Jrrarglblarg
Unregistered
- Joined
- Nov 15, 2010
- Messages
- 12,673
I can't even begin to catalog the Wrong the last post by wogoga.
Since air particles colliding with the shock layer in front of the heat shield (see #308) have theoretical temperatures in the order of tens of thousands degrees Kelvin (see above), their collisions with shock layer particles lead in the first place rather to ultraviolet than to infrared radiation.
Wait, are you saying that the velocity/temp of air molecule interaction with the compression zone is greater than the velocity/temperature of the compressed gasses?
There is a plasma exiting off the edge of the capsule. That MUST be carrying off heat, right? That would be considered a convective heat transfer, right? Plasma out, compression zone stays the same size therefore........?
The Apollo heat shield is assumed to generally work substantially below 5000 Fahrenheit resp. 3000°K, and thermal radiation in this temperature range lies primarily in the infrared (see Wien's displacement law). So "gases produced in the ablation process" which are "substantially opaque to infrared" would prevent the heat shield from performing its main task, namely from radiating off heat.[/INDENT]
Thus, the assumption that bombardment of the spacecraft by high-speed air particles represents "cooler air" for the heat shield is completely absurd.
...their collisions with shock layer particles lead in the first place rather to ultraviolet than to infrared radiation.
A chatroom-chat-free version of this thread nevertheless taking into account all relevant counter-arguments...
That's the main task of an ablation shield?
What this looks like to the layman (which I am) is someone pretending to know what they're talking about throwing lots of complex looking numbers at something in the hope that no-one will notice they're wrong and in so doing making it impossible to see wood in a whole batch of trees.
Ok, might someone in the know either give a summary, or point me to a post here that does.
Points to consider:
- capsule enters atmosphere dense enough to start the compression bow wave then.
The energy of the moving capsule is transferred to.......
... heating of the compression zone
... heating of the heat shield
... that heat is then sent away by some mechanisms
... all of this must contribute to the slowing of the capsule(after all the only energy input is the kinetic energy of the capsule, one mechanism of energy transfer in this system involves heating and sending the heat away from the capsule.
We can stop there with the lie of "assumed" followed by ignorant gibberish and more "assumption" lies, wogoga.Hot air and/or gaseous heat-shield particles are assumed...
Nitpick: not the shuttle. It was, with the oft-discussed latrine innovations and thermal shielding, a literal brick **** house. It used ablative elements on a leading edge, but mostly it just radiated heat from the brick cladding.
Thank you, sir.The reinforced carbon-carbon on the nose and leading edge of the orbiter wings was not ablative.
...hear of replacing the Leading Edges
--especially as it had little-to-no back-up structure there...
Actually, with the proper layup, you can get pretty much the thermal CoE you want-negative, even. The optical bench on Clementine was inevitable such I worked with. I didn't do the composites-not my specialty- but I did have the aluminum and Tutanium structure around it...Each segment of the leading edge was in the neighborhood of $800,000. It's far easier to manufacture RCC in sheets or other regular shapes. The high cost was due to having to manufacture them in the particular shapes required for the orbiter.
By design. RCC remains solid at very high temperatures but has a coefficient of thermal expansion that requires a floating mount. You can't bolt them directly to a spar. Nor would you anyway, because you need an insulator between RCC elements and structure.