Are 4 to 4.5 hour office fire simulations valid?

Don't do that, the more money AE/911 twoofers, scam off the ignorant unwashed masses that believe them, the less they will breed.

Do you want the ignorant unwashed masses breeding?:D

Tony is doing the human race a favor and holding down the reproduction of twoofer dumb, and I do mean Dumb.


It is simply amazing that anyone in this world could have been so easily duped without a shred of evidence.
 
How will this help your CD fantasy? As Gage goes more nuts on 9/11, how will you recover from pushing the lie of CD. Gee, Gage believes in a stand down, how paranoid and crazy can Gage go before you expose him as a loon?

Failed to present evidence for CD, so you make up BS about the NIST report. Fire caused the collapse, your silent explosives remain fantasy.

I can't wait until you complete SIOP for 9/11 is explained. Here you are stuck on Flight 11, and Flight 175; what great fantasies do you have for Flight 77 and Flight 93; after this tangent of BS attacking NIST fails?

The NIST WTC 7 report was shown to be invalid by the ARUP analyses, since the NIST push off can't work due to girder trapping. The ARUP analyses were then shown themselves to contain fatal errors by me and the Weidlinger report.

We are now looking at the Weidlinger report (October 2010) to see if it shows fire could have caused the collapse without any of the fatal flaws exhibited in the other two reports (NIST in November 2008 and ARUP in April 2010).
 
Last edited:
The NIST WTC 7 report was shown to be invalid by the ARUP analyses, since the NIST push off can't work due to girder trapping. The ARUP analyses were then shown themselves to contain fatal errors by me and the Weidlinger report.

We are now looking at the Weidlinger report (October 2010) to see if it shows fire could have caused the collapse without any of the fatal flaws exhibited in the other two reports (NIST in November 2008 and ARUP in April 2010).


The hours-long duration of uncontrolled fires, major impact damage and structural buckling made it quite clear as to the cause of the collapse.
 
The hours-long duration of uncontrolled fires, major impact damage and structural buckling made it quite clear as to the cause of the collapse.

Maybe if the NIST and ARUP report authors had you on board they could have avoided the errors they made and we wouldn't be having this discussion.

In the meantime, the only report still standing is Weidlinger and its 4.5 hour fire heating in one spot needs to be scrutinized as it is not the norm.
 
Last edited:
Maybe if the NIST and ARUP report authors had you on board they could have avoided the errors they made and we wouldn't be having this discussion.


Errors or not, it is quite clear that fire, in conjunciton with impact damage, was responsible for the collapse of WTC 7.
 
The NIST WTC 7 report was shown to be invalid by the ARUP analyses, since the NIST push off can't work due to girder trapping. The ARUP analyses were then shown themselves to contain fatal errors by me and the Weidlinger report.

We are now looking at the Weidlinger report (October 2010) to see if it shows fire could have caused the collapse without any of the fatal flaws exhibited in the other two reports (NIST in November 2008 and ARUP in April 2010).

But Tony, you do get that none of these reports is intended to prove a specific scenario happened, right? And that they don't actually contradict each other because they are all looking at different scenarios, right? They are all examining what could have happened in reasonable--but different--fire scenarios, and they all rely on different tools and assumptions.

ARUP's reports, for example, were designed to illustrate reasonable scenarios in which the unfilled flutes (i.e., negligent construction) could have caused a collapse where filled flutes would not have. WAI is intending to show, in response to ARUP's limited scenarios, that collapse would have occurred with or without filled flutes.
 
Last edited:
But Tony, you do get that none of these reports is intended to prove a specific scenario happened, right? And that they don't actually contradict each other because they are all looking at different scenarios, right? They are all examining what could have happened in reasonable--but different--fire scenarios, and they all use different tools and assumptions.

ARUP's reports, for example, were designed to illustrate reasonable scenarios in which the unfilled flutes (i.e., negligent construction) could have caused a collapse where filled flutes would not have. WAI is intending to show, in response to ARUP's limited scenarios, that collapse would have occurred with or without filled flutes.

ARUP actually does contradict NIST in that they specifically show that girder A2001 cannot be pushed off its seat at column 79 to the west. This is the NIST initiating event.

Weidlinger then shows neither NIST or ARUP can break through the next floor down with girder A2001 falling off its seat. This was independently shown by myself six months ago, prior to my seeing the Weidlinger report in June of this year.
 
Last edited:
ARUP actually does contradict NIST in that they specifically show that girder A2001 cannot be pushed off its seat at column 79 to the west. This is the NIST initiating event.

Weidlinger then shows neither NIST or ARUP can break through the next floor down with girder A2001 falling off its seat. This was independently shown by myself six months ago, prior to my seeing the Weidlinger report in June of this year.

No, ARUP shows that in the specific heating scenarios they examined that the girder could not be pushed off to the west. They never independently tested NIST's heating scenario or any of the other infinite possible heating scenarios beyond their choice scenarios. If you put NIST's exact temperature model into the ARUP model and the girder got trapped, then you would have a good argument that ARUP showed NIST's model was flawed for omission of certain parts, but that's not what ARUP did.
 
ARUP actually does contradict NIST in that they specifically show that girder A2001 cannot be pushed off its seat at column 79 to the west. This is the NIST initiating event.

Weidlinger then shows neither NIST or ARUP can break through the next floor down with girder A2001 falling off its seat. This was independently shown by myself six months ago, prior to my seeing the Weidlinger report in June of this year.

Bravo.

Can you demonstrate multiples of 192 explosive detonations spread (according to you) over approx. 1 second just prior to global collapse?

I think you should start there, with actual evidence, rather than hinting that fire-induced collapse was impossible therefore there must have been multiples of 192 explosions.

Collapse following damage and fire has many ways to lead to collapse, but the explosives only one. You have zero evidence of explosives.
 
I think the Weidlinger report is problematic with continuous heating of one area for 4.5 hours. They reference the fire analysis conducted by Beyler (2010) for Hughes Associates, who was also involved in the NIST report, but they don't provide it or explain how it supports the claim for 4.5 hour heating of one area.

At what point does this line of questioning dovetail with controlled demolition?
 
Maybe if the NIST and ARUP report authors had you on board they could have avoided the errors they made and we wouldn't be having this discussion.

In the meantime, the only report still standing is Weidlinger and its 4.5 hour fire heating in one spot needs to be scrutinized as it is not the norm.

What is?
 
Maybe you should write your own report.


I could keep it very simple and easily debunk the WTC 7 CD theory based on available evidence and facts on what it takes to bring down a steel frame building with explosives.

What can you tell us about the following report?


Chief Peter Hayden, FDNY

"Early on, we saw a bulge in the southwest corner between floors 10 and 13, and we had put a transit on that and we were pretty sure she was going to collapse. You actually could see there was a visible bulge, it ran up about three floors."


In reference to WTC 7, what did the 'visible bulge' indicate?
 
I am curious to hear the voices of those who frequent this forum as to whether 4 to 4.5 hour fire simulation times are valid for WTC 7 studies such as those contained in the NIST and Weidlinger Associates analyses. The ARUP study used just one hour in its fire simulation.

Would you support a longer study over a much larger area?

Certainly the condition of the building as a whole is more important than focusing on one area in isolation. Would you agree?
 
Tony still has not explained and properly sourced what his 4 (NIST) and 4.5 (WAI) hours of ... something refer to, and what he wants to claim they are relevant to.

As far as NIST is concerned, he so far pointed to Chapter 10 of NCSTAR 1-9. This chapter contains no fire simulation and thus cannot contain any justification for any duration of heating applied to any region within the structure.
It is entirely unclear, what region, and which 4 hours of what he is even speaking about.

As for the WAI study: A URL would be nice, followed by a couple of quotes with page number or some such, to start establishing something to talk about.

Somehow, Tony feels that 4 to 4.5 of something someway hot are somehow not quite right, but he hasn't even begun to construct an argument.

I suggest we all first wait for Tony to present an argument.
 
I am curious to hear the voices of those who frequent this forum as to whether 4 to 4.5 hour fire simulation times are valid for WTC 7 studies such as those contained in the NIST and Weidlinger Associates analyses. The ARUP study used just one hour in its fire simulation.

We have all heard that the fires will burn up the fuel in any one area in about 1 to 2 hours maximum and also that the fires reach temperatures above 600 degrees C for about 40 to 60 minutes and then start to cool. This was shown in the Cardington test data.

See http://www.mace.manchester.ac.uk/pr...aBase/TestData/FullScaleFireTestBRE215741.pdf

It is also interesting that the Cardington test data for protected steel does not reach temperatures which would produce failure. WTC 7's steel was protected.

If WTC7 is one of the big towers, they know the heat protection on the structural steel was blown off by the crashes on the floor(s) they impacted due to the dustification on contact of the planes as they crashed in (due to speed).

That was on television within a couple of months as intelligent analyses had started being available - as opposed to the near immediate crap ideas from the loose brains tools!!!
 
Tony still has not explained and properly sourced what his 4 (NIST) and 4.5 (WAI) hours of ... something refer to, and what he wants to claim they are relevant to.

As far as NIST is concerned, he so far pointed to Chapter 10 of NCSTAR 1-9. This chapter contains no fire simulation and thus cannot contain any justification for any duration of heating applied to any region within the structure.
It is entirely unclear, what region, and which 4 hours of what he is even speaking about.

As for the WAI study: A URL would be nice, followed by a couple of quotes with page number or some such, to start establishing something to talk about.

Somehow, Tony feels that 4 to 4.5 of something someway hot are somehow not quite right, but he hasn't even begun to construct an argument.

I suggest we all first wait for Tony to present an argument.

You can find the WAI report here: http://www.thorntontomasetti.com/projects/world_trade_center_7_collapse_investigation/

The report cites an expert report by Dr. Craig Beyler (a world renowned fire science expert and Chair of the International Association for Fire Safety Science) that provides the basis for WAI's temperature model. The Beyler report is not independently available, as far as I know (like the main WAI report itself, it seems to have been prepared for the defense in the Aegis litigation but never ultimately filed with the court since that case was won on summary judgment, but it was not released with the WAI report). There are, however, references in the report to a 4.5 hour time frame for the peak temperatures in the collapse-initiating area resulting from the fires modeled. If you look at page 17 of the WAI report, fore example, you can get a sense for the fire modeled. Based on the hockey stick of the temperatures, it seems he was likely modeling a traveling fire that only reached peak intensity at the collapse area in the hour before the collapse initiated.

And, just because I like reminding people that these engineering issues really are of great interest to (and not ignored by) the structural engineering community, I'll also note that the WAI WTC 7 report won the following awards:

2015 Grand Award, American Council of Engineering Companies, World Trade Center 7 Collapse Analysis and Assessment Forensic Study, New York, New York
2015 Diamond Award, American Council of Engineering Companies of New York, World Trade Center 7 Collapse Analysis and Assessment Forensic Study, New York, New York

This also answers the question as to why the report, though not ultimately filed in the Aegis litigation, was ultimately released to the public and touted on WAI's website sometime this year--they are celebrating it as a substantial professional achievement.

EDIT: here is a video of Dr. Abboud receiving his award for the WAI WTC 7 investigation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6VGDqoJWXf0
 
Last edited:
If WTC7 is one of the big towers, they know the heat protection on the structural steel was blown off by the crashes on the floor(s) they impacted due to the dustification on contact of the planes as they crashed in (due to speed).

That was on television within a couple of months as intelligent analyses had started being available - as opposed to the near immediate crap ideas from the loose brains tools!!!

Just in case: at speed, the outer metal skin and softer parts were mostly turned to tiny particulates moving at high speed inward towards rooms, walls and structural material. The structural material had initially fireproofing coating that would have inhibited the possibility of heating to softness, but, the high speed particles of aircraft scraped off pretty much all the fireproofing/heat insulating material so the supports were now able to be heated enough to weaken and allow the floors to break down/past/throughwith them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom