Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

[qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg] [qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg]
That is the central error of false dichotomy that Tony has been persisting with for many months.

(Tony says)"I have proved that "xyz" is wrong THEREFORE I am right." Where "xyz" is ARUP or Nordenson or....whoever - it matters not.


Utter idiotic nonsense.

I matters not how many explanations Tony proves wrong - if he claims CD he has to prove CD.

Tony is - of course - well aware of that true situation. Which is why he is happy for members to keep arguing for ARUP, Nordenson, whoever....

...as long as they DON'T identify Tony's single fatal error. He has not and cannot prove CD.

I have too say Tony's calculations are right for a limited set of impacts with the lower beam connections at elevated temperatures, however he ignored the mechanical advantage of a cold connection forming a fulcrum and applying leverage on the Connection to force a shear lag fracture. At above 220 C the steel is too soft to form a fulcrum and litterally pry the connection apart.
In Tony's defense this is something anyone could easily have missed the hotter the steel the less likely it is to lever itself out of the connection instead it will ductilly deform.

The formation of a fulcrum at the connection is critical to reducing the energy to induce failure, from induced levered shear.
 
I have applied elevated temperatures to the floors below. You seem to think there is a lot more to it than that, but aren't sure, so you keep it vague. You may not realize that I can see you lack experience here.

When are you going to show where WAI corrected Nordenson's use of a point load for the falling beam and girder assembly and show me where WAI provides an analysis for the amplification?

Girders and beams just don't fail as easily as these people are trying to say and to break through them requires a significant amplified load. I have already shown that and it was something Nordenson got right.

WAI didn't evaluate the floor collapse propagation with back-of-the-envelope 2-D equations like you and Nordenson; they simulated the entire collapse via explicit non-linear finite element analysis via Flex in their fulsome SAP 2000 model of the building. The collapse propagation observed in their model is laid out in great detail in Section 4 to Appendix B and Appendix D to their report. If you want to argue that the industry standard simulation tools are not properly taking into account certain material/impact properties, you are free to do so, but you have a far heavier lift than merely asserting as much.

Based on Crazy Chainsaw's posts, it seems your approach to analyzing the collapse is not only wanting for lack of rigor in all respects as you have freely admitted, but also due to your own misapplication of the underlying formulas, by the way, so you may want to fix that before even trying to address WAI's model.
 
Last edited:
I have done the calculations necessary to support my conclusions. They are available in papers and occasionally on forum posts I have made over the years.

Take them to the FBI and get the bad guys. What is stopping you to take action and get the FBI moving?

What is stopping you?
 
Did you ever do these calculations with Chandler?

  1. Force stack up on moment frame of WTC7 through collapse
  2. Error margins on acceleration measurements

How about these all by yourself?
  • Probability of fire being extinguished by dust.
  • Amount of explosives necessary for demolition
  • Decibel levels, frequencies of noise generated by necessary explosives
  • Ditto for Thermite, except include light emission
I'm sure there are more I could ask, and I'm sure others can chime in, knowing your posting history, etc.

Don't expect any more from me though, I freely admit i'm doing this for the lulz. Your cause is dead, no matter what, in my opinion.

He has conceded that it's at least 192, each of which would be have to be sufficient to destroy a single core column's support on one floor.

In reality it would take multiples of that, though each charge could be reduced in size where working in pairs or other multiples.

The cognitive dissonance must be astronomical in Tony's case, which is why he always avoids getting into that particular discussion.
 
It doesn't matter if NIST is wrong or not, CD can only be proven By evidence of CD of which there has never been and never will be any.

Exactly. There is no physical evidence to support the ridiculous story of CD. These people have no understanding of reality.
 
Last edited:
The cognitive dissonance must be astronomical in Tony's case, which is why he always avoids getting into that particular discussion.

I find it strange that truthers will deliberately avoid discussing the points that are 'uncomfortable', like how did the explosives survive the fires? That's a biggie and no-one has the stones to touch it.
 
He has conceded that it's at least 192, each of which would be have to be sufficient to destroy a single core column's support on one floor.

In reality it would take multiples of that, though each charge could be reduced in size where working in pairs or other multiples.

The cognitive dissonance must be astronomical in Tony's case, which is why he always avoids getting into that particular discussion.

Tony should ask Weidlinger Associates for some help laying out his blast hypothesis. After all, they are the ones who make the engineering software the DoD uses to analyze the susceptibility of structures to blast scenarios and they surely owe Tony a huge debt for proving (through vague insinuations on an internet message board, no less) that their fulsome analysis of WTC 7 was all wrong.
 
Last edited:
WAI didn't evaluate the floor collapse propagation with back-of-the-envelope 2-D equations like you and Nordenson; they simulated the entire collapse via explicit non-linear finite element analysis via Flex in their fulsome SAP 2000 model of the building. The collapse propagation observed in their model is laid out in great detail in Section 4 to Appendix B and Appendix D to their report. If you want to argue that the industry standard simulation tools are not properly taking into account certain material/impact properties, you are free to do so, but you have a far heavier lift than merely asserting as much.

Based on Crazy Chainsaw's posts, it seems your approach to analyzing the collapse is not only wanting for lack of rigor in all respects as you have freely admitted, but also due to your own misapplication of the underlying formulas, by the way, so you may want to fix that before even trying to address WAI's model.

Analysis of shock loads with software requires special software which I am assuming is Flex in their case. The software can show what the amplification was, but WAI did not. Why not? Of course, this is why you can't tell me what it was, because it is not in their report. You are just trusting their word.

The shear failure calculations required here can be done by hand. What can't be is the modal analysis needed to find the stiffness of the falling assembly. I used FEA to find it for the northeast floor section to correct Nordenson's point load infinite stiffness. I don't see where WAI talks about the dynamics other than to say if the lower floor wasn't hot it wouldn't have failed. That is far from sufficient and they have not proven their case.

Crazy Chainsaw is well........crazy if he thinks the shock load can be what he says to break the girder connections below due to leverage he hasn't even quantified. You are showing you have no business discussing this if you are simply taking his word for what it would take to fail the girders below. It is thoroughly ridiculous that you would even say such a thing.
 
Last edited:
Analysis of shock loads with software requires special software which I am assuming is Flex in their case. The software can show what the amplification was, but WAI did not. Why not? Of course, this is why you can't tell me what it was, because it is not in their report. You are just trusting their word.

You also still haven't shown me where WAI showed Nordenson's point load was wrong. Why not? Are you having trouble finding what you claimed was them also correcting what I had shown Nordenson did wrong?

The shear failure calculations required here can be done by hand. What can't be is the modal analysis needed to find the stiffness of the falling assembly. I used FEA to find it for the northeast floor section to correct Nordenson's point load infinite stiffness. I don't see where WAI talks about the dynamics other than to say if the lower floor wasn't hot it wouldn't have failed. That is far from sufficient and they have not proven their case.

Crazy Chainsaw is well........crazy if he thinks the shock load can be what he says to break the girder connections below due to leverage he hasn't even quantified. You are showing you have no business discussing this if you are simply taking his word for what it would take to fail the girders below. It is thoroughly ridiculous that you would even say such a thing.

Multiple sections of the report are dedicated solely to rebutting Nordenson's errors, including most of Appendix C. I suspect you know this because I suspect your "discovery" of Nordenson's errors was actually cribbed from WAI.

I'm glad, in any event, that at the end of this long back-and-forth we've come to a place where you're admitting (1) you can't say that either ARUP or WAI got their respective collapse initiation mechanisms wrong, and (2) you can't say that WAI got its collapse propagation analysis wrong. Try to remember this the next time you are tempted to mislead your fellow travelers with bold proclamations re the impossibility of fire induced collapses.

Re Crazy--considering you haven't shared your detailed analysis/calculations, I'm just taking your word for it too. Difference is, I've now caught you being deliberately dishonest on several occasions and so I trust you far less.
 
Last edited:
Analysis of shock loads with software requires special software which I am assuming is Flex in their case. The software can show what the amplification was, but WAI did not. Why not? Of course, this is why you can't tell me what it was, because it is not in their report. You are just trusting their word.

You also still haven't shown me where WAI showed Nordenson's point load was wrong. Why not? Are you having trouble finding what you claimed was them also correcting what I had shown Nordenson did wrong?

The shear failure calculations required here can be done by hand. What can't be is the modal analysis needed to find the stiffness of the falling assembly. I used FEA to find it for the northeast floor section to correct Nordenson's point load infinite stiffness. I don't see where WAI talks about the dynamics other than to say if the lower floor wasn't hot it wouldn't have failed. That is far from sufficient and they have not proven their case.

Crazy Chainsaw is well........crazy if he thinks the shock load can be what he says to break the girder connections below due to leverage he hasn't even quantified. You are showing you have no business discussing this if you are simply taking his word for what it would take to fail the girders below. It is thoroughly ridiculous that you would even say such a thing.

It is not talk Tony, your metha bunk thread is BS, the stiffness of the falling girder is irrelevant,
Because steel even in Liquid form is non compressible.

I don't have to fail the girder seat, just the bolts that have a tensile strength of 150,000 psi per inch, that attach the seat to the girder.
The impact the simply dislodging the girder causes it to fall.

Your attempting to only view the impact in an idealized hypothetical strongest case for resisting collapse, Just like Banzant did the towers.
Both are pure fallacy.
 
Multiple sections of the report are dedicated solely to rebutting Nordenson's errors, including most of Appendix C. I suspect you know this because I suspect your "discovery" of Nordenson's errors was actually cribbed from WAI.

I'm glad, in any event, that at the end of this long back-and-forth we've come to a place where you're admitting (1) you can't say that either ARUP or WAI got their respective collapse initiation mechanisms wrong, and (2) you can't say that WAI got its collapse propagation analysis wrong. Try to remember this the next time you are tempted to mislead your fellow travelers with bold proclamations re the impossibility of fire induced collapses.

Re Crazy--considering you haven't shared your detailed analysis/calculations, I'm just taking your word for it too. Difference is, I've now caught you being deliberately dishonest on several occasions and so I trust you far less.

I actually hadn't even gotten a copy of Weidlinger's report until this June. I found and corrected Nordenson's error in January, so there was nothing cribbed from anyone. Weidlinger claims the girder yields in the plastic zone in Nordenson's case, and I found that the girders would have remained fully elastic and just deflected. We do come close to agreement on what the actual impact force would be in a room temperature situation while correcting Nordenson.

I did share my analysis on Metabunk. I can say that Nordenson is wrong hands down and I suspect Weidlinger is overestimating the load amplification and the steel temperatures.
 
I actually hadn't even gotten a copy of Weidlinger's report until this June. I found and corrected Nordenson's error in January, so there was nothing cribbed from anyone. Weidlinger claims the girder yields in the plastic zone in Nordenson's case, and I found that the girders would have remained fully elastic and just deflected. We do come close to agreement on what the actual impact force would be in a room temperature situation while correcting Nordenson.

I did share my analysis on Metabunk. I can say that Nordenson is wrong hands down and I suspect Weidlinger is overestimating the load amplification and the steel temperatures.

(I accused you of cribbing the WAI report simply to get you to actually read it as you were being rather obtuse and demonstrating you had not. Since that worked and you've now evidently read Appendix C now, I retract my accusation.)

All I can say is that, based on all of the extant literature, you are smart enough to know that you do not have any reason to be certain that a fire induced collapse of WTC 7 was unlikely, let alone impossible. It is clear that there are multiple scenarios in which a fire induced collapse could have originated at a particular weak area of the building. No one can say for sure exactly how it happened because no one knows the exact parameters of the fire, but its possible that it did happen. You are very invested in the subject and I get that, but I really wish you could, given the limitations to your own analysis and your ability to critique the analyses of others as highlighted in this conversation, just step back and try to be objective about the possibility of fire induced collapse, even if you can't bring yourself to say it was likely or certain.
 
Last edited:
I actually hadn't even gotten a copy of Weidlinger's report until this June. I found and corrected Nordenson's error in January, so there was nothing cribbed from anyone. Weidlinger claims the girder yields in the plastic zone in Nordenson's case, and I found that the girders would have remained fully elastic and just deflected. We do come close to agreement on what the actual impact force would be in a room temperature situation while correcting Nordenson.

I did share my analysis on Metabunk. I can say that Nordenson is wrong hands down and I suspect Weidlinger is overestimating the load amplification and the steel temperatures.

Sorry not able to link the PDF,
MAXWELL'S RECIPROCAL THEOREM
ssu.ac.ir › fileadmin › MofidOther › Jozve

Page 35.
 
I actually hadn't even gotten a copy of Weidlinger's report until this June. I found and corrected Nordenson's error in January, so there was nothing cribbed from anyone. Weidlinger claims the girder yields in the plastic zone in Nordenson's case, and I found that the girders would have remained fully elastic and just deflected. We do come close to agreement on what the actual impact force would be in a room temperature situation while correcting Nordenson.
Load, temperature, Cross section, length and boundary conditions, please.
Show us a free body diagram.
You say you have analysis. It shouldn't take you 10 minutes to show that much to us, if you have actually done the work.

I did share my analysis on Metabunk. I can say that Nordenson is wrong hands down and I suspect Weidlinger is overestimating the load amplification and the steel temperatures.
 
(I accused you of cribbing the WAI report simply to get you to actually read it as you were being rather obtuse and demonstrating you had not. Since that worked and you've now evidently read Appendix C now, I retract my accusation.)

All I can say is that, based on all of the extant literature, you are smart enough to know that you do not have any reason to be certain that a fire induced collapse of WTC 7 was unlikely, let alone impossible. It is clear that there are multiple scenarios in which a fire induced collapse could have originated at a particular weak area of the building. No one can say for sure exactly how it happened because no one knows the exact parameters of the fire, but its possible that it did happen. You are very invested in the subject and I get that, but I really wish you could, given the limitations to your own analysis and your ability to critique the analyses of others as highlighted in this conversation, just step back and try to be objective about the possibility of fire induced collapse, even if you can't bring yourself to say it was likely or certain.

I would not for one minute champion a position I knew for a fact was wrong and it is a tenet of my profession to be objective.

The fact that all four corners of WTC 7 came down at the same time and that it went into free fall acceleration makes it very hard to show or believe fire caused the collapse.

You have to then admit that the finding of omissions, distortions, and ignoring of pertinent structural features in the NIST report doesn't engender confidence that we are being told the truth.

You have brought the Weidlinger Associates Report to the fore and I will have to take the time to go through it thoroughly.
 
Last edited:
I would not for one minute champion a position I knew for a fact was wrong and it is a tenet of my profession to be objective.

The fact that all four corners of WTC 7 came down at the same time and that it went into free fall acceleration makes it very hard to show or believe fire caused the collapse.

You have to then admit that the finding of omissions, distortions, and ignoring of pertinent structural features in the NIST report doesn't engender confidence that we are being told the truth.

Even if NIST is wrong there is no relevant competitive hypothesis, and yes NIST was wrong on a couple of things when I called them, what of it,
It does not change the fact, no competent theory exists, for an alternative.
 
I would not for one minute champion a position I knew for a fact was wrong and it is a tenet of my profession to be objective.

The fact that all four corners of WTC 7 came down at the same time and that it went into free fall acceleration makes it very hard to show or believe fire caused the collapse.

You have to then admit that the finding of omissions, distortions, and ignoring of pertinent structural features in the NIST report doesn't engender confidence that we are being told the truth.

You have brought the Weidlinger Associates Report to the fore and I will have to take the time to go through it thoroughly.

It might not be entirely intentional, but you do often describe the fire induced collapse scenarios and aspects of possible such scenarios as "impossible" when you should know that is a bridge too far. I've given you credit, and will continue to give you credit, for having pointed out errors with both the NIST report and ARUP. I'm sure you'll find shortcomings in the WAI report as well (I'm sure you'll quickly notice that it points out shortcoming in the ARUP and Bailey reports that you haven't picked up on yet). But we're dealing with a very chaotic and unknown environment and so we're dealing in a world of best guesses and probabilities. I doubt the building collapsed exactly like any of the 4 major reports to date have claimed. They are all undoubtedly wrong in that exacting sense. But that doesn't mean they are wrong in the more important sense of identifying the weakest area of the building and showing some of the ways it could have been susceptible to collapse as a result of fires conditions that could reasonably have been expected to have occurred.
 
Last edited:
The fact that all four corners of WTC 7 came down at the same time and that it went into free fall acceleration makes it very hard to show or believe fire caused the collapse.
Why do you insist on distorting the truth?
One of those four corners was missing over the lower dozen levels. If the others were moving it had nothing to offer to resist moving itself.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom