If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
My claim: This argument is beyond absurd, and I keep repeating this.

Proof 1: Verinage is done to low-rise concrete buildings. A low rise concrete building is not a steel-framed high rise. Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NiHeCjZlkr8
Do the laws of physics apply differently to them?

Proof 2: Deceleration is observed in a verinage collapse. Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NiHeCjZlkr8
So is in WTC1.

Proof 3: Ronan Point was not a steel-frame high rise. Ronan Point had no external support structure. The portion of the structure that collapsed did so due to sudden-impact loading. There is no evidence the collapse occurred at freefall. Source: http://engagedscholarship.csuohio.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1021&context=encee_facpub
Neither is there in WTC1.

Proof: Skyline Towers was also not a steel-frame high rise. Here is a direct quote from the investigation:


There is no evidence anywhere that claims the Skyline Tower collapse occurred at freefall. Additionally, the entire building did not collapse.
Do the laws of physics apply differently to it?
 
Scaling does NOT affect Newton’s laws.
Thanks.

whatever...

1/10 on the flounce scale.
Wow. Your avoidance of the substance of his post is noted. Here it is in its entirety, for reference, with the only bits you responded to highlighted:


FalseFlag,

Cole is NOT performing a structural experiment. It is absurd to think his experiment is modeling structural data when his floors consist of paper and toothpicks, or matchsticks.

Absolute, unmitigated rubbish. You haven’t the slightest clue…

OF COURSE it’s a “structural experiment”. And proven below.

If Jonathan Cole were competent enough to run a competent experiment, then toothpicks & paper are far, FAR too massive & strong to accurately model the towers at this stupid scale factor.

Cole is performing experiments to show Newton's laws of motion in action.

Absolute & utter rubbish.

NOBODY needs Cole to demonstrate or prove any of Newton’s Laws.

Further, that is NOT what he is doing. This is YOUR delusion, not our mistake.
If Cole were doing that, he’d be sliding or hitting a plastic puck across an air table.

Everyone here knows that Newton’s laws always hold.
__

As an aside, one key factors that YOU don’t realize is that all 3 of Newton’s laws are accurately & reliably built into the software that NIST used to model the Towers & WTC7. (The first two into every static model, and all 3 into the WTC7’s collapse model.) And that the engineers who use that software have no access to feature. they can’t turn them on or off, they can’t increase or decrease their effects, etc.

In other words, every single one of NIST’s models scrupulously, rigorously adheres to Newton’s Laws.
__

Although everyone seems to be kicking and screaming while denying this, scale has no effect on Newton's laws. They apply equally regardless of the magnitude of the mass of the object and the magnitude of the forces involved.

Yes, you keep saying this.
The ONLY reason that you keep saying this is that you’re not HEARING that nobody is disagreeing about this.

Scaling does NOT affect Newton’s laws.
But Newton’s laws are NOT the only laws that need be applied.
Newton’s Laws are 100% INSUFFICIENT to say anything about the collapse of the towers.

And THAT is the issue under contention.
NOT Newton’s Laws.

See if you can follow:

A heavy block is placed on a span of thin glass. The glass breaks & the block falls.
A heavy block is placed on a span of thicker glass . The glass bows very minimally & supports the block.
The same block is place on a span of thin wood. The wood bows a lot, & supports the block.
The same block is placed on a span of thick wood. The wood bows somewhat, & supports the block.

All 3 of Newton’s Laws are ALL true, ALL of the time, in ALL of 4 these “experiments”.
Other than determining the weight of the block, Newton’s Laws, while true, are completely, utterly INSUFFICIENT to the outcome ("the structure either fails or supports the block") of these experiments.

Material science & mechanical engineering (shape, thickness, length of the span, strength & toughness) are REQUIRED determine the outcomes.

Next, you drop the block onto the 3 remaining “structures”. (Yes, they are structures.)
The thin wood breaks, the thick glass breaks & the thick wood survives.

All 3 of Newton’s Laws are ALL true, ALL of the time, in ALL of 3 this group of “experiments”, too.
Newton’s Laws are required to determine the speed with which the block impacts the structure.
But Newton’s Laws are, again, completely, utterly, 100% unable to predict the outcome of these experiments.

Again, material science & mechanical engineering are REQUIRED to determine the outcome.

QED.

NOBODY needs Jonathan Cole to demonstrate or prove Newton’s Laws.
This is YOUR fantasy.

It is also YOUR fantasy that anybody here is saying that any of Newton’s Laws are being violated in ANY event that has ever happened, from the collapse of the tower to the partial collapse of Cole’s clueless experiment.

If YOU stop blabbering this stupid assertion, then people will stop blabbering about “scale & Newton’s Laws”.

The part that IS true, is that scale is an absolutely CRITICAL aspect of the study (mechanical engineering) that IS required to determine the outcome of the above experiments.

And, if you could get it thru your thick skull …
NOBODY (except you) needs any convincing about Newton’s Laws.
EVERYBODY is discussing the applicability of mechanical engineering to the collapse of Cole’s model vs. the collapse of the WTC Towers.

And Jonathan Cole is included in this last “EVERYBODY”. He is also pompously, cluelessly, incompetently bloviating about the applicability of his model to the collapse of the towers. He is NOT talking about Newton’s Laws either. He IS talking about mechanical engineering. And totally screwing up the discussion.

The 100% PROOF that Cole does, in fact, view his contraption as “a structural model” as well as “a structural model for the WTC towers”, and even more so, “a structural model for the collapse of the WTC towers” is explicitly stated every single time he states “Is this (whatever his model did) what we saw in the collapse of the towers?”

Even Jonathan Cole, in his stupidity, does not match you, in yours.

I keep saying this, correctly, and it keeps being ignored. It is being ignored because you don't like it, so you refuse to accept it.

whatever...
 
The investigation was done by "sloppy", but "expert" professionals. That is a claim made by another skeptic. Don't you think we need an investigation that isn't sloppy?
Video analysis is not the field of expertise of the NIST engineers. Forensic engineering is. It's no surprise their video analysis was sloppy. Their forensic work was not sloppy.
 
Does Newton's first law of motion apply to both the gymnast and the elephant? Yes. Since the answer is yes, scale does not matter.

Is it your claim, then, that demonstrating that Aliyah Mustafina can, in fact, stick a double-somersault full-twist dismount off a balance beam "proves" that an elephant can do the same?
 
Last edited:
The floors were removed by something other than the falling mass. Other than CD, please explain how this could happen.

Once again, the clumsy attempt a the Verónica Grande. This is why you think you are "scoring points".

First, you have to indicate that the "removal" of the floors did happen.
 
You do understand that at least three skeptics, including yourself, have stated scale does not matter in Newton's laws of motion. Did you forget what you posted? I guess you did, or you wouldn't be mentioning it again.

This sort of attempt at fancy footwork will not save your fundamental error; nor does outright dishonesty about what has been posted "score points".

The Laws of Motion apply equally at any scale.

It is the effect of those Laws upon incompetently-scaled models that is the point of contention.

Do they have Matchbook® or HotWheels® toy cars where you come from?

Take one Matchbook® die-cast scale model car (mass, ~35 g, length ~7 cm). Drop an adult guinea pig (~300 g) onto your car model from a distance of 35 cm onto the scale model of the car. Observe and record the results.

Now repeat the demonstration with a Fiat 500 (~800kg) an elephant (~6800kg) and a drop height of 15m. Observe and record the results.

Describe the differences in the results.

Explain the reason.
 
You make a claim, you need to support it if you expect to have it accepted. You made a claim about the initial fall of the upper section of WTC 1. You based your claim on a video of the collapse. Your claim; your burden to back it with evidence.

This post admits I provided proof. The issue is that you disagree with it so you claim it's not credible. I have met my burden of proof. You simply refuse to accept the proof.

Proofs are what one does in Mathematics. Here, we are more interested in evidence.

What you presented was a link to one of Cole's YouTube videos. Therein was a graph alleging to show the velocity of descent of WTC 1 for the first few seconds of its collapse.

The graph shows neither constant velocity nor constant acceleration. Instead, it shows average velocity from which an average acceleration is derived. And it would appear that the average velocity is based on averages of averages.

What you attempt to pass off as evidence is incompetent, irrelevant, and immaterial (to borrow a phrase popularized by Erle Stanley Gardner). In no way does that meet your "burden of proof."

(Well, actually, you based your claim on comments made by Cole, comments that were either taken out of context by you, misinterpreted by you, or just flat out wrong to begin with.)

Here you make a claim. You now have the burden of proof. What comments were taken out of context by me? What did I misinterpret? What was I flat out wrong with (in regards to Cole's videos)?

Were this my bugbear I'd enthusiastically provide relevant evidence. It is not. Accept or reject my parenthetical remark as you choose, but there is ample evidence in this very thread for anyone who cares to look.

Rather than supporting your claim with credible evidence, instead you exposed your ignorance of video technologies, their impact on data gathering from video images, what video technologies would have been available in 2001, what raw data was collected, how it was collected, the meaning of "constant" versus the meaning of "average"...the list goes on.
Please explain how anything I have posted regarding videos supports your claim.

Do you deny you stated that interlacing and compression were not significant factors in data gathering from the videos?

Please explain how, throughout this entire thread, I have continued to remain ignorant to the subjects you are mentioning.

Strawman.

Then, if you actually do prove this, explain how this ignorance prevents me from understanding NIST's claim of freefall for 2.25 seconds.

Please stay focused. WTC 1, remember? You may move the goalposts later.

You claimed the upper section of the WTC 1 tower fell with constant acceleration. You have yet to support this claim with credible evidence.
I have posted credible evidence. You just refuse to accept it.

Just so we are all looking at the same thing, what evidence is it that supports your claim of constant acceleration for WTC 1's collapse?
 
You do understand that at least three skeptics, including yourself, have stated scale does not matter in Newton's laws of motion. Did you forget what you posted? I guess you did, or you wouldn't be mentioning it again.

Newton's laws have no connection to scaling effects, but scaling effects have an enormous effect: n scaled models.

Cole IS attempting to model aspects of the WTC towers. To argue otherwise is quite incredible.

Cole's models utterly fail at modelling any of the aspects of the collapse of the towers.
It has been explained many times that the core and perimeter were linked by the floor trusses. That provided the lateral support required . Destroy that lateral support and the structure comes apart due to instablity.

Cole never bothers to model this at all. He has models that have "columns" with lateral support independant of the "floors". He has models in which the "floor"seats are enormously strong. IOW he has designed the scale of various aspects of his models to avoid investigating the mechanisms of the collapse of the towers.
 
Video analysis is not the field of expertise of the NIST engineers. Forensic engineering is. It's no surprise their video analysis was sloppy. Their forensic work was not sloppy.

Sorry, this has no place anywhere in any argument.

NIST could and did use independent contractors. If they thought they couldn't get the results from the video, they were welcome to get someone who could.
 
Sorry, this has no place anywhere in any argument.

NIST could and did use independent contractors. If they thought they couldn't get the results from the video, they were welcome to get someone who could.
They did it to the level they thought it deserved. Frankly, I think they shouldn't have wasted the effort.
 
Sorry, this has no place anywhere in any argument.

NIST could and did use independent contractors. If they thought they couldn't get the results from the video, they were welcome to get someone who could.
There was no time to do that in the time between the draft and the final version.
 
Here is a nice party trick for Falseflag to try!

So why don't you pick up a 20 pound rock, and throw it vertical into the air. Now stand beneath the rock flying upwards. According to your understanding of Newton's first law, the rock will keep flying upwards (An object at rest stays at rest and an object in motion stays in motion with the same speed and in the same direction)until it reaches the moon. So give it a try, and film the entire experiment for us to laugh at :)
 
Sorry, this has no place anywhere in any argument.

NIST could and did use independent contractors. If they thought they couldn't get the results from the video, they were welcome to get someone who could.
NIST got what they needed from the video, and the Video is low resolution, low frame rate; and NIST did not waste time with BS methods. What NIST took from the Video was sufficient to track the facade falling; wasting more time, or saying free-fall means CD is delusional BS.

If you were working for NIST and wasted as much time as 911 truth or NIST haters on study of the video, you would be fired, released, sent home for wasting time on BS.
Your CD of WTC 7 failed on 911; fourteen years of umpteenth fail.

Does it look like CD, or is it a gravity collapse, which CD is anyway. irony, simile rules 911 truth fantasy.
 
Does Newton's first law of motion apply to both the gymnast and the elephant? Yes. Since the answer is yes, scale does not matter.

The gymnast can hold up an elephant as well as the elephant can hold up the gymnast?:jaw-dropp
 
They did it to the level they thought it deserved. Frankly, I think they shouldn't have wasted the effort.

Sorry, this has no place anywhere in any argument.

NIST could and did use independent contractors. If they thought they couldn't get the results from the video, they were welcome to get someone who could.

I disagree with you completely.

How many engineering test reports have you ever written?
At a guess, I've written around 100 in my career.

Have you had to produce any task where your boss was standing behind you, hammering you to, "get it done!", because the VP of your division was hammering him, because the president was hammering him, because the Chairman of the Board of Directors was hammering him, because some political puke in Washington DC was hammering him every day? When none of them had the slightest clue what was involved in the task?

I HAVE been in this position, twice, because the sales of the product for which I was responsible was shut down until I'd found a solution for a problem & written an engineering report documenting the tests to prove that my fix was going to do the job. The issues, in my case, were absolutely crucial. Life & death crucial.

How about when all the senior engineers in the group tell the boss that "this crap doesn't matter in the slightest".

Why on earth do you think that absolutely ignorant amateurs get to set the priorities of professionals?

Dr. Sunder has been crystal clear about the fact that the near free fall speed, over this short interval, was not in the slightest bit surprising. That is doesn't indicate CD in the slightest.

Other than you personal distrust of all those engineers, do you have any evidence whatsoever that this matters in the slightest?

What if I could provide you with evidence that a "near free fall acceleration" was to be expected?
Would you change your mind?

I've been in that position several times, under crushing pressure to "freeze the design" of something that I was designing, when I was convinced that the design wasn't sufficiently robust, but the business guys had to mollify the investors ... who had cut the schedule that I had prepared by 40%.

Easy for you guys, who've never been on the field, to shout opinions from the cheap seats.

This issue was first introduced to NIST around Aug 28, 2008 (IIRC), after the publication of the Draft Report.

The final report came out on Nov. 25, 2008 (again, IIRC).

That is roughly a 3 month window.
As far as the engineers at NIST were concerned, I'm quite sure that this issue was near the bottom of the barrow in terms of importance.

Figure that the report needs about a month for proof reading, final review & printing, leaving about 60 days. Figure that they got to this after they'd addressed the substantive issues.

They may well have had anywhere from 3 days to 6 weeks to do this. Therefore the fastest way to get it done was to

I said earlier that there were several indicators that the engineer who drew the short straw was rushed & a junior engineer. I listed those indicators in that post.

I said that the engineer who prepared this section was a bit "sloppy" in leaving out the adjective "approximately G", and instead said "at G" in his conclusions.

Even though he had said "approximately G" in his detailed discussion.
__

One of your cohorts quote-mined my comments and, lying thru his teeth, claimed that "another skeptic (i.e., me) said that the NIST engineers were sloppy".

That is a bald-faced lie.

If I said that "a third string player for the Oakland Warriors missed a free throw shot", it would be a bald-faced lie for someone to claim that I'd said that "none of the Warriors were competent basketball players."

There is absolutely no difference between that example & what happened here.

Please answer me a question: "Why is it that truthers constantly resort to outright lying, as this other poster did, in your "search for the truth"??

Do you guys not understand how hypocritical this is??
Do you not understand how lying like this undermines all of your credibility?

Whenever I see a skeptic assert something that is wrong, I'll step in & correct him. How do you guys tolerate the liars in your group?
 
Last edited:
[quote=FalseFlag;11158194]The thread title is part of a famous quote by Richard P. Feynman. The full quote is, "It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong."
Recently, two new videos were posted by Jonathan H. Cole, PE.
The first video is a response to the blacksmith video which recently went viral. The second video discusses the collapse of WTC1 and WTC2.
Everyone should watch them both.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WgCtvTmshZ8

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJNzaMRsN00

Instead of attacking me, or Mr. Cole, I challenge anyone in this forum to conduct an experiment proving just ONE of Mr. Cole's claims are wrong. You pick the claim, and you make your own video showing how he is wrong. Words and computer models don't count. Prove, by an experiment conducted by yourself and documented in your own video, just one of Mr. Cole's claims are wrong.
I know this challenge will go unanswered until the end of time, but good luck, anyway.
So many skeptics on this forum insist the truther movement is dead. I think it's alive and well, and continuing to gain momentum.
Let the personal attacks begin. I know that is what will happen, because that is all the skeptics have.

____________________________________________________________
Cole’s two experiments are wrong in the attempt to prove the Towers collapsed by explosives and not by fire and plane damage. They are falsified by the actual full scale results of the "experiments" on 9/11.

Here is NIST’s analysis:
12. Was there enough gravitational energy present in the WTC towers to cause the collapse of the intact floors below the impact floors? Why weren’t the collapses of WTC 1 and WTC 2 arrested by the intact structure below the floors where columns first began to buckle?
Yes, there was more than enough gravitational load to cause the collapse of the floors below the level of collapse initiation in both WTC towers. The vertical capacity of the connections supporting an intact floor below the level of collapse was adequate to carry the load of 11 additional floors if the load was applied gradually and 6 additional floors if the load was applied suddenly (as was the case). Since the number of floors above the approximate floor of collapse initiation exceeded six in each WTC tower (12 floors in WTC 1 and 29 floors in WTC 2), the floors below the level of collapse initiation were unable to resist the suddenly applied gravitational load from the upper floors of the buildings.


Consider a typical floor immediately below the level of collapse initiation and conservatively assume that the floor is still supported on all columns (i.e., the columns below the intact floor did not buckle or peel off due to the failure of the columns above). Consider further the truss seat connections between the primary floor trusses and the exterior wall columns or core columns. The individual connection capacities ranged from 94,000 pounds to 395,000 pounds, with a total vertical load capacity for the connections on a typical floor of 29,000,000 pounds (see Section 5.2.4 of NIST NCSTAR 1-6C). The total floor area outside the core was approximately 31,000 square feet, and the average load on a floor under service conditions on Sept. 11, 2001, was 80 pounds per square foot. Thus, the total vertical load on a floor outside the core can be estimated by multiplying the floor area (31,000 square feet) by the gravitational load (80 pounds per square foot), which yields 2,500,000 pounds (this is a conservative load estimate since it ignores the weight contribution of the heavier mechanical floors at the top of each WTC tower). By dividing the total vertical connection capacity (29,000,000 pounds) of a floor by the total vertical load applied to the connections (2,500,000 pounds), the number of floors that can be supported by an intact floor is calculated to be a total of 12 floors or 11 additional floors.


This simplified and conservative analysis indicates that the floor connections could have carried only a maximum of about 11 additional floors if the load from these floors were applied statically. Even this number is (conservatively) high, since the load from above the collapsing floor is being applied suddenly. Since the dynamic amplification factor for a suddenly applied load is 2, an intact floor below the level of collapse initiation could not have supported more than six floors. Since the number of floors above the level where the collapse initiated exceeded six for both towers (12 for WTC 1 and 29 for WTC 2), neither tower could have arrested the progression of collapse once collapse initiated. In reality, the highest intact floor was about three (WTC 2) to six (WTC 1) floors below the level of collapse initiation. Thus, more than the 12 to 29 floors reported above actually loaded the intact floor suddenly.

1). Falling weight on boards experiment:
Error 1: The experiment loads are not proportional to The Towers loads.
Error 2: The Tower floors failed at the sheared floor truss to columns connections supporting the floor, not at the floor itself as shown by Cole. This was seen in the debris with nearly all the supports sheared off from the columns.


To validly compare NIST’s calculations with Cole’s experiment, Cole’s data needs to be adjusted on a pounds per square foot basis and corrected.

NIST floor load weight = 80 #/SF.
[1] Cole board size = ~ 22” x 8” / 144 SI= 1.22 SF.
[2] Cole cement boards weight = 2.53 #/SF per 1 /2” board x 4 bds. =10.12 #/SF.

[3] NIST weight falling on the floor below (Tower 1) = 11 floors x 80 #/SF = 880 # /SF.
[4] Cole weight falling on the first board = 20 # / 1.22 SF = 16.4 #/SF.

[5] NIST total weight / floor = 80# x 31,000 SF = 2,480,000 # .
[6] NIST total capacity of connectors to floor load =29,000,000# / 2,480,000# = 11.7 times the floor load.
NIST “the dynamic amplification factor for a suddenly applied load is 2”.
Impact Loading.
http://tinyurl.com/hgmmdg3

To scale actual conditions to Cole’s experiment the following corrections are needed:
Cole before board size = ~ 22” x 8”.
Cole after board size =12” x 12” = 1 SF (to simplify calculations).

Cole before = 20# dropped weight.
[7] Cole after = 110 # dropped weight (weight of 4 cement boards floor ~10 # from [2]) x 11 board floors falling from above.

Cole before board connectors = none, supported by wood ledgers .
[9] Cole after board connectors = the sum of connectors should be installed to fail at a static loading of ~ 117#. 10# /SF floor weight x 11.7 factor = 117#. (From [6]).

Revised experiment run:
1.. 110# load dropped from a sufficient height is amplified to 220#.
2.. The first boards (floor) below, connectors fail at 117# and fall to the floor below.
3.. The now 12 floors weigh 120# and its falling amplified load is 240#
4. The second boards below connectors fail at 117# and fall to the floor below. The moving mass increases at each collapsed floor, and so on.



Here’s an example of how one relatively small impact can progressively collapse an entire structure.

Here’s another.


2).. Firecrackers exploding paper tower experiment:
Error 3: The sounds of firecracker explosives is clear. No sounds of explosives was heard at The Towers.
a).. Many cameras recorded the sound of rumbling the collapsing towers, not exploding.
b).. The FDNY was taped in the lobby of WTC1 when WTC2 collapse a hundred feet away, rumbling sounds, not explosives.
c).. That poor fellow who was recorded in Tower 2 on a 911 call directly above the collapse when he screamed oh no oh no and went silent. No sounds of explosives.
d).. That structural engineer, Buzzelli, who was trapped in the stairwell of Tower 1 as the building collapsed on top of him, no sounds of explosives.
“Then, as he reached the 22nd floor, the building shook, stairs started to heave. It sounded to Buzzelli like heavy objects were being dropped right above his head. The sound got louder, closer.”
“One fireman said he heard each floor come down, like a drum roll”.
http://nymag.com/nymetro/news/sept11/2003/n_9189/

No explosives sounds. Inside the building as it was collapsing.


Error 4: The perimeter walls were exploded hundreds of feet, and before the floors collapsed. (from Chandler also).
The floors inside sequentially collapsed and the outer columns toppled.
Pictures of large connected sections of exterior columns, not exploded, spandrels undamaged
http://www.911myths.com/assets/images/columns.jpg

July 2009
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4948739#post4948739



Cole’s first experiment is the wrong experiment that proves he doesn’t know what he should be testing. His second experiment debunks his opinions by another falsifying experiment - the full scale recorded, measured, analyzed, verified results on 911.



FF asked for One Cole error. Here are four.
The Towers collapsed due to fire and planes damage, not explosives.




 
Please answer me a question: "Why is it that truthers constantly resort to outright lying, as this other poster did, in your "search for the truth"??

Do you guys not understand how hypocritical this is??
Do you not understand how lying like this undermines all of your credibility?

Whenever I see a skeptic assert something that is wrong, I'll step in & correct him. How do you guys tolerate the liars in your group?

I can't answer for anyone else other than myself. I'm not part of a group, apart from where I am labelled as such by members of this forum.

I would say that there are both deliberate and accidental lies on both sides of the debate. Perhaps one man's lie is anothers assertion of something that turns out to be wrong :)

I don't know, it's a problem, one of many. It's frustrating. Personally, I'm honest to a fault, however that does not mean that I do not make mistakes, which can include misrepresenting opinion as fact, or asserting mistakes. On my part these are not lies, but I can see how they might look that way to others. It all comes down to definitions again.
 
I'll try again, perhaps AClark sees this now.
That's all very well and mathy, but it makes some very glaring omissions. Primarily the trigonometry of the situation. If you are going to have pieces toppling, then you are going to need pivot points, and enough geometry for your javelin.
You are Moving the Goal Posts.

You had declared:
The amount of energy required to eject steel sections a considerable distance is very large...
So I asked:
Can you quantify this "very large" energy required?

There are basically two theories on the table that would explain the source of that energy:
  • Gravity (GPE - Gravitational Potential Energy)
  • Explosives (ChE - Chemical Energy)
I quantified the requirement for the first theory - that GPE is the energy source: Drop height of 10 to 40 floors - easily available for collapses starting 78+ floors above ground.

Remember: You made a claim about the quantity of energy.

Now you:
How much explosives (equivalent to chemical energy, ChE) does it take, per mass unit of steel to propel a steel section to 60 mph?
That calculation is much less straightforward.
I have done it.
Have you?
Can you guess?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom