Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

Given that this is your response to my answer to a question as to where my evidence could be found, forgive me for being critical of your claim to be a "good critical thinker."
My, the butthurt is strong in this one.

Yes, the question was where, and you provided a link. Here.

What you're not getting is that you can point to something and say "this is the evidence" but if the interpretation is ambiguous then someone could reject that evidence. In other words, to them you have not provided the evidence because what you provided was not evidence.

Here is a plastic knife. This is evidence that I do not starch my jeans.


To borrow a bigfoot example, I could ask for evidence of bigfoot and someone could respond with a post that included a link to the Patterson/Gimlin film. A few pages later, I might ask for evidence again and be directed to the post with the PGF. The problem is that the PGF is not evidence of bigfoot, it's evidence that people will sometimes produce hoaxes of bigfoot.
 
My, the butthurt is strong in this one.

Yes, the question was where, and you provided a link. Here.

What you're not getting is that you can point to something and say "this is the evidence" but if the interpretation is ambiguous then someone could reject that evidence. In other words, to them you have not provided the evidence because what you provided was not evidence.

catsmate put scare quotes around evidence, which refutes your interpretation. And this while admitting that he or she hasn't even found the evidence yet. I'm sure that rejecting evidence before one has even seen it shows "good critical thinking."
 
Last edited:
In case anyone hadn't noticed, here is yet another example of caveman1917's shameless and blatant troll tactics.
Here is my original post:

Seems to me you made a claim that democracy doesn't exist, and then changed it to a claim that democracy doesn't exist in the US. That is a quite different position. Hence my request for "statistically relevant" evidence. Not "statistically-based" evidence. There is a major difference there. You have only provided evidence for the US, which is not in any way statistically relevant, given that, by some standards at least, there are 123 democracies in the world, out of 192 countries.
Source: http://www.borgenmagazine.com/many-democratic-nations/

Even allowing you to redefine your original claim, there still remains the issue of the evidence you have provided to support this claim. I will admit I have not read the entirety of the report, but the summary and conclusions do not appear to match the conclusion you are claiming. For example, from the conclusion:
Americans do enjoy many features
central to democratic governance, such as regular elections,
freedom of speech and association, and a widespread
(if still contested) franchise. But we believe that if
policymaking is dominated by powerful business organizations
and a small number of affluent Americans, then
America’s claims to being a democratic society are seriously
threatened.
This is a long way from concluding that democracy does not exist in the US.
Moreover, this study is not, to my understanding, that solid at all. I am no statistician, I will freely admit, but there are objections to the methodology that I will not pretend to understand:
http://www.newyorker.com/news/john-cassidy/is-america-an-oligarchy

You are still, it seems to me, doing everything I asked you not to do: moving the goalposts, and applying a clear double standard of evidence. Add to that your continued insulting and confrontational approach, plus a marked tendency to avoid referring to any points or evidence that contradict your stated beliefs. Net result? You are provoking, or attempting to provoke, reactions in other posters, that are (perhaps understandably) less than kind, and then shouting this from the rooftops. That, to me, is classic troll behaviour. If you were actually serious about addressing the issues at hand, and trying to resolve our differences, you would be doing almost the opposite of this. I am still hopeful that you are not a troll, and wish to engage in a rational and honest conversation.
Do please prove me right, in this at least.

This is represented by caveman1917 as this:

True to some extent. The people who engaged with the evidence are you, Dave Rogers and Cosmic Yak.

Cosmic Yak acknowledged not being able to objectively evaluate the evidence for lack of prior knowledge, but did indeed make a good-faith attempt in providing a link to some objections.

I think the difference is obvious, and cannot be simply explained away by simple error or oversight.
Unapologetic trolling. Pointless and unproductive, at least for anyone who is not caveman1917.
 
Another error, negatives can sometimes be proven. The claim "democracy doesn't exist" could, for instance, be proven by showing that all governments in the scope under consideration are dictatorships.

No, it would have to be proven by showing that all governments and organisations in existence everywhere are not democratic. If one democratic organization exists, then democracy exists. And the best you could possibly advance in evidence is that all governments and organisations you are personally aware of are not democratic.

And still, you made a negative claim that "democracy doesn't exist" and backed it up with a single study that doesn't even agree with your claim. From the excerpt posted above by Cosmic Yak, one can deduce that if "America’s claims to being a democratic society" are merely "seriously
threatened," then those claims are currently extant.

Rather than be amused perhaps you should think instead.

It's even more amusing, in the light of the above, that you take it as a given that everyone disagreeing with you doesn't.

Dave
 
In case anyone hadn't noticed, here is yet another example of caveman1917's shameless and blatant troll tactics.

I see I misjudged, should've included you in the "subjective, fallacy-laden derision of the claimant" group.

Here is my original post:

Seems to me you made a claim that democracy doesn't exist, and then changed it to a claim that democracy doesn't exist in the US. That is a quite different position. Hence my request for "statistically relevant" evidence. Not "statistically-based" evidence. There is a major difference there. You have only provided evidence for the US, which is not in any way statistically relevant, given that, by some standards at least, there are 123 democracies in the world, out of 192 countries.
Source: http://www.borgenmagazine.com/many-democratic-nations/

Meh.

Even allowing you to redefine your original claim, there still remains the issue of the evidence you have provided to support this claim. I will admit I have not read the entirety of the report, but the summary and conclusions do not appear to match the conclusion you are claiming. For example, from the conclusion:
Quote:
Americans do enjoy many features
central to democratic governance, such as regular elections,
freedom of speech and association, and a widespread
(if still contested) franchise. But we believe that if
policymaking is dominated by powerful business organizations
and a small number of affluent Americans, then
America’s claims to being a democratic society are seriously
threatened.

This is a long way from concluding that democracy does not exist in the US.

1. Admitting to not having even read the entire report.
2. Providing someone's personal beliefs as evidence. Given that we can all find someone whose personal belief coincides with what we want to assert, this should obviously get rejected on sight.

Here is an example of how easy it is to make this sort of argument:
"Yes, friends, governments in capitalist society are but committees of the rich to manage the affairs of the capitalist class." - James Connolly

Moreover, this study is not, to my understanding, that solid at all. I am no statistician, I will freely admit, but there are objections to the methodology that I will not pretend to understand:
http://www.newyorker.com/news/john-c...a-an-oligarchy

3. Providing a link to some objections.
4. Admitting to "not being a statistician" and not understanding the objections.

You are still, it seems to me, doing everything I asked you not to do: moving the goalposts, and applying a clear double standard of evidence. Add to that your continued insulting and confrontational approach, plus a marked tendency to avoid referring to any points or evidence that contradict your stated beliefs. Net result? You are provoking, or attempting to provoke, reactions in other posters, that are (perhaps understandably) less than kind, and then shouting this from the rooftops. That, to me, is classic troll behaviour. If you were actually serious about addressing the issues at hand, and trying to resolve our differences, you would be doing almost the opposite of this. I am still hopeful that you are not a troll, and wish to engage in a rational and honest conversation.
Do please prove me right, in this at least.

5. Attacking the arguer rather than the argument.

This is represented by caveman1917 as this:
Cosmic Yak acknowledged not being able to objectively evaluate the evidence for lack of prior knowledge, but did indeed make a good-faith attempt in providing a link to some objections.

After rejection of point 2 above we are left with
- Not having read the entire report.
- Providing a link to some objections.
- Not being able to objectively evaluate the evidence ("not understanding the objections") for lack of prior knowledge ("I'm not a statistician").

Look at that, that almost looks like exactly what I said.
 
Last edited:
No, it would have to be proven by showing that all governments and organisations in existence everywhere are not democratic. If one democratic organization exists, then democracy exists. And the best you could possibly advance in evidence is that all governments and organisations you are personally aware of are not democratic.

Meh.

And still, you made a negative claim that "democracy doesn't exist" and backed it up with a single study that doesn't even agree with your claim. From the excerpt posted above by Cosmic Yak, one can deduce that if "America’s claims to being a democratic society" are merely "seriously
threatened," then those claims are currently extant.

Also using someone's personal beliefs as evidence. Not concluding to include you in the "subjective, fallacy-laden derision of the claimant" group as you're still missing "derision." But I'll conclude to reduce your "objective evaluation of the claims made" contribution from 0.5 to 0, because using personal belief as argument is necessarily subjective and hence not objective.

It's even more amusing, in the light of the above, that you take it as a given that everyone disagreeing with you doesn't.

I don't take it as a given, only when it's clear that is actually happening. You could for instance notice that The Shrike disagreed with me yet I don't take it as a given that he or she isn't thinking, which refutes your statement. That you fail to reach this conclusion is why I conclude you should perhaps start thinking rather than "being amused."
 
Last edited:
Also using someone's personal beliefs as evidence.

So when you cite a report it's irrefutable evidence that proves your claim beyond argument, but when we point out that the conclusion actually disagrees with your claim then suddenly it's merely a personal belief? And yet you're allowed to shrug off criticism with "Meh"?

No, I think being amused is actually the rational response.

Dave
 
Last edited:
caveman1917 said:
Also using someone's personal beliefs as evidence.
So when you cite a report it's irrefutable evidence that proves your claim beyond argument, but when we point out that the conclusion actually disagrees with your claim then suddenly it's merely a personal belief? And yet you're allowed to shrug off criticism with "Meh"?

No, I think being amused is actually the rational response.

Dave

Exactly. The quote is from the conclusion of the report.
caveman1917: either you did not recognise the quote, in which case you clearly didn't read the report you linked to, or you did, and are now distancing yourself from the conclusions of the only evidence you have presented to support your claim. Not a great choice, it must be said. Something about rocks and hard places springs to mind.
I would hope for an answer more detailed and productive than "meh", but the limits of my optimism have now been exceeded. I'm with Dave on the idea that amusement is the only rational response.
 
To be fair, he also linked to a German research study that also does not back up his assertions. So that would be two self-refuting sources, not just one.
 
Two things.

Thing #1
Some posts related to democracy and whether the US be a democratic nation were moved to AAH in error, and they have been returned. My error. I apologize.

Thing #2
The democracy arc really is a derail, but it was intertwined extensively into this thread and isn't easily split out. It is also in the wrong subforum to qualify as thread drift.

So, please in this thread stay with the original topic or something closely related. Anyone wanting to continue the democracy / not democracy and related discussions, please start a new thread (or threads) in an appropriate section of the forum. (From the several posts I read, Conspiracies and Conspiracy Theories would be a good match.)

Thank you in advance for your cooperation.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jsfisher
 
I did not claim "democracy doesn't exist because people believe it doesn't" but I claimed the idea "Is not silly to the population in general (60% of Germans believe democracy isn't real)"

It's right here for you to see:


I believe this sort of stuff is what some might consider "evidence of trolling."

So yes, amusement is the only rational response. Do not expect further responses until you make a serious argument.

It's a good thing the world didn't go with "The political opinion of the German people is teh Truth". We'd be in a serious mess.
 
The 'Mentality of Skeptics' thread was purportedly started to expose the alleged closed-mindedness, cognitive dissonance and denialist approach of many members here.
It quickly became clear that this was not, in fact, the aim of the thread: it was, in fact, another Bigfoot thread.
However, before it was ruled OT, there were a few discussions about alleged examples of this, discussions that I thought were shut down too quickly. Moreover, these kinds of allegations have been made in other threads too, especially in the Conspiracies sub-forum.
I am not alone in repeatedly asking for examples of this, from actual posts by actual members, and so I am starting this thread with this purpose.
I would like to see actual examples of the following, as alleged, repeatedly, by certain members here:
  • Blind obedience to an "Official Story".
  • A refusal to accept evidence for a non-conventional idea or assertion.
  • Cognitive dissonance and/or anxiety caused by a subconscious acceptance of such ideas, coupled by a public disavowal of same.
  • Insulting, aggressive posts that attack the arguer, not the argument. (Probably best to exclude Beachnut from this, really....:) )
  • Pseudo-skepticism.
  • Unqualified, uncritical support for governments, police forces and other establishment organisations.
  • Shilling for corporations or security forces.
If examples are posted here, I and others can look at them. It may be possible that I, and others are doing this without realising how it looks from the other side, in which case I will be perfectly happy to modify my approach and posting style.
On the other hand, if no such examples can be found, then I would like to ask those members responsible to stop making false accusations.
In other words, put up or shut up.

After the examples which have been provided have been moved outside the thread we can conclude that that no such examples have been provided and hence the OP is justified in his statement:
"On the other hand, if no such examples can be found, then I would like to ask those members responsible to stop making false accusations.
In other words, put up or shut up."

Brilliant self-perpetuating system, you couldn't construct it by will even if you wanted to.
 
After the examples which have been provided have been moved outside the thread we can conclude that that no such examples have been provided and hence the OP is justified in his statement:
"On the other hand, if no such examples can be found, then I would like to ask those members responsible to stop making false accusations.
In other words, put up or shut up."

Brilliant self-perpetuating system, you couldn't construct it by will even if you wanted to.

I've had more posts removed from this thread than anyone else, so I really have no idea what point you're trying to make here.
 
I would like to see actual examples of the following, as alleged, repeatedly, by certain members here:
  • Blind obedience to an "Official Story".
  • A refusal to accept evidence for a non-conventional idea or assertion.
  • Cognitive dissonance and/or anxiety caused by a subconscious acceptance of such ideas, coupled by a public disavowal of same.
  • Insulting, aggressive posts that attack the arguer, not the argument. (Probably best to exclude Beachnut from this, really....:) )
  • Pseudo-skepticism.
  • Unqualified, uncritical support for governments, police forces and other establishment organisations.
  • Shilling for corporations or security forces.
If examples are posted here, I and others can look at them. It may be possible that I, and others are doing this without realising how it looks from the other side, in which case I will be perfectly happy to modify my approach and posting style.
On the other hand, if no such examples can be found, then I would like to ask those members responsible to stop making false accusations.

These two quotes are from a thread in the 911 Conspiracies sub-forum.

.

I hope that any truther who stumbles onto this website sees this post early on in their research. The fact that no one (or not everyone) is willing to watch the videos should be a clear sign that there is a problem here. Absolutely nothing that the skeptics argue should be taken with any seriousness. It is abundantly clear they have an agenda to perpetuate the lies in the official story, regardless of what evidence they are presented with.

This thread, and the responses of the skeptics, can not make that fact any clearer.

I will make this offer. If anyone here is willing to pay for the cost of materials, I will gladly duplicate the experiments. I will do it without hesitation. Of course, like I said before, it won't matter. Nothing will change a skeptic's mind. There are two reasons. First, some members are delusional, and second, some members are here solely to misinform and act as gatekeepers.

FalseFlag, would you care to substantiate these charges? Who, specifically, are you accusing, and what evidence do you have that they are here "solely to misinform"?
 
After the examples which have been provided have been moved outside the thread we can conclude that that no such examples have been provided and hence the OP is justified in his statement:
"On the other hand, if no such examples can be found, then I would like to ask those members responsible to stop making false accusations.
In other words, put up or shut up."

Brilliant self-perpetuating system, you couldn't construct it by will even if you wanted to.

So your suggesting the OP, members and the moderation team are working together to suppress the truth?
 
So your suggesting the OP, members and the moderation team are working together to suppress the truth?

He can't be, because it would be a
Brilliant self-perpetuating system, you couldn't construct it by will even if you wanted to.

So even if we wanted to do that, we couldn't.
I'm not sure what he's trying to say, to be honest.
 
He can't be, because it would be a


So even if we wanted to do that, we couldn't.
I'm not sure what he's trying to say, to be honest.

Well we've certainly seen buthurt like this before.

Hey how about this Caveman....post up some evidence that's not a complete derail, you know stuff that's relative to the OP?
Not your opinion, you know facts and examples from this fourm that would be a good start.
And if you can't or won't we can all assume your just full of **** ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom