Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

I am no fan of Geller or Wilders, but no matter how much of an ******* either of them are, or how bigoted and in opposition their ideals to freedom are, neither deserve violence for their speech. Yes, to an extent the possibility that something like this could happen is why the police were present. I feel sorry for the guard, and would do so even if were an employee of the organization who's event his was.

The news is now saying one of the gunmen was on the radar of US Intelligence for attempting to meet with or contacting Al Shabab. The other gunman was the first's roommate. It is unfortunate that this event hadn't been prevented from happening in the first place. I am curious to find out how much US Intelligence knew about the gunmen.
 
Have any of those who are asserting that this gathering was a bunch of irrational idiots actually taken the time to listen to the speech by Geert Wilders at said event? Or put any effort into assessing, rather than just assuming, whether they are like that or not?

No, and I don't care to do so either, nor do I need to because I don't see this as an issue of how rational or otherwise that they are; for me, the less rational and less sympathetic the better as it clarifies a point that they are and should be within their rights to vomit out their bile without being killed for doing so. I extend the same courtesy to you too, and I believe that the law should never be able to take that away.
 
No, and I don't care to do so either, nor do I need to because I don't see this as an issue of how rational or otherwise that they are; for me, the less rational and less sympathetic the better as it clarifies a point that they are and should be within their rights to vomit out their bile without being killed for doing so. I extend the same courtesy to you too, and I believe that the law should never be able to take that away.

Well stated.
 
There's all the difference in the world between offensive speech and attempted murder. You need to check your moral compass.

My moral compass is just fine. Geller and Wilder are hate-filled bigoted individuals. The perps were murderous hate-filled bigoted individuals. That gives Geller/Wilder about a +2 on the scale of People Who Foolmewunz Give A **** About. Her tweet after the shooting was a "call to arms". Anyone else read it in any other way?

And now one of our very own is crossing the line from mildly repulsive bigotry (which people are terming "racism", as it's so much more "civil and polite") to cheering for the "coming race war", a la Stormfront.
 
Last edited:
No, and I don't care to do so either, nor do I need to because I don't see this as an issue of how rational or otherwise that they are; for me, the less rational and less sympathetic the better as it clarifies a point that they are and should be within their rights to vomit out their bile without being killed for doing so. I extend the same courtesy to you too, and I believe that the law should never be able to take that away.

Indeed.

The cornerstone of a civil society where citizens resolve issues through discussion and voting, not resorting to illegitimate violence.
 
I am no fan of Geller or Wilders, but no matter how much of an ******* either of them are, or how bigoted and in opposition their ideals to freedom are, neither deserve violence for their speech. Yes, to an extent the possibility that something like this could happen is why the police were present. I feel sorry for the guard, and would do so even if were an employee of the organization who's event his was.

This.
 
Indeed.

The cornerstone of a civil society where citizens resolve issues through discussion and voting, not resorting to illegitimate violence.

Kidding, kidding
 

Attachments

  • TediousDebate.jpg
    TediousDebate.jpg
    3.3 KB · Views: 157
My moral compass is just fine. Geller and Wilder are hate-filled bigoted individuals. The perps where murderous hate-filled bigoted individuals. That gives Geller/Wilder about a +2 on the scale of People Who Foolmewunz Give A **** About. Her tweet after the shooting was a "call to arms". Anyone else read it in any other way?

Here's distinct groups:

A) hate filled folks who say that people who beleive "x" are bad

B) hate filled folks who say that people who beleive "x" should be killed

C) hate filled folks who try and kill people who beleive "x"

Pam geller et al appear to be in bucket (a). That is a world away from buckets (b) or (c). If you think that they are neighbors then you do in fact need an urgent check-up on your moral compass.
 
Police? Aren't we overlooking the massive Army exercise going on in Texas? Coincidence? Police, or Army snipers? ;)
 
Here's distinct groups:

A) hate filled folks who say that people who beleive "x" are bad

B) hate filled folks who say that people who beleive "x" should be killed

C) hate filled folks who try and kill people who beleive "x"

Pam geller et al appear to be in bucket (a). That is a world away from buckets (b) or (c). If you think that they are neighbors then you do in fact need an urgent check-up on your moral compass.

Geller just crossed to B. That's a neighbor of C. You don't see it? I do.
 
Quite right. The SPLC has been exposed as a greedy, fraudulent organization


By whom? Based on what evidence? Please include citations for your references.

and was recently disavowed by the FBI, I believe it was, or at least they indicated they would no longer be utilizing the SPLC's list.

<snip>


Got any cites for this one?
 
Geller just crossed to B. That's a neighbor of C. You don't see it? I do.

Was the "call to arms" a rhetorical device, saying "there is a real threat to freedom of speech, we need to defend it" or a call to take up arms and shoot people?

This should make it easy for you to get your head round the concept of rhetoric... when president Obama called on some groups to "punish their enemies", was he talking about voting a specific way in an election or about taking GOP candidates down to a dungeon and giving them a good spanking?
 
How is the right to critique religion involved?

Did you mean some fictitious right to critique religion without consequences?

Surely, there is a right to critique religion without being fired on.

The group sponsoring this is a hate group, plain and simple. One hate group fighting another hate group - arrest the survivors.

Sorry, what charge do you think is appropriate for the survivors?

I think Pamela Geller is a horrible person. I'm not defending a contest to purposely offend a religious group, for no apparent reason other than venting and provoking, as a morally good thing. But I don't see any particular U.S. or Texas law that it violates. What do you have in mind?
 
This is very important that these insults keep coming. Forget about who is doing the insulting, this is a great service. When Muslims can take an insult and not want to kill in retaliation.... that's when you stop the insulting.
 
To quote Otto von Bismark, "better pointed words than pointed bullets".

Sad when Bismark has a better idea of civil society than the SPLC.

Sorry, what did the SPLC say that suggests they don't understand civil society? Have they defended the use of "pointed bullets"?

Surely, there is nothing wrong with pointing out that Geller's rhetoric is offensive and hateful, is there? Did von Bismarck claim that whenever one uses "pointed words", we shouldn't criticize them?

I'm not quite following your message, obviously.
 
All of you criticizing Pamela Gellar should be careful. Don't you know any criticism of any Jewish person ever is Antisemitism?

I guess maybe the one exception is if you're attacking on behalf of a group with even more diversity points.
 
This is very important that these insults keep coming. Forget about who is doing the insulting, this is a great service. When Muslims can take an insult and not want to kill in retaliation.... that's when you stop the insulting.

What a remarkable grasp of human nature you have.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom