of 171A ORIGINAL images! What are they GM?


The continued incivility, the irrelevance of the comment, and the dishonesty in trying to deflect the burden of proof are noted.

By whom? A guy that isn't sure he even owns a book on the topic of plasma physics?


It has been concluded that there is no objective quantitative explanation for the claim that the TRACE running difference image shows a solid/rigid/iron surface thousands of kilometers below the photosphere. That conclusion has been reached because after almost seven years of requesting a quantitative objective explanation, nobody is willing or able to provide it. As with anything in science, the conclusion is provisional. If any such explanation is ever offered, the conclusion may be amended.

I refuse to discuss any RD images with you until you CORRECTLY identify and CORRECTLY describe the light sources of original images, and you CORRECTLY explain the horizon line color of in iron ion composite image!


Until I acknowledge that an incorrect explanation is correct? That's a pretty stupid argument. But the admission of willful ignorance and the dishonesty in trying to deflect the burden of proof are again noted.

You never cited any source when you claimed to have written and you spoke for the SDO team when you claimed that the green COLOR of the horizon was due to a MISALIGNMENT of RGB images. You wouldn't be committing FRAUD would you? Who *SPECIFICALLY* did you talk to at SDO that told you that the green color was related to MISALIGNMENT of the images?


The continued incivility, the irrelevance of the comment, and the dishonesty in trying to deflect the burden of proof are noted.

So where do things stand?


It has been claimed that the SDO PR image allows us to see through 80,000 kilometers of plasma, but after almost two years since the claim was originally made, it still cannot be quantitatively or objectively supported. That's where things stand on that issue.
 
What source of light is there other than the Sun?

The outside surface of the photosphere is only 6,000 Kelvin. That surface doesn't have anything to do with these emissions.

30 seconds on NASA's site reveal two pieces of information that, by themselves, completely invalidate your claims about seeing deep into the interior of the Sun and about solid features on the surface.

1. The instrument is called the Transition Region and Coronal Explorer
2. The filter used for those images captures a temperature passband of 160,000 to 200,000,000 Kelvin

I don't doubt that claim, but it doesn't invalidate my beliefs in any way.

http://trace.lmsal.com/Project/Instrument/inspass.htm

Why do you ignore these simple facts? Why do you make claims that are so utterly divorced from reality?

The only one divorced from reality is the one claiming that electrical discharges do not and cannot occur in conductors, and reconnection is a plasma optional process. That's just nonsense.

There's no way to explain RD images until one CORRECTLY identifies the light sources, and one CORRECTLY understands WHERE that "transition region' is located in relationship to the surface of the photosphere. It's UNDER the photosphere in the SDO images!
 
Last edited:
The continued incivility, the irrelevance of the comment, and the dishonesty in trying to deflect the burden of proof are noted.

You still didn't identify the light sources, or your supposed contact at SDO. Why am I not surprised?

It has been concluded

We already know what YOU CONCLUDED and none of it is accurate, starting with you conclusion that electrical discharges do not occur in conductors. You're not even sure you own a book on MHD theory, so I therefore don't care what you've concluded about solar images. You don't have the appropriate KNOWLEDGE to even discuss the topic.
 
I don't doubt that claim, but it doesn't invalidate my beliefs in any way.
:jaw-dropp

You agree that the images are showing regions where the plasma temperature is 160,000 to 200,000,000 Kelvin, yet you insist that you see solid structures in the images. WTF is wrong with you?


There's no way to explain RD images until one CORRECTLY identifies the light sources, and one CORRECTLY understands WHERE that "transition region' is located in relationship to the surface of the photosphere. It's UNDER the photosphere in the SDO images!
:jaw-dropp

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_transition_region
 
You completely deny his definition yet you continue to cite him as support for yours.

This is profoundly dishonest of you. Stop it.

Huh? I don't "deny" any such thing! You're the one in DENIAL of the fact that electrical discharges occur in flares. That's profoundly dishonest of YOU, not me. I accept Dungey's use of the term "electrical discharge" in relationship to solar flares. You do not.
 
:jaw-dropp

You agree that the images are showing regions where the plasma temperature is 160,000 to 200,000,000 Kelvin, yet you insist that you see solid structures in the images. WTF is wrong with you?

It didn't claim to see a solid surface in the ORIGINAL images. I claimed to see "rigid surface" and "rigid features" in RD images! WTF is wrong with you?
 
Huh? I don't "deny" any such thing! You're the one in DENIAL of the fact that electrical discharges occur in flares. That's profoundly dishonest of YOU, not me. I accept Dungey's use of the term "electrical discharge" in relationship to solar flares. You do not.
No. You haven't even read that paper, because you don't have access to it, and you have completely ignored the fact that his definition of the term in that paper is completely different than yours.
 
There's no way to explain RD images until one CORRECTLY identifies the light sources, and one CORRECTLY understands WHERE that "transition region' is located in relationship to the surface of the photosphere. It's UNDER the photosphere in the SDO images!


Yet given every opportunity to support those claims, including some help by providing sample images to demonstrate them, the response is unsupported assertions and an admission of willful ignorance.

Also, just as with the photosphere having a particular definition, the transition region is defined. It is the region between the chromosphere and the corona. Its location is easily observed and easily measured. Attempting to redefine commonly understood terms in an effort to wish a sci-fi fantasy into reality is not only dishonest, it is certain to result in failure.
 
It didn't claim to see a solid surface in the ORIGINAL images. I claimed to see "rigid surface" and "rigid features" in RD images! WTF is wrong with you?
Does the temperature of the plasma change when you make a running difference image out of the original images?
 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_transition_region

The solar transition region is a region of the Sun's atmosphere, between the chromosphere and corona.

The problem with that claim is that it's not located between the chromosphere/corona boundary. The "transition region" seen in the composite SDO image is actually located UNDER the photosphere, it's not sitting at the very top of the orange ring that defines the chromosphere in that image.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom