does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

I have not seen you say anything which would show you are an engineer.

However, the files are available to you on the 911 free forum.

It sounds like you are crying about it just to have something to complain about. There is nothing to complain about. You have access to the files.

It is this kind of drivel that keeps people like me from answering a lot of posts here.
Does this mean you plan to discuss your volume of work on the 9/11 forum?
 
I have not seen you say anything which would show you are an engineer.

However, the files are available to you on the 911 free forum.

It sounds like you are crying about it just to have something to complain about. There is nothing to complain about. You have access to the files.

It is this kind of drivel that keeps people like me from answering a lot of posts here.
Then you are a really crappy researcher. On this very site, I have posted my certification and the means to verify it.

It is no secret. I actually have a string of alphabet soup after my name and my identity is no secret. I cannot help that you are useless at research, I can only observe the fact that you are so.

As for your files, you have yet to explain why you cannot post them here while you post them here. What is that about? Either you can post them or you cannot. Which is it?
 
Last edited:
It is exactly like the drawing. The bearing seat was welded to the column flange at it back surface and sat on a 14" deep x 2" thick support plate that was welded to the column side plates. It is not held to the column by tension or compression.

You are showing your lack of education in these matters here. It doesn't sound like you are qualified to comment.

A weld would be a tension feature Tony.

I see you broke the bolts, not a ductile deformation tear out,

Interesting when I put in the numbers for the strength of the steel ductile tear out looks to be
More likely than bolt sheer especially for steel that is heated.

When I run this though a very simple FEA, ductile tear of the set, and the girder, reduce the weight the set can support, and make the stiffeners useless.

Did you run the FEA with ductile tear out as bolt failure mode as well as bolt breakage?
 
Nope. You claimed that it was impossible to post them here. That was your claim.

Your new claim is that you have posted them here. These claims cannot both be correct. Which is it?

Am I a qualified engineer? Yup. Have I provided my email address? Yup. Have I recieved an email from TS? Nope. My only available conclusion is obvious. I fulfilled TS's pointless requirements. TS failed to fulfil his own. That's how it is.

There is nothing I can do about that.
looks like he's going for the suicide by Mod option...
 
A weld would be a tension feature Tony.

I see you broke the bolts, not a ductile deformation tear out,

Interesting when I put in the numbers for the strength of the steel ductile tear out looks to be
More likely than bolt sheer especially for steel that is heated.

When I run this though a very simple FEA, ductile tear of the set, and the girder, reduce the weight the set can support, and make the stiffeners useless.

Did you run the FEA with ductile tear out as bolt failure mode as well as bolt breakage?

I had the bolts out because I was giving that to NIST. The intent of the FEA on girder trapping and stiffener stress was to allow the girder to be pushed. That can't happen with the bolts unbroken. NIST claimed they broke due to thermal expansion of the girder and beams and I don't object to that. It had to happen due to bolt shear and not shear tear out, because the girder would be pushing on the bolts.

It is clear you are talking about things with which you have little familiarity and are just embarrassing yourself further by pretending otherwise.
 
Last edited:
Right, that's the straight line down the middle representing a single column that came off.

Most of what you're seeing in that photo is dust. Only a few pieces of steel were flung far enough to even touch WTC 7.


Enough steel from the collapse of WTC 1 to seriously damage the south wall and the southwest corner of WTC 7. I might add that WTC 1 did not collapse within its own footprint.
 
Last edited:
I had the bolts out because I was giving that to NIST. The intent of the FEA on girder trapping and stiffener stress was to allow the girder to be pushed. That can't happen with the bolts unbroken. NIST claimed they broke due to thermal expansion of the girder and beams and I don't object to that.

It is clear you are talking about things with which you have little familiarity and are just embarrassing yourself further by pretending otherwise.

Then you haven't checked all possible failure modes?
 
That is an interesting comment, Tony.
In what way are you qualified to comment on Beyler's WTC7 analysis?

As a mechanical engineer I was schooled in heat transfer and thermodynamics as well as strength of materials, stress analysis, and mechanics in general.

I have done a significant amount of both structural and thermal design and analysis in my career.

Did you read the article published by Dr. Robert Korol et al on what the likely temperatures were that WTC 7 steel in fire affected areas would have reached? They are far below what the WAI report claims.

The article is titled Performance-based fire protection of office buildings: A case study based on the collapse of WTC 7 and can be found on-line.
 
Last edited:
As a mechanical engineer I was schooled in heat transfer and thermodynamics as well as strength of materials, stress analysis, and mechanics in general.

I have done a significant amount of both structural and thermal design and analysis in my career.

Did you read the article published by Dr. Robert Korol et al on what the likely temperatures were that WTC 7 steel in fire affected areas would have reached? They are far below what the WAI report claims.

The article is titled Performance-based fire protection of office buildings: A case study based on the collapse of WTC 7 and can be found on-line.

Do you think it is accurate to say that any given beam in wtc 7 could have been heated for no more than 25 min? That's what Korol's garbage paper requires you to believe. It is a paper written to reach a conclusion, not a serious forensic investigation of the actual fire conditions possible.

Edit: removed incorrect URL and comment per the below.
 
Last edited:
Do you think it is accurate to say that any given beam in wtc 7 could have been heated for no more than 25 min? That's what Korol's garbage paper requires you to believe. It is a paper written to reach a conclusion, not a serious forensic investigation of the actual fire conditions possible.

Since Tony is reluctant to just link his cited garbage paper (likely because he keenly understands how useless it actually is) here is a link for reference: http://www.scientistsfor911truth.org/docs/Korol_Challenge_2016.pdf

What duration for peak gas temperature do you think it should be?

You actually gave a link for a different paper by Dr. Korol. The right link is http://www.challengejournal.com/index.php/cjsmec/article/view/36

I gave the link to the right Korol paper on WTC 7 earlier in a post to Oystein on this thread. Did you miss that?
 
Last edited:
What duration for peak gas temperature do you think it should be?

I gave the link to the Korol paper earlier in a post to Oystein on this thread. Did you miss that?

I think you should go back to the Cardington study and try to reconcile this garbage paper with that. Do you think the Cardington study authors were blind and had broken thermometers when they observed how traveling fires actually worked?

And yes, I did not see that you previously linked said garbage paper. Skimmed over the last few pages. Apologies.
 
I think you should go back to the Cardington study and try to reconcile this garbage paper with that. Do you think the Cardington study authors were blind and had broken thermometers when they observed how traveling fires actually worked?

And yes, I did not see that you previously linked said garbage paper. Skimmed over the last few pages. Apologies.

I think you are banging on a door that won't break. There is no question that there would not be enough fuel to reach the steel temperatures claimed in the WAI report.

I recently mentioned this extreme steel temperature claim in the WAI report to a structural engineering professor and he asked "where's the fuel for that?".

The WAI report extreme steel temperature claim is obviously a result of a need due to reverse engineering what it would take to break through the next floor down. It won't stand up to scrutiny and that is why no specifics about Beyler's analysis were given in the WAI report and why it isn't available publicly.
 
Last edited:
I think you are banging on a door that won't break. There is no question that there would not be enough fuel to reach the steel temperatures claimed in the WAI report.

I recently mentioned this extreme steel temperature claim in the WAI report to a structural engineering professor and he asked "where's the fuel for that?".

How long did the fires in the Cardington study heat given elements in that structure, Tony? Was it for 25 min?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom