The Mentality of Skeptics

That's not it.
Pseudo-skepticism is when you cloak your existing irrational belief(s) or irrational mindset in skeptically sounding rhetoric.

That's pretty much the same thing, except I forgot to add that they try to hide behind the label of skeptic.
 
That's pretty much the same thing, except I forgot to add that they try to hide behind the label of skeptic.

Lying and Projection, fearful of Bigfoot's rejection.
Underhanded practices and blatant misdirection.
Avoidance of honest questions,
never learning lessons.
Logging in now every day
to enjoy your gaming sessions.

E.T.A

Have a Happy New Year, OS, and use it wisely, eh?
 
Last edited:
Why not simply propose that all Bigfoot skeptics lie all the time? That we live with Bigfoots as valets who both live in our closets and help plan the outfits for us to wear each day, but lie to avoid admitting their existence? Why even bother with pop-psychology stuff? Lying works even better as an explanation and as an irritating conclusion to generate more posts.

I am even lying to you right now! (sorry if this paradox causes your computer to blow up just like in an episode of the original Star Trek.)
 
Last edited:
Why not simply propose that all Bigfoot skeptics lie all the time?

They lie to themselves, not to others. These are people who are somewhat well-read on the subject, except are trying to convince themselves that Sasquatch aren't real. They lie to themselves about the quality and quantity of evidence. This is to remove the cognitive dissonance that comes with not knowing the answer.

The belief that Bigfoot doesn't exist is supposed to be supported by a lack of evidence, except the evidence isn't really lacking and that's why their belief is so fragile.
 
They lie to themselves, not to others. These are people who are somewhat well-read on the subject, except are trying to convince themselves that Sasquatch aren't real. They lie to themselves about the quality and quantity of evidence. This is to remove the cognitive dissonance that comes with not knowing the answer.

The belief that Bigfoot doesn't exist is supposed to be supported by a lack of evidence, except the evidence isn't really lacking and that's why their belief is so fragile.
Evidence?
 
The belief that Bigfoot doesn't exist is supposed to be supported by a lack of evidence, except the evidence isn't really lacking and that's why their belief is so fragile.

I recommend you read Arthur Conan Doyle's Coming of the Fairies. He was deluded into believing that 18" inch fairies gamboled and frolicked in the English countryside - a proposition far more plausible than undetected 8' apes creeping about North America a century later - but it's stunning how closely his "arguments" match yours.

Bigfoot is too scary to photograph; fairies don't cast shadows because they're made of glowing ectoplasm.
 
They lie to themselves, not to others. These are people who are somewhat well-read on the subject, except are trying to convince themselves that Sasquatch aren't real. They lie to themselves about the quality and quantity of evidence. This is to remove the cognitive dissonance that comes with not knowing the answer.

The belief that Bigfoot doesn't exist is supposed to be supported by a lack of evidence, except the evidence isn't really lacking and that's why their belief is so fragile.

 
The belief that Bigfoot doesn't exist is supposed to be supported by a lack of evidence, except the evidence isn't really lacking and that's why their belief is so fragile.
The evidence put forth by Bigfootery is the stuff that can be faked. The evidence that cannot be faked is about the only evidence that has not been presented. It is the necessary evidence. It is missing.

This is exactly what we would expect for a mythical and legendary creature. It is not what we expect for an actual creature. Bigfoot meets the criteria for a mythical being which is loved by a certain segment of society as if it were an actual being. The society as a whole has already embraced Bigfoot as an American myth. You can see this by looking at pop culture. Bigfoot is portrayed in TV commercials (Jack Links) and cable TV (Finding Bigfoot) as something that we all know about and can be entertained by.

The Jack Links commercials wouldn't make any sense or even be funny to American society if Bigfoot was a real being.
 
But bigfoot is lacking.

Sorry, but OS presents nothing and we must apparently be afraid of this nothing because OS says so. You are afraid of this nothing, I am afraid of this nothing, in fact every participant in this thread is afraid of this nothing. Because OS says so and whatever OS says is true.

Go ahead and work that out.
 
You were told that this thread, like all other OS threads, was about Bigfoot a fortnight ago. Have you been extremely inebriated since then, or do you just feign ignorance on a regular basis?

LOL @ "original intent." The thread is obviously about Bigfoot, it always has been, there was no original intent to delve into the supposed mentality of sceptics, this is about as clear as clear can be, or it at least should be, if you're sober. I'm astounded that anyone actually presumed OS was at all interested in scepticism or any aspect of its workings.

His avatar is a bloke in a bad Chewie suit with a diaper on. I'll let that sink in for a moment.

The title is "Mentality of a skeptic" not once in that first post did the word Bigfoot, Sasquatch, ect. come up. He talked about ambiguity and cognitive dissonance and the ability or inability to tolarate ambiguity. Which is basically, cognitive closure. No Bigfoots.

By post 23 the Bigfoot derailing occurs. I got it back on track by pounding on the psychology issues, but the the thread got rejacked by the herd mentality and group think of this forum.

Again, psychology seems to make the majority of people here very uncomfortable.
 
Sorry, but OS presents nothing and we must apparently be afraid of this nothing because OS says so. You are afraid of this nothing, I am afraid of this nothing, in fact every participant in this thread is afraid of this nothing. Because OS says so and whatever OS says is true.
...
The most afraid is OS. A strong, (almost) pathological belief in bigfoot, but no sign of an actual bigfoot anywhere, anytime, including the future.
OS is afraid for his irrational belief. There's only only way to maintain it .....
 
The title is "Mentality of a skeptic" not once in that first post did the word Bigfoot, Sasquatch, ect. come up. He talked about ambiguity and cognitive dissonance and the ability or inability to tolarate ambiguity. Which is basically, cognitive closure. No Bigfoots.

By post 23 the Bigfoot derailing occurs. I got it back on track by pounding on the psychology issues, but the the thread got rejacked by the herd mentality and group think of this forum.

Again, psychology seems to make the majority of people here very uncomfortable.

I think OP is the most uncomfortable with his non skepticism regarding bigfoot. The unfortunate lack of an actual bigfoot anywhere and apparently anytime makes the OP very uncomfortable.
 
The title is "Mentality of a skeptic" not once in that first post did the word Bigfoot, Sasquatch, ect. come up. He talked about ambiguity and cognitive dissonance and the ability or inability to tolarate ambiguity. Which is basically, cognitive closure. No Bigfoots.
Cognitive dissonance? You joined the thread at post #107 by which time OS had gone way down the bigfoot rabbit hole and contributed a whole bunch of "Laws" that were entirely made of whole cloth.

By post 23 the Bigfoot derailing occurs. I got it back on track by pounding on the psychology issues, but the the thread got rejacked by the herd mentality and group think of this forum.
Rejacked by OS who wanted this to be about bigfoot from the start.

Again, psychology seems to make the majority of people here very uncomfortable.
Errrr, no. No, not at all.
 
By post 23 the Bigfoot derailing occurs. I got it back on track by pounding on the psychology issues, but the the thread got rejacked by the herd mentality and group think of this forum.

Since there is no Bigfoot, any conversation about Bigfoot naturally must turn into a discussion of the disordered thinking that is required to believe in it. In this case, Ontario Squatch reversed the process.

Pointing out that OS's worldview only exists to justify Bigfoot is fair comment.
 
Again, psychology seems to make the majority of people here very uncomfortable.

The idea that there's something wrong with rejecting ridiculous, unsupported conceits cannot be propped up by fake analysis; we'll just continue to laugh and shake our heads.

It's true, though, that laughing and shaking one's head can become uncomfortable if one doesn't take a break every few hours.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom