Bazant...Why is his PE calculation so wrong?

It's a very simplified model, but it's useful mainly as a limiting case. The Bazant calculations demonstrate that the buildings would have collapsed even if the detailed dynamics of the process had been the least favourable case possible to continuing collapse. Since any real collapse dynamics would be more favourable to collapse, demonstrating that the collapse would continue in the Bazant case is equivalent to demonstrating that it would continue in any case.



They're not perfect, but they're enough to demonstrate beyond reasonable doubt that collapse would be total once it started.

Dave

I like your answer in the other thread, about reducing the estimate by 40%, and even then it is more than enough PE to collapse and destroy the structure.
 
I like your answer in the other thread, about reducing the estimate by 40%, and even then it is more than enough PE to collapse and destroy the structure.

I can recommend Greening's articles on 911 Myths; you can find them here. They're not a bad starting point, although a lot more detailed study has been done since then.

Dave
 
...I suspect that a competent structural engineer would find the suggestion quite absurd...
Yes.

Remembering that we are discussing the 'collapse progression' or 'global collapse stage'.

When I first sought to satisfy myself as to the realities I quickly realised that the available forces and energies available for the actual collapse mechanism were order of magnitude overwhelming.

Since I was interested more in 'what actually happened' rather than academic abstractions the question as to whether Bazant was right for the abstract model of his limiting case assumption was of little interest for me. The big difference between the two being that Bazant leaves the columns in place and shows that they would buckle. Reality was that the columns were scarcely involved. And there is at least one order of magnitude difference in that key point.

What sort of frustrates or irritates me is the many times when people from either 'side' wrongly apply Bazantian abstractions to the real world. The extreme example of that error of thinking IMO being 'Missing Jolt'.
 
Last edited:
Illuminati,

I think you need to be a little clearer on what you are talking about.

Are you talking about the Bazant model? Then we ought to be debating within the framework of that model. Or actually: models. Which Bazant paper contains the PE estimate that is under scrutiny here? That's the paper with the model we ought to be talking about.

Or are you talking about the actual, real-world collapse, that didn't conform to the assumptions and boundaries of the Bazant model and, for example, largely bypassed all columns during transition and progression?


Following up on my last sentence, you also should be clear whether there allegedly was too little energy available to initiate collapse, to transition from intiation to progressive phase, or for the entire progression to finish into the basements?



If it is the latter that is contended - and many truthers do contend that the totally of destruction with all the fine pulverization cannot be explained by PE - then I would point to Gregory Urich's paper "Analysis of the Mass and Potential Energy of World Trade Center Tower 1". He basically tallied all building materials floor by floor, estimated their mass, estimated PE floor by floor, and added up. Results:
  • Total mass of one tower was 288,100 metric tons
  • Total PE relative to the 1st floor was 480,600 MJ - which is equivalent to 115 tons of TNT.
(This does consider that the tower was bottom-heavy - Urich meticulously tallies all column elements from bottom to top with their dimensions as are know from blueprints. So his results are equivalent with the center of mass of the tower being not at 50% its height, as would be if mass was distributed evenly, but only slightly above 40%)

IIRC, Bazant assumed that each tower weighed 500,000 tons, and I'd tend to believe that Urich is much closer, so Bazant very probably indeed overestimates the total PE, IMO.

However, if the proposition that's being forwarded is
(1) The total PE was not sufficient to cause all the destruction​
then it doesn't matter very much if Urich is closer or Bazant. It suffices to have an idea of the magnitudes we are talking about.

Here's my argument:

Let's denote the total PE as, well, "PE", and the energy expended to cause all the actual observed destruction ad "DE". Then we can express the claim (1) as follows:
(2) PE < DE​
Since energy is conserved, we must convert this inequality into an equality by adding a term for some assitional energy "AE":
(3) PE + AE = DE​
.

Whoever makes claim (1) and (2) can only do so if he can numerically estimate an upper bound for PE and a lower bound for DE. Now I submit that both energies can only be estimated with a significant amount of uncertainty. Just witness the discrepancy in estimates for the mass of the tower - 500,000 tons 74% more than 288,000 tons! (and 288 is 42% less than 500).

Let's assume that your work colleague making that proposition (1) can estimate both PE and DE with an accuracy of +/- 10% - quite an optimistic assumption, wouldn't you agree? Then his upper bound for PE is PEest*110%, and his lower bound for DE is DEest*90%.

In other words, in order for him to claim that the only imprecisely know value for PE is smaller than the imprecisely know value for DE, even when applying a margin of uncertainty of 10% either way, they must be different by more than about 20%.

And so we can state:

(3) PEest*110% <= DEest*90%
<=> PEest +0.1PEest + 0.1DEest <= DEest
<=> PEest +0.1(PEest+DEest) <= DEest
<=> PEest +0.1(PEest+PEest+DEest-PEest) <= DEest
<=> PEest +0.2PEest+0,1(DEest-PEest) <= DEest​
Since it is claimed that DE>PE, the term 0,1(DEest-PEest) > 0, and 0.2PEest+0,1(DEest-PEest) > PE*20%.

Let's denote the magnitude of this uncertainty then as "UE", so
(4) UE > PEest*20%​
The term AE in (2) must be at least larger than this uncertainty, and so it follows that
(5) AE > PEest*20%​

Now we DO have an estmated potential energy PEest - from Urich: It's 115 "tons of TNT" - and that's probably a conservative (low) estimate. So if your colleague wants to claim that the inequality (1) is true, AND he allows for all estimates to have a range of uncertainty of at least 10%, despite which (1) remains true, then he must agree to (5) and claim that the additional energy needed to cause all the actual destruction that PE is not sufficient for is more than 23 "tons of TNT".

This value increases if you allow for uncertainties to be larger than 10% up and down (which they certainly are), it also increases in the likely circumstance that Urich's estimate is too conservative (low). And of course you need to multiply that by 2, for both towers. Plus whatever you'd posit for WTC7


And soon you run into trouble with all the logistics problems and lack of noise and other ovbious signs of demo charges. Remember, in almost all highrise demolitions undertaken so far, total amount of explosives was under a ton, typically a few hundreds of pounds; and just witness how incredibly, awesomely loud they invariably are!
 
Remember, in almost all highrise demolitions undertaken so far, total amount of explosives was under a ton, typically a few hundreds of pounds; and just witness how incredibly, awesomely loud they invariably are!

A couple of extreme data points from here: the Seattle Kingdome, the largest structure ever demolished using explosives, required 4,700lb of explosives; and the J. L. Hudson department store, the tallest, required 2,728lb. These are tiny amounts compared to the potential energy in the structure. In fact, the strongest argument that tall buildings in general contain enough potential energy to bring about their own collapses is that they can be demolished using, relatively speaking, such small amounts of explosives.

Dave
 
Illuminati,

I think you need to be a little clearer on what you are talking about.

Are you talking about the Bazant model? Then we ought to be debating within the framework of that model. Or actually: models. Which Bazant paper contains the PE estimate that is under scrutiny here? That's the paper with the model we ought to be talking about.

Or are you talking about the actual, real-world collapse, that didn't conform to the assumptions and boundaries of the Bazant model and, for example, largely bypassed all columns during transition and progression?


Following up on my last sentence, you also should be clear whether there allegedly was too little energy available to initiate collapse, to transition from intiation to progressive phase, or for the entire progression to finish into the basements?



If it is the latter that is contended - and many truthers do contend that the totally of destruction with all the fine pulverization cannot be explained by PE - then I would point to Gregory Urich's paper "Analysis of the Mass and Potential Energy of World Trade Center Tower 1". He basically tallied all building materials floor by floor, estimated their mass, estimated PE floor by floor, and added up. Results:
  • Total mass of one tower was 288,100 metric tons
  • Total PE relative to the 1st floor was 480,600 MJ - which is equivalent to 115 tons of TNT.
(This does consider that the tower was bottom-heavy - Urich meticulously tallies all column elements from bottom to top with their dimensions as are know from blueprints. So his results are equivalent with the center of mass of the tower being not at 50% its height, as would be if mass was distributed evenly, but only slightly above 40%)

IIRC, Bazant assumed that each tower weighed 500,000 tons, and I'd tend to believe that Urich is much closer, so Bazant very probably indeed overestimates the total PE, IMO.

However, if the proposition that's being forwarded is
(1) The total PE was not sufficient to cause all the destruction​
then it doesn't matter very much if Urich is closer or Bazant. It suffices to have an idea of the magnitudes we are talking about.

Here's my argument:

Let's denote the total PE as, well, "PE", and the energy expended to cause all the actual observed destruction ad "DE". Then we can express the claim (1) as follows:
(2) PE < DE​
Since energy is conserved, we must convert this inequality into an equality by adding a term for some assitional energy "AE":
(3) PE + AE = DE​
.

Whoever makes claim (1) and (2) can only do so if he can numerically estimate an upper bound for PE and a lower bound for DE. Now I submit that both energies can only be estimated with a significant amount of uncertainty. Just witness the discrepancy in estimates for the mass of the tower - 500,000 tons 74% more than 288,000 tons! (and 288 is 42% less than 500).

Let's assume that your work colleague making that proposition (1) can estimate both PE and DE with an accuracy of +/- 10% - quite an optimistic assumption, wouldn't you agree? Then his upper bound for PE is PEest*110%, and his lower bound for DE is DEest*90%.

In other words, in order for him to claim that the only imprecisely know value for PE is smaller than the imprecisely know value for DE, even when applying a margin of uncertainty of 10% either way, they must be different by more than about 20%.

And so we can state:

(3) PEest*110% <= DEest*90%
<=> PEest +0.1PEest + 0.1DEest <= DEest
<=> PEest +0.1(PEest+DEest) <= DEest
<=> PEest +0.1(PEest+PEest+DEest-PEest) <= DEest
<=> PEest +0.2PEest+0,1(DEest-PEest) <= DEest​
Since it is claimed that DE>PE, the term 0,1(DEest-PEest) > 0, and 0.2PEest+0,1(DEest-PEest) > PE*20%.

Let's denote the magnitude of this uncertainty then as "UE", so
(4) UE > PEest*20%​
The term AE in (2) must be at least larger than this uncertainty, and so it follows that
(5) AE > PEest*20%​

Now we DO have an estmated potential energy PEest - from Urich: It's 115 "tons of TNT" - and that's probably a conservative (low) estimate. So if your colleague wants to claim that the inequality (1) is true, AND he allows for all estimates to have a range of uncertainty of at least 10%, despite which (1) remains true, then he must agree to (5) and claim that the additional energy needed to cause all the actual destruction that PE is not sufficient for is more than 23 "tons of TNT".

This value increases if you allow for uncertainties to be larger than 10% up and down (which they certainly are), it also increases in the likely circumstance that Urich's estimate is too conservative (low). And of course you need to multiply that by 2, for both towers. Plus whatever you'd posit for WTC7


And soon you run into trouble with all the logistics problems and lack of noise and other ovbious signs of demo charges. Remember, in almost all highrise demolitions undertaken so far, total amount of explosives was under a ton, typically a few hundreds of pounds; and just witness how incredibly, awesomely loud they invariably are!

Thanks for the detailed reply, yes the noise levels is a bit of a give away against CD.

Urich's estimate is better is probably closer than Bazants estimation and thats what i will use in future. I appreciate your reply.
 
Thanks for the detailed reply, yes the noise levels is a bit of a give away against CD.

Urich's estimate is better is probably closer than Bazants estimation and thats what i will use in future. I appreciate your reply.

I'd like to stress again the point that whoever claims that PE < DE must concede that the additional energy needed to conserve energy would be a significant (>20%, more realistically >50%) proportion of the PE. In the case of the entire tower, that'd be more than >25 tons of conventional explosives; in the case of just the first collapsing floor, that would be at least half a ton for the 12 floors of the north tower (plus roof and antenna) and at least 1.5 tons for the 30 floors of the south tower.

And again, please try to be clear if you (or your alleged colleagues) see the problem with the early phases of collapse, or with the total destruction.
 
...Urich's estimate is better is probably closer than Bazants estimation and thats what i will use in future. I appreciate your reply.
May I suggest that you don't limit yourself to only responding to abstract models based on energy considerations.

They are all based on models which only approximate what really happened. And, IMO 'approximate' is being very generous. ;)

The actual global collapse phase is simple to understand:
1) Three mechanisms involved;
a) Lots of falling material, initially the integral top portion of tower, dropped down the 'tube' of the open office space causing shearing off of the floor joists in a runaway scenario;
b) That left the outer perimeter columns unbraced in the 'out from the building' direction so they fell over - peeling off in sheets;
c) The top portion and debris which fell on the core landed mostly on horizontal beams and sheared them off. The columns falling in the resulting mess;

2) All of those mechanisms meant that the primary strength of the columns in axial compression was bypassed - the residual involvement of the columns merely the force to resist shearing of floor joist or beam connections - both those an order of magnitude lower than the axial load carrying strength;

3) Consequently you only need 'ball park guestimations' to demonstrate that all the forces relevant to the collapse progression were 'overwhelming';

4) And the outer perimeter columns were not failed by buckling under axial overload - visual evidence - and most likely same situation with core columns but visual evidence not readily available.

That real situation is totally at odds with the energetic solutions which are based on columns buckling in axial overload. And if you only focus on arguing energy derived explanations you will almost certainly run into reasoning which is flawed because it switches from 'abstract' to 'real' scenarios in an invalid manner.

One of the most prominent examples of misapplication of Bazantian modelling - due to the invalid mixing of bits of abstract with bits of real models, is the paper 'The Missing Jolt'. The main error in that paper IMNSHO is that it adopts the Bazant & Zhou 'limiting case' assumptions with its 'not real world' model and attempts to use that unreal model to analyse what really happened in the real world. Doomed to fail from the start.

So, the bottom lines of the two bits of advice I offer are:
1) Understand both the abstract energetic based explanations AND the actual real world mechanism of global collapse; THEN
2) Watch out for people who get them confused. Better to not mix them than to mix them and get the mix wrong. :rolleyes:
 
May I suggest that you don't limit yourself to only responding to abstract models based on energy considerations.

They are all based on models which only approximate what really happened. And, IMO 'approximate' is being very generous. ;)

The actual global collapse phase is simple to understand:
1) Three mechanisms involved;
a) Lots of falling material, initially the integral top portion of tower, dropped down the 'tube' of the open office space causing shearing off of the floor joists in a runaway scenario;
b) That left the outer perimeter columns unbraced in the 'out from the building' direction so they fell over - peeling off in sheets;
c) The top portion and debris which fell on the core landed mostly on horizontal beams and sheared them off. The columns falling in the resulting mess;

2) All of those mechanisms meant that the primary strength of the columns in axial compression was bypassed - the residual involvement of the columns merely the force to resist shearing of floor joist or beam connections - both those an order of magnitude lower than the axial load carrying strength;

3) Consequently you only need 'ball park guestimations' to demonstrate that all the forces relevant to the collapse progression were 'overwhelming';

4) And the outer perimeter columns were not failed by buckling under axial overload - visual evidence - and most likely same situation with core columns but visual evidence not readily available.

That real situation is totally at odds with the energetic solutions which are based on columns buckling in axial overload. And if you only focus on arguing energy derived explanations you will almost certainly run into reasoning which is flawed because it switches from 'abstract' to 'real' scenarios in an invalid manner.

One of the most prominent examples of misapplication of Bazantian modelling - due to the invalid mixing of bits of abstract with bits of real models, is the paper 'The Missing Jolt'. The main error in that paper IMNSHO is that it adopts the Bazant & Zhou 'limiting case' assumptions with its 'not real world' model and attempts to use that unreal model to analyse what really happened in the real world. Doomed to fail from the start.

So, the bottom lines of the two bits of advice I offer are:
1) Understand both the abstract energetic based explanations AND the actual real world mechanism of global collapse; THEN
2) Watch out for people who get them confused. Better to not mix them than to mix them and get the mix wrong. :rolleyes:

Thanks for the detailed reply, I was wondering if you could help with a question I had, I was thinking about the collapse initiation, and I am not sure where you stand, but going by the NIST side of things, the sagging floor trusses pulled on the perimeter columns and caused them to fail, my question is, I presume the perimeter columns failed at the point where they were connected to one another?
 
Thanks for the detailed reply, I was wondering if you could help with a question I had, I was thinking about the collapse initiation, and I am not sure where you stand, but going by the NIST side of things, the sagging floor trusses pulled on the perimeter columns and caused them to fail, my question is, I presume the perimeter columns failed at the point where they were connected to one another?

Those would be the splices, and it does appear that is where most (but not all) columns failed.
 
Thanks for the detailed reply, I was wondering if you could help with a question I had, I was thinking about the collapse initiation, and I am not sure where you stand, but going by the NIST side of things, the sagging floor trusses pulled on the perimeter columns and caused them to fail, my question is, I presume the perimeter columns failed at the point where they were connected to one another?
I see that Newtons Bit has already answered your main question...there is little that I can add on that point:
Those would be the splices, and it does appear that is where most (but not all) columns failed.
As for 'where I stand on NIST' from my first days of posting on Internet 9/11 matters my stance has been that I do not rely on NIST findings. The historic reason being that I saw so much confusion of objectives - discussion of the straight forward question 'Was there CD at the WTC Twin Towers?' would keep diverging into 'Was NIST's explanation correct?' I don't like unclear thinking which confuses objectives NOR deliberate trickery which uses confused objectives for tactical reasons. So I use NIST data to help me form my own conclusions but I don't rely on their reasoning. Same goes for Bazant et al who has caused more confusion on these sort of threads than all the truthers combined. (And that is lèse majesté - probably a capital offence on this forum. :o ) Being a Civil/Structural engineer with some Military Demolition training helps. Plus a long career managing engineers including those who are often seen around these discussions who get lost in details and lose the plot. Fuller explanation available if needed - I have made explanatory statements many times.

The big issue of false reasoning to watch for is a cluster of partial truths around the relationship between 'perimeter column pull in' and 'column bowing and buckling'. There are several big bits of nonsense to watch out for.

The first is the 'single factor' false assumption.
The false assumption being that the single factor of sagging floor joists pulling in the perimeter columns and causing buckling was all that was involved >>>>leading to pseudo 'proof' by geometry that sagging could not do the job.

Hogwash. There were two main factors, not one.

The basic issue to comprehend is that a column is very strong taking loads in axial compression - what it is designed to do. BUT it gets weaker quickly if the load is off centre. And, taking it further, it gets very weak if there is a bit of a bend in the column. So much that a heavily loaded column which gets kinked out of line will self destruct because the axial load which is safe on a straight and centrally loaded column is far more than the column can support once it gets our of line. 'Eccentric loading'.

So all the sagging floor joists had to do was start the bending out of vertical straight line and pretty soon the applied load will take over and complete the destruction without further help from joist sagging.

So that is the two factor basics put as simply as I can:
1) Sagging floor joists starts the inwards bowing which seriously weakens the column; THEN
2) The already applied vertical load finishes the job.

There are a couple of other bits of nonsense you will see associated with this. One is the idea that the columns needed to lose the bracing from the floor joists before they became unstable which is claimed to conflict with the need for the joists to stay connected to deliver the pull in. That one is a confusion of two separate issues which apply in different stages or different physical locations of the collapse.

Those two matters will help you deal with most of the nonsense you see from truthers. (And some of the not so careful debunkers who fall for the trickery. ;) )
 
Oz, reply to you.

Chris Mohr, you may want to read this. It contains some subtleties that I believe would greatly help one of your explanations. Specifically the canard that "for all the columns to fail simultaneously, they must have been blown." See the last couple of paragraphs.

The basic issue to comprehend is that a column is very strong taking loads in axial compression - what it is designed to do. BUT it gets weaker quickly if the load is off centre. And, taking it further, it gets very weak if there is a bit of a bend in the column. So much that a heavily loaded column which gets kinked out of line will self destruct because the axial load which is safe on a straight and centrally loaded column is far more than the column can support once it gets our of line. 'Eccentric loading'.

So all the sagging floor joists had to do was start the bending out of vertical straight line and pretty soon the applied load will take over and complete the destruction without further help from joist sagging.

So that is the two factor basics put as simply as I can:
1) Sagging floor joists starts the inwards bowing which seriously weakens the column; THEN
2) The already applied vertical load finishes the job.

I assume, from the mention of "inward bowing", that you are talking about the towers here, not WTC7.

I know that you're familiar with most of the prose below. I'm including it for both my purposes (to construct the logic completely) & for others who may struggle with a few of the concepts.

In other words, Pardon my Pedantry.

And I agree with every thing that you've said above. I'd add a bit.
__

I would encourage you to include consideration of "time constants" into the causes that you've mentioned. Meaning "the time constants over which the different effects occurred." Specifically, slow gradual change in gross geometry, and then sudden, rapid collapse initiation.

The causes of each must match the time constants seen for the towers: 1 & 2 hours slow geometry change & ~seconds for collapse initiation.

There are only two time constants that seem to me likely to be measured on the order of 20 minutes to 2 hours: a) creep and b) heating (or cooling) of large structural components.

NIST's explanation for final stages of collapse initiation (last ~20 minutes in each tower) included the uneven heating of some core columns, their thermal expansion & taking on a high percent of the load from the outer columns, the core columns' creep (i.e., shortening) at high load & moderate temperature (400 - 800°C), their cooling once fires had passed & shedding an excessive amount of load back to the outer columns, and then very sudden buckling of either:

1. perimeter columns due to excess gravitational load, or
2. core columns due to abnormal bending moments.

Note a few other things (pedantry alert..!):

1. the sag of the floors also falls into the category of creep.

2. once the floors have buckled, the floor loads turn from almost pure shear into a lateral, catenary pull. That inward pull must be transferred as bending & inward compressive loads to the composite floors above & below the sagging floor.

___

One other thing regarding time constants...

The time constant for the for collapse of the column in buckling after the critical load has been reached is highly depending on the load condition, which can be lumped into …

a) force driven: the load is increased while the compression and lateral curvature are unconstrained.

Force driven collapse happens very quickly (milliseconds to seconds) once the critical load has been reached.

b) strain driven: the compressive shortening of the column is increased while the lateral curvature & load are unconstrained, as one might get using an Instron tester.

Strain driven collapse occurs at the applied strain rate, whatever that may be.
__

For a lattice-work (i.e., 2D array) of columns PRIOR to global collapse, the load condition is essentially "strain driven". This is because, as the strain increases, even if a particular column has buckled and is capable of supporting only tiny load, other nearby columns will pick up the shed load & the column's bolted connections to the structure prevent its further collapse.

The vast majority of columns whose inward bowing was detectable from the ground had almost certainly gone way past critical buckling, were providing only a small fraction (~10%) of their designed support to the structure, but were prevented from collapsing further by their connections to other components.

[Perhaps one of the structures guys could tell us how much vertical compression would bring a 3 story outer columns to its critical buckling point. I'd guess < 2", resulting in minimal inward bowing.]

The strain rate that was applied to the buckled / buckling / about to buckle columns was determined by the slow global shift of the structure in response to the (long time constant) fires, expansion, creep, cooling, etc.

But, once the structure's global safety margin is gone (i.e., one final column buckles & the rest of the columns cannot pick up its shed load), then the load condition on the columns immediately changes from strain driven mode to load driven mode.

And it is precisely this sudden shift in load conditions that produces the "simultaneous failure of all columns" that bother truthers (& Gage) so terribly.

We've expressed this same concept in different terms before, but this is the first time that I've thought about it in terms of time constants & buckling load modes.


Tom


PS. Sorry I remind you of your sister. I hope I didn't twist your words too much, to change your meaning to match what I wanted to discuss...
 
Last edited:
Oz, reply to you.

Chris Mohr, you may want to read this. It contains some subtleties that I believe would greatly help one of your explanations. Specifically the canard that "for all the columns to fail simultaneously, they must have been blown." See the last couple of paragraphs...
tfk your post noted with interest and appreciation.

My covering disclaimer being that we should remember that my post that you respond to was written with the objective of explaining at a quite simple level for the non-engineers. (Plus those engineers who sometimes lose context through focussing on too few details. The 'forests for trees' problem. You look - I'll point. :( )

I agree it should be of interest for Chris Mohr but I think it is probably too detailed/subtle for direct inclusion in the web 're-rebuttals' Let me think about that one.

OK - down to some more specifics:
I assume, from the mention of "inward bowing", that you are talking about the towers here, not WTC7.

I know that you're familiar with most of the prose below. I'm including it for both my purposes (to construct the logic completely) & for others who may struggle with a few of the concepts.

In other words, Pardon my Pedantry.

And I agree with every thing that you've said above. I'd add a bit....
a) Agreement understood - thanks;
b) Yes I was talking about the Twin Towers;
c) Reason for detailed logic understood; AND
d) I tend to be pedantic myself when it is needed. :)

PLUS I think we need to explain 'strain' for the non-engineers - they may have a looser definition of the word.

In engineering 'strain' means 'deformation of a solid due to stress' where 'stress' for our purposes here means 'force per area'. AND that 'force' can be 'normal stress' - applied along the length of a member as 'compression' or 'tension' OR that 'force' can be 'shear stress' applied across the member. We could get more pedantic but no need. Those suffice to explain that, to an engineer, 'strain' refers to the physical change of shape of a member. It results from 'force' but is not a force per se. End of that bit of pedantry. ;)

I would encourage you to include consideration of "time constants" into the causes that you've mentioned....
Agreed for introduction into my thinking and my explanations. Valuable stuff and thank you. I may not choose to confuse non-engineers with it even though in this thread doing so should pose no risk - we have all the reasoning exposed in full view.
Meaning "the time constants over which the different effects occurred." Specifically, slow gradual change in gross geometry, and then sudden, rapid collapse initiation.

The causes of each must match the time constants seen for the towers: 1 & 2 hours slow geometry change & ~seconds for collapse initiation.

There are only two time constants that seem to me likely to be measured on the order of 20 minutes to 2 hours: a) creep and b) heating (or cooling) of large structural components.

NIST's explanation for final stages of collapse initiation (last ~20 minutes in each tower) included the uneven heating of some core columns, their thermal expansion & taking on a high percent of the load from the outer columns, the core columns' creep (i.e., shortening) at high load & moderate temperature (400 - 800°C), their cooling once fires had passed & shedding an excessive amount of load back to the outer columns,...
By paragraphs:
Yes;
Yes;
Yes; AND
Yes.

... and then very sudden buckling of either:

1. perimeter columns due to excess gravitational load, or
2. core columns due to abnormal bending moments.

Note a few other things (pedantry alert..!):

1. the sag of the floors also falls into the category of creep.

2. once the floors have buckled, the floor loads turn from almost pure shear into a lateral, catenary pull. That inward pull must be transferred as bending & inward compressive loads to the composite floors above & below the sagging floor....
Yes to all including your 'mini conclusions' which I have highlighted by bold italic. The third one is probably subject to further complications but leave it here it is for now.

...One other thing regarding time constants...

The time constant for the for collapse of the column in buckling after the critical load has been reached is highly depending on the load condition, which can be lumped into …

a) force driven: the load is increased while the compression and lateral curvature are unconstrained.

Force driven collapse happens very quickly (milliseconds to seconds) once the critical load has been reached.

b) strain driven: the compressive shortening of the column is increased while the lateral curvature & load are unconstrained, as one might get using an Instron tester.

Strain driven collapse occurs at the applied strain rate, whatever that may be.
__

For a lattice-work (i.e., 2D array) of columns PRIOR to global collapse, the load condition is essentially "strain driven". This is because, as the strain increases, even if a particular column has buckled and is capable of supporting only tiny load, other nearby columns will pick up the shed load & the column's bolted connections to the structure prevent its further collapse....
Broadly agreed - may add details after more thought. HOWEVER this was the reason why I got pedantic over the word 'strain' for benefit of the non-engineers. :o
...The vast majority of columns whose inward bowing was detectable from the ground had almost certainly gone way past critical buckling, were providing only a small fraction (~10%) of their designed support to the structure, but were prevented from collapsing further by their connections to other components....
Agreed - and 'gut feeling' says very much less that 10% ...HOWEVER:
...[Perhaps one of the structures guys could tell us how much vertical compression would bring a 3 story outer columns to its critical buckling point. I'd guess < 2", resulting in minimal inward bowing.]...
My guess was a 'couple of inches' but I was avoiding the complicated issue of where 'eccentric loading' becomes 'buckling of an already bent column'. Someone may want to do the maths for the eccentric loading 'point of failure' i.e. how eccentric the load needs to be before the column fails under 'axial load' even though 'pull-in' was more likely the principal initiating mechanism.

...The strain rate that was applied to the buckled / buckling / about to buckle columns was determined by the slow global shift of the structure in response to the (long time constant) fires, expansion, creep, cooling, etc.

But, once the structure's global safety margin is gone (i.e., one final column buckles & the rest of the columns cannot pick up its shed load), then the load condition on the columns immediately changes from strain driven mode to load driven mode.

And it is precisely this sudden shift in load conditions that produces the "simultaneous failure of all columns" that bother truthers (& Gage) so terribly....
Agreed three paragraphs.
...We've expressed this same concept in different terms before, but this is the first time that I've thought about it in terms of time constants & buckling load modes.


Tom...
Understood and, once again, thanks.
thumbup.gif


Eric C.

PS
...PS. Sorry I remind you of your sister. I hope I didn't twist your words too much, to change your meaning to match what I wanted to discuss...
Nah. You are too open and taking too many big steps at once. So it makes you far too obvious.

And these references should be meaningless to other members. :D

(My sister died about 5 years back - pancreatic cancer.)
 
Last edited:
...
[Perhaps one of the structures guys could tell us how much vertical compression would bring a 3 story outer columns to its critical buckling point. I'd guess < 2", resulting in minimal inward bowing.]
...
You are way off. Keep guessing.
 
Was there actually enough Potential energy to destroy and enable collapse of both towers?
Yes.
And if yes which paper would you cite to back this up?
Don't need a paper, the towers collapsed on 911. Two full up models, real models, collapsed because there was enough potential energy. Models are used to help explain, help understand, help design. NO model is needed since the towers really did fall due to impacts and fire.

911 truth believers have no clue what happen on 911 and can't understand models. They attack logic and reason and settle for woo, the dumbed down claptrap pushed by nuts like Gage, Balsamo and Jones et al. E=mgh is not used by 911 truth pushers of delusional lies.

What got you asking this question? Which idiot is pushing the failed claim of not enough E=mgh? Is Balsamo branching out into structural engineering after failing in flight?
 
Oz, reply to you.

Chris Mohr, you may want to read this. It contains some subtleties that I believe would greatly help one of your explanations. Specifically the canard that "for all the columns to fail simultaneously, they must have been blown." See the last couple of paragraphs.



I assume, from the mention of "inward bowing", that you are talking about the towers here, not WTC7.

I know that you're familiar with most of the prose below. I'm including it for both my purposes (to construct the logic completely) & for others who may struggle with a few of the concepts.

In other words, Pardon my Pedantry.

And I agree with every thing that you've said above. I'd add a bit.
__

I would encourage you to include consideration of "time constants" into the causes that you've mentioned. Meaning "the time constants over which the different effects occurred." Specifically, slow gradual change in gross geometry, and then sudden, rapid collapse initiation.

The causes of each must match the time constants seen for the towers: 1 & 2 hours slow geometry change & ~seconds for collapse initiation.

There are only two time constants that seem to me likely to be measured on the order of 20 minutes to 2 hours: a) creep and b) heating (or cooling) of large structural components.

NIST's explanation for final stages of collapse initiation (last ~20 minutes in each tower) included the uneven heating of some core columns, their thermal expansion & taking on a high percent of the load from the outer columns, the core columns' creep (i.e., shortening) at high load & moderate temperature (400 - 800°C), their cooling once fires had passed & shedding an excessive amount of load back to the outer columns, and then very sudden buckling of either:

1. perimeter columns due to excess gravitational load, or
2. core columns due to abnormal bending moments.

Note a few other things (pedantry alert..!):

1. the sag of the floors also falls into the category of creep.

2. once the floors have buckled, the floor loads turn from almost pure shear into a lateral, catenary pull. That inward pull must be transferred as bending & inward compressive loads to the composite floors above & below the sagging floor.

___

One other thing regarding time constants...

The time constant for the for collapse of the column in buckling after the critical load has been reached is highly depending on the load condition, which can be lumped into …

a) force driven: the load is increased while the compression and lateral curvature are unconstrained.

Force driven collapse happens very quickly (milliseconds to seconds) once the critical load has been reached.

b) strain driven: the compressive shortening of the column is increased while the lateral curvature & load are unconstrained, as one might get using an Instron tester.

Strain driven collapse occurs at the applied strain rate, whatever that may be.
__

For a lattice-work (i.e., 2D array) of columns PRIOR to global collapse, the load condition is essentially "strain driven". This is because, as the strain increases, even if a particular column has buckled and is capable of supporting only tiny load, other nearby columns will pick up the shed load & the column's bolted connections to the structure prevent its further collapse.

The vast majority of columns whose inward bowing was detectable from the ground had almost certainly gone way past critical buckling, were providing only a small fraction (~10%) of their designed support to the structure, but were prevented from collapsing further by their connections to other components.

[Perhaps one of the structures guys could tell us how much vertical compression would bring a 3 story outer columns to its critical buckling point. I'd guess < 2", resulting in minimal inward bowing.]

The strain rate that was applied to the buckled / buckling / about to buckle columns was determined by the slow global shift of the structure in response to the (long time constant) fires, expansion, creep, cooling, etc.

But, once the structure's global safety margin is gone (i.e., one final column buckles & the rest of the columns cannot pick up its shed load), then the load condition on the columns immediately changes from strain driven mode to load driven mode.

And it is precisely this sudden shift in load conditions that produces the "simultaneous failure of all columns" that bother truthers (& Gage) so terribly.

We've expressed this same concept in different terms before, but this is the first time that I've thought about it in terms of time constants & buckling load modes.


Tom


PS. Sorry I remind you of your sister. I hope I didn't twist your words too much, to change your meaning to match what I wanted to discuss...

I don't get the concept of inward bowing in split second tandem with football field length ejections of huge steel objects.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom