does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

To use a common scale for all heat maps most people would use the worst case, which would have been about 750 °C if what you are saying is true. You are clearly guessing as to what NIST's intent was, but I will agree that they might have left off the actual max color and value if they manually cut and pasted the results color key. My guess is they wanted to show as much red as possible on all maps, so they edited the keys on all to show red at a lower temperature than the actual max and then didn't use the color key for those that exceeded the cut off. The software would have put a gray block at the end in those cases and showed the actual max numerical value.
Finally.
Thanks.

We should also consider why NIST has the steel on floors 9 and 10 at about 500 °C. Why the big difference between what they show and what Weidlinger shows?
Maybe "we" should do that some other time.
IIRC, this whole discussion started out when benthamitemetric challenged your assertion that - my paraphrasing may be imprecise here, so my advance apologies for that, and correct me, if I am wrong - steel never got hotter than some figure in the NIST report, and that, furthermore, it would be impossible for fires to heat beams to ... whatever figure you cited; 700? 800? Degrees.
benthamitemetric claimed, in opposition - and again, my paraphrasing may be inaccurate - that temperatures of XXX, which you deem impossible, are actually consistent with the Cardington tests, the NIST models, the WAI models, and (?) the ARUP models. In essence: All these competent scientific studies refute your assertion.

THAT is where the debate ought to continue.

I personally think Wedilinger's temperatures are nothing more than reverse engineered to get what they needed on two contiguous floors to have the first floor collapse and break through the next one down. NIST's analysis doesn't have two contiguous floors at high temps like 700 °C and they actually have none as high as those claimed by Weidlinger.
I might do the same as you, if I were hell-bent on not changing my mind - to claim malfeasance on the part of the authors when a study result refutes my hypothesis.
But you are right - that is your personal prejudice, and thus irrelevant.

We have seen how Nordenson and NIST failed on the break through count and they had to know it couldn't occur at the temperatures they showed in the areas they said it happened. NIST didn't even show an analysis for it and Nordenson ridiculously used an infinite stiffness.
How can you know that NIST "failed" on the break through count, when you haven't seen the analysis?
Nordenson's lower floor was assumed to be cool. That is a question I think I raised in our Metabunk debate: Whether the connection strength Nordenson assumed was realistic, or whether it should be somewhat lower due to possible fire damage on that floor.
NIST's lower floor was the 12th, which was heated by 11th floor fires, and NIST had computed temperatures in the 79-44 girder at 5pm in the vicinity of 300 °C (Figure 10–37). Their ANSYS model, as shown in Figure 11–34, had the 79-76 girder completely disconnected at c79. This would allow the heated beams coming from the east wall to push c79 westward, such that, perhaps, the falling 13th floor girder did't impact the 12th floor girder but the slab to the east of it.
Have you considered this?
Abboud has shown that heating or not heating the floor below can make a world of a difference wrt break-through (progression of floor collapses).

Weidlinger brought up the problem with breaking through the next floor down for ARUP, so they knew it, and I think decided to ensure enough heating on two contiguous floors to make it plausible and moved the implausibility to the temperature they needed.
That is the oldest of all the old Truther ploys - to claim evidence is faked when it refutes the conspiracy theory.
Rejected.

The extreme temperature they claim would require much more work for others to mathematically ascertain than the structural calculations for break through, even if it would seem implausible on its face to experienced people, due to lack of fuel load and time at temperature for the fire to generate those extreme temperatures on large pieces of insulated steel.
We are all aware that Abboud and Beyler are actually the experienced people here - especially Beyler is a world authority on modelling enclosed fires - while Szamboti is not.
 
...
I think all three reports are bogus and the NIST and ARUP reports have been proven to be non-explanatory due to omissions and inaccurate claims.
...

If you agree to commit to this standard, I'd be happy to discuss with you...
  • The Harrit et al (2009) study
  • AE911truth's proposal for a 2017 AIA resolution
  • Your own "arson+explosive CD" hypothesis for WTC7
Or, you could preemptively agree that all three have ommissions, make inaccurate or misleading claims, and are thus proven non-explanatory and bogus. :)
 
Surely some photographic expert can (or has tried to) look into the possibility of leaning by measuring individual pixels?


That is too vague a possibility to look into. Measuring which individual pixels and measuring what, exactly, about them?

Pixels by definition are all the same size. No point in measuring that.

Each pixel by definition is all the same color; that is, a single set of color values. Those color values are already numbers to begin with (they must be converted into visible colors for display, not the other way around) so there's no need to measure them. If you want to compare different pixels in the same image/frame, or the same pixel between different images/frames, you can do that (it's literally comparing numbers) but you must establish meaning for the comparison. Say one pixel's numbers are a bit different from another's; how would you show leaning from that? Now suppose they're the same; how would you show the absence of leaning from that?

Firefighter eyewitnesses perceiving the lean from the (familiar to them) viewing position of sighting upward from the base of the tower exterior like a carpenter sighting along a board is credible evidence of a lean (if, as is likely, the lean represented curvature of the vertical line(s) of the building). "Somebody shoulda measured the pixels in some photograph to show a lean" is not credible evidence of the lack of one. To achieve that, you'd have to carry out some quantitatively validated (including quantitatively establishing the error range and detection threshold) pixel-based lean-detecting procedure.
 
That is too vague a possibility to look into. Measuring which individual pixels and measuring what, exactly, about them?

Pixels by definition are all the same size. No point in measuring that.

Each pixel by definition is all the same color; that is, a single set of color values. Those color values are already numbers to begin with (they must be converted into visible colors for display, not the other way around) so there's no need to measure them. If you want to compare different pixels in the same image/frame, or the same pixel between different images/frames, you can do that (it's literally comparing numbers) but you must establish meaning for the comparison. Say one pixel's numbers are a bit different from another's; how would you show leaning from that? Now suppose they're the same; how would you show the absence of leaning from that?

Firefighter eyewitnesses perceiving the lean from the (familiar to them) viewing position of sighting upward from the base of the tower exterior like a carpenter sighting along a board is credible evidence of a lean (if, as is likely, the lean represented curvature of the vertical line(s) of the building). "Somebody shoulda measured the pixels in some photograph to show a lean" is not credible evidence of the lack of one. To achieve that, you'd have to carry out some quantitatively validated (including quantitatively establishing the error range and detection threshold) pixel-based lean-detecting procedure.

Why else would they have set a transit on the building?

Anyone who did any research would have found that out.

http://the911forum.freeforums.org/bulging-and-leaning-absent-from-nist-simulations-t553.html

Also look at the steam in the photo, would that be from sprinklers or ruptured Diesel fuel lines? Or damaged day tanks?
 
As others have noted, this is not the case at all. What's more, two posters have offered to take him up on this debate. I have not because I am not an engineer. I was also not aware until now that science was conducted through debates on internet forums. Does this only apply to conspiracy theory science, or do you have other examples of this in other scientific fields?


I've suggested strongly enough, but I'll make the offer explicit: I'm willing to debate with Tony the proposition "an extensive new investigation of the events of 9/11 should be conducted." (The wording may be adjusted but the occurrence of a new investigation should remain the central idea). Such an investigation is Tony's claimed goal, so let's debate it.

Such issues as the quality or claimed errors of past investigations could of course be raised as points of argument in such a debate, as could anything else relevant to the question of whether there should be a new investigation. I might not be able to address every engineering point, but that shouldn't matter to the main questions regarding a new investigation.

Why? Because it's necessarily a proposition concerning future public action or policy. (Private investigations need no one's permission so there is no need to discuss or debate about those). As a citizen of the U.S. republic I'm as qualified to debate it as anyone else. Engineers on either side might contribute background, but they will never unilaterally decide the question, any more than they get to decide whether or not a city can afford to build a new bridge once they've computed how much it would cost.

Any 9/11 debate solely about engineering is avoiding the main issues. Insistence on such debate and no other can only be seen as avoiding the main issues deliberately.
 
Hey, MicahJava!

How do you explain the building's movement? You know, http://www.formauri.es/personal/pgimeno/xfiles/11-s/633033152-highpass.gif

This is the third time I ask. You don't want it to look like you're evading the question, do you?

I answered. I'm not really sure why the building moved 90 seconds before collapse. It moved more about 6 seconds before the East Penthouse came down. No scientific literature promoting structural failure of WTC 7 has ever explained this.
 
Why else would they have set a transit on the building?


I can think of several possible reasons:

- Visual perception of building exterior lines going out of true, as we've been discussing.

- Personnel inside the building (that would have had to be earlier in the day) perceiving movements or vibrations suggesting instability.

- Audible sounds familiar to firefighters as suggesting structural movements and therefore instability.

- General awareness of the possibility of the observed structural damage and uncontrolled fire conditions leading to accumulating structural instability culminating in collapse, which possibility might be confirmed via a transit.

- Hope of the transit observations disconfirming significant structural movements or growing instability, in which case there might have been an opportunity to reduce the operational limitations in the zone so as to e.g. facilitate rescue efforts nearby.

- A veteran firefighter saying, "I have a bad feeling about this," who happens to have a transit handy.
 
That is too vague a possibility to look into. Measuring which individual pixels and measuring what, exactly, about them?

Pixels by definition are all the same size. No point in measuring that.

Each pixel by definition is all the same color; that is, a single set of color values. Those color values are already numbers to begin with (they must be converted into visible colors for display, not the other way around) so there's no need to measure them. If you want to compare different pixels in the same image/frame, or the same pixel between different images/frames, you can do that (it's literally comparing numbers) but you must establish meaning for the comparison. Say one pixel's numbers are a bit different from another's; how would you show leaning from that? Now suppose they're the same; how would you show the absence of leaning from that?

Firefighter eyewitnesses perceiving the lean from the (familiar to them) viewing position of sighting upward from the base of the tower exterior like a carpenter sighting along a board is credible evidence of a lean (if, as is likely, the lean represented curvature of the vertical line(s) of the building). "Somebody shoulda measured the pixels in some photograph to show a lean" is not credible evidence of the lack of one. To achieve that, you'd have to carry out some quantitatively validated (including quantitatively establishing the error range and detection threshold) pixel-based lean-detecting procedure.

Well, until somebody presents actual photographic evidence, quoting unsubstantiated witnesses saying either of the buildings were leaning should be off the table.
 
Why else would they have set a transit on the building?

Anyone who did any research would have found that out.

http://the911forum.freeforums.org/bulging-and-leaning-absent-from-nist-simulations-t553.html

Also look at the steam in the photo, would that be from sprinklers or ruptured Diesel fuel lines? Or damaged day tanks?

Because five and a half hours before the building collapsed, an engineer (identity unknown) told the fire chiefs that the building would collapse "in five or six hours".
 
Well, until somebody presents actual photographic evidence, quoting unsubstantiated witnesses saying either of the buildings were leaning should be off the table.


Off what table?

This field of study we're engaged in here has a name: history. On that table, witnesses saying and reporting the same things (substantiating one another) is how we know what happened.

Was there a Battle of Lexington? Well, people witnessed it, and wrote down or recounted to others what they saw and heard and did, but there's no photographic evidence, so...
 
I've suggested strongly enough, but I'll make the offer explicit: I'm willing to debate with Tony the proposition "an extensive new investigation of the events of 9/11 should be conducted." (The wording may be adjusted but the occurrence of a new investigation should remain the central idea). Such an investigation is Tony's claimed goal, so let's debate it.

Such issues as the quality or claimed errors of past investigations could of course be raised as points of argument in such a debate, as could anything else relevant to the question of whether there should be a new investigation. I might not be able to address every engineering point, but that shouldn't matter to the main questions regarding a new investigation.

Why? Because it's necessarily a proposition concerning future public action or policy. (Private investigations need no one's permission so there is no need to discuss or debate about those). As a citizen of the U.S. republic I'm as qualified to debate it as anyone else. Engineers on either side might contribute background, but they will never unilaterally decide the question, any more than they get to decide whether or not a city can afford to build a new bridge once they've computed how much it would cost.

Any 9/11 debate solely about engineering is avoiding the main issues. Insistence on such debate and no other can only be seen as avoiding the main issues deliberately.

Tony participated in the Microspheres debate with Jones, myself and Dr. Greening, if he were capable of doing Science, he would have realized the size of many of the Microspheres match those produced for xerography, he could have googled it and got the spectra for the spheres manufactured from fly ash from Xerox.
Tony isn't and will never be interested in science, science that is still occurring even as we speak.
Tony said nothing about Jones using the RJ. Lee report to imply a false and misleading average of Microspheres in the dust, but he must have known Jones was being dishonest.
That is why debating Tony holds no interest for me, the science of 9/11 interests me, the frauds of the truth movement do not.
 
Because five and a half hours before the building collapsed, an engineer (identity unknown) told the fire chiefs that the building would collapse "in five or six hours".


Do we have photographic evidence of that unsubstantiated witness claim? Or is that not needed, for this particular claim?
 
This is abject nonsense. You have not proved what you claim to have proved, but that is really a deliberate distraction, anyway.

There is no way that you will ever be able to disprove every possible fire-induced hypothesis by merely speculating about what was happening inside the building. The only way that you can prove the negative claim that fire did not cause the collapse is by proving that something else caused it. If something else caused it, there should be evidence, so that should be entirely possible. But you will not even make the attempt because you know you cannot even formulate a plausible hypothesis, much less prove it.

You will never face up to this because it shuts down your entire game. Arguing with such a disingenuous person is a complete waste of time.

It isn't speculation to scrutinize reports we have been given which are speculating.

The NIST collapse initiation hypothesis has been proven to be impossible because the stiffeners they omitted would prevent the girder flange from folding if the web was pushed beyond the seat. They also neglected girder trapping behind the side plate of column 79. They also insisted there were no shear studs on the girder when they had information showing there were. The NIST WTC 7 report is essentially a contrived piece of crap foisted on the public and you really shouldn't expect others to have to accept a travesty like that.

The ARUP (Nordenson) floor cascade has been proven to be impossible due to its use of an infinite stiffness for the falling beam and girder assembly. When corrected the math shows the falling frame could not generate nearly enough load to shear the seat of the girder below.

I would argue that it is perhaps you who is not facing reality by continuing to accept these provably non-explanatory reports as having merit.
 
Last edited:
Finally.
Thanks.


Maybe "we" should do that some other time.
IIRC, this whole discussion started out when benthamitemetric challenged your assertion that - my paraphrasing may be imprecise here, so my advance apologies for that, and correct me, if I am wrong - steel never got hotter than some figure in the NIST report, and that, furthermore, it would be impossible for fires to heat beams to ... whatever figure you cited; 700? 800? Degrees.
benthamitemetric claimed, in opposition - and again, my paraphrasing may be inaccurate - that temperatures of XXX, which you deem impossible, are actually consistent with the Cardington tests, the NIST models, the WAI models, and (?) the ARUP models. In essence: All these competent scientific studies refute your assertion.

THAT is where the debate ought to continue.


I might do the same as you, if I were hell-bent on not changing my mind - to claim malfeasance on the part of the authors when a study result refutes my hypothesis.
But you are right - that is your personal prejudice, and thus irrelevant.


How can you know that NIST "failed" on the break through count, when you haven't seen the analysis?
Nordenson's lower floor was assumed to be cool. That is a question I think I raised in our Metabunk debate: Whether the connection strength Nordenson assumed was realistic, or whether it should be somewhat lower due to possible fire damage on that floor.
NIST's lower floor was the 12th, which was heated by 11th floor fires, and NIST had computed temperatures in the 79-44 girder at 5pm in the vicinity of 300 °C (Figure 10–37). Their ANSYS model, as shown in Figure 11–34, had the 79-76 girder completely disconnected at c79. This would allow the heated beams coming from the east wall to push c79 westward, such that, perhaps, the falling 13th floor girder did't impact the 12th floor girder but the slab to the east of it.
Have you considered this?
Abboud has shown that heating or not heating the floor below can make a world of a difference wrt break-through (progression of floor collapses).


That is the oldest of all the old Truther ploys - to claim evidence is faked when it refutes the conspiracy theory.
Rejected.


We are all aware that Abboud and Beyler are actually the experienced people here - especially Beyler is a world authority on modelling enclosed fires - while Szamboti is not.
Still falling for Tony's admission of a minor point (and an erroneous admission at that), so you go on not noticing the evasion everywhere else.
What is the significance of temperatures >670 C in steel?
 
It isn't speculation to scrutinize reports we have been given which are speculating.

The NIST collapse initiation hypothesis has been proven to be impossible because the stiffeners they omitted would prevent the girder flange from folding if the web was pushed beyond the seat. They also neglected girder trapping behind the side plate of column 79. They also insisted there were no shear studs on the girder when they had information showing there were. The NIST WTC 7 report is essentially a contrived piece of crap foisted on the public and you really shouldn't expect others to have to accept a travesty like that.

The ARUP (Nordenson) floor cascade has been proven to be impossible due to its use of an infinite stiffness for the falling beam and girder assembly. When corrected the math shows the falling frame could not generate nearly enough load to shear the seat of the girder below.

I would argue that it is perhaps you who is not facing reality by continuing to accept these provably non-explanatory reports as having merit.

Does human error in the reports Falsify collapse by fire, in all possible sinarios?

Given of course the wide range of unknowable variables naturally at play in such a dynamic environment.
 
Does human error in the reports Falsify collapse by fire, in all possible sinarios?

Given of course the wide range of unknowable variables naturally at play in such a dynamic environment.

No, it means those particular reports (NIST and ARUP) did not explain the collapse of WTC 7 and a new investigation is needed.

Of course, if you want to say Weidlinger explains it then we need to see the heat transfer and fire simulation analyses, which have not been made public. Right now Weidlinger's claim for simultaneous extreme steel temperatures on two contiguous floors on the east side of the building (floors 9 and 10) is technically unsupported.
 
Last edited:
No, it means those particular reports (NIST and ARUP) did not explain the collapse of WTC 7 and a new investigation is needed.

Of course, if you want to say Weidlinger explains it then we need to see the heat transfer and fire simulation analyses, which have not been made public. Right now Weidlinger's claim for simultaneous extreme steel temperatures on two contiguous floors on the east side of the building (floors 9 and 10) is technically unsupported.

Would those temperatures be induced by carbon black drawn into the intake of a chimney effect higher up in the core fueled by the carbon black from pyrosis of hydrocarbon plastics?

That is of course assuming that an ignition source ignited enough plastic at once to over come the protective effect of the nitrogen fire retardants that would normally slow the fire progressions.
 
Well, we can add "Never prepared and published a formal report" along with "Have no clue what FEA is" to the Resumes of Tony (and Crazy Chainsaw and Oystein)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom