If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
There's your problem, right there.
A definition of "Similar" that apparently only you are aware of...
What is your definition of "similar", and how does it differ from Cole's? How does your definition support your opinion that Cole is wrong?
 
2 forces- gravity and the normal force?

WTF? Over...

Please make this post a sticky.

Don't expect anyone to give you any credit for having the most basic understanding of physics after that post. You just nuked your credibility.
 
I also have to laugh when the model he tested that actually was the closest to the WTC Structure, where he used the pizza stands on their size, actually did show a progressive collapse, and yet FF and Cole both seem to have totally ignored this particular experiment. The crazy thing is that the less his models resemble the WTC the less collapse he gets, the closer he gets, the closer he is to the WTC the more likely he is to get a progressive collapse. Funny that.

Are you claiming that the structure of the twin towers was so unstable that you could compare it to a model where the floors are supported by pizza stands? I think the engineers who designed the building would disagree with your assessment.

You also claim that one of Cole's models actually shows a progressive collapse. Is that what he was trying to replicate? No. He was trying to replicate the crush down, crush up claim made by Bazant, et al. Perhaps you should try to replicate the crush down, crush up theory. Can you? Can anyone?
 
Cole's are set up in such a fashion as it cannot globally fail. However other models are set up such that they can. Therefore Cole's assumptions about the simplistic application of Newton's laws of motion must be in error.
What? Do you even understand what you are trying to say?

Cole's also does not model any mechanism in any way similar to what is a widely accepted scenario for the WTC tower progression to global structural failure.

So many posts that are sticky-worthy. If Cole's model doesn't replicate the "widely accepted" scenarios, what is the ONLY LOGICAL CONCLUSION? Yes, caps are appropriate. The only logical conclusion is that the "widely accepted scenarios", based on words and not experiments, are wrong.
 
Are you claiming that the structure of the twin towers was so unstable that you could compare it to a model where the floors are supported by pizza stands? I think the engineers who designed the building would disagree with your assessment.

You also claim that one of Cole's models actually shows a progressive collapse. Is that what he was trying to replicate? No. He was trying to replicate the crush down, crush up claim made by Bazant, et al. Perhaps you should try to replicate the crush down, crush up theory. Can you? Can anyone?

Crush down crush up are simplifications used in a computer model, to help the model
Deal with mass retention. The fact that you are miss reading the model, because you
Haven't seen the program, just the abstract of the program says a lot.
 
What is the obsession with "proof"???

There are only aspects of material performance to DEMONSTRATE. Cole is not showing or demonstrating what he thinks he is and what he wants others to believe his models demonstrate. He either knows this and is deceiving people or he doesn't and he is also deceiving himself.

People who understand physics and material science can see the flaws in his "thinking" and the fact that his models/experiments do not demonstrate what he claims they do.

Mick at metabunk understands the limits of the models and what the objectives and limitations of his models/experiments are.
 
Non sequitir. The consensus exists,

Silence is not consensus, consensus being defined as "general agreement".

(When AE911 did try to formally bring their claims up in front of AIA, they were overwhelmingly rejected, so that is not a promising start.)

Agreed, but Gage has learned from his mistakes. Let's see what happens this year.

But according to you, anyone with "common sense" and "basic physics" can figure out what really happened. So why the appeal to the McGuffin of AE911's "evidence", which somehow hasn't been presented in the right way or to enough people or whatever? You're not being very consistent.


No. Can you provide any documentation which shows that everyone who voted on the AIA resolution was presented with all of the evidence?

I do agree with the (modified) statement where everyone with common sense and a knowledge of basic physics can figure out what the most likely hypothesis is. The most likely hypothesis was not investigated by NIST.

Nope. I'm saying that what relevant professional societies have issued formal positions on the causes of the WTC collapses do not support claims such as controlled demolition, nor do the bulk of analyses done by technically competent experts. This contrasts sharply with the qualifications and body of work done by ad hoc advocacy groups such as AE911. Like it or not, that is a consensus. If you can offer actual evidence that the bulk of engineers, architects, etc., think otherwise, you are certainly welcome to offer it, but you cannot use argument from silence to support your views.

We will have to disagree on the conclusions that can be made. Yes, many of your statements are facts, which is amazing to find here in this forum. We do not come to the same conclusions. If I were to discuss the reasons that I come to a different conclusion than you I would need to start a new thread, and I can't keep up with the discussions I am already involved in.

I will have to leave this as, yes, you have stated facts, but I disagree with your conclusions.

Especially when you reject all, as far as I can tell, the experts who don't agree with you.

I will reject any argument from any expert that I am certain does not conform to basic physical principles.

But you're telling me that you validate Cole because his claims are in line with your "basic" understanding.

Is this wrong? No, it's not. I believe that you are trying to make a claim that only experts have the authority and credibility to understand what really happened. This is partially true. I certainly don't have the authority and credibility to tell you exactly what happened during the three collapses. What I can do is apply very basic laws of physics to tell you with 100 percent certainly that what we have been told happened is a lie. You don't need to listen to me, I can point you to experts who will say the same thing.
 
Last edited:
Crush down crush up are simplifications used in a computer model, to help the model
No, crush down, crush up are mentioned in a paper, not a model. The paper was written by Bazant, et al.

Computer models, without experiments to show they are correct, are meaningless.
 
What is the obsession with "proof"???

We are discussing the collapse of buildings that killed almost 3000 people. It was the worst attack on America ever. Don't you think proof is relevant when someone makes a claim?

There are only aspects of material performance to DEMONSTRATE. Cole is not showing or demonstrating what he thinks he is and what he wants others to believe his models demonstrate. He either knows this and is deceiving people or he doesn't and he is also deceiving himself.

How is Cole demonstrating material performance? He's not. He is trying to replicate observed motion.

People who understand physics and material science can see the flaws in his "thinking" and the fact that his models/experiments do not demonstrate what he claims they do.

OK. You have made a statement. Please provide proof to support your claim. You are an engineer. It seems obvious that you should understand the importance of proof.

Mick at metabunk understands the limits of the models and what the objectives and limitations of his models/experiments are.
If you are performing an experiment to replicate the direction of acceleration or the sequence of net forces, how do these limits substantively affect the results to the point where they are no longer relevant?
 
Let me eliminate all doubt from your mind. I have made no claims of being qualified as an engineer or architect.

Any follow-up questions?
No.

Let me repeat my opinion about your opinion of the signers of the petition.

You are certainly entitled to your opinion. You are certainly entitled to make your own conclusions. The issue is that your conclusions are those of an average person, not a person who is a scientist, architect, or engineer. Because of this, I do not give any credibility to your conclusions.
 
And how will you know if they reject basic science?

Simple. Provide a sample statement by one of the so-called "experts", and I will tell you whether or not it conforms to or rejects basic science. If it does neither, or is clearly on a topic that I am not qualified to make a credible statement on, I will say so.
I will also provide you with proof to support my claim, which is more than anyone else here seems to be willing to do.

So all you're really saying is you'll accept the opinions of those who agree with you, and reject everything else.

No, I'm not saying this. Read what I just wrote.
 
What is this standard? What exams and certifications are required?

It would depend on what profession you wanted to enter.
Different professions require different qualifications.
Even some qualifications require you to have already obtained qualifications before you can start a course of study towards them.

In addition some professions insist on additional licensing after you obtain the required educational qualifications.
They are all ways of calibrating people's brains against standards.
 
Are you claiming that the structure of the twin towers was so unstable that you could compare it to a model where the floors are supported by pizza stands?

Where did I say that? I said it was closer to the structure than anything else he used. That doesn't mean it was the same.

I think the engineers who designed the building would disagree with your assessment.

You mean your strawman.

You also claim that one of Cole's models actually shows a progressive collapse. Is that what he was trying to replicate? No. He was trying to replicate the crush down, crush up claim made by Bazant, et al. Perhaps you should try to replicate the crush down, crush up theory. Can you? Can anyone?

If he was trying to do that then he fails on two accounts. First he used a weight so there is no "crush up" able to occur, and second, even Bazant, et al don't believe that the WTC Collapse was a crush down, crush up. What they wrote in their paper was a limiting case for the collapse so that certain information could be gained about the collapse. It speaks to limits, not to what actually happened, something that you'd know if you read the paper and understood it.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom