Illuminati,
I think you need to be a little clearer on what you are talking about.
Are you talking about the Bazant
model? Then we ought to be debating within the framework of that model. Or actually: model
s. Which Bazant paper contains the PE estimate that is under scrutiny here? That's the paper with the model we ought to be talking about.
Or are you talking about the actual, real-world collapse, that didn't conform to the assumptions and boundaries of the Bazant model and, for example, largely bypassed all columns during transition and progression?
Following up on my last sentence, you also should be clear whether there allegedly was too little energy available to
initiate collapse, to
transition from intiation to progressive phase, or for the entire
progression to finish into the basements?
If it is the latter that is contended - and many truthers do contend that the totally of destruction with all the fine pulverization cannot be explained by PE - then I would point to Gregory Urich's paper "
Analysis of the Mass and Potential Energy of World Trade Center Tower 1". He basically tallied all building materials floor by floor, estimated their mass, estimated PE floor by floor, and added up. Results:
- Total mass of one tower was 288,100 metric tons
- Total PE relative to the 1st floor was 480,600 MJ - which is equivalent to 115 tons of TNT.
(This does consider that the tower was bottom-heavy - Urich meticulously tallies all column elements from bottom to top with their dimensions as are know from blueprints. So his results are equivalent with the center of mass of the tower being not at 50% its height, as would be if mass was distributed evenly, but only slightly above 40%)
IIRC, Bazant assumed that each tower weighed 500,000 tons, and I'd tend to believe that Urich is much closer, so Bazant very probably indeed overestimates the total PE, IMO.
However, if the proposition that's being forwarded is
(1) The total PE was not sufficient to cause all the destruction
then it doesn't matter very much if Urich is closer or Bazant. It suffices to have an idea of the magnitudes we are talking about.
Here's my argument:
Let's denote the total PE as, well, "PE", and the energy expended to cause all the actual observed destruction ad "DE". Then we can express the claim (1) as follows:
(2) PE < DE
Since energy is conserved, we must convert this
inequality into an equality by adding a term for some assitional energy "AE":
(3) PE + AE = DE
.
Whoever makes claim (1) and (2) can only do so if he can
numerically estimate an upper bound for PE and a lower bound for DE. Now I submit that both energies can only be estimated with a significant amount of uncertainty. Just witness the discrepancy in estimates for the mass of the tower - 500,000 tons 74% more than 288,000 tons! (and 288 is 42% less than 500).
Let's assume that your work colleague making that proposition (1) can estimate both PE and DE with an accuracy of +/- 10% - quite an optimistic assumption, wouldn't you agree? Then his upper bound for PE is PE
est*110%, and his lower bound for DE is DE
est*90%.
In other words, in order for him to claim that the only imprecisely know value for PE is smaller than the imprecisely know value for DE, even when applying a margin of uncertainty of 10% either way, they must be different by more than about 20%.
And so we can state:
(3) PEest*110% <= DEest*90%
<=> PEest +0.1PEest + 0.1DEest <= DEest
<=> PEest +0.1(PEest+DEest) <= DEest
<=> PEest +0.1(PEest+PEest+DEest-PEest) <= DEest
<=> PEest +0.2PEest+0,1(DEest-PEest) <= DEest
Since it is claimed that DE>PE, the term 0,1(DE
est-PE
est) > 0, and 0.2PE
est+0,1(DE
est-PE
est) > PE*20%.
Let's denote the magnitude of this uncertainty then as "UE", so
(4) UE > PEest*20%
The term AE in (2) must be at least larger than this uncertainty, and so it follows that
(5) AE > PEest*20%
Now we DO have an estmated potential energy PE
est - from Urich: It's 115 "tons of TNT" - and that's probably a conservative (low) estimate. So if your colleague wants to claim that the inequality (1) is true, AND he allows for all estimates to have a range of uncertainty of at least 10%, despite which (1) remains true, then he must agree to (5) and claim that the additional energy needed to cause all the actual destruction that PE is not sufficient for is
more than 23 "tons of TNT".
This value increases if you allow for uncertainties to be larger than 10% up and down (which they certainly are), it also increases in the likely circumstance that Urich's estimate is too conservative (low). And of course you need to multiply that by 2, for both towers. Plus whatever you'd posit for WTC7
And soon you run into trouble with all the logistics problems and lack of noise and other ovbious signs of demo charges. Remember, in almost all highrise demolitions undertaken so far, total amount of explosives was under a ton, typically a few hundreds of pounds; and just witness how incredibly, awesomely loud they invariably are!