science fraud is common place

<snip>

1. Scientists are poor communicators. They hide behind scientific jargon so as to avoid being questioned by the general public. They mask their inability to articulate their discipline and indulge in garbled esoteric mambo jumbo to protect themselves under the disguise of science.

2. The scientific community are made up of short sighted people barely able to cope with the immediate problems and have little use for long term goals that are less sensational.

3. There is excessive fraud among the scientific community a disservice to the Corporations and Institutions that fund their research. Gross incompetence and dangerously inept unreliable research bordering on criminal negligence has raised doubts and suspicion on what was once a noble profession.

Remind me in what area of science your expertise lies.
 
That's why I like to point out that I'm a scientist. People are perfectly comfortable with accusing scientists of various things--for precisely the same reason we don't care when stormtroopers get shot. They're nameless, faceless people behind white lab-coats. Put a name and a face on them (so to speak), and suddenly those attacks become less acceptable. It's one thing to say "Scientists are evil and in cahoots with the big corporations!" It's much harder to picture Dinwar, a random forum denizen, of being that.

I am the same way, but add in the fact that I am part of the commie professors who are indoctrinating students.

To be fair, a good fraction of my colleagues are indeed very liberal, and one is pretty much a socialist. But I also have colleagues who are very conservative, one exceedingly so. We had him teach a course on the FDA last spring. Of course, he has 40 years experience in the area of drug approval and working with the FDA, so he knows more about than pretty much anyone you will find.

However, despite the number of lefty leaning faculty, the worst example I've heard of someone "indoctrinating" in class was by a guy who started each class with a prayer.

I have no doubt that my colleagues' liberal leanings are not exactly hidden in class, but it's not like they waste time going on about them. They are irrelevant to the subject material, and so they never come up. We don't have enough time to waste talking about politics.

I have a colleague in a different department who made Horowitz's book. However, that is based nothing, because if you talk to the students who take his course, they don't report anything improper or outside of the scope of the class. Horowitz just doesn't what he teaches.

I was tempted to write to Horowitz once asking him to include me in his book, because, shamefully, I did espouse an opinion on a topic that was unrelated to the content of the course. I made a comment once that was something like, "This is something you can do in-between checking out the comics in the campus newspaper," to which I added, "Speaking of that, why did they get rid of [some comic]? That was my favorite." Yes, I admit, I opined on a topic outside of the scope of the class. Write me up!

But back to the story, when people talk about lefty professors indoctrinating students, I can ask, do you think I do that? Same on the Evil Scientists. Do you think I do that? Because I am a professor (and a lefty one at that) and I am a scientist.
 
The OP and this thread are absurd. There is no human endeavor -- other the sciences -- where the accuracy of findings are more zealously scrutinized.
Indeed. Unfortunately some people dislike the fact that such scrutiny invalidates their pet theories so the attempt to denigrate the process.

Remind me in what area of science your expertise lies.
:D
 
No, I haven't. If anything, someone couuld potentially think that I was saying that I said what I was calling a lie, but I thought it was pretty clear.

You're one of the few people who've complained about my posting style in the past few years. So I'd say I'm good.

Maartenn100 has demonstrated a hopeless ignorance of the topic at hand and an unwillingness to learn the actual information, along with an inability to acurately re-state what he has been told. There's no war to fight with him. You're not much better--your main tactic in this post is to ignore everything I've said and re-state mere opinions about an activity you clearly know nothing of as if they were data!!

You've misunderstood what I said. My demand is that you present evidence that I have committed those crimes. You want to attack "scientists", and I don't want to let you hide behind such nonsense. When you say "scientists", you're talking about ME--and a host of others here on this forum. You are saying I do this. And it's perfectly acceptable for me to demand you provide evidence for these accusations, or appologize for the libel.

Some are, some aren't. I've communicated complex ideas to grade schoolers, and i've met scientists that couldn't explain an acid/base reaction to a fellow chemist. We're HUMAN; we're variable.

The rest of this point is unsupported nonsense that does not follow at all from the opening premise. As I have said, there's nothing esoteric or even particularly difficult about scientific jargon. We use it because it's very precise, and such precision is necessary in what we do. The difference between a mandibular fossa and a mandibular fenestra may be obscure and esoteric to you, but to an anatomist they are very precise terms that provide a great deal of meaning--and both would best be described as "a hole in the jaw" in the vernacular, which is imprecise and has no taxonomic or physiological value. Species names are similar--the common names merely confuse the issue, and scientists have developed a way to very precisely talk about individual groups due to the need to be able to do so in multiple fields. If you find scientific jargon difficult to comprehend, it is because you have not put the effort into learning it. NO scientist I've met has EVER advocated obscurity; in fact, they advocate clarity and easy of comprehension. The issue is that we're dealing with things English wasn't built to handle, so we've been sort of making up the terms as we go along for the past few hundred years (which is, before you say anything, not the least different from any other field).

If you're too lazy to bother to learn the jargon of the field, you don't get to criticize it for being hard to understand. The problem isn't with the scientists. It's with you, pure and simple.

Also, being a scientist I demand you substantiate your claim that I'm a poor communicator when it comes to scientific ideas. I can often fail to explain other ideas, but when it comes to my areas of expertise I seem to be doing pretty well.

Again, I deamnd you show that I'm short-sighted and barely able to cope with immediate problems. This sounds like nothing mroe than "They don't do the research I want them to in the way I want them to", a common thread among anti-science groups. This interpretation is further supported by your previous ravings concerning unintended consequences.

There is no evidence--in your links or elsewhere--that the highlighted part is true. Is there fraud? Sure. Even some high-profile cases. But as I've demonstrated, you have no idea, outside a few soundbites worth of data, what the history of science is like in regards to fraud (Owen's case for example was rather high-profile, to use gross understatement), and therefore are incapable of evaluating whether it's gone up or down, much less what the impacts would be. Furthermore, you have ignored my first-hand experience in precisely the field you say is degraded.

But I'll let you dig your own grave: Please provide a precise level of fraud that is acceptable and not "excessive". 0% is impossible; again, scientists are not some alien breed, we are human beings. No fraud is ideal, but an unreasonable demand (until you remove fraud from some other field, completely and without exception, don't expect if from science). At what point does fraud become acceptable? And--perhaps more importantly--how do arive at that number?

There might be an explanation for your defensive reaction to this OPs accusatory finger pointing at science and scientists by drawing attention to the increase in scientific fraud in the scientific community. The respondents who were quick to take offense, be offended or insulted were not surprisingly male dominated. Is there an explanation for this gender bias? Yes there is and the study below confirms my suspicions.

Study indicates that scientific fraud may have a male bias
http://blogs.scientificamerican.com...s-that-scientific-fraud-may-have-a-male-bias/
 
The respondents who were quick to take offense, be offended or insulted were not surprisingly male dominated. Is there an explanation for this gender bias?

I'm assuming you meant "mostly male", rather than implying that a particular poster was "male-dominated". And how, pray tell, are you judging our genders? Is "Dinwar" an exclusively masculine name in your culture? Are you assuming that my avatar is really what I look like?
 
No, I haven't. If anything, someone couuld potentially think that I was saying that I said what I was calling a lie, but I thought it was pretty clear.

You're one of the few people who've complained about my posting style in the past few years. So I'd say I'm good.

Maartenn100 has demonstrated a hopeless ignorance of the topic at hand and an unwillingness to learn the actual information, along with an inability to acurately re-state what he has been told. There's no war to fight with him. You're not much better--your main tactic in this post is to ignore everything I've said and re-state mere opinions about an activity you clearly know nothing of as if they were data!!

You've misunderstood what I said. My demand is that you present evidence that I have committed those crimes. You want to attack "scientists", and I don't want to let you hide behind such nonsense. When you say "scientists", you're talking about ME--and a host of others here on this forum. You are saying I do this. And it's perfectly acceptable for me to demand you provide evidence for these accusations, or appologize for the libel.

Some are, some aren't. I've communicated complex ideas to grade schoolers, and i've met scientists that couldn't explain an acid/base reaction to a fellow chemist. We're HUMAN; we're variable.

The rest of this point is unsupported nonsense that does not follow at all from the opening premise. As I have said, there's nothing esoteric or even particularly difficult about scientific jargon. We use it because it's very precise, and such precision is necessary in what we do. The difference between a mandibular fossa and a mandibular fenestra may be obscure and esoteric to you, but to an anatomist they are very precise terms that provide a great deal of meaning--and both would best be described as "a hole in the jaw" in the vernacular, which is imprecise and has no taxonomic or physiological value. Species names are similar--the common names merely confuse the issue, and scientists have developed a way to very precisely talk about individual groups due to the need to be able to do so in multiple fields. If you find scientific jargon difficult to comprehend, it is because you have not put the effort into learning it. NO scientist I've met has EVER advocated obscurity; in fact, they advocate clarity and easy of comprehension. The issue is that we're dealing with things English wasn't built to handle, so we've been sort of making up the terms as we go along for the past few hundred years (which is, before you say anything, not the least different from any other field).

If you're too lazy to bother to learn the jargon of the field, you don't get to criticize it for being hard to understand. The problem isn't with the scientists. It's with you, pure and simple.

Also, being a scientist I demand you substantiate your claim that I'm a poor communicator when it comes to scientific ideas. I can often fail to explain other ideas, but when it comes to my areas of expertise I seem to be doing pretty well.

Again, I deamnd you show that I'm short-sighted and barely able to cope with immediate problems. This sounds like nothing mroe than "They don't do the research I want them to in the way I want them to", a common thread among anti-science groups. This interpretation is further supported by your previous ravings concerning unintended consequences.

There is no evidence--in your links or elsewhere--that the highlighted part is true. Is there fraud? Sure. Even some high-profile cases. But as I've demonstrated, you have no idea, outside a few soundbites worth of data, what the history of science is like in regards to fraud (Owen's case for example was rather high-profile, to use gross understatement), and therefore are incapable of evaluating whether it's gone up or down, much less what the impacts would be. Furthermore, you have ignored my first-hand experience in precisely the field you say is degraded.

But I'll let you dig your own grave: Please provide a precise level of fraud that is acceptable and not "excessive". 0% is impossible; again, scientists are not some alien breed, we are human beings. No fraud is ideal, but an unreasonable demand (until you remove fraud from some other field, completely and without exception, don't expect if from science). At what point does fraud become acceptable? And--perhaps more importantly--how do arive at that number?

A tip of my hat to you sir (or mam)!

:th:
 
Last edited:
1. Scientists are poor communicators. They hide behind scientific jargon so as to avoid being questioned by the general public. They mask their inability to articulate their discipline and indulge in garbled esoteric mambo jumbo to protect themselves under the disguise of science.

2. The scientific community are made up of short sighted people barely able to cope with the immediate problems and have little use for long term goals that are less sensational.

3. There is excessive fraud among the scientific community a disservice to the Corporations and Institutions that fund their research. Gross incompetence and dangerously inept unreliable research bordering on criminal negligence has raised doubts and suspicion on what was once a noble profession.
Sorry, justintime, but you are very wrong:
1) Scientists are great communicators - to other scientists. There is no requirement for scientists in general to communicate to the public. They use scientific language to communicate effectively to scientists. They show their ability to articulate their discipline and indulge in clear and concise language to communicate to scientist.

Scientists who make it their job to communicate to the public generally do a very good job.

2) The scientific community is made up of long sighted people able to cope with the immediate problems and have many uses for long term goals.

3) There are some cases of fraud/incompetence/unreliable research among the scientific community. That is a very small percentage of the large body scientific research. Only quite ignorant people would think that this small amount of abuse has raised doubts and suspicion on what is still "a noble profession". Any doubts are from the sensationalist press coverage of these few events.
 
justintime said:
There might be an explanation for your defensive reaction to this OPs accusatory finger pointing at science and scientists by drawing attention to the increase in scientific fraud in the scientific community.
I'm not defensive. I'm annoyed. There's a difference.

Secondly, you've yet to demonstrate that there's any actual increase in fraud. When we say "Where's the data?" you accuse us of getting defensive. Completely nonsense.

Third, your posts have nothing to do with fraud. They are simply baseless attacks against scientists as a whole, combined with cowardly evasions of the implications of your accusations and a refusal to actually defend them.

The respondents who were quick to take offense, be offended or insulted were not surprisingly male dominated.
Mere coincidence, I assure you. I'm downright calm compared to the reaction of the female scientists I've met to such nonsense.

This is nothing more than an attempt to evade the fact that your accusations are off-topic and unsupported. I note that you said this in place of actually responding to any of my points.

It's nothing more than a smear campaign intended to make us feel guilty about sexism when we disagree with you. The argument boils down to "You have a penis, so your argument is invalid". It is, ironically, naked sexism of the worst kind. And it's openly dishonest, being an ad hom attack rather than an actual attempt to address anything said in this thread. An unsubstantiated one, too--even if I were to accept the idea that females commit less fraud than males, this has NOTHING to do with me being annoyed at your continued baseless accusations. Unless you are arguing that I am committing/have committed fraud, your link and entire bloody post are wiithout value in this conversation and serve only to hide the fact that you cannot muster a valid argument.

Provide evidence for an increase in fraud in science, or admit you can't. It's real simple. Given your complete failure to understand how science works or the history of science thus far, and your attempts to evade the burden of proof, however, I won't hold my breath.
 
The respondents who were quick to take offense, be offended or insulted were not surprisingly male dominated. Is there an explanation for this gender bias?
Could it be because that this "gender bias" does not exist because you have presented no evidence that the respondents are mostly male, justintime?
Could it be that this forum is a biased selection ("mostly" male), justintime?
Could it be that this section of the forum is a biased selection ("mostly" male), justintime?
Could it be that this thread in this section of the forum is a biased selection ("mostly" male), justintime?

Could it be that you have the delusion that you can read the minds of the respondents and see that they are offended or insulted, justintime :rolleyes:?
 
And how, pray tell, are you judging our genders? Is "Dinwar" an exclusively masculine name in your culture?

Given the name's history--a conlang I created as a kid, for a fantasy world I used to imagine--that would certainly be an interesting coincidence. Honestly, I thought I made the word up!

Reality Check said:
Scientists who make it their job to communicate to the public generally do a very good job.
In my experience, scientists are really good at communicating their ideas to a small audience, regardless of who the scientist is. Put a random scientist in a room with three people who want to talk to the scientist and they'll explain pretty much any idea in a way that all three can understand. Communicating with "the public"--ie, people en mass--is another thing entirely. You're right, those who go that route tend to be excellent at it; the rest of us tend to be hit and miss.
 
I stopped reading there. Anyone who says this clearly doesn't know the first thing about science, so his opinions are not worth reading.

But it's true. My research supervisor locked me up in this dungeon and told me not to come out until I can fudge enough data to prove that Black Holes actually have marshmallow cores.
 
I'm not defensive. I'm annoyed. There's a difference.

Secondly, you've yet to demonstrate that there's any actual increase in fraud. When we say "Where's the data?" you accuse us of getting defensive. Completely nonsense.

Third, your posts have nothing to do with fraud. They are simply baseless attacks against scientists as a whole, combined with cowardly evasions of the implications of your accusations and a refusal to actually defend them.

Mere coincidence, I assure you. I'm downright calm compared to the reaction of the female scientists I've met to such nonsense.

This is nothing more than an attempt to evade the fact that your accusations are off-topic and unsupported. I note that you said this in place of actually responding to any of my points.

It's nothing more than a smear campaign intended to make us feel guilty about sexism when we disagree with you. The argument boils down to "You have a penis, so your argument is invalid". It is, ironically, naked sexism of the worst kind. And it's openly dishonest, being an ad hom attack rather than an actual attempt to address anything said in this thread. An unsubstantiated one, too--even if I were to accept the idea that females commit less fraud than males, this has NOTHING to do with me being annoyed at your continued baseless accusations. Unless you are arguing that I am committing/have committed fraud, your link and entire bloody post are wiithout value in this conversation and serve only to hide the fact that you cannot muster a valid argument.

Provide evidence for an increase in fraud in science, or admit you can't. It's real simple. Given your complete failure to understand how science works or the history of science thus far, and your attempts to evade the burden of proof, however, I won't hold my breath.

Surely a 10 fold increase in scientific fraud would be a cause for alarm.
Tenfold increase in scientific research papers retracted for fraud
http://www.theguardian.com/science/2012/oct/01/tenfold-increase-science-paper-retracted-fraud

Why the epidemic of fraud exists in science today
http://creation.com/science-fraud-epidemic

Top 10 scientific frauds and hoaxes.
http://listverse.com/2008/04/09/top-10-scientific-frauds-and-hoaxes/

http://www.neatorama.com/2006/09/19/10scientific-frauds-that-rocked-the-world/#!qbO6E

Here is something closer to home.
Paleontology Fraud & Hoaxes Wiki
http://paleontologyfraudhoaxes.wikia.com/wiki/Paleontology_Fraud_&_Hoaxes_Wiki
 
Last edited:
Justintime, thank you for the data.

Intresting to read about the peerreview filtering process:

"The Sokal affair was a hoax by Alan Sokal (a physicist) perpetrated on the postmodern cultural studies journal Social Text (published by Duke University). In 1996, he submitted a paper of nonsense camouflaged in jargon to see if the journal would “publish an article liberally salted with nonsense if (a) it sounded good and (b) it flattered the editors’ ideological preconceptions.”

and

Another recent example of this same situation is the 2005 Rooter Paper; this was a paper randomly generated by a computer which was submitted – and consequently approved as legitimate – to a scientific conference.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bogdanov_Affair
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCIgen
 
Last edited:
Sorry, justintime, but you are very wrong:
1) Scientists are great communicators - to other scientists. There is no requirement for scientists in general to communicate to the public. They use scientific language to communicate effectively to scientists. They show their ability to articulate their discipline and indulge in clear and concise language to communicate to scientist.

Gee, unsurprisingly, that's exactly like other professions. Computer programmers talking to each other sounds like ancient egyptian to most people.
 
justintime said:
Surely a 10 fold increase in scientific fraud would be a cause for alarm.
Tenfold increase in scientific research papers retracted for fraud
This is a non sequitor. An increase in retraction is not necessarily an increase in occurrance. It may be an increase in awareness or tollerance for accusations--which is certainly the case (as the book I referenced earlier clearly demonstrates).

Why the epidemic of fraud exists in science today
You linked to Creation.com. This is akin to linking to the KKK to learn about African culture. The mere act of posting such a link destroys your credibility.

Your last link is of the same caliber. I stopped reading after this quote:

woowebsite said:
That meaning perfectly describes the current state of “fossil paleontologists” today who whoop like an Indian medicine man at every new discovery of every sort of nonsense in their field despite the multitude of hoaxes perpetuated by its own members—past and present

This is so wrong it's remarkable. Every one of us understands the dangers of fraud. My personal view is that I need to wait six months before accepting any findings out of China due to exactly that. However, the overwhelming majority of paleontologists work diligently to combat exactly such issues (and issues that are far more important but which you anti-science fanatics never even mention).

It's truly pathetic that someone would present such nonsense. And I can't print my opinions of people who believe it on this forum. I will note, however, that you're willing to accept the word of a poorly written, poorly formatted, and obviously uninformed website over and above that of a practicing member of that field. There's a conclusion we can draw from this, but I'll leave it to you to determine it.

justintime said:
Top 10 scientific frauds and hoaxes.
Any measurable and variable quantity will have a top 10. And there are millions of scientists--an epidemic would require at least tens of thousands of retractions due to fraud.

Finally, I want to note that you STILL have not addressed ANY of my points, preferrring instead to dodge the issues. Are you able to address them?

Maartenn100 said:
Justintime, thank you for the data.
He didn't provide any--at best, he provided propaganda websites.

http://retractionwatch.com/
Here's an okay source for REAL data.

Intresting to read about the peerreview filtering process:
Okay, so there are some flaws. Not a big deal. What you, justintime, and the rest of the "Science is failing!" crowd don't understand is that peer review is the first, not the last, step. Once a paper has been reviewed, the REAL test begins. Scientists who actually use the data determine whether it's true, valid, and useful. The stuff that is, gets perpetuated. The stuff that's not, doesn't. It can be directly attacked, or simply ignored.

A fantastic example of this is Dibblee's work. He did fantastic work, but a lot of it has been revised. He's still the go-to author for SoCal geology, particularly in the Mojave, but none of us doing geology out here even hesitates to correct his maps when we feel he was wrong.

THAT process--the churning of the data by inumerable researchers--is the REAL review. THAT is where the quality of the paper is ACTUALLY tested. And it cannot be otherwise. There are all kinds of controversies, and only by churning the data and working with it can we hope to accomplish any resolution. Reviewers and editors of journals do not and cannot act as arbiters of truth.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom