Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reports that Israel dropped pamphlets in North Gaza the day before that told people to evacuate to Gaza City.

Then the IDF unexpectedly bombs the living hell out of the same neighborhoods they told people to evacuate to
 
Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu says he will never recognize the right of Palestine to exist.

http://www.timesofisrael.com/netanyahu-finally-speaks-his-mind/

Now we know.

He says that he can't give Palestinians full sovereignty because the growth of groups like Hamas (and ISIS etc in the region) mean that full sovereignty (and unregulated borders) would be a security nightmare for Israel.

I can sympathize with that.

Note: he explicitly links his refusal to countenance full Palestinian autonomy to the existence and growth of Islamist extremist factions with apocalyptic goals. Not because he simply wants to stick it to Palestinians.
 
Well, let's see
  • Occupying foreign forces surround the land and as long as the population does not interfere with the overarching imperialist plans they are left alone to govern themselves.
  • Religious zealots lead the occupied population and are relentlessly trying to get rid of the occupation power.
  • The population is fed up with the occupying soldiers making their lives hell.
  • Occasionally the people boil over with violence.
  • Some religious zealots called Sicarii go around committing terrorist acts against the occupation powers.
  • The occupying forces decide to crush the interminable irritation that results from religious gnats biting every now and then.
  • The people decide that it is better to commit suicide by fighting a superior military power they have no hope in ejecting.
  • Rinse and repeat the cycle as many times as needed.
Well, I can see a lot of comparison points there.... so it does compare as far as history attests.

It does have a lot of similar points, and massive points of difference.
The glaring similarity is the fanaticism of Hamas/Bar Kochba. Led by sheer emotion and conviction, not cool strategic thinking (although that may be deceiving, Hamas could be seen as very successful).
Hamas can rely on public opinion (in and outside Israel) and Western culture to stop Israel from flattening Gaza and selling it's survivors as slaves.

Speaking of historical similarities: Israel's settlement policies are eerily similar to those used by the British in Ireland in, what? The senteen-hundreds. And we are still stuck with the repercussions of settling Brits in Ireland.

Similarities may be shallow, but we can still draw lessons from them.
 
Wow. Talk about spin and ignoring relevant facts. You may be a master of it. If you think that this is in any way a valid counter to the points I made, however, you are utterly wrong.

Hot air and ad hominem guff are not regarded a valid arguments on this site.




Feel free to put forth the necessary evidence required to supports these claims. Certainly, Israel does bear responsibility for things like Operation Brother's Keeper, but even then, the raw number of arrests and people killed don't even remotely tell the whole story. If a Palestinian throws a grenade at the IDF and gets shot and killed as a result, for example, that's not considered in such numbers. On the other hand, number of buildings destroyed isn't reflected in such numbers.


Here is a list of more than more than 200 Israeli ceasefire violations, including killings and incursions, between 11/22/2012 and 07/06/2014:

http://blog.thejerusalemfund.org/2012/12/israeli-ceasefire-violations-in-gaza.html




After taking a look, this looks pretty close to worthless to bring up in this crowd.



Do you really need the gaping problems with these "debunk" attempts pointed out? For most of them, again, were you paying attention to this thread?

Please respond with something more concrete than this. Thank you.
 
Baloney. Being a Jew is a choice just like being a Christian....ans there is nothing special about being a Jew. Jews are not special little Snowflakes: they are just another group of deluded people who believe in a Sky Daddy. Nothing special here.

There is no Jewish Gene. So...our special little Jewey Snowflakes must reconcile that they are only human after all. Just like everyone else.

Wrong. Again. There's no CHEROKEE gene as well. What kind of nonsense are you on about. And YES there is a difference in genetic history of Jewish people. That's what Ashkenazi Jews have prevalence of specific diseases.


:rolleyes:

http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Health/genetics.html


If you are a non practicing Jew you are still a Jew. If you are a non practicing Christian you are not a Christian. How about some education on this before blathering on nonsense.
 
Last edited:
Your analogy does not make sense on any level of scientific epistemology! Your remarks display ignorance of real history, biology, sociology, anthropology and most surprisingly, even theology.

The Sioux/Cherokee were tribes who lived for Generation as one tribe living in the one geographical area on one continent. The Cherokee are not Sioux and vice versa. Each was a distinct homogeneous autochthonous group of people.

Jews are neither isolated geographically nor culturally except by RELIGIOUS CULTURE and are varied genetically from blonds to blacks.

If the Sioux spread out over Europe and Africa and Asia and intermarried with all sorts of peoples for over 3000 years, would we then still call them an AUTOCHTHONOUS group of people distinct from their fellow citizens in whatever country they are living in?

What distinguishes Jews is JUDAISM not genetics, just like the Bahai people (the Zoroatrians too) are still Persians despite their persecution in Iran and their distinct religious adherence. And if a Sioux converts to Bahaism he does not become Persian any more than if a Persian converts to Judaism does he become a descendent of the mythical 12 brothers.






Are there black Jews? Are there Blonde Jews? Are there Indian Jews? Are there Chinese Jews?

You do know that the supposed 12 tribes are supposed to be descended from 12 brothers? You do know that Abraham is a myth and so were Isaac and Jacob? They were no more reality than Remus or Romulus. Or do you believe that all Italians today come from these two brothers?

Do you believe that the world is 5774 years old and that it all started with Adam and Eve too?

In what classes are you teaching that Jews are like the Cherokee and are still allowed to teach...it must be in a religious institution.


By no sane definition can one consider any people who lived on 3 continents thousands of years and have phenotypes varying from blond-blue-eyed whites to blacks as a homogeneous autochthonous race descended from 12 brothers from 4 mothers, two of whom were sisters who in turn were first cousins to the father?

In fact it is actually even more preposterous because 10 of the tribes are supposed to have vanished and ALL Jews Sephardim /Ashkenazim / Falasha / Mizrahim etc. are supposed to be descended only from the two tribes of Judah and Benjamin (with a few Levites maybe).

Are there any black Sioux? What about Blue-Eyed Blond-Haired Cherokee?

Unfortunately for your class they are not reading this tidbit of information
A 2013 study of Ashkenazi mitochondrial DNA by a team led by Martin B. Richards of the University of Huddersfield in England tested the full 16,600 DNA units composing mitochondrial DNA in all their subjects. The study found that the four main female Ashkenazi founders had descent lines that were established in Europe 10,000 to 20,000 years in the past[21] whilst most of the remaining minor founders also have a deep European ancestry. The study states that the great majority of Ashkenazi maternal lineages were not brought from the Levant, nor recruited in the Caucasus, but were assimilated within Europe. The study estimated that 80 percent of Ashkenazi maternal ancestry comes from women indigenous to Europe, 8 percent from the Near East, and the remainder undetermined.[21] According to the study these findings 'point to a significant role for the conversion of women in the formation of Ashkenazi communities.'[22][23][24][25][26][27]​





Read this bit again
The study estimated that 80 percent of Ashkenazi maternal ancestry comes from women indigenous to Europe, 8 percent from the Near East, and the remainder undetermined.[21] According to the study these findings 'point to a significant role for the conversion of women in the formation of Ashkenazi communities.'​


So how does that make Judaism any different from any other religion. People from all around the world intermarried and CONVERTED to Judaism and are now Jews.... how is that different from Christianity?

Can one CONVERT to Cherokeeism? Can one convert to Christianity? In fact most early Christians became so because their mothers or wives converted.

Can one convert to Judaism? Your answer is “ if a Jewish man marries a non Jew conversion is required to raise the children Jewish”…. So how is that different from any other religion?

If the Sioux intermarry with Europeans for generation are they still Sioux.... I have met many people here in the US who keep claiming that they are One-Umpteenth Apache etc. Maybe I should advise them to attend your class in order to learn how to claim that they are FULL Cherokee or whatever and maybe claim the right to shares in that Casino they have.


Good points all around. If a JEW intermarries they are STILL A JEW. :confused::confused:
 
Hot air and ad hominem guff are not regarded a valid arguments on this site.

Indeed. Maybe you could actually address the points that were actually made before, though, rather than throwing out something as completely pointless as you tried to?


Here is a list of more than more than 200 Israeli ceasefire violations, including killings and incursions, between 11/22/2012 and 07/06/2014:

http://blog.thejerusalemfund.org/2012/12/israeli-ceasefire-violations-in-gaza.html

Thank you for the link. With that said, after looking at numerous articles that the website linked to, it's actually not clear that many of them actually were violations, nor that the Israeli actions were unwarranted in many of them, and frankly, the details are quite sparse, to say the least, in nearly all of them, very much including details highly relevant to determining where any fault lies, if any does in the first place. With that said, I would be quite surprised if none of them actually were violations by Israeli forces, to say the least, though, as Israel has been nowhere close to completely "good" when it comes to a number of things.






Please respond with something more concrete than this. Thank you.

What? Like, for the former, "Oh no! Public Relations people are pointedly using language that sounds more favorable than other ways to put it while not actually lying!" Shocking!

For the latter?

1) It isn't occupied. It is being suppressed, quite certainly, as is to be expected when it's being led by an organization as violently antagonistic to Israel, historically and policy-wise, as Hamas has been. Reversing the very deeply rooted and justified mistrust there is not something that can be done either quickly or with a few words. By the looks of it, they were making somewhat decent strides in recent years, though, until the recent outbreak of hostilities.

2) This one's really dumb, and the "debunk" probably even moreso. Both sides want a ceasefire, but have significantly different requirements before they'd be willing to agree to one. Saying that Hamas is quite willing to agree to a ceasefire, but only if they get what they want isn't actually much of a defense.

3) As has been noted, Israel's dropped a LOT of bombs for such a low casualty count, Hamas has asked civilians to put themselves in the line of fire, and Hamas has been using civilian structures for military purposes, among a number of other things. In short, Israel may indeed have deliberately been targeting civilians, but the actions of the Palestinians muddy the waters far too much to be able to tell without a proper investigation.

4) See 3. Again, Israel almost certainly has committed a number of war crimes, but the actions of the Palestinians muddy the waters far too much to be able to tell without proper investigations.

5) From wikipedia -

Human shield is a military and political term describing the deliberate placement of non-combatants in or around combat targets to deter the enemy from attacking these targets. It may also refer to the use of persons to literally shield combatants during attacks, by forcing them to march in front of the soldiers. A third meaning is when a combatant holds another person in front of them to shield them from projectiles (usually bullets), often by holding then in a headlock or nelson hold.

When "human shield" has been used here and in general, it's been used as the first, which is fairly indisputably true, unless you want to try to argue that the deliberate placement of combat targets in noncombatant and civilian areas somehow doesn't count. The "debunking" keeps dealing with the second and third uses, which aren't being used in the first place, except by the quite ignorant, much as that has quite a bit to do with some of the technicalities. After all, "asking" a culture where martyrdom is praised isn't the same as "forcing."

I think that's enough to make my point for the moment, though.
 
Last edited:
Indeed. Maybe you could actually address the points that were actually made before, though, rather than throwing out something as completely pointless as you tried to?

You mistakenly and ignorantly equated Gaza with the Palestinian homeland, ignoring the fact that Palestinians have been forced to live densely packed into such a small area like sardines because of Israel's colonialist aggression and ethnic cleansing campaigns.

Entire neighborhoods have been flattened in the current hyperviolent assault. Entire civilian neighborhoods do not constitute "military targets". They are being cleared to create a "buffer zone", stealing yet more living space from Palestinian people.

No one is forcing Israel to kill civilians. They are choosing to do so.


Thank you for the link. With that said, after looking at numerous articles that the website linked to, it's actually not clear that many of them actually were violations, nor that the Israeli actions were unwarranted in many of them, and frankly, the details are quite sparse, to say the least, in nearly all of them, very much including details highly relevant to determining where any fault lies, if any does in the first place. With that said, I would be quite surprised if none of them actually were violations by Israeli forces, to say the least, though, as Israel has been nowhere close to completely "good" when it comes to a number of things.

That's a lot of wandering words saying nothing of any substance.


What? Like, for the former, "Oh no! Public Relations people are pointedly using language that sounds more favorable than other ways to put it while not actually lying!" Shocking!

Cynically orchestrated lies and propaganda, much of which is regurgitated as truth on these very pages.

Inside Mark Regev's Skull

For the latter?

1) It isn't occupied. It is being suppressed, quite certainly, as is to be expected when it's being led by an organization as violently antagonistic to Israel, historically and policy-wise, as Hamas has been. Reversing the very deeply rooted and justified mistrust there is not something that can be done either quickly or with a few words. By the looks of it, they were making somewhat decent strides in recent years, though, until the recent outbreak of hostilities.

The occupation started in 1948 and has never stopped. The recent "outbreak of hostilities" was orchestrated by a deliberate campaign of lies cynically exploiting the murder of three young Israeli from an illegal settlement (i.e. stolen land).

2) This one's really dumb, and the "debunk" probably even moreso. Both sides want a ceasefire, but have significantly different requirements before they'd be willing to agree to one. Saying that Hamas is quite willing to agree to a ceasefire, but only if they get what they want isn't actually much of a defense.

Israel's occupation and blockade is illegal under international law. There is no reason why Hamas should accept it.

3) As has been noted, Israel's dropped a LOT of bombs for such a low casualty count, Hamas has asked civilians to put themselves in the line of fire, and Hamas has been using civilian structures for military purposes, among a number of other things. In short, Israel may indeed have deliberately been targeting civilians, but the actions of the Palestinians muddy the waters far too much to be able to tell without a proper investigation.

It's not a "low casualty count". Rest assured that it wouldn't be considered low if the casualties were Israelis, many murdered in their own homes - innocent men, women and children.

Journalists in Gaza have found no evidence that Hamas has asked civilians to put themselves in the line of fire. Entire neighborhoods have been flattened by Israel's so'called "precision bombing".


4) See 3. Again, Israel almost certainly has committed a number of war crimes, but the actions of the Palestinians muddy the waters far too much to be able to tell without proper investigations.

How?

5) From wikipedia -



When "human shield" has been used here and in general, it's been used as the first, which is fairly indisputably true, unless you want to try to argue that the deliberate placement of combat targets in noncombatant and civilian areas somehow doesn't count. The "debunking" keeps dealing with the second and third uses, which aren't being used in the first place, except by the quite ignorant, much as that has quite a bit to do with some of the technicalities. After all, "asking" a culture where martyrdom is praised isn't the same as "forcing."

I think that's enough to make my point for the moment, though.

There is no "culture of martyrdom" amongst the innocent civilians who have been slaughtered. They all wanted to live as much as you and I do.

The use of "human shields" depends on the unwillingness of the aggressor to kill non-combatants. Israeli shows no such unwillingness. Even when it knows there are children in a school, it bombs it anyway, and then blames Hamas.

Journalists in Gaza have reported that they have seen no evidence of people being used as human shields by Hamas. There is evidence from the past of Palestinians being used as humans shields by Israeli soldiers, however.

~~~~~~~~~

Open letter from doctors and scientists on what Israel is doing to Gaza
The Lancet 30 July 2014:

We are doctors and scientists, who spend our lives developing means to care and protect health and lives. We are also informed people; we teach the ethics of our professions, together with the knowledge and practice of it. We all have worked in and known the situation of Gaza for years.

On the basis of our ethics and practice, we are denouncing what we witness in the aggression of Gaza by Israel.

...

We denounce the myth propagated by Israel that the aggression is done caring about saving civilian lives and children's wellbeing.

Israel's behaviour has insulted our humanity, intelligence, and dignity as well as our professional ethics and efforts. Even those of us who want to go and help are unable to reach Gaza due to the blockade.

... more

An open letter for the people in Gaza
 
Last edited:
I'm confused. How is Jules still a forum member?

Why are you so confused?

Anyways...here's an article describing how Israel is still killing refuges:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/world...643588-17a5-11e4-85b6-c1451e622637_story.html

Wow! Isn't is nice that the US gives Israel Billions of Dollars a year - so the mighty Israeli Defense Forces can kill defenseless Arab civilians in order to keep the Jewish State Pure? (Yeah...and that's a cynical Joke, but it is no joke that Israel's Zionism is Violent and Racist)
 
Last edited:
There is no "culture of martyrdom" amongst the innocent civilians who have been slaughtered. They all wanted to live as much as you and I do.


"From the Al-Qassam Brigades to the Zionist soldiers: The Al-Qassam Brigades love death more than you love life."
​

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/2075072.stm



http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/1446003.stm

http://www.theblaze.com/stories/201...kids-with-improvised-rocket-exploding-noises/

“We can forgive you for killing our sons. But we will never forgive you for making us kill yours.”

- Israeli Prime Minister Golda Meir to Egyptian President Anwar Saddat, 1978
 

A Brigade is not a culture. Doh!

Anyway...here's an article telling why Israel murders its own soldiers:

http://www.globalresearch.ca/israel-murders-idf-soldier-to-prevent-his-capture/5393552
 
Last edited:
I see that a number of show biz celebs are taking up that HAMAS cause. Latest form of mindless Radical Chic.
 
I see that a number of show biz celebs are taking up that HAMAS cause. Latest form of mindless Radical Chic.

Mumia's dead, might as well double down from cold-blooded murderer to genocidal religious fanatics.
 
"Colonialist". Last I checked, Israel wasn't in the business of kidnapping Palestinian women and feeding them to dogs while making a livestream of it or imbibing them with whiskey while spreading Smallpox. Nor were they in the business of enslaving natives and hacking off their hands for not meeting work quotas or forcibly addicting them to opium. There's no colonialism like old school colonialism.

"Ethnic Cleansing". I don't see any accordion players magically removing kebab from the premises. In fact, he is probably disappointed about how slow Israel is going with their casualty rates.

Since Day Zero, Israel has been threatened with extinction by the neighbours but proceeded to clean their clocks everytime the neighbours try to make good on that threat. No way they're letting anyone succeed where Hitler failed and that is why Israel exists (fun fact, many jews had to live in displaced persons camps for a few years after the holocaust.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom