Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Further to my question about where Hamas should best launch their rockets from:

Google Earth shows several nice open fields. They could also try building military centers away from the civilians.

What do you think would be the best way for the Palestinians to decommission Israel's equipment?

The negotiating table.
 
Oh there will be lots of judgment .... however, there will not be any sentencing or penalties.

You must not have heard the good news:

Well.. When people pull the rope too much (say, Jews in the 1920s) it is logical that the other side gets quite angry
Whatever will happen to the Jews in a few months or years, you can`t say they did all they could to avoid :D
 
The negotiating table.

I disagree. The negotiating table is the best option if they want to do things like end the blockade of Gaza, end the current conflict, end the death toll, officially gain control of the West Bank, have Israel move a number of its settlements out of the West Bank, and so on. It is not a particularly good option for Palestinians seeking to dismantle Israel's military and military equipment, however. Nor is it a good option for Hamas' desire to get rid of Israel entirely, hence why their charter is very specific about how completely opposed they are to efforts to reach a final peaceful solution.

It's also a little sad that, despite KumarS' repeated claims that Israel's holding a gun to the Palestinian's heads, what the people of Gaza are doing is trying to hold a gun to Israel's head and force them to just give concessions that they've quite showily demonstrated are neither warranted nor earned, regardless of the actually legitimate grievances that the Palestinians have.
 
Last edited:
No it's not. So right there you lose all credibility. Being Jewish is not at all the same as being Christian.

I always have to explain this in my classes and I'll say "A Jew is like a Sioux"

Jews are descendants from the 12 tribes of Israel. That's why there are so many different types of Jews around the world. Lineage is matrilineal and so if a Jewish man marries a non Jew conversion is required to raise the children Jewish.

It's not a choice any more than being a Cherokee is a choice.

Your analogy does not make sense on any level of scientific epistemology! Your remarks display ignorance of real history, biology, sociology, anthropology and most surprisingly, even theology.

The Sioux/Cherokee were tribes who lived for Generation as one tribe living in the one geographical area on one continent. The Cherokee are not Sioux and vice versa. Each was a distinct homogeneous autochthonous group of people.

Jews are neither isolated geographically nor culturally except by RELIGIOUS CULTURE and are varied genetically from blonds to blacks.

If the Sioux spread out over Europe and Africa and Asia and intermarried with all sorts of peoples for over 3000 years, would we then still call them an AUTOCHTHONOUS group of people distinct from their fellow citizens in whatever country they are living in?

What distinguishes Jews is JUDAISM not genetics, just like the Bahai people (the Zoroatrians too) are still Persians despite their persecution in Iran and their distinct religious adherence. And if a Sioux converts to Bahaism he does not become Persian any more than if a Persian converts to Judaism does he become a descendent of the mythical 12 brothers.



Jews are descendants from the 12 tribes of Israel. That's why there are so many different types of Jews around the world. Lineage is matrilineal and so if a Jewish man marries a non Jew conversion is required to raise the children Jewish.


Are there black Jews? Are there Blonde Jews? Are there Indian Jews? Are there Chinese Jews?

You do know that the supposed 12 tribes are supposed to be descended from 12 brothers? You do know that Abraham is a myth and so were Isaac and Jacob? They were no more reality than Remus or Romulus. Or do you believe that all Italians today come from these two brothers?

Do you believe that the world is 5774 years old and that it all started with Adam and Eve too?

In what classes are you teaching that Jews are like the Cherokee and are still allowed to teach...it must be in a religious institution.


By no sane definition can one consider any people who lived on 3 continents thousands of years and have phenotypes varying from blond-blue-eyed whites to blacks as a homogeneous autochthonous race descended from 12 brothers from 4 mothers, two of whom were sisters who in turn were first cousins to the father?

In fact it is actually even more preposterous because 10 of the tribes are supposed to have vanished and ALL Jews Sephardim /Ashkenazim / Falasha / Mizrahim etc. are supposed to be descended only from the two tribes of Judah and Benjamin (with a few Levites maybe).

Are there any black Sioux? What about Blue-Eyed Blond-Haired Cherokee?

Unfortunately for your class they are not reading this tidbit of information
A 2013 study of Ashkenazi mitochondrial DNA by a team led by Martin B. Richards of the University of Huddersfield in England tested the full 16,600 DNA units composing mitochondrial DNA in all their subjects. The study found that the four main female Ashkenazi founders had descent lines that were established in Europe 10,000 to 20,000 years in the past[21] whilst most of the remaining minor founders also have a deep European ancestry. The study states that the great majority of Ashkenazi maternal lineages were not brought from the Levant, nor recruited in the Caucasus, but were assimilated within Europe. The study estimated that 80 percent of Ashkenazi maternal ancestry comes from women indigenous to Europe, 8 percent from the Near East, and the remainder undetermined.[21] According to the study these findings 'point to a significant role for the conversion of women in the formation of Ashkenazi communities.'[22][23][24][25][26][27]​


No it's not. So right there you lose all credibility. Being Jewish is not at all the same as being Christian.


Read this bit again
The study estimated that 80 percent of Ashkenazi maternal ancestry comes from women indigenous to Europe, 8 percent from the Near East, and the remainder undetermined.[21] According to the study these findings 'point to a significant role for the conversion of women in the formation of Ashkenazi communities.'​


So how does that make Judaism any different from any other religion. People from all around the world intermarried and CONVERTED to Judaism and are now Jews.... how is that different from Christianity?

Can one CONVERT to Cherokeeism? Can one convert to Christianity? In fact most early Christians became so because their mothers or wives converted.

Can one convert to Judaism? Your answer is “ if a Jewish man marries a non Jew conversion is required to raise the children Jewish”…. So how is that different from any other religion?

If the Sioux intermarry with Europeans for generation are they still Sioux.... I have met many people here in the US who keep claiming that they are One-Umpteenth Apache etc. Maybe I should advise them to attend your class in order to learn how to claim that they are FULL Cherokee or whatever and maybe claim the right to shares in that Casino they have.
 
Last edited:
From the bottom of the second article




Oh there will be lots of judgment .... however, there will not be any sentencing or penalties.

This has happened NUMEROUS times before and in fact almost on monthly basis for decades. All have elicited lots of judgment. But so far no consequences other than a lot of hot air. So why would this time be any different.

Have a look at this video and tell me why is this time any different from all the other times before it.... if nothing got done those times, then the very same reasons will also be why nothing will be done this time either.

It is called MIGHT IS RIGHT and objectors who open their mouths will have something shoved in them real tight.



Thanks for your comments. Due to technological limitations I'm unable to watch the video at the moment.

I agree with your pessimism. However, it took decades to bring down the apartheid regime in South Africa and it was a grassroots campaign of boycotts, divestment and sanctions that eventually did it. The tide has turned against Israel's colonialist violence. Many more people around the world have come out onto the streets to protest this time and condemnation of Israel's barbarism is seeping into the mainstream media with even loyal supporters seeing through Israel's tired propaganda.
 
Last edited:
I disagree. The negotiating table is the best option if they want to do things like end the blockade of Gaza, end the current conflict, end the death toll, officially gain control of the West Bank, have Israel move a number of its settlements out of the West Bank, and so on. It is not a particularly good option for Palestinians seeking to dismantle Israel's military and military equipment, however. Nor is it a good option for Hamas' desire to get rid of Israel entirely, hence why their charter is very specific about how completely opposed they are to efforts to reach a final peaceful solution.

It's also a little sad that, despite KumarS' repeated claims that Israel's holding a gun to the Palestinian's heads, what the people of Gaza are doing is trying to hold a gun to Israel's head and force them to just give concessions that they've quite showily demonstrated are neither warranted nor earned, regardless of the actually legitimate grievances that the Palestinians have.

Hamas dropped their call for the destruction of Israel in 2006

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2006/jan/12/israel
 
Hamas dropped their call for the destruction of Israel in 2006

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2006/jan/12/israel

Thank you for pointing this out directly. That was a good step... and one of the ones that they really, really couldn't avoid making if they hoped to have any chance of being politically accepted by the world at large, which makes it much less trustworthy. As it said in the article, though, they still refused to recognize Israel's right to exist in the first place, though, which means that their position didn't actually change much, officially, a position that I had quoted a Fatah leader speaking for the Fatah party as also holding in 2011 in a previous post.

Either way, when both major Palestinian parties are running on platforms that are seemingly roughly as non-conducive to finding a long-term peaceful co-existence as Israel's Likud party's platform, that's not particularly encouraging.
 
Thanks for your comments. Due to technological limitations I'm unable to watch the video at the moment.

I agree with your pessimism. However, it took decades to bring down the apartheid regime in South Africa and it was a grassroots campaign of boycotts, divestment and sanctions that eventually did it. The tide has turned against Israel's colonialist violence. Many more people around the world have come out onto the streets to protest this time and condemnation of Israel's barbarism is seeping into the mainstream media with even loyal supporters seeing through Israel's tired propaganda.


Very similar situations.
I think the main culprit is the United States, who was supporting the apartheid regime in South Africa and it is supporting the Zionists now.
I still do not understand why Mandela accepted to take pictures with Obama

As for the core of the Palestinian issue, I think things are turning quite bad for the Jews.
The Islamic State is making inroads in Syria, soon it may arrive close to the Golan Heights.
Hamas is not backing down.
The Palestinians in the West Bank are rising
The relationship between Israel and Turkey are at an all time low.

I wonder how much time the Zionists can keep their apartheid regime going and, most important, what will it happen afterwards?
I mean.. we all know what the Islamists do to traitors, right?
 
Thank you for pointing this out directly. That was a good step... and one of the ones that they really, really couldn't avoid making if they hoped to have any chance of being politically accepted by the world at large, which makes it much less trustworthy.

By this measure no political power in the world is trustworthy. Even military dominant powers have to compromise.

As it said in the article, though, they still refused to recognize Israel's right to exist in the first place, though, which means that their position didn't actually change much, officially, a position that I had quoted a Fatah leader speaking for the Fatah party as also holding in 2011 in a previous post.

Israel's "right" to exist has been earned by decades of colonial terrorism and military conquest. That's how international politics works, unfortunately. Not recognizing this "right" and vowing Israel's destruction are two completely different things. In fact, all Palestinian's current, elected representatives do recognize Israel's right to exist, within its pre-1967 borders.

Either way, when both major Palestinian parties are running on platforms that are seemingly roughly as non-conducive to finding a long-term peaceful co-existence as Israel's Likud party's platform, that's not particularly encouraging.

Palestinians want to end the siege, occupation and destruction of their homeland. That's a perfectly reasonable demand. Most of the word agrees with them.


Pro-Peace Protests Are Sweeping Israel Right Now… and Israeli ‘JDL’ Fascists Are Freaking Out
 
This has happened NUMEROUS times before and in fact almost on monthly basis for decades. All have elicited lots of judgment. But so far no consequences other than a lot of hot air. So why would this time be any different.

You must not have heard the good news:

As Iran is getting stronger, the Islamic State is taking land, Hamas has more missiles and China is siding with Russia and Iran
Evil regimes like the US and the Israeli soon or late they all collapses.
The Soviet Union collapsed
The Nazi Empire was called the Empire of the 1000-year and collapsed only after 12 years.
The US-supported Apartheid regime collapsed.
The US-backed Zionist regime will collapse as well
No regime based on terrorism and children killing like the Zionist can survive long
In my opinion, the Zionists do not kill children as they like it, but as they are desperate as they know their hours are counted.
The minimum sign of weakness and they will be wiped out by the neighboring Arabs.
Hamas has already killed almost 50 Zionist soldiers, by far more than last time, they are better equipped and more determined.
They know that time is on their side.
As soon as the Islamists will solidify their gains in Syria, my bet is that they will ally with Hamas to root out the Jews out of Israel
When this will happen, the Jews will have only themselves to blame.
Along with their stubborn ignorance of history
 
2638953d4eec00aa61.jpg


lol
 
By this measure no political power in the world is trustworthy. Even military dominant powers have to compromise.

It seems that, at best, you're misunderstanding what I said, if you're responding with that. More likely, you're simply trying to conflate related but quite distinct concepts, like before. Nothing in that statement dealt with compromise, really. The closest that it comes to compromise is where Hamas took one of the official steps that it absolutely needed to take for it not to be officially counted as a group of terrorists, under duress. One of the ones that it could make without actually changing nearly anything regarding how it actually acts.


Israel's "right" to exist has been earned by decades of colonial terrorism and military conquest.

Just no, in much the same way that "genocide" was highly inaccurate and misleading, before.

That's how international politics works, unfortunately. Not recognizing this "right" and vowing Israel's destruction are two completely different things. In fact, all Palestinian's current, elected representatives do recognize Israel's right to exist, within its pre-1967 borders.

Frequently with stipulations that they think will lead to Israel effectively ceasing to exist in the long run, at last check, among other things. Either way, hopefully, Netanyahu will be replaced with someone with who is more likely to be able to find a peaceful solution sooner rather than later, given that I harbor little in the way of hopes that the Likud Party is acting in as much good faith as it could. Of course, the Likud Party and their supporters likely gained power, in large part, as a reaction to the actions of Palestinian hardliners and terrorists.

Palestinians want to end the siege, occupation and destruction of their homeland. That's a perfectly reasonable demand. Most of the word agrees with them.

Indeed. That would certainly be desirable. It's far more complex and not as reasonable as you're trying to claim, though, as has been illustrated over and over. The rockets being fired at Israel, despite the ceasefire requests, are a case in point.

Either way, if they didn't want their homeland destroyed, they should stop turning civilian areas into military targets and actively forcing a military response that will have to target those areas. If they want to end the siege, they should stop actively antagonizing their primary neighbor, both military-wise and policy-wise. Giving them the Gaza Strip in the first place to self govern was a first step in ending the occupation that you claim... which the Palestinians used to turn around and make it very undesirable and unwise for Israel to loosen their grasp on the West Bank.



Just going by the article as biased as it looks, good luck to the peace protesters and no luck, hopefully, to those who try to use violence against them.
 
Last edited:
I disagree. The negotiating table is the best option if they want to do things like end the blockade of Gaza, end the current conflict, end the death toll, officially gain control of the West Bank, have Israel move a number of its settlements out of the West Bank, and so on. It is not a particularly good option for Palestinians seeking to dismantle Israel's military and military equipment, however. Nor is it a good option for Hamas' desire to get rid of Israel entirely, hence why their charter is very specific about how completely opposed they are to efforts to reach a final peaceful solution.

It's also a little sad that, despite KumarS' repeated claims that Israel's holding a gun to the Palestinian's heads, what the people of Gaza are doing is trying to hold a gun to Israel's head and force them to just give concessions that they've quite showily demonstrated are neither warranted nor earned, regardless of the actually legitimate grievances that the Palestinians have.


I understand your overall point, and I agree. However, the negotiating table still has a higher likelihood of removing more Israeli military equipment from use and mothballed (dismantled) than any other option open to Hamas right now.

(I also think the Likud Party and Netanyaho are basically asses who haven't helped.)
 
Evil regimes like the US

Perhaps the US is evil! After all, the US has given Palestinians more useful aid than any other country in the world, in numerous ways, at last check. Other than helping them smuggle in the weapons that keep leading to more Palestinian death and suffering or supporting UN resolutions that wouldn't actually do much of anything except add to the antagonism and spur on more self-inflicted Palestinian suffering, at least. How could the Palestinians do anything but hate such a country?
 
Of course, the Likud Party and their supporters likely gained power, in large part, as a reaction to the actions of Palestinian hardliners and terrorists.

Israeli hardliners (and terrorists) were largely responsible for putting Hamas in power. It suited and still suits their expansionist, genocidal purposes.


Either way, if they didn't want their homeland destroyed, they should stop turning civilian areas into military targets and actively forcing a military response that will have to target those areas.

The whole of Gaza is a civilian area. No one is forcing Israeli war makers to kill civilians - 100% innocent men, women and children, who have done nothing to turn "civilian areas into military targets". The Zionist regime chooses to do so because it calculates that it can get away with it. It calculates that Palestinian lives are very cheap, compared to Israeli lives.

Most people living in Gaza haven't chosen to live there. It's not their "homeland". They have already been driven from their homes elsewhere is Palestine/Israel. They are refugees living in a giant refugee camp, also often and accurately described as an open-air prison.

The current round of blood-letting was provoked, over many months of killings and violent incursions, by Israel. Why shouldn't Palestinians defend themselves?


Gaza violence sparks global protests - in pictures
 
Last edited:
Israeli hardliners (and terrorists) were largely responsible for putting Hamas in power. It suited and still suits their expansionist, genocidal purposes.


This is the line of reasoning that I find most offensive in the entire problem. You think the Palestinians have no agency, no power, no responsibility, no control. In short, that they aren't human people. They've been reduced their status as 'victim' in a story. Reduce to device, a plot point measured against the villains.

They are human people. They have agency. They have choices. They have will, and agency, and mistakes, and virtues. They are more than tools for attacking Israel and the US. They are to me anyway, but you and a few other posters dehumanize them at every chance while perversely accusing others of that.

Propaganda up and down.
 
They are more than tools for attacking Israel and the US.

No. They are not attacking the US. Neither is Iran, Neither is the Hezbollah. Neither is Syria. Neither is the Muslim Brotherhood.

They got a Boner for Israel. So leave the US out of it. It is not the USA's war.
 
This is the line of reasoning that I find most offensive in the entire problem. You think the Palestinians have no agency, no power, no responsibility, no control. In short, that they aren't human people.

They are human people even if they are treated as animals by the US-supported Zionists
And they do have choices,: accept the status quo and live as slaves or fight the US-supported Zionist criminals and strive for their dignity
They have chosen the latter even at risk of their lives
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom