The ballad of the 911 shill

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, Tony, that doesn't tell me anything I did not already know.
Something tells me that real fire sciences engineers know all that and more Tony.
In fact the WAI report specifically mentions preheating prior to flames reaching the area around column 79.
But you dont think that matters because you think the girder was still at 20C when that compartment began burning.

If you are using upper level gas temps to determine heating time, why do you then switch to radiative heating?

Preheating is a joke. I think we will be able to show there would be very little preheating from fires not directly in the area of the steel members in question. The entire building is an enormous sink and the gas temperatures even 50 feet away will be much lower and in addition won't contribute much since it is direct radiation which would be the major contributor and there is no view from that far away on the floor with a height of just 13 feet.

You guys are groping at straws.

I did not get a chance to fully develop what I was saying on a fast moving jerky forum like this. That is why the kind of debate I had with tfk is best for coming to the reality. There is time to think and coagulate all of the relative factors. I knew instinctively what I was saying what was right this afternoon but needed more time to fully think it through. That is how real engineering works. It is not a quick shot from the hip as many do here.
 
Last edited:
All agreed.
What is significant heating?
Well at 200C structural steel yeild strength is reduced by about 15%. ,and at 400C it is reduced by 45%. So if we look at the graph we note that gas temps were in the region of 200 to 400 for 30 minutes.
I would consider that significant.
Gas temps then spent two hours rising from 400C to 1000C.
I would consider that significant.
And, gas temps then remained over 850C for another 15 minutes.
I would consider that significant too.
So I am at a loss as to how Korol and Tony Szamboti can claim significant heating only occured over a 30 minute period.

Astounding.

I annotated the NIST graph to reflect Tony/Korol's interpretation of events based on Tony's ridiculous defense in this thread. Happy New Year!
 

Attachments

  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    33.2 KB · Views: 8
The reason you are at a loss is that you don't seem to know much about heat transfer.

Heat from a fire is transferred three ways.

1. By radiation from the fire.
2. By radiation from the hot gas.
3. By convection from the hot gas.

The most significant portion is by radiation from the fire and when the fire burns out that is gone because a view is needed and the fire needs to be somewhat directly under the steel in question.

Heat transfer rate is dependent on the temperature difference. The smaller the difference the lower the rate.

It also takes time for heat to transfer through the fire protection. This time is significant and causes a lag. Once the fire burns out the air in the vicinity starts to cool. If the heating is not continuously applied to the fire protection for longer than the duration of its rating in hours it will not transfer much heat from the hot gas due to radiation and convection.

Most of the heating of fire protected steel occurs by direct radiation from the fire and once it burns out that method is no longer available. This coupled with the fact that the fires directly under the steel only burn for about 20 to 30 minutes is why the steel does not get to extremely high temperatures.

Another issue is that large steel members take a lot of energy to heat up. The specific heat of steel is 500 joules/kg-degK. This means that to heat up a structural member like girder A2001 to 800 C, which weighed about 2,650 kg, would take over a billion joules. If the fire is only under the steel for 30 minutes that would require nearly 600 Kw to go directly to the girder. The heat release rate for a 32 kg/m^2 fuel load is about 340 Kw, so it can't get anywhere near 800 C. Even under very efficient transfer the girder would only get to about 500 C.

Benthamitemetric is naively sticking his neck out again, like he did with the ARUP reports, and he is going to get humiliated again. I seriously doubt they will make the Beyler analysis public because they know we will find a serious problem with it which was used to generate extreme steel temperatures in an illegitimate way (similar to the illegitimate infinite stiffness used by Nordenson). However, it can be shown that the steel structural members on the 9th and 10th floors on the east side of WTC 7 could never get to the temperatures shown in the Weidlinger report without ever seeing that analysis.

Tony-- show me on the graph where 99% of the heat transfer occurs. Attached is figure 10-1 annotated to show your laughably ridiculous claims in this thread.
 

Attachments

  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    33.2 KB · Views: 1
Tony when are you going to start the stand alone thread to discuss your CD explanation.?

Since your convinced it was not fire. Let us see what you got regarding CD.

Either I am on ignore or your unwilling to take up the task.
 
I annotated the NIST graph to reflect Tony/Korol's interpretation of events based on Tony's ridiculous defense in this thread. Happy New Year!

You aren't heating anything with radiation and convection from the gas for quite a while since it can't get through the fire protection quickly enough before it cools.

Even then direct radiation is where most of the energy transfer occurs and that only lasts for 25 to 30 minutes and the heat release rate isn't nearly high enough to get to any more than about 500 C on the girders and maybe 600 C on the beams due to mass and specific heat requirements.

I hope you get Beyler's analysis. Maybe only then will you listen to reason. I am sure you wouldn't have with the ARUP reports without us having a chance to review them and show what the problem was and why it was invalid.
 
Last edited:
You aren't heating anything with radiation and convection from the gas for quite a while since it can't get through the fire protection quickly enough before it cools.

Show me on the graph specifically where you think 99% of heat transfer occurs, Tony. You explicitly claimed there is a 25-30 min period when it occurs. Where is it? From when to when?
 

Attachments

  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    33.2 KB · Views: 1
Preheating is a joke. I think we will be able to show there would be very little preheating from fires not directly in the area of the steel members in question. The entire building is an enormous sink and the gas temperatures even 50 feet away will be much lower and in addition won't contribute much since it is direct radiation which would be the major contributor and there is no view from that far away on the floor with a height of just 13 feet.

You guys are groping at straws.

I did not get a chance to fully develop what I was saying on a fast moving jerky forum like this. That is why the kind of debate I had with tfk is best for coming to the reality. There is time to think and coagulate all of the relative factors. I knew instinctively what I was saying what was right this afternoon but needed more time to fully think it through. That is how real engineering works. It is not a quick shot from the hip as many do here.

Does this post represent what you meant to say? I think you need more time...........
 
Does this post represent what you meant to say? I think you need more time...........

What do you even know about it? You just sound like a wise guy making a general comment because it is really something he knows nothing about. Don't you get embarrassed? You should because what you are doing is obvious.
 
Last edited:
Show me on the graph specifically where you think 99% of heat transfer occurs, Tony. You explicitly claimed there is a 25-30 min period when it occurs. Where is it? From when to when?

The 25 to 30 minute period is for direct radiation. Very little heat will be transferred to the steel by the hot gas before it cools down due to the fire protection.
 
What do you even know about it? You just sound like a wise guy making a general comment because it is really something he knows nothing about. Don't you get embarrassed? You should because what you are doing is obvious.
"The entire building is an enormous sink"

Wow Tony...........just Wow. :eek:
 
The 25 to 30 minute period is for direct radiation. Very little heat will be transferred to the steel by the hot gas before it cools down due to the fire protection.

So you truly believe the heat transfer to the beam from the first 4.5 hours of heating on this graph leaves the beam at 20 C? If not, how hot is the beam at 4.5 hours?

You know you're just making stuff up, right? Why are you doing it? I thought you just wanted to help people get good information.
 

Attachments

  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    33.2 KB · Views: 1
So you truly believe the heat transfer to the beam from the first 4.5 hours of heating on this graph leaves the beam at 20 C? If not, how hot is the beam at 4.5 hours?

You know you're just making stuff up, right? Why are you doing it? I thought you just wanted to help people get good information.

I would bet the heating of items 40 feet or more away from direct fire isn't more than about 200 C. That is quite insignificant for what we are talking about.
 
This thread makes it clear that the best way to deal with WTC7 truthers is to force them to address the entire context.

Say, Tony, where does KSM/Flight 93/Pentagon etc etc etc fit into your ballad?

I'm guessing in the instrumental interludes?

I've tried that approach.

He'll call you a nincompoop, and proudly announce you're going on ignore.

Save your keystrokes.

I challenged Tony to a debate on the four plane crashes starting with Shanksville and he ran away like a little coward.

15 years of utter failure and counting....
 
I would bet the heating of items 40 feet or more away from direct fire isn't more than about 200 C. That is quite insignificant for what we are talking about.

You would bet? Come on, Tony. Be specific. You cited the NIST report. Don't you know what it says about the beam temperatures? NIST actually did measure beam temperatures throughout the whole simulation (unlike Korol who, even you now admit, started with a beam temp at least 180 C too low).

In fact, attached, in addition to the graph of your ridiculous theory, is pg 452 from the NIST report that shows the beam temperatures at the location of the graph temperature sampling point. How hot are the beams there at 4:30, Tony? Do I really have to keep rope-a-doping you with stuff you should already know?
 

Attachments

  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 452.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 452.jpg
    34.1 KB · Views: 4
  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    33.2 KB · Views: 1
Last edited:
You would bet? Come on, Tony. Be specific. You cited the NIST report. Don't you know what it says about the beam temperatures? NIST actually did measure beam temperatures throughout the whole simulation (unlike Korol who, even you now admit, started with a beam temp at least 180 C too low).

In fact, attached, in addition the graph of your ridiculous theory, is pg 452 from the NIST report that shows the beam temperatures at the location of the graph temperature sampling point. How hot are the beams there at 4:30, Tony? Do I really have to keep rope-a-doping you with stuff you should already know?

You used the NIST 13th floor temperatures even though what you are trying to defend is at the 9th and 10th floors on the east side.

The NIST WTC 7 report is clearly on the high side of reality at the 13th floor, where they claim the failure occurred, only to be shown to be invalid due to things other than their fire simulation.

If you want to use NIST to back Weidlinger you need to use the NIST temperatures from the 9th and 10th floors on the east side between columns 79 and 80. At 4:30 PM their Case A temperatures for the 9th and 10th floor beams in that area are about 300 C. At 5:00 PM they are at about 400 C. This is way off of what Weidlinger wants to say. Why is that?
 
Last edited:
The NIST WTC 7 report is clearly on the high side of reality at the 13th floor, where they claim the failure occurred, only to be shown to be invalid due to things other than their fire simulation.

If you want to use NIST to back Weidlinger you need to use the NIST temperatures from the 9th and 10th floors on the east side between columns 79 and 80. At 4:30 PM their Case A temperatures for the 9th and 10th floor beams in that area are about 300 C. At 5:00 PM they are at about 400 C. This is way off of what Weidlinger wants to say.

So, at minimum, you agree that the Korol analysis is complete garbage and you apologize for this whole back and forth, right? You also agree you completely fabricated your 99% heating in 25-30 min claim to try to win an argument? You see now that the beam could have already been heated to nearly 400 C when Korol begins his heating at 20 C, right?

Come on--muster your intellectual honesty for once. Re-attaching the graph and floor 13 beam temperatures for reference.
 

Attachments

  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 390 10-1 SZAMBOTI DELUSION.jpg
    33.2 KB · Views: 0
  • NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 452.jpg
    NIST NCSTAR 1-9 pg 452.jpg
    34.1 KB · Views: 1
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom