Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

It is part of the narrative of the event that has been presented. Do you contend it is appropriate to be skeptical/not be skeptical about only certain aspects of this event?

I contend that it's appropriate to be skeptical only of the relevant facts. Whether or not he's a bona fide genius is irrelevant to the response of the authorities.

As to how we judge his treatment by the school and police, what he actually built or didn't build is somewhat relevant. For example, the highly credible accusation that he didn't build anything worthwhile at all should lead a skeptic to question his motive for bringing his "invention" to school.

Why? Kid cheats for recognition. News at 11.
 
Our society has reached such a pathetic point of disconnect from the Means Of Production of our material culture that a whole movement has spawned where grownups tear down clocks and lamps and hot glue the parts on other things. It's Cargo Cult understanding of what things are and how they work. An average kid today probably hasn't had the joy of surviving the Wrath Of Dad for disassembling a Big Ben alarm clock. I did, more than once.

The process of disassembling a manufactured object is an educational act all by itself. By reassembling the parts in an open architecture frame Ahmed created a bench-ready piece of research hardware. He might not have any idea what to do next, but he demonstrated basic understanding of the device and named the sub components. I'll check GO for that task.

Deconstruction and reconstruction of objects is not always the result of simple disassembly. The display might not work as intended, just inferring from something he said. But it was screwed on to the lid. Obviously the power supply worked, was connected, and probably taught him an important safety lesson along the way regarding the need to screw things down. Some very fundamental mindset lessons are embedded in solving the frustration of trying to parse a thing with a multimeter and having wires bust off the board. I saw evidence of solder rework on at least one part of his clock.

So he get a GO for bench rugged and a GO for repair as needed to restore basic functionality.

He gets a NO GO for plugging it in during English class. Confiscation until the end of day and maybe a yellow slip that needs signing by a parent to get it back.
 
He may not have made any electrical modifications, however he did make a case mod. The crystal display is clearly screwed into the pencil case. And it may have been a lot cleaner and well put together before the police got their hands on it. In any event, he's 14, you shouldn't expect a masterpiece. He was tinkering, told everyone he was tinkering, and was proud of his tinkering. Give the 14-year old a break.

Being a nerd is not a crime.

And this is where defending him requires reaching. Yes, case-modding is fine and grand. But he didn't tell anybody that he "case modded" a clock; that wasn't the narrative. He told everyone that he invented a clock. And it's not some minor semantic heckle; he repeatedly, in multiple interviews, refers to the clock as "his invention" and the way he talks about having built it very clearly implies we're intended to believe he used some kind of special electronics knowledge to piece together a working clock out of individual parts.

At the very beginning of this video for instance:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3mW4w0Y1OXE

Ahmed shows another example of an object he clearly did not "invent" in any meaningful sense; a large PCB with some attached I/O boards and a speaker, likely the innards of a radio, stereo, or other type of music or perhaps video player, and likely again taken in their entirety from the appliance as opposed to assembled. He comments that "I invent things, I make this type of stuff" as he shows off the nest of components, the names of only some of which he even barely knows, and which are not sitting in any kind of casing whatsoever. And he uses the exact same language to describe this object that he uses to describe the clock he "made", which makes it a very hard sell to assert that when he says he "built" and "invented" the clock he actually meant to convey that he had merely "case-modded" an existing clock. Unless you want to argue that no case is a case-mod.

Based on the language he has used in describing the devices he has "invented" I have yet to see any evidence that he has even a rudimentary grasp of electronics, or is aware of what half the components of his invented clock even are, much less what they do.
 
Last edited:
He may not have made any electrical modifications, however he did make a case mod. The crystal display is clearly screwed into the pencil case. And it may have been a lot cleaner and well put together before the police got their hands on it. In any event, he's 14, you shouldn't expect a masterpiece. He was tinkering, told everyone he was tinkering, and was proud of his tinkering. Give the 14-year old a break.

Being a nerd is not a crime.

He should have made it so the alarm played "Puttin' on the Ritz", from a tinny sound chip.




Explanation for youngsters: In "Young Frankenstein", the monster was debuted to the public by doing a tap dance number to "Puttin' on the Ritz". Rather than focus on the fact that dead tissue had been reassembled and animated, the crowd focused on the fact that the monster was a lousy tap dancer.

The corollary to this one is that they aren't focusing on a kid who has an interest in electronics and initiative to act on that interest, but focusing on what an unimpressive job he did.
 
And this is where defending him requires reaching. Yes, case-modding is fine and grand. But he didn't tell anybody that he "case modded" a clock; that wasn't the narrative. He told everyone that he invented a clock. And it's not some minor semantic heckle; he repeatedly, in multiple interviews, refers to the clock as "his invention" and the way he talks about having built it very clearly implies we're intended to believe he used some kind of special electronics knowledge to piece together a working clock out of individual parts.

At the very beginning of this video for instance:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3mW4w0Y1OXE

Ahmed shows another example of an object he clearly did not "invent" in any meaningful sense; a large PCB with some attached I/O boards and a speaker, likely the innards of a radio, stereo, or other type of music or perhaps video player, and likely again taken in their entirety from the appliance as opposed to assembled. He comments that "I invent things, I make this type of stuff" as he shows off the nest of components, which are not sitting in any kind of casing whatsoever. And he uses the exact same language to describe this object that he uses to describe the clock he "made", which makes it a very hard sell to assert that when he says he "built" and "invented" the clock he actually meant to convey that he had merely "case-modded" an existing clock.


This is unbelievable. A 9th grader's claim that his clock innards in a book case are his "invention" is simply not noteworthy, except possibly to his teacher, school principal and parents, who may apply mild correction to stop him making such claims and to explain to him the meaning of the word "invention."

The only reason we're talking about him is that a completely and obviously harmless and easily identifiable smidgen of electronic components caused said 9th grader to be cuffed and hauled off for questioning. That he mislabeled his clock innards as his own invention has nothing to do with nut-so overreaction of the police. I have an idea about motives: Those making claims that this kid's use of the word "invention" is relevant to this discussion are desperate apologists for unfettered police power.
 
Checkmite, you're requiring a 14-year to use perfect jargon for things he's experimenting with and learning about. I'm not the one who's reaching.
 
Ahmed shows another example of an object he clearly did not "invent" in any meaningful sense; a large PCB with some attached I/O boards and a speaker, likely the innards of a radio, stereo, or other type of music or perhaps video player,...

Based on the language he has used in describing the devices he has "invented" I have yet to see any evidence that he has even a rudimentary grasp of electronics, or is aware of what half the components of his invented clock even are, much less what they do.

In other words, he has clear interest in the subject, but his knowledge is almost zero. Maybe what we need is a place where people with interest, but little knowledge, could be taught to act on their interest. A place that would help inspire kids to learn what they need in order to fulfill their dreams. A place where experienced individuals could share what it really means to "invent" things, and guide youngsters to become actual inventors. If we had such a place, Ahmed could have taken it there, and they would have helped him take the next step.

Instead, he took it to school, where he was arrested.
 
Checkmite, you're requiring a 14-year to use perfect jargon for things he's experimenting with and learning about. I'm not the one who's reaching.

Not in the least. Inventing isn't merely "the wrong word"; it has a rather unmistakable definition and saying "I invented this" implies something very specific. And it's not beyond the grasp of a high schooler.

If he were 7, maybe, and you wanted to tell me that perhaps he was unwittingly using the word "invent" incorrectly, I would likely accept that as plausible.
 
Checkmite, you're requiring a 14-year to use perfect jargon for things he's experimenting with and learning about. I'm not the one who's reaching.

I'd expect a 14 year old to know what inventing something means, but I don't see how it matters to this story other than that the media and other people like to repeat convenient mistruths and then accuse anyone who corrects them as being a bigot or some other name.
 
This is unbelievable. A 9th grader's claim that his clock innards in a book case are his "invention" is simply not noteworthy, except possibly to his teacher, school principal and parents, who may apply mild correction to stop him making such claims and to explain to him the meaning of the word "invention."

The only reason we're talking about him is that a completely and obviously harmless and easily identifiable smidgen of electronic components caused said 9th grader to be cuffed and hauled off for questioning. That he mislabeled his clock innards as his own invention has nothing to do with nut-so overreaction of the police. I have an idea about motives: Those making claims that this kid's use of the word "invention" is relevant to this discussion are desperate apologists for unfettered police power.

A naive kid who might not speak English at home is now chastised for naive use of the word "invention" to describe his naive experiments with deconstructing and reconstructing technology.

Bad Ahmed! Bad!

Can we move on?
 
Checkmite, you're requiring a 14-year to use perfect jargon for things he's experimenting with and learning about. I'm not the one who's reaching.

Indeed, and as hgc says below, especially in the highlighted part, his ability isn't the case. He took his modification to school to show the teachers - presumably because he was enthusiastic, and was accused of trying to make a hoax bomb.


This is unbelievable. A 9th grader's claim that his clock innards in a book case are his "invention" is simply not noteworthy, except possibly to his teacher, school principal and parents, who may apply mild correction to stop him making such claims and to explain to him the meaning of the word "invention."
The only reason we're talking about him is that a completely and obviously harmless and easily identifiable smidgen of electronic components caused said 9th grader to be cuffed and hauled off for questioning. That he mislabeled his clock innards as his own invention has nothing to do with nut-so overreaction of the police. I have an idea about motives: Those making claims that this kid's use of the word "invention" is relevant to this discussion are desperate apologists for unfettered police power.

In addition the fact that it was recognised that it wasn't a bomb is part of the problem, because the narrative is that he brought in a modified clock that didn't look like a real bomb and which the family state he always said it was a clock.

Against that, we have someone who said that they thought it didn't look like a real bomb, but a fake one, and also that he was "passive aggressive" when asked about it. It's probably a good thing that teacher isn't in the UK, as they sound rather dim, and would likely be regular recipients of passive aggressive comments and sarcasm from any brighter kids that they taught.

ETA:

In other words, he has clear interest in the subject, but his knowledge is almost zero. Maybe what we need is a place where people with interest, but little knowledge, could be taught to act on their interest. A place that would help inspire kids to learn what they need in order to fulfill their dreams. A place where experienced individuals could share what it really means to "invent" things, and guide youngsters to become actual inventors. If we had such a place, Ahmed could have taken it there, and they would have helped him take the next step.

Instead, he took it to school, where he was arrested.
Well said
 
Last edited:
Checkmite, you're requiring a 14-year to use perfect jargon for things he's experimenting with and learning about. I'm not the one who's reaching.

Not in the least. Inventing isn't merely "the wrong word"; it has a rather unmistakable definition and saying "I invented this" implies something very specific. And it's not beyond the grasp of a high schooler.

If he were 7, maybe, and you wanted to tell me that perhaps he was unwittingly using the word "invent" incorrectly, I would likely accept that as plausible.

I am going to assume that your real world experience with 14 yo 9th graders is limited. I have one living in my house and have (almost) daily interactions with several more. I would find it quite plausible that one or more of my young teenage acquaintances would use the word invention to describe a similar creation of their own. I can assure you that striving for linguistic accuracy in their daily conversations is not a priority for these kids. They use many words "incorrectly" but somehow the message still gets through.
 
Not in the least. Inventing isn't merely "the wrong word"; it has a rather unmistakable definition and saying "I invented this" implies something very specific. And it's not beyond the grasp of a high schooler.

If he were 7, maybe, and you wanted to tell me that perhaps he was unwittingly using the word "invent" incorrectly, I would likely accept that as plausible.
Exactly! What the school and police did was beyond stupid, but this kid didn't invent anything. He didn't even improve an existing product, if anything he took a perfectly functioning product and made it less practical.

He's not some electronics prodigy worthy of all the attention he's getting from MIT and Microsoft and Facebook. It's like getting take-out at a restaurant, dumping it all on a dinner plate and claiming you cooked it and then getting nationally known restaurants crowing about what a great chef you are. Or plagiarizing a book but putting it in a new binding and then being hailed as a great budding author by all the big publishers. It's bizarro world.
 
Exactly! What the school and police did was beyond stupid, but this kid didn't invent anything. He didn't even improve an existing product, if anything he took a perfectly functioning product and made it less practical.

He's not some electronics prodigy worthy of all the attention he's getting from MIT and Microsoft and Facebook. It's like getting take-out at a restaurant, dumping it all on a dinner plate and claiming you cooked it and then getting nationally known restaurants crowing about what a great chef you are. Or plagiarizing a book but putting it in a new binding and then being hailed as a great budding author by all the big publishers. It's bizarro world.

Are you arguing against something that someone has claimed?
 
He was told not to show any other teachers; an instruction which he pointedly disobeyed when he took the object out during English class and even plugged it in.

Do you have any evidence he took it out of the bag and plugged it in ?

Otherwise, I assume it was running off battery back-up and the alarm went off accidentally,as was claimed.

And this is where defending him requires reaching. Yes, case-modding is fine and grand. But he didn't tell anybody that he "case modded" a clock; that wasn't the narrative. He told everyone that he invented a clock. And it's not some minor semantic heckle; he repeatedly, in multiple interviews, refers to the clock as "his invention" and the way he talks about having built it very clearly implies we're intended to believe he used some kind of special electronics knowledge to piece together a working clock out of individual parts.


At any rate, even though 14 year aren't usually wordsmiths (Is english even his first language ?):

in·vent
inˈvent/Submit
verb
create or design (something that has not existed before); be the originator of.
"he invented an improved form of the steam engine"

Unless you can show me some existing pencil case digital clocks, I think he invented it.
 
In other words, he has clear interest in the subject, but his knowledge is almost zero. Maybe what we need is a place where people with interest, but little knowledge, could be taught to act on their interest. A place that would help inspire kids to learn what they need in order to fulfill their dreams. A place where experienced individuals could share what it really means to "invent" things, and guide youngsters to become actual inventors. If we had such a place, Ahmed could have taken it there, and they would have helped him take the next step.

Instead, he took it to school, where he was arrested.

Separately, the business with involving the police was inexcusably ridiculous.

Back on target; certainly it's okay for someone to be interested in something they have zero knowledge in. In a child that interest should be cultivated at any reasonable cost.

What should not be cultivated - what should, in fact, be actively and positively discouraged - is an attitude that "fake it 'til you make it" is an acceptable way to proceed.

Say for instance, a very young child is keenly interested in drawing, but (like basically all very young children) obviously they don't start out very good at it. But you want to encourage that child to learn. So you praise the efforts they make and what skill they do have, and take note of and validate even small improvements as they learn.

If, however, you observe the child tracing a drawing, and then showing off to his friends and bragging that he drew it freehand, you do not want to encourage that behavior, you want to make it clear that you do not approve of and support it. I don't mean calling out and embarrassing the child in front of his peers; but on the other hand, you do not tack that drawing up on the wall or stick it on the fridge. You do not praise such an effort of deception, call it a "good job for someone his/her age", prevaricate by calling it "a well-done case of tracing", excuse it by claiming "tracing can help teach drawing techniques" while completely sidestepping the fact of his attempt at deception, or justify it as an acceptable expression of "interest in learning", because it isn't, it's just interest in attention and attaining the rewards of effort without bothering with the effort. The child didn't tell his friends he drew it by himself because he was trying to make them admire him for being a "really good tracer".

So it is in this case - only there's less room for patience on the part of a teacher, because while very young children are impulsive and they haven't always fully formed values like the importance of honest presentation and effort, a teenage high school student has been around the block a few times and has no excuse for not knowing that cheating or being otherwise dishonest about the way he presents his work is "wrong"; at that point it starts to become an integrity problem.
 
Last edited:
In other words, he has clear interest in the subject, but his knowledge is almost zero. Maybe what we need is a place where people with interest, but little knowledge, could be taught to act on their interest. A place that would help inspire kids to learn what they need in order to fulfill their dreams. A place where experienced individuals could share what it really means to "invent" things, and guide youngsters to become actual inventors. If we had such a place, Ahmed could have taken it there, and they would have helped him take the next step.

Instead, he took it to school, where he was arrested.

Followed by adults posting long screeds on the internet criticizing his abilities in electronics, his abilities to use precise English, and what he "should have known" regarding the paranoia and over reaction of some adults in his school and on the police force.
 
Separately, the business with involving the police was inexcusably ridiculous.

Back on target; certainly it's okay for someone to be interested in something they have zero knowledge in. In a child that interest should be cultivated at any reasonable cost.

What should not be cultivated - what should, in fact, be actively and positively discouraged - is an attitude that "fake it 'til you make it" is an acceptable way to proceed.

Say for instance, a very young child is keenly interested in drawing, but (like basically all very young children) obviously they don't start out very good at it. But you want to encourage that child to learn. So you praise the efforts they make and what skill they do have, and take note of and validate even small improvements as they learn.

If, however, you observe the child tracing a drawing, and then showing off to his friends and bragging that he drew it freehand, you do not want to encourage that behavior, you want to make it clear that you do not approve of and support it. I don't mean calling out and embarrassing the child in front of his peers; but on the other hand, you do not tack that drawing up on the wall or stick it on the fridge. You do not praise such an effort of deception, call it a "good job for someone his/her age", prevaricate by calling it "a well-done case of tracing", excuse it by claiming "tracing can help teach drawing techniques" while completely sidestepping the fact of his attempt at deception, or justify it as an acceptable expression of "interest in learning", because it isn't, it's just interest in attention and attaining the rewards of effort without bothering with the effort. The child didn't tell his friends he drew it by himself because he was trying to make them admire him for being a "really good tracer".

So it is in this case - only there's less room for patience on the part of a teacher, because while very young children are impulsive and they haven't always fully formed values like the importance of honest presentation and effort, a teenage high school student has been around the block a few times and has no excuse for not knowing that cheating or being otherwise dishonest about the way he presents his work is "wrong"; at that point it starts to become an integrity problem.

Well said. It's kind of amazing how low an opinion of 14 year olds that people here seem to have. While 14 year olds are just kids in some respects, they are not really kids like 6 year olds, or even 10 year olds are. In Massachusetts, which is hardly some backwater, a 14 year old accused of murder is tried as an adult. There are also thousands, if not tens of thousands of 14 year olds in this country, who could pass for accomplished adults in many disciplines, their youthful appearance notwithstanding.

The vast majority of the kids in this high level performance (including the soloist) are 14 or younger:

 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom