Terrible news from Afghanistan

Do you understand what that word means? You're not just saying that because you're too dogmatic and ill-informed to back down from an argument once you've started for example?
Well, that's ironic.

So you are saying that a criminal is NOT necessarily responsible for the reasonably foreseeable results of their criminal actions?

But you cannot explain why you think this way?
Pop quiz:

1. Was 9/11 a criminal act?
2. Did Al Qaeda and Osama expect the US to come after them?
2b. Were they, in fact, trying to start a war?
3. If "Yes" to 1, was the Afghan War a reasonably forseeable consequence of 9/11?

Those are all rhetorical, by the way. Criminals aren't generally held responsible for actions others take in response to their allegedly criminal acts, and by your own logic, the Afghan war was Osama's fault.
 
Last edited:
You seem to have missed the several links throughout the past few pages pointing out that the Taliban is objectively more dangerous for the people of Afghanistan than the Taliban is. They both kill more people than the Coalition, and deliberately target civilians.

LOL, I love the use of the word "objectively" there. I already addressed all such comments when I pointed out that it is axiomatic that a criminal is responsible for all the reasonably foreseeable results of their own criminal actions. ie the US is responsible for all the deaths all the harm all the terror and injuries and so on that happened because of their war(s). Unlike your use of the word that statement really is "objective". It doesn't even rely on any evidential facts that someone could question.

In fact that's a very weak form of the axiom and I could probably remove either "criminal" or "reasonably foreseeable" but that's more of a moral philosophy type of discussion.....

Turnabout is fair play; can you consider that it might not be? Can you say "The study might not be biased?"

I don't see that such a statement serves any purpose except possibly to make you feel happier which is not something I am really into sorry. Think about what you are saying. It's like you're saying we should give SOME weight to evidence that could be wholly manipulated and fabricated because... oh well it's 50-50, right? So where would that get us? Every UFO report we'd have to say it was 50-50 chance of being right. Since there's hundreds of them then the odds they are ALL wrong is 2 to the power of hundreds right? Which is billions to one. That's the sort of flawed logic that people use all the time but skeptics are supposed to refute.

Yes the study might not be biased but we can't give that any weight. If we did then every dictator and occupier would be pumping out such polls and saying "My poll deserves to be taken seriously". After all it might not be biased.

The US government is attempting to prove its case here so let them do so. They have every reason to lie and prima facie their case is unreasonable. Generally when you invade a country and kill thousands of people the citizens of that country tend to not like you very much. If the US government wishes to present a case that general rule is violated here then they need extraordinary evidence.

And, really, the fact that you consider Hussein comparable to the Coalition is absurd. He was a tyrant, a despot, an oppressor

And he was put in power by the US and supported in power by the US over the years. In what sense is he not comparable?

Murder requires deliberately attempting to kill people with malice aforethought. Killing civilians by accident in a war is not murder.

It's not an "accident" when you do something criminal that any reasonable person could foresee will cause the "accident". Any reasonable person knows that if you start a war thousands or millions of civilians will die. And incidentally the US also murdered all the combatants not only on the Afghan side but on the US side too by the same logic.

Now you're using the British definition of murder I think. I thought that malice included being reckless in the UK? If you just don't care that what you are doing is obviously going to kill people it counts as murder still, right? If you go up to someone and shoot them in the head with no malice or intention to kill, that's still murder right? because any reasonable person can see that putting a bullet in someone's head might kill them.

But you may be correct on the exact name of the offense here, and too it likely has different names in different countries. I think it might be the war crime called "breach of the peace". In any case it is deliberately or recklessly killing people during the commission of a crime. If you want to say that's not murder then fine.

Deliberately targeting civilians, like Osama did on 9/11

There's no evidence that the 9-11 attacks (whoever did them) were deliberately attacking civilians. On the contrary the targets appear to have been chosen as military. Or do you seriously expect me to believe that Al-Qaeda or whoever figured they'd kill more civilians by bombing the pentagon than let's say a packed football stadium? or a packed tube train carrying commuters?

There is evidence that the US has deliberately targeted civilians, but not Al-Qaeda so far as I know. The tube bombing in Spain targeted civilians but was it Al-Qaeda? Al-Qaeda seem a lot more moral than the US as far as that goes, but that's just my impression and if you disagree we can discuss the evidence. However you better bring something better than what you just did. I mean seriously? Calling the pentagon a civilian target????

Flying a plane into the Twin Towers was an act of war. What do you think the US should've done, pray tell? Smacked Osama on the back of a wrist with a ruler?

Well whether it was an act of war depends on a few things and it seems that it was not. Firstly because Al-Qaeda (if it was them) are not a country. You don't declare war on a bunch of right-wing beardie weirdies living in caves. Maybe as a metaphor like the war on drugs, but not in fact.

But if you actually accept that Al-Qaeda is a country as president Bush appeared to promote them to, following 9-11, then there's another problem which is that this "war" had already been going on for years so how is that a provocation? If you are fighting a war and you hit an enemy military target isn't that the sort of thing you're supposed to do in a war?

In that view the 9-11 hijackers were regular soldiers fighting in a war against all the odds who pulled off an incredibly complex and heroic attack. They should be applauded if you're the sort of person that applauds bravery in any soldiers.

Now unprovoked attacks killing thousands do happen -- the US does that sort of thing all the time. For example when president Clinton bombed that pharmaceutical factory in the Sudan that time.

Either 9-11 was a terrorist attack in which case what should have happened is that someone should have investigated the crime and made arrests and had a trial like any other crime. Or it was an attack made during an on-going war in which case no response was necessary other than to continue the war against the country called "Al-Qaeda" (perhaps they should have found it on a map? Apparently it lies within Iraq somewhere).

Depends. Did America support terrorists who killed thousands of people?

Well duh. The US does that all the time. Here's an example that you might enjoy. President Clinton supported the IRA back when they were blowing up babies in Liverpool. But mostly when I say the US backs terrorism I mean by supplying weapons and money and training etc. For example how they backed the Afghan freedom fighters and the Taliban and Al-Qaeda. But those are just the most humorous examples. At one point I think Amnesty said the US was responsible for over 50% of all the terrorism in the world but damned if I could ever find that quote again so sorry about that.

So back to the question: do you think it would be OK if other countries invaded the US and killed thousands or millions of people there?

Do you really want us to get into WW2 comparisons here? Because that is really all it takes.

Well war was criminalised in large part as a reaction to the horrors of WW1 and WW2, so I'd say that would be very reasonable. Go ahead if you feel it helps you.

I also note that you're rather vague on whether these folks are combatants or not.

It doesn't matter. Murder of a civilian is not worse than murder of a soldier. There's no distinction. Now there's a distinction in terms of the so-called laws of war which are the other war crimes and are to do with breaching the gentleman's agreements on how to go about genocide and mass murder in a civilized manner, but there's no distinction when it comes to the ultimate crime of starting a war itself.

None of those people would even be combatants if the US hadn't started the war so to dismiss their deaths because they chose to stand and fight for their families against a vicious invader seems to put it mildly rather muddled thinking.
 
LOL, I love the use of the word "objectively" there. I already addressed all such comments when I pointed out that it is axiomatic that a criminal is responsible for all the reasonably foreseeable results of their own criminal actions.

And everyone rejects that axiom, so stop using it.
 
Did you think I was asking a trick question somehow?

The first resolution allowed the use of force against terrorism and their sponsors.

Yes you already stated your unsupported and uneducated opinion. I asked you to explain what.... oh let me just reprint it all:

What in YOUR opinion (hint: I already gave the correct answer on the previous page) is the means by which you can tell if a UN SC resolution is actually giving its permission for an invasion and not just mouthing off platitudes with no force or meaning in law?

You failed to address that key question so guess what? You get asked again. You won't get asked a third.
 
The UN SC didn't recognize the Taliban as the government of Afghanistan, they considered them part of the terrorism problem they all agreed to take action against, so the invasion and removal of the Taliban was legit.
 
Last edited:
It would be nice if you answered our questions for a change.

Do you think the USSR are responsible for all the reasonably foreseeable results of their own criminal actions when they invaded Afghanistan?
 
In what possible world are the "insurgents" not the good guys?

Not this one.

USA invaded yet another country and bombed and murdered hundreds of thousands of people which is on-going.

Which had allowed the organization responsible for the 9/11 attacks to train there, to use its territory as a safe house and refused to hand over the criminals responsible for trial.

It's a black and white case of unprovoked aggression, the use of force, a breach of the peace, a war crime under the Nuremburg principles and a violation of the UN charter.

Ummmm, no. The UN passed a number of resolutions on this (already posted in this thread). The attack was hardly unprovoked on the part of the US, was not I violation of the UN Charter. And the Nuremberg Principles were not violated.

Sorry for not commenting on this earlier but, I have been with the family and away from the computer so I missed this earlier
 
The Coalition did not fly across the world to kill civilians. It seeks to reduce harm to civilians wherever possible, but mistakes happen in a war.

Far be it from me to doubt the word of someone who is so sophisticated in their analysis that they claim the pentagon as a civilian target, but could you go over why you think the US doesn't target civilians please?

In Iraq the US killed seven digits of civilians. That sure sounds clumsy. Who knows how many civilians have died in Afghanistan?

Let's back it up a moment to avoid the emotion. Go back to first principles. How would you go about deciding if an attacker was targeting civilians, and how would you determine if they were minimizing civilian harm?

Al Qaeda started it with 911.

You do know that 9-11 wasn't even the first time that Al-Qaeda tried to blow up the twin towers don't you (if we assume it was them on 9-11)? They tried it years before. so if they'd already done the same thing years before how can 9-11 be "starting it"?

False. If a bully has been bothering a child for weeks, and teases his victim into hitting him, was he not provoked? In fact, I'd be very surprised if you could find a single dictionary that supports your claim that a provocation has to be the first event of its kind.

In other words you are claiming to be ignorant of a whole list of attacks by the US prior to 9-11? Is that correct?

The Taliban supported Osama and Al Qaeda. They actively hired Al Qaeda members as enforcers.

So? The US also supported Al-Qaeda at various times. They are all part of the same group of messed up terrorists. By that logic the US should have bombed itself. And Saudi Arabia and Pakistan. Oh well the US is bombing Pakistan now so I guess better late than never. Pakistan is an ally an the US are bombing it anyway. That's how messed up these groups are. Al-Qaeda and the US have even been on the same side SINCE Al-Qaeda "declared war" on the US (because of prior US hostilities).

I don't see how that follows. Where does the UN say a response has to be "proportional", or needs to be "on-going"?

It doesn't. The UN Charter forbids all war of any kind. But there's a limited exception for self defence in article 51. Self defence is defined as a proportional response to an on-going act. Otherwise it's either escalation (if the response exceeds proportionality) or revenge (if the attack has already ceased). But in any case Afghanistan never attacked the US so its moot.

The US acted to end a proven and known threat to its people

It did not. The attack was over by October 7th and in any case the US attacked two countries that were not behind 9-11. Incidentally the 9-11 attacks aren't what I would call "proven" or "known" even to this day an they certainly were not on October 7th.

Should the US have said "well, it's not an ongoing threat, so that's all right, then?"

Exactly. At least if the attack had been by a country which it was not of course. There's a very good reason for banning revenge attacks like that. that is how wars start. Country A complains that Country B soldiers shot and killed a soldier in a border dispute. Country A demands a revenge attack and kills two soldiers of Country B. Now Country B demands a revenge attack back as reprisals for that attack and shoots a missile which kills 3 soldiers and a civilian in an army barracks. At this point Country A says it has a right to retaliate.

You see where all that is leading right? So, yes, the UN Charter bans retaliation. That is US law and UK law, and international law.

You said it yourself; 9/11 wasn't the first time Al Qaeda had clashed with the US. Even after the war, they were still planning to strike at the US, ten years on.

Like most conflicts claims were made on both sides. I mean if you count Al-Qaeda as a country which it obviously isn't.

Nice try. When you make a claim, you present evidence. This is a skeptics' forum. Asking you to present evidence is not a sign of ignorance.

So you are one of those people who reads through a reply line by line and when you wrote that you didn't realise that I had actually answered your request for links in full?

As I recall, Afghanistan under the Taliban didn't actually give two craps about the UN.

So? You're right they didn't. They were more or less created by the US so like father like son. Is your argument that it was OK to murder thousands of innocent Afghans because the Taliban are bad people?

They also said that Bin Laden needed to be turned over to the US for the 1998 embassy bombing.

Well there was no extradition treaty between the US and Afghanistan at the time. As I recall the Taliban offered to give up Osama several times but they asked for evidence of his guilt which the US either could not or would not provide.

This is normal behaviour for extradition. In fact many times European countries refuse to hand over suspected terrorists to the US because the US is considered too barbaric under European law to treat it's prisoners humanely (because of their death penalty mostly). But sure if the US simply refused to even give any evidence nobody would extradite anyone.

Obviously the US never wanted to catch Osama. That IS OBVIOUS I hope? The US wanted to use 9-11 as a cassus belli to invade Afghanistan, a country they had been planing to invade anyway. the last thing they wanted was to have Osama given up to them so they made it impossible for the Talibs to do so.

And then again the ridiculously keystone cops attempts to capture Osama after the invasion. For that matter the very idea that any country would spend a trillion dollars to capture a suspect in a crime and then turn around as Bush did and say oh he's not that important. I really hope I am not saying anythign controversial here in pointing out that the US didn't want Osama.

Not that it is really relevant to the discussion I suppose......

Let me guess. You're going to assert that the actions of the Coalition were war crimes, because the NP says they were war crimes, but you are not going to be more specific.

I already did say exactly what the crime was and linked to the UN Charter and the Nuremberg principles (neither of which is a lefty blog) that you couldn't Google for yourself. "Crime against the peace" is the name for the ultimate war crime, the crime of starting a war.

The Taliban are war criminals.

So?
So it's "praiseworthy and honorable" to trick children into being bombers and to deliberately target civilians who have nothing to do with the Coalition?

Do you want a discussion on the morality of self defence in war time?
So the Taliban is not responsible for any of the innocents they choose to murder, and it's all the big bad Americans' fault for invading the country because this was a "reasonable consequence".

Not quite. Even a defender can be culpable if they exceed the definition of self defence by being (as I said above) disproportionate or continuing hostilities after the attack has ceased. Also even under self defence you have a duty to avoid civilian casualties where possible. At any rate it is possible for more than one person to be fully responsible for the same events. What I originally pointed out was that the US was fully responsible for all the deaths and so on. That does not mean that other parties had no guilt. But it is enough to refute all the silly statements you and others made about how the Taliban were responsible for more deaths than the invading forces.

I would argue that this was not reasonable. Attacking innocent civilians, and using kids to do so, are the actions of lunatics and fanatics, not reasonable men.

Well you say you would argue it but currently you've merely stated it. Would you like to argue it?

Also: There is something wrong with you.

I don't think you would.
 
Also even under self defence you have a duty to avoid civilian casualties where possible.

Again, for the hundredth time the Taliban target them directly. They want civilian casualties.

Far be it from me to doubt the word of someone who is so sophisticated in their analysis that they claim the pentagon as a civilian target
Tell me, who were on the plane that hit the Pentagon?
 
Last edited:
BTW David, if the Coalition is responsible for the Taliban attacks, isn't the USSR responsible for creating the Taliban to begin with? After all, there wouldn't have been any Mujahideen fighting the Soviets if they hadn't invaded Afghanistan illegally in the first place.

So by your own axiom, the USSR is 100% responsible for whatever happened after their invasion.

Well of course the Soviets reacted to prior attacks from Afghanistan by fighters armed by the US. Brzezinski admitted (bragged) about prior US involvement in an interview with a French magazine although then he took it back and/or said he was misrepresented. At any rate the US was paying Afghan fighters before the Soviet invasion.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Cyclone#Background

This sort of he-said she-said accusations are typical where two countries border each other. Of course if one nation flies thousands of miles across the world to start a war it's a rather more black and white situation.
 
At any rate the US was paying Afghan fighters before the Soviet invasion.

You're not answering my question. I'm trying to apply your axiom to Afghanistan. You never said where it stops.

Did the Soviets illegally invade Afghanistan or didn't they?

Of course if one nation flies thousands of miles across the world to start a war it's a rather more black and white situation.
So your axiom is really about who spends most gas mileage?
 
Last edited:
Al-Qaeda and the US have even been on the same side SINCE Al-Qaeda "declared war" on the US (because of prior US hostilities).

You know you're not making any sense.

Incidentally the 9-11 attacks aren't what I would call "proven" or "known" even to this day an they certainly were not on October 7th.

If you want to argue that 9/11 wasn't caused by AQ you should talk about it here, that subforum is dedicated to that sort of stuff, you'll have a fun time.
 
Criminals aren't generally held responsible for actions others take in response to their allegedly criminal acts

Oh really.

Recently, the entire nation woke up to the news that Sarah McKinley, 18, a widowed Oklahoma teen-mom shot and killed an intruder who tried to break into her home on New Year’s day. She was alone in her Blanchard, Oklahoma home around 2 p.m. December 31. when two men tried to break in; she grabbed a shotgun, called 911 and asked the dispatcher if it was alright to shoot. The dispatcher answered, “I can’t tell you that you can do that, but you do what you have to do to protect your baby.”

McKinley opened fired and killed Justin Martin, 24, one of the perpetrators; Martin was wielding a knife as he kicked his way through the door. His body was later found by the police and now Dustin Stewart 29; his accomplice has been arrested and is charged with first degree murder. The question some are asking is, why charge Stewart with murder when he did not fire the fatal shot? And why is the shooter Sarah McKinley not facing any murder charge for the killing? To answer the questions, you must understand the Felony Murder-Rule.

The Felony Murder Rule
At common law, one who is responsible for unintended death of another, during the perpetration or attempted commission of a felony, was guilty of murder.
 
The UN SC didn't recognize the Taliban as the government of Afghanistan, they considered them part of the terrorism problem they all agreed to take action against, so the invasion and removal of the Taliban was legit.

That makes even less sense that your story before. If the idea is that the Taliban AND Al-Qaeda were just hangin' out in Afghanistan then how does that justify invading Afghanistan and bombing thousands of people to death? After all Al-Qaeda were also present in the USA. They trained to fly airplanes in Florida.

You are literally making up stuff at this point.

I asked you to tell me how you think a UN SC resolution that formally allows for the use of force specifies that in a resolution (to distinguish it from a resolution that is just bs political pandering about nothing much without any force in law), and you were unable to respond. Was that (1) because you have no idea, or was it (2) because you do know but answering will be to admit that you lied this whole time?

Either way you don't look too good here.

But I already gave you three chances and I will wait for a skeptic to take up this case if any skeptic actually would ever doubt what I am saying that is. You are certainly no skeptic.
 
If the idea is that the Taliban AND Al-Qaeda were just hangin' out in Afghanistan then how does that justify invading Afghanistan and bombing thousands of people to death?

Because the Taliban ruled over Afghanistan, that's where the AQ training camps were. What's illogical about that?

After all Al-Qaeda were also present in the USA. They trained to fly airplanes in Florida.
They were no longer present in the US as of 10 AM september 11th 2001, since they were vaporized out of existence.

I asked you to tell me how you think a UN SC resolution that formally allows for the use of force specifies that in a resolution
And I told you, they allowed the use of force to suppress terrorists and their allies, which the Taliban were, and still are.

If you ask me again I will answer the same thing.
 
You're not answering my question. I'm trying to apply your axiom to Afghanistan. You never said where it stops.

It stops when events are no longer reasonably foreseeable consequences of the original criminal action.

I'd answer your question in more depth but it is apparent that you don't deserve my respect or attention because you've shown you lack the motivation to break out of your powerful prejudices on this topic and really THINK about the issues.

Sorry that sounds awfully patronising but it's true. I guess everyone has their issues where they cannot see anything but their own prejudices and Americans are essentially brainwashed from birth with this American cult of the state, or nationalism. You are trained as children to salute the flag and sing praises to the state and all that Nazi-like stuff. Really creepy but it's not your fault.

That's right isn't it? That other guy sounds British and they don't get all that nationalistic crap the same way. I mean he's biased and been subjected to a lot of propaganda but he's not utterly unreachable. He tries to make sense. He makes arguments based on what he sees as facts and logic. You don't. And I only mean on this topic I am sure you are fine on anything which isn't undermining your patriotism.

I don't know what to say.

Can you stand there and honestly tell me that you are really trying to discuss this rationally with me and really trying to think about your position?

I apologise sincerely if this comment is causing offense that is not my intent.
 
It stops when events are no longer reasonably foreseeable consequences of the original criminal action.

The Soviet Afghan war caused 2 million deaths, and caused the subsequent creation of the Taliban, you mean to tell me this wasn't foreseeable?


Sorry that sounds awfully patronising but it's true. I guess everyone has their issues where they cannot see anything but their own prejudices and Americans are essentially brainwashed from birth with this American cult of the state, or nationalism. You are trained as children to salute the flag and sing praises to the state and all that Nazi-like stuff. Really creepy but it's not your fault.
The problem is I'm not American.

Montréal is in Canada.

That's right isn't it? That other guy sounds British and they don't get all that nationalistic crap the same way.
He doesn't strike me as British.

And what country are you from? You patronize about prejudices but it looks like you are the one filled with prejudices based on nationality.

I don't know what to say.
Answer my question then.

You said the Pentagon wasn't an attack on civilians, who do you think were on flight 77 that crashed into it, civilians, military personnel, or robots?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom