Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

Since air particles colliding with the shock layer in front of the heat shield (see #308) have theoretical temperatures in the order of tens of thousands degrees Kelvin (see above), their collisions with shock layer particles lead in the first place rather to ultraviolet than to infrared radiation.
​


Even if you are correct, what then would be absorbing the radiated UV/NIR ?

UV is not far removed in Freq from IR. Perhaps you'd like to ask JU what the spectra width of the opacity of the gases is.​
 
Wait, are you saying that the velocity/temp of air molecule interaction with the compression zone is greater than the velocity/temperature of the compressed gasses?

There is a plasma exiting off the edge of the capsule. That MUST be carrying off heat, right? That would be considered a convective heat transfer, right? Plasma out, compression zone stays the same size therefore........?

Actually the plasma pushes upward against the capsule, that is going downward, though the air stream in an equal and opposite reaction that is what slows the capsule.

The heat shield also burns away in the center, that is why it is thickest there.

This is Forty year old science the steeper the decent the more compression the higher the plasma temperature the more resistance to downward motion.

Friction does occur on the edge of the heat shield as the plasma is expelled from under the heat shield but it is minimal.

The plasma simply acts similar to a rocket engine in an equal and opposite reaction with the main energy source being gravity.
The speed of re entry imparts energy to the gas causing formation of a plasma do to increased particle collisions in the gas, and between the space craft and the gas, that causes the gas to expand in all directions slowing the gravitational decent, in an equal but opposite reaction.
 
The Apollo heat shield is assumed to generally work substantially below 5000 Fahrenheit resp. 3000°K, and thermal radiation in this temperature range lies primarily in the infrared (see Wien's displacement law). So "gases produced in the ablation process" which are "substantially opaque to infrared" would prevent the heat shield from performing its main task, namely from radiating off heat.[/INDENT]

That's the main task of an ablation shield?
 
Wogoga seems to assume that the shield-generated gases, opaque to IR, would not be affected by IR? They would not be heated beyond initial temperature on exposure to the radiant energy of the shockwave compression layer, carrying some of that energy away?
 
Ok, might someone in the know either give a summary, or point me to a post here that does.
Points to consider:
- capsule enters atmosphere dense enough to start the compression bow wave then.
The energy of the moving capsule is transferred to.......
... heating of the compression zone
... heating of the heat shield
... that heat is then sent away by some mechanisms
... all of this must contribute to the slowing of the capsule(after all the only energy input is the kinetic energy of the capsule, one mechanism of energy transfer in this system involves heating and sending the heat away from the capsule.
 
Thus, the assumption that bombardment of the spacecraft by high-speed air particles represents "cooler air" for the heat shield is completely absurd.

Good thing your simplistic picture of the fluid flow is not what we rely upon to achieve the convection component.

...their collisions with shock layer particles lead in the first place rather to ultraviolet than to infrared radiation.

Arguing from theory is one thing. Measuring the actual wavelengths in a high-velocity wind tunnel is another. Have you done this? Guess who has. But I notice you want to quibble over wavelengths rather than confront the part of the overall mechanism that you didn't know about: namely that your fretting and stewing over radiative heat transfer presumes there can be no way of insulating the spacecraft against it. Again, this was not new technology for Apollo. This was developed in the 1950s for ICBMs.

A chatroom-chat-free version of this thread nevertheless taking into account all relevant counter-arguments...

What a crock of crap. You're cherry-picking the parts of this discuss that make it seem like you're not losing. That's incredibly dishonest.
 
What this looks like to the layman (which I am) is someone pretending to know what they're talking about throwing lots of complex looking numbers at something in the hope that no-one will notice they're wrong and in so doing making it impossible to see wood in a whole batch of trees.

Wogoga, all your abstruse calculations do not hide the fact that verifiably correct photographic and film evidence exists of Apollo 4 taking off, orbiting and heading for splashdown. It was tracked and monitored throughout this process in a global effort by people who are still around.

Throwing ever more numbers at your 'problem' is masking reality, not explaining it.
 
What this looks like to the layman (which I am) is someone pretending to know what they're talking about throwing lots of complex looking numbers at something in the hope that no-one will notice they're wrong and in so doing making it impossible to see wood in a whole batch of trees.

Yep, it's a great big bluff. He doesn't know what he's talking about. He has no experience with practical thermal design techniques. He seems to have a smattering of high-school level physics, but he doesn't see how the big-picture designs work in the real world, or the low-level mechanics either. And his knowledge of the history of the field is sorely lacking, leading him to couch his claims in the presumption that this could be credibly lied about by hoax perpetrators.

Again, this sort of stuff is not a military secret or a trade secret. It's published in the literature, which began by studying meteor trajectories.
 
Well, I'm just an overeducated carpenter and I understand it. My observation over the years suggests active effort is required to maintain belief in the face of contradictory information.
 
Ok, might someone in the know either give a summary, or point me to a post here that does.
Points to consider:
- capsule enters atmosphere dense enough to start the compression bow wave then.
The energy of the moving capsule is transferred to.......
... heating of the compression zone
... heating of the heat shield
... that heat is then sent away by some mechanisms
... all of this must contribute to the slowing of the capsule(after all the only energy input is the kinetic energy of the capsule, one mechanism of energy transfer in this system involves heating and sending the heat away from the capsule.

Wikipedia has a nice page about it:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_entry

Halfway down they start talking about Shock layer gas physics.
 
The truth about ablative heat shields that wogoga denies

Hot air and/or gaseous heat-shield particles are assumed...
We can stop there with the lie of "assumed" followed by ignorant gibberish and more "assumption" lies, wogoga.
The truth is ablative heat shields work using known physics that forms a cooler layer between the spacecraft and the hotter shock wave.
The truth is ablative heat shields have been tested in experiments for about 50 years.
The truth is ablative heat shields have been used for hundreds of mission from Mercury to Apollo to the Space Shuttle to Soyuz.
 
Nitpick: not the shuttle. It was, with the oft-discussed latrine innovations and thermal shielding, a literal brick **** house. It used ablative elements on a leading edge, but mostly it just radiated heat from the brick cladding.
 
Nitpick: not the shuttle. It was, with the oft-discussed latrine innovations and thermal shielding, a literal brick **** house. It used ablative elements on a leading edge, but mostly it just radiated heat from the brick cladding.


Didn't use ablative hear shields.
It had ablative material on the wings
Make up your mind, please.
 
The reinforced carbon-carbon on the nose and leading edge of the orbiter wings was not ablative.
Thank you, sir.
As was widely discussed early in the program, the biggest concern was with the tiles. Never in my years working STS Payloads did we ever hear of replacing the Leading Edges, which, had they been ablative, would require frequent replacement because of material loss. Never happened.
An ablative LE which punctured as easily as that one was wouldn't be very useful--especially as it had little-to-no back-up structure there...
 
I stand corrected. The carbon-carbon was not ablative but already burnt. So radiative rejection only.
 
...hear of replacing the Leading Edges

Each segment of the leading edge was in the neighborhood of $800,000. It's far easier to manufacture RCC in sheets or other regular shapes. The high cost was due to having to manufacture them in the particular shapes required for the orbiter.

--especially as it had little-to-no back-up structure there...

By design. RCC remains solid at very high temperatures but has a coefficient of thermal expansion that requires a floating mount. You can't bolt them directly to a spar. Nor would you anyway, because you need an insulator between RCC elements and structure.
 
Each segment of the leading edge was in the neighborhood of $800,000. It's far easier to manufacture RCC in sheets or other regular shapes. The high cost was due to having to manufacture them in the particular shapes required for the orbiter.



By design. RCC remains solid at very high temperatures but has a coefficient of thermal expansion that requires a floating mount. You can't bolt them directly to a spar. Nor would you anyway, because you need an insulator between RCC elements and structure.
Actually, with the proper layup, you can get pretty much the thermal CoE you want-negative, even. The optical bench on Clementine was inevitable such I worked with. I didn't do the composites-not my specialty- but I did have the aluminum and Tutanium structure around it...
It's matching it to the structure you fasten it to that a problem...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom