does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

I see the problem!

Complete video = more information = anti-Truther.

He'll never do it.

Do you see all that black smoke indicating a very hot fire, pyrosising tons of hydrocarbon plastics into carbon Black, Carbon black itself which in The NIST 1989 study I posted can burn between 1000 and 2000C.

Seems Tony's fire Ideas have gone up in smoke.
 
Do you see all that black smoke indicating a very hot fire, pyrosising tons of hydrocarbon plastics into carbon Black, Carbon black itself which in The NIST 1989 study I posted can burn between 1000 and 2000C.

Seems Tony's fire Ideas have gone up in smoke.

All of Tony's ideas go up in smoke when he can't even show the intellectual courage to answer one simple question from the likes of me.
 
You have the option to debate him to yourself.

I don't have the skills or background.

It looked like gravity did it to me. I'm amazed stuff isn't falling down all the time. As near as I can tell, it's only centrifugal force from the spinning earth keeping skyscrapers up at all.
 
Last edited:
I don't have the skills or background.

It looked like gravity did it to me. I'm amazed stuff isn't falling down all the time. As near as I can tell, it's only centrifugal force from the spinning earth keeping skyscrapers up at all.

I am begining to think an earth worm has more engineering skill than Tony maybe he should debate one of them, they have enough sense to stay out of the heat.
Tony keeps getting burned but keeps coming back for more.
 
We won't know until he's gone to Harvard and shouted, ""Which of you half-educated morons has the self-belief to give me a degree without me having to do any work?" for a couple of hours.


Ironically, I once did almost exactly that, except it was for a couple of semesters.
 
You debate here all the time. I am just asking to do the debate one-on-one to eliminate all of the noise from other posters and allow time for more thoughtful responses.

I am trying to show you and others that the present official story explanations for the collapses of the three WTC high-rises do not withstand scrutiny and in a more serious debating situation that can be done, where on a fast paced forum with a lot of different posters arguments get drowned out.
Really? Let's see how true that is.
I will discuss the matter with you under the following rules:
[...snipped rules...]

These rules are designed to be pretty much like those in any other forum discussion. If what you said above is true, there should be no problem for you to agree to them.

Are you game?
And as it turns out, you're not. I rest my case.


It sounds like you don't want a one-on-one debate with your insistence on it being a "forum discussion" and even having to consider the possibility of interference, which would then require a moderator's interaction.
I don't want a debate in the sense that you seem to be framing it here (2nd meaning here: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/debate). I want a debate in the sense that you framed it in the first of the posts I've quoted above, which is the 3rd or 4th meaning. You're conflating the different meanings of the word and using them at your convenience. Avoiding the ambiguous word debate helps keeping focus on what is exactly meant. That's why I chose "forum discussion".

Because, when you said "You debate here all the time", you didn't mean "You have an argument or discussion, generally in an ordered or formal setting etc. here all the time", did you?

No, you meant "You have a discussion of opposing views here all the time".

But you don't want that. Otherwise you would have no reason to reject my proposal. You want a show where only the views that you want to expose are discussed. I won't play that game.


I do not want to be held to any of the ISF's rules and will not debate on this forum.
Funny that. You do it all the time when you post here (OK, you break some rules from time to time, like when you wrote s__t a few days ago, or when you start your usual ad hom).

Not wanting to abide by these rules is further proof that you want to play with loaded die.


Rules concerning frequency and length of posts, and time for response are necessary. There can't be a debate without them.
Informal discussions are just like that every time.


The debate I proposed is about technical issues concerning the WTC Tower and WTC 7 collapses and any verifiable public domain information about them. If you want to talk about other issues you aren't even considering the debate I proposed.

I do not think your rules are conducive to an ordered and structured debate/discussion and I can't go along with them.

My counter is to debate on the 911 Free Forum with at least most of the rules set up for the debate I had with tfk. The differences can be: no opening statements, and no need to respond point by point if it isn't desired. If you can't do that I have to wonder what you really have in mind other than a straightforward discussion.
You know what's funny? My main focus is the question of whether there is evidence for CD or not. That's what I really want to discuss. I don't want to discuss the merits of the existing reports, which are inconsequential to whether there's any actual proof for CD (except for NCSTAR 1A section 3.3 and NCSTAR 1-9 appendix D, about hypothetical blast scenarios). Under your rules, by discussing them you'd be off topic if you started to discuss them. Under my rules, you'd be allowed.

I bet this has been enlightening for everyone. Thanks for that.
 
Tony--for posterity, attached is a pic of the "4.5 hour" fire timeline used by WAI, which you are claiming is impossible. This comes directly from the WAI report you claim to have read.

Can you see what is happening? The 4.5 hour timeframe is a global timeframe. The fire modeled is clearly a traveling fire that does not persist at maximum intensity for more than 30-60 minutes in any given location. This is exactly consistent with the Cardington study fire and even your own claims as to how the fire should have behaved. Read the whole of Section 3 (starting on page B-81 in the WAI report) for a step by step walk through of this fire scenario as applied.

So, I ask you again, based on actual facts and not based on mischaracterizations and/or bare assertions, can you articulate an actual critique to this fire model?

Can you be intellectually honest enough to admit that a fire induced collapse was possible (we can leave probable for another day)? You've managed to reason yourself to the edge of a breakthrough. You now understand, based on what you've said in this thread alone, that, if a fire scenario comparable to the one modeled by WAI occurred, then the building would have collapsed. Take the next step: admit that you do not have any actual factual reason to rule out the WAI scenario and follow the logic of the previous sentence from there. The truth shall set you free.
 

Attachments

  • WAI Report B-83.jpg
    WAI Report B-83.jpg
    35.6 KB · Views: 12
Last edited:
Tony--for posterity, attached is a pic of the "4.5 hour" fire timeline used by WAI, which you are claiming is impossible. This comes directly from the WAI report you claim to have read.

Can you see what is happening? The 4.5 hour timeframe is a global timeframe. The fire modeled is clearly a traveling fire that does not persist at maximum intensity for more than 30-60 minutes in any given location. This is exactly consistent with the Cardington study fire and even your own claims as to how the fire should have behaved. Read the whole of Section 3 (starting on page B-81 in the WAI report) for a step by step walk through of this fire scenario as applied.
.

The graphic is on page B-83 for those interested.
 
The graphic is on page B-83 for those interested.

Thanks, I should have noted that. It's very important to actually see the graphics in detail in high resolution (which my screenshot failed to provide) as the temperature units vary from graphic to graphic. The peak temperature reached in the 4.5 hour graphic is somewhere between 792 C and 859 C, and it is only reached on a single beam. Again, as if I didn't beat this into the ground enough already, this is entirely consistent with the temperatures observed in Tony's cited experimental test case.
 
Last edited:
You know what's funny? My main focus is the question of whether there is evidence for CD or not. That's what I really want to discuss. I don't want to discuss the merits of the existing reports, which are inconsequential to whether there's any actual proof for CD (except for NCSTAR 1A section 3.3 and NCSTAR 1-9 appendix D, about hypothetical blast scenarios). Under your rules, by discussing them you'd be off topic if you started to discuss them. Under my rules, you'd be allowed.

I think that any debate/discussion of largely hypothetical and un-provable collapse initiation scenario's published in any report (official or non-official) is a complete waste of time that will accomplish nothing. Clearly what Tony really wants is to promote a Controlled Demolition explanation for the collapse of 7 WTC (and presumably both Twins).

So why aren't we concentrating on that?

Tony thinks that prove NIST was wrong (about a detail) = it must have been CD, the faulty logic of that being obvious to most of us anyway. This is why he wants to talk about NIST and doesn't want to talk about CD. But the only way to move the project forward as it were would be to discuss CD. Tony is convinced there was a combination of arson and deliberate demolition using pre-planted devices. This is the true agenda he wishes to push. This should then be the topic of discussion.

This is after all a CT forum so we should be discussing CT's, not engineering reports.

Just my humble opinion, valued as always at precisely $0.02
 
Tony thinks that prove NIST was wrong (about a detail) = it must have been CD, the faulty logic of that being obvious to most of us anyway.

A point that has been made innumerable times, to Tony and others, ever since the meme began.
Good Canadian boy that I am, I offer the following;
I feel
My head is spinning round
Round, round we go (round, round we go)
 
Tony thinks that prove NIST was wrong (about a detail) = it must have been CD, the faulty logic of that being obvious to most of us anyway.

The faulty logic is obvious to people outside this forum, which is likely why -- gaslighting to the contrary notwithstanding -- nobody pays his claims any attention.

This is after all a CT forum so we should be discussing CT's, not engineering reports.

At least at one point, Tony's conspiracy theory was that someone either leaned on NIST to fudge the results, or someone within NIST took it upon themselves to fudge them. Tony's crusade was to restore the good name of NIST. Arguing in favor of controlled demolition doesn't have to enter that picture. Naturally, nothing that happens in this forum will have the slightest effect one way or another on NIST's reputation. So the line of reasoning -- at least as far as ISF is concerned -- seems to be Prove NIST was wrong (about a detail) = Tony matters. I don't see this as anything but a desperate plea for relevance.
 
Since the two individuals who said they were considering a debate seemed to want to talk controlled demolition I have added it into a set of revised ground rules. I actually fully intended to discuss that with tfk but he left before we ever got that far.

The proposed rules are below and are simplified with discussion of controlled demolition called for specifically.

1. The debate is restricted to the collapses of WTC 1, 2 & 7 in NYC on September 11, 2001, the NIST reports on these events, any additional objectively verifiable information and analyses in the public domain about them, and the probability of fire vs. controlled demolition causing the collapses.

2. The JREF/ISF challenger will have the option of going first.

3. Each starting post will be considered a topic. Discussion of a topic consists of a maximum of 4 posts. Person A will start a post on a specific issue/topic. Person B then replies, Person A counters, then Person B counters, and that topic is closed. Person B then leads off the next sequence.

4. Individual posts are limited to 1,000 words.

5. Each person shall make no more than one post per day and shall not make another until it is responded to.

6. Responses shall take no more than a week. If a post is not responded to within a week the person not responding is considered to have forfeited his/her turn & the other person will proceed with his/her next statement.

7. Each point that either person makes must be addressed in some manner by the other.

8. There shall be no name calling or defamatory language used.

9. The debate will end after 40 total posts.
 
Last edited:
Since the two individuals who said they were considering a debate seemed to want to talk controlled demolition I have added it into a set of revised ground rules. I actually fully intended to discuss that with tfk but he left before we ever got that far.

The proposed rules are below and are simplified with discussion of controlled demolition called for specifically.

1. The debate is restricted to the collapses of WTC 1, 2 & 7 in NYC on September 11, 2001, the NIST reports on these events, any additional objectively verifiable information and analyses in the public domain about them, and the probability of fire vs. controlled demolition causing the collapses.

2. The JREF/ISF challenger will have the option of going first.

3. Each starting post will be considered a topic. Discussion of a topic consists of a maximum of 4 posts. Person A will start a post on a specific issue/topic. Person B then replies, Person A counters, then Person B counters, and that topic is closed. Person B then leads off the next sequence.

4. Individual posts are limited to 1,000 words.

5. Each person shall make no more than one post per day and shall not make another until it is responded to.

6. Responses shall take no more than a week. If a post is not responded to within a week the person not responding is considered to have forfeited his/her turn & the other person will proceed with his/her next statement.

7. Each point that either person makes must be addressed in some manner by the other.

8. There shall be no name calling or defamatory language used.

9. The debate will end after 40 total posts.


As I see it, the CD debate is already over because fire and impact evidence has been presented and such evidence is clear and undeniable whereas video and audio evidence in conjunction with seismic data and lack of CD hardware at WTC ground zero has proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that no CD evidence ever existed.

15 years and counting and still, no CD evidence to present in a debate.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom