Tony Szamboti
Illuminator
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2007
- Messages
- 4,976
No, Tony, that doesn't tell me anything I did not already know.
Something tells me that real fire sciences engineers know all that and more Tony.
In fact the WAI report specifically mentions preheating prior to flames reaching the area around column 79.
But you dont think that matters because you think the girder was still at 20C when that compartment began burning.
If you are using upper level gas temps to determine heating time, why do you then switch to radiative heating?
Preheating is a joke. I think we will be able to show there would be very little preheating from fires not directly in the area of the steel members in question. The entire building is an enormous sink and the gas temperatures even 50 feet away will be much lower and in addition won't contribute much since it is direct radiation which would be the major contributor and there is no view from that far away on the floor with a height of just 13 feet.
You guys are groping at straws.
I did not get a chance to fully develop what I was saying on a fast moving jerky forum like this. That is why the kind of debate I had with tfk is best for coming to the reality. There is time to think and coagulate all of the relative factors. I knew instinctively what I was saying what was right this afternoon but needed more time to fully think it through. That is how real engineering works. It is not a quick shot from the hip as many do here.
Last edited: