How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wonder how long it'll take before Overstock sucks all the money out of the exchanges?

I'm immensely curious about that. If the exchanges are having so many issues dealing with small-time conversions (relatively speaking), then what will happen when a major corporation gets involved? It seems like a logistics nightmare.
 
I've been following this thread for a while out of morbid curiosity. To me, this is a wonderful scam. "A fool and his bitcoin are soon parted"......

That's a scam easily done with any fiat currency. Take the buyer where there are no cameras/witnesses and ask for cash. Refuse to give your product and the buyer has the same legal case against you. There's even less trace of the transaction left behind compared to using bitcoin (with bitcoin you have at least a wallet address and the transaction is documented in the blockchain).

So while this particular theft scores no points in the bitskeptic camp, that thread does demonstrate something about bitcoin community. Instead of gloating and victim-blaming, a random dude gave the OP 1 BTC for his loss.
 
Last edited:
Define "heaps".

Define "very few".

It's been explained that even the large exchanges can't handle large transactions.

Really? Care to recap as to why that is and what's your source/who provided that information? I'm trying to keep up with bitcoin news and haven't encountered a large exchange that didn't pay out yet. Maybe you have some inside information. Although I suspect you're just wrong.
 

So you're saying that i f I cash out $100,000 of BTC it won't be a problem at all ?

Define "very few".

I've heard of a handful of places that accept BTC, but I've seen none, and even BTC proponents admit so.

Your turn.

Really? Care to recap as to why that is and what's your source/who provided that information?

My source is this thread, actually. As to why, I don't know. Ask a BTC proponent, not me.
 
I've heard of a handful of places that accept BTC, but I've seen none, and even BTC proponents admit so.

Your turn.

I was assuming you're following the thread, but in any case, I posted a couple of links earlier listing places that accept bitcoin. It should be in the top 3 results when googling 'vendors who accept bitcoin': https://www.spendbitcoins.com/places/

Maybe you need vendors in the millions to not consider it "very few". I'm from a country with 1.3m population, and that non-exhaustive list is "heaps" to me. You hear every week new vendors accepting bitcoin if you bother reading bitcoin news.

My source is this thread, actually. As to why, I don't know. Ask a BTC proponent, not me.

Then psionl0 was right, there have only been allegations, no-one in this thread, at least for the last 15 or so pages, hasn't provided any evidence for that claim.
 
I'm immensely curious about that. If the exchanges are having so many issues dealing with small-time conversions (relatively speaking), then what will happen when a major corporation gets involved? It seems like a logistics nightmare.

Suppose Overstock does $25,000 in BTC business on the first day, and goes to Mt. Gox, and the Goxies say "Oh, you can have your money in three weeks." I can see two possible outcomes:

1) Overstock sues.

2) Overstock stops taking BTC.

Note: These are not mutually exclusive.

The problem for the exchanges is that a large business like Overstock is going to want USD, and they're going to want it now, and not in three weeks or however long it's now taking to process transactions of any real size. That's just going to exacerbate the obvious liquidity problems the exchanges have.
 
Strange, at the moment MtGox is the only one over $1000/coin all the other exchanges on bitcoin wisdom are about $100 below that.

That's because it's paper-fortune land; there's some question about whether they have anywhere near enough capitalization to get money out, at least in part due to the USD seizures that occurred on their Dwolla side actually directly impacting the amount of cash they have, and in part because they're routing everything through an itty bitty bank in Poland (because nobody else will deal with them, apparently).

Reliability!

Thanks -- that was the one I was thinking of when I remarked earlier, and for some reason I couldn't remember where the link was. Worth noting that the post above was "Posted by killhamster - November 27, 2013 at 9:35 am", so this is less than two months old -- not someone trying to cash out in 2011.

Oh, and look, someone trying to schlep off some hot gift cards is mentioned in that story as well :D GO FIGURE. :rolleyes: I'm all in favor of the technological advances Bitcoin has pioneered, but Bitcoin _itself_ is firmly ensconced in 'speculation' land. Swim if you like, the water's plenty warm in some places... just watch for the sharks.
 
Suppose Overstock does $25,000 in BTC business on the first day, and goes to Mt. Gox, and the Goxies say "Oh, you can have your money in three weeks." I can see two possible outcomes:

1) Overstock sues.

2) Overstock stops taking BTC.

Note: These are not mutually exclusive.

The problem for the exchanges is that a large business like Overstock is going to want USD, and they're going to want it now, and not in three weeks or however long it's now taking to process transactions of any real size. That's just going to exacerbate the obvious liquidity problems the exchanges have.

Paraphrasing your straw:

1) Suppose Overstock is really stupid.
2) Then Overstock does stupid things.
3) Then they have consequences of doing stupid things.

I'll take their business judgement concerning their business over yours.

....the obvious liquidity problems the exchanges have.
Obvious liquidity problems? Making things up again? I don't see how or why you would cite a specific instance of MtGox having one bank account frozen, then extend it over an entire industry and believe you actually made a logical statement.

You did the total reverse, you made a ridiculous statement. Suppose there was a surge of activity, and exchanges take money in but wait a week or two before delivering coin. That's cash in their hands from the new buyers to pay off the new sellers. That's the exact reverse of a 'liquidity problem'.

You don't even understand how exchanges work.

Why not stick to things you do understand to comment on?

Anyway, merchants use 'bitcoin payment systems'. Not exchanges. Examples from the bitcoin wiki.

Bitcoin payment systems

The below services facilitate payments in Bitcoins. Different from exchanges Bitcoins are treaded as means of payment and not as financial good. Different from eWallets the provided services do not aim to store Bitcoins and facilitate transfers between individuals but to provide smooth Bitcoin payments.

  • BIPS (info), Bitcoin merchant solutions, point of sale system, mobile checkout, currency conversion and withdraw to bank account in the merchants local currency to any country.
  • BitPay (info), merchant payment processing system
  • BitUtils Merchant BitUtils Merchant solution enables merchants to accept bitcoins with simple HTML buttons. No programming or server admin skills required. 0.5% fee for incoming BTCs.
  • Coinbase Provide online merchant services.
  • Coinkite Provide merchant solutions and hardware Point of Sale terminal.
  • PikaPay (info) Send and receive payments to any Twitter account.
  • BitVendor, Bitcoin, Cash, and Debit Card Point of Sale System
  • The BFG Program (Bitcoins For Gets) - Link to swfchan.com and earn bitcoins
  • GoCoin International Payment Processing for Bitcoin
 
Last edited:
This comment sums it up:
It took me about a month to get full privileges on Coinbase but after that, up to 50BTC/day immediate in or out.

Been a while since I signed up with MtGox, but they had 70,000 applications backlog at that time.
 
That's because it's paper-fortune land.....someone trying to schlep off some hot gift cards is mentioned in that story as well .....


BWHAAAHAHAHAHA!

Soon as I mention Gyft.com, and trading bitcoins for gift cards, here's Remirol with allegations that 'those gift cards are hot'.

Must be a lot of hot stuff floating around....

https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Trade#Gift.2FDebit_Cards

Am I seeing a trend here? According to Remirol, if it's done with bitcoin, it's dishonest and/or fraudulent.

Let's see if that continues with the next thing someone mentions buying with bitcoin.
 
Last edited:
Paraphrasing your straw:

1) Suppose Overstock is really stupid.
2) Then Overstock does stupid things.
3) Then they have consequences of doing stupid things.

I'll take their business judgement concerning their business over yours.

Obvious liquidity problems? Making things up again? I don't see how or why you would cite a specific instance of MtGox having one bank account frozen, then extend it over an entire industry and believe you actually made a logical statement.

You did the total reverse, you made a ridiculous statement. Suppose there was a surge of activity, and exchanges take money in but wait a week or two before delivering coin. That's cash in their hands from the new buyers to pay off the new sellers. That's the exact reverse of a 'liquidity problem'.

Isn't this the definition of a Ponzi scheme?
 
1) Suppose Overstock is really stupid.
2) Then Overstock does stupid things.
3) Then they have consequences of doing stupid things.

Overstock wanting to get paid for stuff they sold is "really stupid"?

ETA: Surely you don't think Overstock is just going to hold on to the BTC? They can't use them for anything. They can't pay suppliers, they can't pay their employees, they can't buy more stuff (except hot gift cards). So yes, they're going to be redeeming them at the exchanges, and if there's any significant usage at all they're going to suck the exchanges dry in nothing flat.

To me this sounds like someone at Overstock heard about BTC, and wanted to be hip and edgy, and didn't do any homework about the mechanics of the thing. I predict that Overstock will quietly stop accepting BTC within six months of whenever they start accepting it.
 
Last edited:
Of course it must be easy for Overstock to figure out what to charge when the bitcion $ price is moving by 20% in the last 24 hours or so. No problem at all to factor the wild variation in quoted price from those marvels of price discovery they call exchanges.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom