You seem to have missed the several links throughout the past few pages pointing out that the Taliban is objectively more dangerous for the people of Afghanistan than the Taliban is. They both kill more people than the Coalition, and deliberately target civilians.
LOL, I love the use of the word "objectively" there. I already addressed all such comments when I pointed out that it is axiomatic that a criminal is responsible for all the reasonably foreseeable results of their own criminal actions. ie the US is responsible for all the deaths all the harm all the terror and injuries and so on that happened because of their war(s). Unlike your use of the word that statement really is "objective". It doesn't even rely on any evidential facts that someone could question.
In fact that's a very weak form of the axiom and I could probably remove either "criminal" or "reasonably foreseeable" but that's more of a moral philosophy type of discussion.....
Turnabout is fair play; can you consider that it might not be? Can you say "The study might not be biased?"
I don't see that such a statement serves any purpose except possibly to make you feel happier which is not something I am really into sorry. Think about what you are saying. It's like you're saying we should give SOME weight to evidence that could be wholly manipulated and fabricated because... oh well it's 50-50, right? So where would that get us? Every UFO report we'd have to say it was 50-50 chance of being right. Since there's hundreds of them then the odds they are ALL wrong is 2 to the power of hundreds right? Which is billions to one. That's the sort of flawed logic that people use all the time but skeptics are supposed to refute.
Yes the study might not be biased but we can't give that any weight. If we did then every dictator and occupier would be pumping out such polls and saying "My poll deserves to be taken seriously". After all it
might not be biased.
The US government is attempting to prove its case here so let them do so. They have every reason to lie and
prima facie their case is unreasonable. Generally when you invade a country and kill thousands of people the citizens of that country tend to not like you very much. If the US government wishes to present a case that general rule is violated here then they need extraordinary evidence.
And, really, the fact that you consider Hussein comparable to the Coalition is absurd. He was a tyrant, a despot, an oppressor
And he was put in power by the US and supported in power by the US over the years. In what sense is he not comparable?
Murder requires deliberately attempting to kill people with malice aforethought. Killing civilians by accident in a war is not murder.
It's not an "accident" when you do something criminal that any reasonable person could foresee will cause the "accident". Any reasonable person knows that if you start a war thousands or millions of civilians will die. And incidentally the US also murdered all the
combatants not only on the Afghan side but on the US side too by the same logic.
Now you're using the British definition of murder I think. I thought that malice included being reckless in the UK? If you just don't care that what you are doing is obviously going to kill people it counts as murder still, right? If you go up to someone and shoot them in the head with no malice or intention to kill, that's still murder right? because any reasonable person can see that putting a bullet in someone's head might kill them.
But you may be correct on the exact name of the offense here, and too it likely has different names in different countries. I think it might be the war crime called "breach of the peace". In any case it is deliberately or recklessly killing people during the commission of a crime. If you want to say that's not murder then fine.
Deliberately targeting civilians, like Osama did on 9/11
There's no evidence that the 9-11 attacks (whoever did them) were deliberately attacking civilians. On the contrary the targets appear to have been chosen as military. Or do you seriously expect me to believe that Al-Qaeda or whoever figured they'd kill more
civilians by bombing
the pentagon than let's say a packed football stadium? or a packed tube train carrying commuters?
There is evidence that the US has deliberately targeted civilians, but not Al-Qaeda so far as I know. The tube bombing in Spain targeted civilians but was it Al-Qaeda? Al-Qaeda seem a lot more moral than the US as far as that goes, but that's just my impression and if you disagree we can discuss the evidence. However you better bring something better than what you just did. I mean seriously? Calling the pentagon a civilian target????
Flying a plane into the Twin Towers was an act of war. What do you think the US should've done, pray tell? Smacked Osama on the back of a wrist with a ruler?
Well whether it was an act of war depends on a few things and it seems that it was not. Firstly because Al-Qaeda (if it was them) are not a country. You don't declare war on a bunch of right-wing beardie weirdies living in caves. Maybe as a metaphor like the war on drugs, but not in fact.
But if you actually accept that Al-Qaeda is a country as president Bush appeared to promote them to, following 9-11, then there's another problem which is that this "war" had already been going on for years so how is that a provocation? If you are fighting a war and you hit an enemy military target isn't that the sort of thing you're
supposed to do in a war?
In that view the 9-11 hijackers were regular soldiers fighting in a war against all the odds who pulled off an incredibly complex and heroic attack. They should be applauded if you're the sort of person that applauds bravery in any soldiers.
Now unprovoked attacks killing thousands do happen -- the US does that sort of thing all the time. For example when president Clinton bombed that pharmaceutical factory in the Sudan that time.
Either 9-11 was a terrorist attack in which case what should have happened is that someone should have investigated the crime and made arrests and had a trial like any other crime. Or it was an attack made during an on-going war in which case no response was necessary other than to continue the war against the country called "Al-Qaeda" (perhaps they should have found it on a map? Apparently it lies within Iraq somewhere).
Depends. Did America support terrorists who killed thousands of people?
Well duh. The US does that all the time. Here's an example that you might enjoy. President Clinton supported the IRA back when they were blowing up babies in Liverpool. But mostly when I say the US backs terrorism I mean by supplying weapons and money and training etc. For example how they backed the Afghan freedom fighters and the Taliban and Al-Qaeda. But those are just the most humorous examples. At one point I think Amnesty said the US was responsible for over 50% of all the terrorism in the world but damned if I could ever find that quote again so sorry about that.
So back to the question: do you think it would be OK if other countries invaded the US and killed thousands or millions of people there?
Do you really want us to get into WW2 comparisons here? Because that is really all it takes.
Well war was criminalised in large part as a reaction to the horrors of WW1 and WW2, so I'd say that would be very reasonable. Go ahead if you feel it helps you.
I also note that you're rather vague on whether these folks are combatants or not.
It doesn't matter. Murder of a civilian is not worse than murder of a soldier. There's no distinction. Now there's a distinction in terms of the so-called laws of war which are the other war crimes and are to do with breaching the gentleman's agreements on how to go about genocide and mass murder in a civilized manner, but there's no distinction when it comes to the ultimate crime of starting a war itself.
None of those people would even be combatants if the US hadn't started the war so to dismiss their deaths because they chose to stand and fight for their families against a vicious invader seems to put it mildly rather muddled thinking.