WTC7 Girder 79-44 13th floor and Tony Szamboti’s graphics and inputs analysis.

BasqueArch

Graduate Poster
Joined
Jan 11, 2009
Messages
1,871
A couple of years ago, Tony Szamboti produced computer FEA analysis graphics of the WTC7 13th floor girder 79-44 that he claims proved it could not have fallen off its support.
MileHighMadness requested, at the time, a copy of his input file to review his assumptions. Tony refused.

Tony, can you post here the unaltered graphics then produced and the input file, so that other engineers can review your assumptions.
 
A couple of years ago, Tony Szamboti produced computer FEA analysis graphics of the WTC7 13th floor girder 79-44 that he claims proved it could not have fallen off its support.
MileHighMadness requested, at the time, a copy of his input file to review his assumptions. Tony refused.

Tony, can you post here the unaltered graphics then produced and the input file, so that other engineers can review your assumptions.

Please don't hold your breath waiting on Tony.:D
 
A couple of years ago, Tony Szamboti produced computer FEA analysis graphics of the WTC7 13th floor girder 79-44 that he claims proved it could not have fallen off its support.
MileHighMadness requested, at the time, a copy of his input file to review his assumptions. Tony refused.

Tony, can you post here the unaltered graphics then produced and the input file, so that other engineers can review your assumptions.

Basque, you and others really should do your own analysis after putting the stiffeners on girder A2001 that are shown on Frankel drawing #9114.

The released WTC 7 drawings are available at the two below links

http://www2.ae911truth.org/downloads/NIST_WTC7_FOIA_11-209.zip

http://www2.ae911truth.org/downloads/NIST_WTC7_FOIA_12-009.zip

You will need to download from both links to get everything that was released.
 
Well...it is nice to know some things never change. Avoidance, avoidance, avoidance...

Good luck Tony, I wish you well...and I promise never to bother or criticize you again.

I gave you the information needed. Do your own analysis and let me know what you get.
 
I gave you the information needed. Do your own analysis and let me know what you get.

No, that doesn't satisfy the request. You're being asked to submit your research for peer review. Telling the reviewers they have to go off and do their own research doesn't test your claims.

I assume I don't need to tell you how an undecided reader is likely to view your refusal to turn over your analysis to qualified reviewers, when you insist it is the only valid analysis.
 
No, that doesn't satisfy the request. You're being asked to submit your research for peer review. Telling the reviewers they have to go off and do their own research doesn't test your claims.

I assume I don't need to tell you how an undecided reader is likely to view your refusal to turn over your analysis to qualified reviewers, when you insist it is the only valid analysis.

How would I know who any of you even are, let alone whether or not you are qualified.

People know who I am. We do not really know who you or many of the other posters on here actually are. This is why you can't be taken seriously.

Besides, it is not very hard to do the analysis if you have the knowledge to do simple static stress analysis. Do you?

If you can, do the analysis of girder A2001 with the stiffeners on it shown in Frankel drawing #9114, to see if its flange will fold when its web is past the seat at column 79, and then we can discuss it. If you and the others can't do this basic analysis then you have no business reviewing my work.

I gave you the information you need to do the analysis. If you have any other questions on the information send me a private message.
 
Last edited:
I gave you the information you need to do the analysis. If you have any other questions on the information send me a private message.

Wouldn't be a true comparison of analysis because you have not provided all the input assumptions you used (in your model).

If someone does an analysis, you claim they didn't consider X or misrepresents X. Get it?
 
How would I know who any of you even are, let alone whether or not you are qualified.

People know who I am. We do not really know who you or many of the other posters on here actually are. This is why you can't be taken seriously.

Why would any of this mater? If they find something wrong, you can set them set them straight, right?

I would think you of all people would support complete openness of your work. Wouldn't that fall in line with the true "truther" belief?
 
How would I know who any of you even are, let alone whether or not you are qualified.

Irrelevant. This is the forum you have chosen in which to present and discuss your claims. If you are unwilling to share the data and models on which those claims are based with the critics whom you have selected, then you have no right demanding respect from any of them. If your readers err in reviewing your model, then it would be their error alone, and your subsequent responsibility to identify the error. But if you refuse to supply the model under the presumption that your critics won't understand it, then all the error belongs to you, both in the presumption and in the mean spirit of berating critics whom you insist on keeping in the dark.

This is why you can't be taken seriously.

You want everyone to acknowledge you as a singularly insightful expert on this matter, but you're unwilling to submit to the process by which such eminence arises, even informally. This is likely why you aren't taken seriously -- especially by any whom you might claim as professional peers.

If you can, do...

Again attempting to shift the burden of proof. I assure you an undecided reader is quite able to see the obstacles you're trying to throw in the path of an independent review of your allegedly landmark work. And that undecided reader is probably, at this point, quite attuned to the blustery notion that none of your critics is smart enough to appreciate your genius. That argument grows tedious.

Once again I remind you that you choose to post here. Therefore whining about the alleged unworthiness of your critics is explicitly irrelevant, as are litmus tests you suddenly propose as gatekeeper criteria when others call your hand. If you don't want to hold the discussion here because you think we're all too uninformed, then make it available instead under the auspices an internationally recognized, relevant, peer-reviewed journal and present your discussion of it there. Those critics should be well worth your time.

If you're going to be selective about whom you choose to share your findings with, at least be credibly selective.

I gave you the information you need to do the analysis. If you have any other questions on the information send me a private message.

No, this is not a private thing. You make public arguments that rest upon data and methods you are unwilling to reveal in public. We're just supposed to take your word for it that you did it right. How is that even remotely scientifically valid? Emphasizing that unwillingness does not help you. If your analysis is as strong as you say, then its data, model, assumptions, and methods should speak for themselves.

The undecided reader has to answer the question whether it's the whole industry that's at fault and you're the only engineer who has managed to come up with the right answer, or whether the industry is generally correct (as is most often the case) and you are the one person who has made a crucial error out of inexperience or bias. Your unwillingness to have others examine your work pretty reasonably tips it toward the answer you don't like. What tips it further away is the hypocrisy between Truthers' call for the official investigation's models to be published and their unwillingness to publish their own models for outside review.

And no, someone else making his own model and basing his own analysis upon it doesn't answer the reader's questions about your claim, nor in the abstract sense determine whether your model is appropriate. When the question is whether your model is correct, there is absolutely no relevance in whether someone else's model is right or wrong.
 
Wouldn't be a true comparison of analysis because you have not provided all the input assumptions you used (in your model).

If someone does an analysis, you claim they didn't consider X or misrepresents X. Get it?

I just used the real drawings for the actual configuration where the seat was 12 inches wide and girder A2001 had 3/4" thick x 18" high stiffeners and put the beam's web past the seat and did the stress analysis to see if the flange would fail as NIST claimed after the beams pushed it 6.25" laterally to the west.

It really is quite straightforward.
 
Last edited:
Irrelevant. This is the forum you have chosen in which to present and discuss your claims. If you are unwilling to share the data and models on which those claims are based with the critics whom you have selected, then you have no right demanding respect from any of them. If your readers err in reviewing your model, then it would be their error alone, and your subsequent responsibility to identify the error. But if you refuse to supply the model under the presumption that your critics won't understand it, then all the error belongs to you, both in the presumption and in the mean spirit of berating critics whom you insist on keeping in the dark.



You want everyone to acknowledge you as a singularly insightful expert on this matter, but you're unwilling to submit to the process by which such eminence arises, even informally. This is likely why you aren't taken seriously -- especially by any whom you might claim as professional peers.



Again attempting to shift the burden of proof. I assure you an undecided reader is quite able to see the obstacles you're trying to throw in the path of an independent review of your allegedly landmark work. And that undecided reader is probably, at this point, quite attuned to the blustery notion that none of your critics is smart enough to appreciate your genius. That argument grows tedious.

Once again I remind you that you choose to post here. Therefore whining about the alleged unworthiness of your critics is explicitly irrelevant, as are litmus tests you suddenly propose as gatekeeper criteria when others call your hand. If you don't want to hold the discussion here because you think we're all too uninformed, then make it available instead under the auspices an internationally recognized, relevant, peer-reviewed journal and present your discussion of it there. Those critics should be well worth your time.

If you're going to be selective about whom you choose to share your findings with, at least be credibly selective.



No, this is not a private thing. You make public arguments that rest upon data and methods you are unwilling to reveal in public. We're just supposed to take your word for it that you did it right. How is that even remotely scientifically valid? Emphasizing that unwillingness does not help you. If your analysis is as strong as you say, then its data, model, assumptions, and methods should speak for themselves.

The undecided reader has to answer the question whether it's the whole industry that's at fault and you're the only engineer who has managed to come up with the right answer, or whether the industry is generally correct (as is most often the case) and you are the one person who has made a crucial error out of inexperience or bias. Your unwillingness to have others examine your work pretty reasonably tips it toward the answer you don't like. What tips it further away is the hypocrisy between Truthers' call for the official investigation's models to be published and their unwillingness to publish their own models for outside review.

And no, someone else making his own model and basing his own analysis upon it doesn't answer the reader's questions about your claim, nor in the abstract sense determine whether your model is appropriate. When the question is whether your model is correct, there is absolutely no relevance in whether someone else's model is right or wrong.

Stop being a blowhard and do the simple analysis.
 
How would I know who any of you even are, let alone whether or not you are qualified.

People know who I am. We do not really know who you or many of the other posters on here actually are. This is why you can't be taken seriously. ...
1] This is a false red herring. You have publicly published other works like “the jolt” . The reason you are not posting the girder analysis is because you know it’s wrong and are afraid.
2]
Send the diagram and inputs analysis to MHM and Newtons Bit for their review (this assumes they will care). They are licensed structural engineers and are more qualified that you, so that will no longer be an excuse.
3] Will you send them your complete analysis: answer simply – Yes or No. 4)
 
1] This is a false red herring. You have publicly published other works like “the jolt” . The reason you are not posting the girder analysis is because you know it’s wrong and are afraid.
2]
Send the diagram and inputs analysis to MHM and Newtons Bit for their review (this assumes they will care). They are licensed structural engineers and are more qualified that you, so that will no longer be an excuse.
3] Will you send them your complete analysis: answer simply – Yes or No. 4)

No, it isn't wrong, it is just that I don't have it right in front of me and since it is a simple analysis you should be able to do it quickly. I gave you the drawings, so you have the seat and girder with the stiffeners and know that NIST said the flange folded when the girder was pushed 6.25" and the web was past the seat.

I just realized it might take you a little time to determine the loads, so I will tell you. The load is 65,000 lbs. on that end of girder A2001.

Now you have everything you need to do what shouldn't take more than an hour provided you know how to calculate moment of inertia and shear and bending stress in the welds and parent material.
 
Last edited:
No, it isn't wrong, it is just that I don't have it right in front of me and since it is a simple analysis you should be able to do it quickly. I gave you the drawings, so you have the seat and girder with the stiffeners and know that NIST said the flange folded when the girder was pushed 6.25" and the web was past the seat.

I just realized it might take you a little time to determine the loads, so I will tell you. The load is 65,000 lbs. on that end of girder A2001.

Now you have everything you need to do what shouldn't take more than an hour provided you know how to calculate moment of inertia and shear and bending stress in the welds and parent material.

I don’t have to do my own analysis. NIST and their 200 top of the line experienced engineers, physicists and other experts already did it for me. The girder failed due to lateral-torsional buckling. As shown in NCSTAR 1-9 Section 8.8, their pg 349, and Section 11.2.9 their page 487, once the top girder compression flange rotated past the critical twist angle it lost its load carrying geometry and collapsed. The floor fell and column 79 lost its bracing and collapsed.
http://www.nist.gov/customcf/get_pdf.cfm?pub_id=861611

You are out of excuses. Do the simple analysis and send it to MHM and Newtons Bit in an hour.

Will you send them your complete analysis: answer simply – Yes or No.
 
I just used the real drawings for the actual configuration where the seat was 12 inches wide and girder A2001 had 3/4" thick x 18" high stiffeners and put the beam's web past the seat and did the stress analysis to see if the flange would fail as NIST claimed after the beams pushed it 6.25" laterally to the west.

It really is quite straightforward.
So the rest of the stricture was assumed to be "as built"? Do you consider this to be a reasonable assumption?
 
So the rest of the stricture was assumed to be "as built"? Do you consider this to be a reasonable assumption?

There are photographs showing the stiffeners on the end of girder A2001 in the "as built" configuration with it sitting on its seat at column 79.
 
Last edited:
I don’t have to do my own analysis. NIST and their 200 top of the line experienced engineers, physicists and other experts already did it for me. The girder failed due to lateral-torsional buckling. As shown in NCSTAR 1-9 Section 8.8, their pg 349, and Section 11.2.9 their page 487, once the top girder compression flange rotated past the critical twist angle it lost its load carrying geometry and collapsed. The floor fell and column 79 lost its bracing and collapsed.
http://www.nist.gov/customcf/get_pdf.cfm?pub_id=861611

You are out of excuses. Do the simple analysis and send it to MHM and Newtons Bit in an hour.

Will you send them your complete analysis: answer simply – Yes or No.

I would think MHM and Newton's Bit can do their own analyses and tell us whether or not the girder flange fails with the stiffeners on it.

Lateral torsional buckling isn't the failure mode NIST claims. They have an alternate analysis in Chapter 8 where the girder is pulled back to the east by buckled beams but they say that was only preliminary and not what they support as a failure mode.

In Chapters 11 and 12 they claim the east side girder flange folded as it was not sufficient to take the bending stress once the web was past the seat to the west.
 
Last edited:
I would think MHM and Newton's Bit can do their own analyses and tell us whether or not the girder flange fails with the stiffeners on it.
Perhaps you misunderstood the question I asked:
Will you send them your complete analysis: answer simply – Yes or No.
 
I would think MHM and Newton's Bit can do their own analyses and tell us whether or not the girder flange fails with the stiffeners on it.

Lateral torsional buckling isn't the failure mode NIST claims. They have an alternate analysis in Chapter 8 where the girder is pulled back to the east by buckled beams but they say that was only preliminary and not what they support as a failure mode.

In Chapters 11 and 12 they claim the east side girder flange folded as it was not sufficient to take the bending stress once the web was past the seat to the west.
You are out of fake excuses. Your are wrong, you are afraid and you know it.
Will you send them your complete analysis: answer simply – Yes or No.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom