Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

Luna 24 with launch date 9 Aug 1976 and recovery data 22 Aug 1976 was the last successful lunar sample return mission. According to Wikipedia, this was the third success in eleven attempts of the Soviets to bring down small amounts of moon rock to Earth. The task of returning 170 gram = 9n17 kg of moon rock is incomparably easier than of returning humans whose net weight alone is 200 kg = 2p2 kg or more. Rocks are not sensitive to temperature and high g's (decelerations). And we can take into consideration that the Soviets had been leading in space technology over many years.

In the four decades after Luna 24, only four "Far Earth" sample return missions have been completed, and only one single succeeded in safely landing an extremely small cargo (i.e. dust particles):

  • Stardust: It successfully reentered in 2006 with a peak deceleration of 34 g = 333 m/s2 = 2p333 m/s per sec = 1200 km/s per sec = 745 mph/s.
  • Genesis: "Genesis was launched on August 8, 2001, and crash-landed in Utah on September 8, 2004, after a design flaw prevented the deployment of its drogue parachute."
  • Hayabusa: "The reentry capsule and the spacecraft reentered Earth's atmosphere on 13 June 2010 at 13:51 UTC. The heat-shielded capsule made a parachute landing in the South Australian outback while the spacecraft broke up and incinerated in a large fireball."
  • Phobos-Grunt: "It was launched on 8 November 2011, 20:16 UTC from the Baikonur Cosmodrome, but subsequent rocket burns intended to set the craft on a course for Mars failed, leaving it stranded in low Earth orbit."
It is true that in case of return from "really" outside the Earth's gravitation, reentry velocity is higher than terrestrial escape velocity vesc = 4p112 m/s, whereas in the lunar-mission case, it is normally slightly less than vesc. Nevertheless this difference in kinetic energy has not been substantial.

In meanwhile the Chinese have successfully landed their Chang'e 5 test return-vehicle after coming back from a short lunar orbit:

[qimg]http://www.pandualism.com/upload/Chang_e_5_T1.JPG[/qimg]
Xinhua/Ren Junchuan

Interestingly, I did not hear about this Chinese success when it actually happened on Oct 31, 2014. Maybe, Western media were then primarily covering the launch and crash of Virgin Galactic's SpaceShipTwo happening on exactly the same day.

Unlike Apollo, no confusion prevails on how the Chinese succeeded in landing the return module on Earth (and in resolving other challenges, see). In comparison to Apollo, the Chinese had not only the advantage of 45 years of technological progress, but also of an economy much stronger than in the United States of the 1960s.

If US landing of humans on the moon actually were a hoax then it would have been an incredibly ingenious way to steal from the "evil communists" the honor of having first landed on a celestial body. By redefining "landing on the moon" by "landing men on the moon" with their propaganda machine, the leading capitalist nation then faked not only one landing, but several landings. The organizers would have dwarfed even Joseph Goebbels by making the falsehood so preposterously exaggerated that nobody could imagine such an audacity in deception.

Cheers, Wolfgang
In the long run TRUTH has the best chance

If you don't have a problem with the Chinese mini-soyuz sample return capsule being able to successfully return from the Moon do you think the Soviet Union faked the return of the full size Soyuz capsules that were sent into cislunar and circumlunar space as Zond probes? Some of those made very steep ballistic reentries, perhaps you imagine the Russians have some means of shedding energy that America didn't have.
 
Last edited:
Thus, in #25 I explained that a huge difference prevails between returning from a stable orbit very close to the Earth's surface and coming back from an orbit around the moon.

Cheers, Wolfgang

Can I ask you to calculate the same things with a space shuttle re-entry at 17,500 mph and an Apollo CM at 25,000mph.

Tell us all about the differences.
 
Interestingly, I did not hear about this Chinese success when it actually happened on Oct 31, 2014. Maybe, Western media were then primarily covering the launch and crash of Virgin Galactic's SpaceShipTwo happening on exactly the same day.

Or maybe you just don't subscribe to the right news outlets, eg.

http://www.space.com/27627-china-moon-mission-earth-return.html

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencet...surface-Earth-background-prepares-return.html

http://www.nbcnews.com/science/space/chinas-change-5-t1-probe-returns-after-rounding-moon-n238936

By redefining "landing on the moon" by "landing men on the moon" with their propaganda machine, the leading capitalist nation then faked not only one landing, but several landings.

The US had already done 'landing on the moon' several times before landing people. The one followed the other.
 
Last edited:
I'm honestly curious here; is stuff like "4p65 m" some sort of recognized nomenclature in actual use I've never encountered before, or is it entirely made up?
 
Entirely made up, and as such earns the creator 0.2 TimeCubes.

Thanks; my first assumption when hitting something like that is that the nomenclature's obscure but not entirely made up.

I think 0.2 or 2 x 10^-1 should work out to 1n2, and 1n1 would be 0.1.
 
Thanks; my first assumption when hitting something like that is that the nomenclature's obscure but not entirely made up.

I think 0.2 or 2 x 10^-1 should work out to 1n2, and 1n1 would be 0.1.

Well, when coupled with a laughable attempt to recreate an existing science from first principles using poorly-recalled vestiges of high school physics and Wikipedia entries, I assume the one-off notation is made up.

It's been a while since I've seen this particular form of anti-Apollo woo. Back in the day quite a few went back to their high school physics books to try to "prove" Apollo was physically impossible. It was pretty sad.
 
It's been a while since I've seen this particular form of anti-Apollo woo. Back in the day quite a few went back to their high school physics books to try to "prove" Apollo was physically impossible. It was pretty sad.

But intriguing, from the point of view of explaining why it is wrong.

This is, of course, not true of someone who has seen the same argument 3p8 times...
 
In the four decades after Luna 24, only four "Far Earth" sample return missions have been completed, and only one single succeeded in safely landing an extremely small cargo (i.e. dust particles).

Bonus points for following this with a list of four missions, only three of which left Earth orbit, (even the ESA wouldn't claim that a Mars probe stranded in LEO was "completed") and where samples were recovered from all three.


Other "Far Earth" sample missions may have been planned (maybe even started) and later cancelled in the forty years after Luna 24. In any case, only four of them got completed up to concrete realization (i.e. rocket launch). From these four "Far Earth" sample missions, only one was a full success (at least according to Sample return mission).


Luna 24 with launch date 9 Aug 1976 and recovery data 22 Aug 1976 was the last successful lunar sample return mission. According to Wikipedia, this was the third success in eleven attempts of the Soviets to bring down small amounts of moon rock to Earth.

If you don't have a problem with the Chinese mini-Soyuz sample return capsule being able to successfully return from the Moon do you think the Soviet Union faked the return of the full size Soyuz capsules that were sent into cislunar and circumlunar space as Zond probes? Some of those made very steep ballistic reentries, perhaps you imagine the Russians have some means of shedding energy that America didn't have.


Wikipedia on Skip reentry:

"The technique was used by the Zond series of circumlunar spacecraft, which planned for one skip before landing. Zond 6, Zond 7 and Zond 8 made successful skip entries, although Zond 5 did not. The Apollo Command Module, when returning from the moon, was capable of a one-skip entry. …The Chang'e 5-T1 [China, 2014] also used this technique."​
Wikipedia on Zond 7:

"Like other Zond circumlunar craft, Zond 7 used a relatively uncommon technique called skip reentry to shed velocity upon returning to Earth."​

Wikipedia on Zond 5:

Zond 5 launched on September 15 [1968] and became the first spacecraft to circle the Moon and return to land on Earth. … A biological payload of two Russian tortoises, wine flies, meal worms, plants, seeds, bacteria, and other living matter was included in the flight.

On September 22, the reentry capsule entered the Earth's atmosphere but could not perform a skip reentry due to a failure of the guidance system. Landing was supposed to occur in Kazakhstan, but instead Zond 5 splashed down in the Indian Ocean and was successfully recovered by the USSR recovery vessels Borovichy and Vasiliy Golovin. The USS McMorris was shadowing Soviet ships, collecting intelligence information. Photographs taken by the McMorris of the descent module bobbing in the ocean aroused concern at NASA that the Soviets were planning a manned circumlunar flight soon, especially since the US had been tracking Zond 5 for its entire flight, and may have been a catalyst for the decision to launch Apollo 8 to the Moon in December instead of its originally planned mission of testing the lunar module in high Earth orbit.

Although the ballistic reentry would have been bad for human occupants, it did not appear to affect the biological specimens, all of which were alive and well when the descent module was finally opened four days after landing. It was announced that the tortoises had lost about 10% of their body weight but remained active and showed no loss of appetite.
​
Let us assume that the survival of "tortoises and other biological specimens" was faked, and the Americans knew that. "The Chief Designer" Sergei Korlolev had died in 1966, and maybe in the aftermath of his death, less capable and honest persons (temporarily) took over.

If this or an analogue hypothesis were correct then Americans would have had a form of pressure on participants of the Soviet Space Program suspicious of the claimed successes of Apollo.

In any case, the majority of the Soviet Space Program has not been faked, such as e.g. the first photographs of the dark side of the moon by Luna 3.


There is no confusion about how Apollo command modules landed on Earth.


See: Re-Entry Matters, A Detailed Investigation into Apollo Command Module Returns, Mary DM Bennett

Cheers, Wolfgang
www.pandualism.com
 
Other "Far Earth" sample missions may have been planned (maybe even started) and later cancelled in the forty years after Luna 24. In any case, only four of them got completed up to concrete realization (i.e. rocket launch). From these four "Far Earth" sample missions, only one was a full success (at least according to Sample return mission).







Wikipedia on Skip reentry:

"The technique was used by the Zond series of circumlunar spacecraft, which planned for one skip before landing. Zond 6, Zond 7 and Zond 8 made successful skip entries, although Zond 5 did not. The Apollo Command Module, when returning from the moon, was capable of a one-skip entry. …The Chang'e 5-T1 [China, 2014] also used this technique."​
Wikipedia on Zond 7:

"Like other Zond circumlunar craft, Zond 7 used a relatively uncommon technique called skip reentry to shed velocity upon returning to Earth."​

Wikipedia on Zond 5:

Zond 5 launched on September 15 [1968] and became the first spacecraft to circle the Moon and return to land on Earth. … A biological payload of two Russian tortoises, wine flies, meal worms, plants, seeds, bacteria, and other living matter was included in the flight.

On September 22, the reentry capsule entered the Earth's atmosphere but could not perform a skip reentry due to a failure of the guidance system. Landing was supposed to occur in Kazakhstan, but instead Zond 5 splashed down in the Indian Ocean and was successfully recovered by the USSR recovery vessels Borovichy and Vasiliy Golovin. The USS McMorris was shadowing Soviet ships, collecting intelligence information. Photographs taken by the McMorris of the descent module bobbing in the ocean aroused concern at NASA that the Soviets were planning a manned circumlunar flight soon, especially since the US had been tracking Zond 5 for its entire flight, and may have been a catalyst for the decision to launch Apollo 8 to the Moon in December instead of its originally planned mission of testing the lunar module in high Earth orbit.

Although the ballistic reentry would have been bad for human occupants, it did not appear to affect the biological specimens, all of which were alive and well when the descent module was finally opened four days after landing. It was announced that the tortoises had lost about 10% of their body weight but remained active and showed no loss of appetite.
​
Let us assume that the survival of "tortoises and other biological specimens" was faked, and the Americans knew that. "The Chief Designer" Sergei Korlolev had died in 1966, and maybe in the aftermath of his death, less capable and honest persons (temporarily) took over.

If this or an analogue hypothesis were correct then Americans would have had a form of pressure on participants of the Soviet Space Program suspicious of the claimed successes of Apollo.

In any case, the majority of the Soviet Space Program has not been faked, such as e.g. the first photographs of the dark side of the moon by Luna 3.





See: Re-Entry Matters, A Detailed Investigation into Apollo Command Module Returns, Mary DM Bennett

Cheers, Wolfgang
www.pandualism.com

So much wrong.

1. The link you cite for only a single success contradicts you. You clearly did not read it.

2. The link you cite omits the Apollo missions. It is not an exhaustive list.

3. Your wiki citations are for successful re-entries which you are attempting to claim cannot happen.

4. "Let us assume"? What? Really? If we all assume they were faked then we can conclude they were fake? Circular reasoning is circular.

5. Mary Bennett? You cite Bennett as a form of authority? That nutbar? Seriously? Do you not know that she is flat out crazy? And a proven liar?
 
On September 22, the reentry capsule entered the Earth's atmosphere but could not perform a skip reentry due to a failure of the guidance system. Landing was supposed to occur in Kazakhstan, but instead Zond 5 splashed down in the Indian Ocean and was successfully recovered by the USSR recovery vessels Borovichy and Vasiliy Golovin. The USS McMorris was shadowing Soviet ships, collecting intelligence information. Photographs taken by the McMorris of the descent module bobbing in the ocean aroused concern at NASA that the Soviets were planning a manned circumlunar flight soon, especially since the US had been tracking Zond 5 for its entire flight, and may have been a catalyst for the decision to launch Apollo 8 to the Moon in December instead of its originally planned mission of testing the lunar module in high Earth orbit.

Although the ballistic reentry would have been bad for human occupants, it did not appear to affect the biological specimens, all of which were alive and well when the descent module was finally opened four days after landing. It was announced that the tortoises had lost about 10% of their body weight but remained active and showed no loss of appetite.[/COLOR][/INDENT]

Let us assume that the survival of "tortoises and other biological specimens" was faked, and the Americans knew that. "The Chief Designer" Sergei Korlolev had died in 1966, and maybe in the aftermath of his death, less capable and honest persons (temporarily) took over.

Regardless of whether the biological experiments were unharmed by the 20g accelerations during the re-entry we have a straight in return from the Moon that the capsule's heat shield was able to survive.

Wasn't your point that the kinetic energy of a spacecraft returning from the Moon was too great for a 1960s thermal protection system to handle?
 
Last edited:
Regardless of whether the biological experiments were unharmed by the 20g accelerations during the re-entry we have a straight in return from the Moon that the capsule's heat shield was able to survive.

Wasn't your point that the kinetic energy of a spacecraft returning from the Moon was too great for a 1960s thermal protection system to handle?
It is when he wants it to be and it isn't when he doesn't.
 
At this point Wogoga has devolved into cribbing from known cranks. We're done here.

ETA:
Bennett is a self-proclaimed psychic. She has no training at all in aerospace matters, and no experience. I wish I could count the number of times I've caught her in bald-faced lies and fabricated "research." Naturally neither she nor her sometimes co-author David Percy will debate me directly. They know they're lying. Here it seems she's trying to parlay her lack of understanding of different ways of tracking and measuring entry parameters into some genuine controversy, peppered with cherry-picked quotes from barely-cited sources.

Wogoga, I hope you realize that by quoting the queen of Moon hoax liars, you've essentially ensured no serious scientist or engineer will ever take you seriously again.
 
Last edited:
Mary Bennett makes great play in her piece on 'Aulis' (which should in itself be a clue that it's all a complete crock) that Tom Stafford claimed in his autobiography that his re-entry speed was 28547 mph, which is faster than a return from Mars. Here are her exact words:

Tom Stafford (Apollo 10 again) asserted in his own 2002 biography We Have Capture that his entry speed was 28,547mph, which works out at 41,869ft/sec – faster than a return from Mars!

I have a copy of the book in front of me, and this is what it actually says:

Our trajectory was designed for the fastest return possible, allowing us to cover the 238,000 mile distance in 42 hours, rather than the usual 56 or more. This meant that at one point we reached a speed of 24,791.4 nautical miles (28547 statute miles) an hour, the fastest human beings have ever flown, or ever will fly, until astronauts return from a trip to Mars

Wolfgang - do you see the subtle difference there between what Bennett claimed was written and what was actually written?
 
Other "Far Earth" sample missions may have been planned (maybe even started) and later cancelled in the forty years after Luna 24. In any case, only four of them got completed up to concrete realization (i.e. rocket launch). From these four "Far Earth" sample missions, only one was a full success (at least according to Sample return mission).

Look at the table again; four missions, three successful or partially successful since your arbitrary cutoff of Luna 24.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom