Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

That will come as a bit of a shock to the people who picked out of the sea, as shown in this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SM2KWCMrOYw

John C. Stennis Space Center, who have it on display.

Picking random unsubstantiated nonsense out of [insert appropriate origin] does not amount to evidence, neither does it prove your stupid maths to be correct.



I found this video from youtube last week. It's a little more tech oriented:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnH8wDmN_IA&list=PLLY3VlW7pqsfb4jnV6C6uklJnhTVpG8Cy


And it's a tech doc so....the....narrator.......must........speak.........very..............slowly


It is, and that's the one that I thought had the quantitative analysis of the design.


This one shows the heat shield honeycomb being fitted, filled (all 370,000 of 'em) machined and tested @ 11:29.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pvW03OYJ_1E&list=PLLY3VlW7pqsfb4jnV6C6uklJnhTVpG8Cy&index=10

@ 20:20 shows heat shield failing a drop test.


That's because they were using a Block 1 Boilermaker. Hah! they should have been using a Block 2 boilermaker. PBR chased with Jack Daniels !!!

I wonder why Wogoga thinks he can simply hand wave away all that expertise?
 
I found this video from youtube last week. It's a little more tech oriented:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnH8wDmN_IA&list=PLLY3VlW7pqsfb4jnV6C6uklJnhTVpG8Cy

And it's a tech doc so....the....narrator.......must........speak.........very..............slowly

This one shows the heat shield honeycomb being fitted, filled (all 370,000 of 'em) machined and tested @ 11:29.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pvW03OYJ_1E&list=PLLY3VlW7pqsfb4jnV6C6uklJnhTVpG8Cy&index=10

@ 20:20 shows heat shield failing a drop test.

That's because they were using a Block 1 Boilermaker. Hah! they should have been using a Block 2 boilermaker. PBR chased with Jack Daniels !!!

I wonder why Wogoga thinks he can simply hand wave away all that expertise?
The narrator still didn't talk slowly enough for Wogoga to understand? I don't think anyone could.
 
An air particle colliding with the heat shield of the reentry module gets a huge impulse (off the shield). Yet the particle cannot leave the region close to the 12 m2 heat shield easily, because mean free path even in front of the highly compressed shock wave is only 1 mm = 7n1 meter.

"An air particle colliding with the heat shield" is therefore an event that can only occur for air particles within that mean free path once the shock wave forms, and much of the momentum transfer is therefore due to collisions between atoms elsewhere, ...


Such "collisions elsewhere" can only slow down the spacecraft, if momentum ultimately gets transferred to the heat shield (via collisions with particles situated closer and closer to the heat shield). Without such momentum transfer, a deceleration of the spacecraft is impossible.

The mean free path in the shock-compressed air just before the heat shield is even substantially lower than 1 mm (here assumed as free path outside the compressed shock wave), since this region has much higher density due to bombardment by new air particles (e.g. Mach 30 relative to heat shield). Particles jammed between the 12 m2 heat shield and the newly arriving high-speed air particles need many collisions in order to escape. Where could all this kinetic resp. thermodynamic energy disappear without affecting the heat shield?

Almost half of the radiation emerging in this region is directed to the heat shield.

Two quotes from NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF THE APOLLO 4 REENTRY TRAJECTORY:

High speed reentry velocities lead to a strong shock wave upstream of the vehicle which strongly modifies the state of the fluid behind it. The internal thermodynamic energy of the free-stream fluid particles is small when compared with the kinetic energy of the free stream. As the Mach number is increased, the flow density increases progressively, so the shock layer created by the strong bow shock over the blunt nose becomes thinner; the detachment distance between the wall boundary and the shock wave is really small.

As aforementioned, the collisions between free stream particles and molecules of the dense shock layer excite the rotational, vibrational and electronic modes of the molecules, and give rise to a non-equilibrium between the temperatures and energies corresponding to these modes. Generally, translational and rotational energy modes require a few collisions to equilibrate, so they are usually considered in equilibrium even for Hypersonic flow conditions, for the sake of time-saving. On the other hand, chemical dissociation and vibrational excitation require more collisions to reach their equilibrium state and non-equilibrium effects may be important for hypersonic flow conditions, especially at high altitudes.
​
In any case, the only reasonable hypothesis for Apollo reentry being possible seems this one:

The by far biggest part (substantially more than 90%) of the energy emerging due to transfer of momentum from the spacecraft to the atmosphere is used to break and ionize air molecules or to induce energy in form of rotational, vibrational or electronic "excitation" not transmittable to the heat shield. All these energy forms are only released again when the molecules or their fragments have left the region close to heat shield.​

Since a reentry similar to a Apollo reentry has never been successfully repeated, I prefer the simple and clear arguments suggesting physical impossibility to the complicated and opaque arguments suggesting possibility.
Cheers, Wolfgang
The Apollo Space Program – A gigantic conspiracy?
 
Since a reentry similar to a Apollo reentry has never been successfully repeated...

So, if we ignore all the times it was successfully repeated, it has never been successfully repeated.

Can you enumerate for us all the times it was unsuccessfully repeated? How many space programmes attempted the same reentry and found it impossible? Thanks.
 
Such "collisions elsewhere" can only slow down the spacecraft, if momentum ultimately gets transferred to the heat shield (via collisions with particles situated closer and closer to the heat shield). Without such momentum transfer, a deceleration of the spacecraft is impossible.
Super. But that is not how the heat shield works, so it is irrelevant rubbish.

The mean free path in the shock-compressed air just before the heat shield is even substantially lower than 1 mm (here assumed as free path outside the compressed shock wave), since this region has much higher density due to bombardment by new air particles (e.g. Mach 30 relative to heat shield). Particles jammed between the 12 m2 heat shield and the newly arriving high-speed air particles need many collisions in order to escape. Where could all this kinetic resp. thermodynamic energy disappear without affecting the heat shield?
Fractally wrong.

Almost half of the radiation emerging in this region is directed to the heat shield.
Evidence for this claim please.


Two quotes from NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF THE APOLLO 4 REENTRY TRAJECTORY:

High speed reentry velocities lead to a strong shock wave upstream of the vehicle which strongly modifies the state of the fluid behind it. The internal thermodynamic energy of the free-stream fluid particles is small when compared with the kinetic energy of the free stream. As the Mach number is increased, the flow density increases progressively, so the shock layer created by the strong bow shock over the blunt nose becomes thinner; the detachment distance between the wall boundary and the shock wave is really small.

As aforementioned, the collisions between free stream particles and molecules of the dense shock layer excite the rotational, vibrational and electronic modes of the molecules, and give rise to a non-equilibrium between the temperatures and energies corresponding to these modes. Generally, translational and rotational energy modes require a few collisions to equilibrate, so they are usually considered in equilibrium even for Hypersonic flow conditions, for the sake of time-saving. On the other hand, chemical dissociation and vibrational excitation require more collisions to reach their equilibrium state and non-equilibrium effects may be important for hypersonic flow conditions, especially at high altitudes.
​
In any case, the only reasonable hypothesis for Apollo reentry being possible seems this one:

The by far biggest part (substantially more than 90%) of the energy emerging due to transfer of momentum from the spacecraft to the atmosphere is used to break and ionize air molecules or to induce energy in form of rotational, vibrational or electronic "excitation" not transmittable to the heat shield. All these energy forms are only released again when the molecules or their fragments have left the region close to heat shield.​

Since a reentry similar to a Apollo reentry has never been successfully repeated, I prefer the simple and clear arguments suggesting physical impossibility to the complicated and opaque arguments suggesting possibility.
Cheers, Wolfgang
The Apollo Space Program – A gigantic conspiracy?

Cherry picking is bad enough. Cherry picking quotes you misinterpret is worse.
 
Since a reentry similar to a Apollo reentry has never been successfully repeated, I prefer the simple and clear arguments suggesting physical impossibility

So are you now backtracking from your claim that Apollo 4 did not have a successful re-entry? Are you going to pretend you never said that the photos were of poor quality?

If Apollo 4 can manage a re-entry designed to emulate those of craft returning from the moon, why can't others?
 
I've attempted to tell this to wogoga upthread but it was apparently overlooked: air particles do not impact the heat shield.

The heat shield is ablative, meaning it burns away during use, like brake pads, which are made of similar organic resin binders. The resin decomposes at 200-something degrees C, about the temp for baking muffins in an oven. As it decomposes the gasses outflow. It's this boundary layer of gas that actual air molecules are impacting, and it's these gasses flowing out of the heat shield that carry the heat away. The plume of reentry gasses are very hot.

The bottom of the heat shield is like the bottom of a pot of beans. As long as the water is boiling off it's able to keep the pot bottom at the boiling temp of water. The flame is very hot, but the beans don't burn because hot gasses on the bottom of the pot form a temperature boundary layer, and carry incoming heat away.

The total energy dissipation budget of Apollo reentry cannot be discussed accurately until you acknowledge the energy consumption of the ablative material decomposing, and realize that these gasses prevent ANY air from impacting the surface of the reentry module.

Also, I suggest looking into how Soyuz craft dump heat on reentry. It's the same frigging theory, in continuous service since 1967.
 
Last edited:
Since a reentry similar to a Apollo reentry has never been successfully repeated, I prefer the simple and clear arguments suggesting physical impossibility to the complicated and opaque arguments suggesting possibility.

Sounds more like you don't understand how the thermal protection system actually worked, can't be bothered to learn, and would rather camp on your own ignorant model and claim the people who succeeded in what you fail at must be lying. Is that about right?
 
Such "collisions elsewhere" can only slow down the spacecraft, if momentum ultimately gets transferred to the heat shield (via collisions with particles situated closer and closer to the heat shield). Without such momentum transfer, a deceleration of the spacecraft is impossible.

The mean free path in the shock-compressed air just before the heat shield is even substantially lower than 1 mm (here assumed as free path outside the compressed shock wave), since this region has much higher density due to bombardment by new air particles (e.g. Mach 30 relative to heat shield). Particles jammed between the 12 m2 heat shield and the newly arriving high-speed air particles need many collisions in order to escape. Where could all this kinetic resp. thermodynamic energy disappear without affecting the heat shield?

Almost half of the radiation emerging in this region is directed to the heat shield.

Two quotes from NUMERICAL SIMULATIONS OF THE APOLLO 4 REENTRY TRAJECTORY:

High speed reentry velocities lead to a strong shock wave upstream of the vehicle which strongly modifies the state of the fluid behind it. The internal thermodynamic energy of the free-stream fluid particles is small when compared with the kinetic energy of the free stream. As the Mach number is increased, the flow density increases progressively, so the shock layer created by the strong bow shock over the blunt nose becomes thinner; the detachment distance between the wall boundary and the shock wave is really small.

As aforementioned, the collisions between free stream particles and molecules of the dense shock layer excite the rotational, vibrational and electronic modes of the molecules, and give rise to a non-equilibrium between the temperatures and energies corresponding to these modes. Generally, translational and rotational energy modes require a few collisions to equilibrate, so they are usually considered in equilibrium even for Hypersonic flow conditions, for the sake of time-saving. On the other hand, chemical dissociation and vibrational excitation require more collisions to reach their equilibrium state and non-equilibrium effects may be important for hypersonic flow conditions, especially at high altitudes.
​
In any case, the only reasonable hypothesis for Apollo reentry being possible seems this one:

The by far biggest part (substantially more than 90%) of the energy emerging due to transfer of momentum from the spacecraft to the atmosphere is used to break and ionize air molecules or to induce energy in form of rotational, vibrational or electronic "excitation" not transmittable to the heat shield. All these energy forms are only released again when the molecules or their fragments have left the region close to heat shield.​

Since a reentry similar to a Apollo reentry has never been successfully repeated, I prefer the simple and clear arguments suggesting physical impossibility to the complicated and opaque arguments suggesting possibility.
Cheers, Wolfgang
The Apollo Space Program – A gigantic conspiracy?

I deny your denial
 
I've attempted to tell this to wogoga upthread but it was apparently overlooked: air particles do not impact the heat shield.

The heat shield is ablative, meaning it burns away during use, like brake pads, which are made of similar organic resin binders. The resin decomposes at 200-something degrees C, about the temp for baking muffins in an oven. As it decomposes the gasses outflow. It's this boundary layer of gas that actual air molecules are impacting, and it's these gasses flowing out of the heat shield that carry the heat away. The plume of reentry gasses are very hot.

The bottom of the heat shield is like the bottom of a pot of beans. As long as the water is boiling off it's able to keep the pot bottom at the boiling temp of water. The flame is very hot, but the beans don't burn because hot gasses on the bottom of the pot form a temperature boundary layer, and carry incoming heat away.

The total energy dissipation budget of Apollo reentry cannot be discussed accurately until you acknowledge the energy consumption of the ablative material decomposing, and realize that these gasses prevent ANY air from impacting the surface of the reentry module.

Also, I suggest looking into how Soyuz craft dump heat on reentry. It's the same frigging theory, in continuous service since 1967.

Dammit. I had Soyuz quietly in reserve. Oh well. :D
 
I had Luna 16, 20, and 24, and Stardust in reserve. I mean, quite apart from wogoga's stubborn insistence on not understanding how ablative reentry shielding works, his basic premise is simply wrong. Not that being wrong has slowed him down yet.
 
I had Luna 16, 20, and 24, and Stardust in reserve. I mean, quite apart from wogoga's stubborn insistence on not understanding how ablative reentry shielding works, his basic premise is simply wrong. Not that being wrong has slowed him down yet.

Quite. It seems that any challenge to his quixotic (at best) understanding gets swept under the carpet of subject matter ignorance. He seems entirely unable to get beyond linear relationships. Differential calculus is apparently terra incognita, as is scale, logarithmic graphical axes, the list is endless. Add to that his quirky numerical notation which we can already operate correctly and he cannot all leads to a very dark pit of ignorance.

More offensive is his selective reposting and cherry picking that he chooses to post on his own blog.
 
Since a reentry similar to a Apollo reentry has never been successfully repeated, ..]
Since this post lies by quote mining and then ends with this lie, we know your opinion is based on at least deep ignorance wogoga.
Soyuz alone makes this a lie.
Ditto for Gemini.
Ditto for Mercury.
Ditto for the Space Shuttle.
Ditto for Shenzhou.
These are some of the vehicles that have a reentry similar to a Apollo reentry :jaw-dropp!
 
Lance Armstrong seems to be representative of those having seized the control of the United States, whereas Neil Armstrong who died three days after the irretrievable fall on 2012-10-22 of Lance was rather a tragic hero and liar against will.

A lie of calling Neil Armstrong a "tragic hero and liar against will" is even worse. Neil Armstrong was a hero before Apollo (a test pilot) and a hero during Apollo because he was the first man on the Moon. Neil Armstrong did not lie.


Please watch depressed Neil Armstrong speaking (especially at 12:11):

"Today we have with us a group of students, among America's best. To you we say we have only completed a beginning. We leave you much that is undone. There are great ideas undiscovered, breakthroughs available to those who can remove one of the truth's protective layers. There are many places to go beyond belief. Those challenges are yours – in many fields, not the least of which is space, because there lies human destiny." (Transcript)​

A reasonable video on Apollo with some quite convincing arguments: Conspiracy Theory: Did We Land on the Moon?

Cheers, Wolfgang
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom