does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

It is a fact. But people who believe the fantasy of CD can't figure out Dave uses science. You are proof.

You really can't talk about facts, because what our interaction here shows is that you can't even provide one instance to support your claim that Dave Thomas uses science to back his contention on how the WTC buildings collapsed.
 
Last edited:
No, what our interaction here shows is that you can't support your claim that Dave Thomas uses science to back his contention on how the WTC buildings collapsed.

Dave uses science, it is common knowledge. Your claims are based on fantasy, I am not surprised you quibble about this and can't figure out Dave uses science. Engineers can figure this out, as anyone can with a grade school education. Try harder, use evidence. Plus look up at the top of the page, you are in a location where we discuss the crazy claims of 9/11 truth, like the fantasy of CD.

You can't figure out Dave uses science, as you push the fantasy of CD, inside job, and other dumb claims of 9/11 truth. This is evidence why you refuse to understand Dave uses science. I guess you don't know what science is.

NIST used science too. What do you use? woo (real engineers ask questions and answer them)

You really can't talk about facts, because what our interaction here shows is that you can't even provide one instance to support your claim that Dave Thomas uses science to back his contention on how the WTC buildings collapsed.
oh my

Making up BS about NIST will not make the CD fantasy real. You lack evidence, and you don't seem to understand science, as you deny Dave uses science.

...
Please provide just one instance where you think Dave Thomas has used science to support his contentions on how the WTC buildings collapsed.
You can't? Why not?

The CD fantasy does not use science, 9/11 truth followers and pusher of CD can't figure this out; they don't recognize science.
 
Last edited:
Tony Szamboti: Good to see you back after your little holiday. While you were away, did you have time to put together the evidence for CD we've been asking for? Have you finalised the research paper proving NIST et al wrong, that you are going to submit for peer review? Have you decided which, of the many offers to debate you that were made here, you are going to accept?
I really hope the answer is "yes" to all of these, because I really want to see proper science in action. You're all about the science, right, Tony?
 
Can you show us anything Dave Thomas has done, concerning the building collapses that occurred on Sept. 11, 2001 and science, that hasn't been shown to involve sleight of hand and refuted accordingly?

Remembering, of course, that the definition of "shown to involve sleight of hand and refuted" used here is "inconvenient to the opinions of and hence disagreed with by Tony Szamboti."

Dave
 
You really can't talk about facts, because what our interaction here shows is that you can't even provide one instance to support your claim that Dave Thomas uses science to back his contention on how the WTC buildings collapsed.

He used chemistry, and although his experiments were quite crude, they were several levels more accurate, than anything the truth movement has ever produced.

I caution you Tony not to talk of others when you have been shown on multiple occasions to be Scientificly Illiterate.

Unless you actually believe that Jones's & Harrit's obviously false claim, of six percent for the
Total average of iron rich Microspheres in the dust is accurate for all the dust?

Or that any of Coles designed to fail experiments are valid works of science?

I caution you Tony there are things happening to which you are not aware, and that will make you and the other Cters look so foolish. You are not an engineering professional, or a Scientist, so I caution you not to speak I'll of others who are it might come back to haunt you very soon.
 
Dave uses science, it is common knowledge. Your claims are based on fantasy, I am not surprised you quibble about this and can't figure out Dave uses science. Engineers can figure this out, as anyone can with a grade school education. Try harder, use evidence. Plus look up at the top of the page, you are in a location where we discuss the crazy claims of 9/11 truth, like the fantasy of CD.

You can't figure out Dave uses science, as you push the fantasy of CD, inside job, and other dumb claims of 9/11 truth. This is evidence why you refuse to understand Dave uses science. I guess you don't know what science is.

NIST used science too. What do you use? woo (real engineers ask questions and answer them)

oh my

Making up BS about NIST will not make the CD fantasy real. You lack evidence, and you don't seem to understand science, as you deny Dave uses science.

You can't? Why not?

The CD fantasy does not use science, 9/11 truth followers and pusher of CD can't figure this out; they don't recognize science.

Beechnut, unfortunately, I can't help you, give an example of Tony's idiocies, because according to the great Tony, slight of hand artist, I burned up alive from Radiant heating while operating a leaf blower on a stump pile.
Someone who makes such Scientificly Illiterate and inaccurate claims as Tony shouldn't be
Discussing the validity of someone else's understanding of Science.
 

FACT remains Ziggi, that there IS ample evidence that columns were cut by thermitic lances AFTER the towers collapsed.


You have a conjecture, a fiction, a fantasy with absolutely nothing other than "could'a been, you don't know" to go on.
That IS called an "Argument from Ignorance" logical fallacy, akin to a Creationist's "God of the Gaps" fallacy.
You must have missed post 1204

Anything to say, Ziggi?

Along comes Tony to the rescue, to distract and deflect from the immediate subject.

Can you show us anything Dave Thomas has done, concerning the building collapses that occurred on Sept. 11, 2001 and science, that hasn't been shown to involve sleight of hand and refuted accordingly?

THERE IS direct evidence that columns were cut AFTER the collapses, using thermitic lances.

The pure conjecture of the use of thermite before collapse is nothing more than fiction until any unambiguous evidence can be brought forth.
 
Along comes Tony to the rescue, to distract and deflect from the immediate subject.

A more immediate subject are the questions Tony so studiously avoids:
So, Tony, as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?
Still waiting for answers to this.
I would like to hear from Tony himself on this but am also interested in what Ziggi or Mich Java might feel about this.
chirp, chirp chirp go the crickets.



To facilitate the quoting, I repeat:

There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!


I see Tony asking question, while at the same time refusing to answer questions. Bad manners!

Tony, please answer eventually:

[1] as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?


[2] There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!


[3]Tony also ran away from another question in another thread (I think)m that went like this:
Tony, more than 15 years after 9/11, and after you have spent so many years reviewing all of the evidence, what is, in your opinion today, the most likely ultimate cause of the WTC7 collapse?
(Remember, a straight and honest answer could easily be a single word, or a brief sentence )
 
Can you show us anything Dave Thomas has done, concerning the building collapses that occurred on Sept. 11, 2001 and science, that hasn't been shown to involve sleight of hand and refuted accordingly?

For starters, there's my 10-year anniversary review in the Skeptical Inquirer, Vol. 35.4, July-August 2011. (Nice PDF version here.) You can whine that this is "refuted sleight-of-hand" all you want, but I contend this is much more solid science than, say, your so-called "Missing Jolt" paper, or your pathetic attempts to imply that because NIST might have gotten a small detail wrong, then something "nefarious" happened on 9/11, or your continued refusal to provide even a bare outline of what you think really went down on 9/11.

As for Ziggi, he's trying desperately to dodge the fact that his baloney on the angle-cut steel beams was definitively shot down. As for Ziggi's so-called "science," how's that Basile study coming along? :rolleyes:

Fact is, Gage was eager to debate me until the S/I piece came out. Since then he hasn't asked me for further debate, realizing that any possible benefit of appearing onstage with a real physicist was offset by the risk of having his followers read my non-nonsense, fact-based rebuttal of so-called "9/11 Truth".
 
Tony is so blinded by his biases that he cannot make even simple evaluations regarding scientific merit. It's why he baldly lied and attempted to wholesale fabricate a heretofore unknown scientific principle (that 99% of heating in a compartmental fire occurs in 25-30 min) in an attempt to rationalize his unsubstantiated claims and why he still cannot disavow a paper that relies on that same debunked principle.

We're still waiting for him to demonstrate the "demonstrably" ridiculous nature of the WAI temperatures too. It's only been a month since he made the claim. Of course he still needs time to gather his thoughts. Maybe he'll come up with a new rationalization around the time Mark Basile follows through on his promises.

The leaders of the Truther movement are either dishonest or completely lost to woo. When will their fellow travelers wake up and demand better?
 
As for Ziggi, he's trying desperately to dodge the fact that his baloney on the angle-cut steel beams was definitively shot down. As for Ziggi's so-called "science," how's that Basile study coming along? :rolleyes:.

Why the gibberish Dave? It is no better than your cartoon. Can u say who listed what I said and explain how this person shot it down? Because it certainly was not you who tried to refute anything I said - U are still trying to dodge that..but are u now ready to address what I said?
 
Why the gibberish Dave? It is no better than your cartoon. Can u say who listed what I said and explain how this person shot it down? Because it certainly was not you who tried to refute anything I said - U are still trying to dodge that..but are u now ready to address what I said?

My point is that you all accept that without precise gov documentation with timestamped listing of cut beams, and further that you assume that ALL the cut beams found must have been cut during the clean up and that no beam could have been cut via thermitic cutter charges prior to building collapse.

Had anyone thought of checking for it, it would have taken expert inspections to distinguish between beams cut via thermite cutters and lances. Had FEMA and NIST followed the NFPA921, the first responder testimonies of melted metal and explosions would have automatically set in motion a forensic investigation which would have looked for forensic evidence for explosives and "exotic accelerants" including thermitic materials.

No truck driver transporting the beams or any inspector at the storage areas had any reason to raise a red flag due to angle cut beams with melted metal sputter since the clean up crews left these sorts of marks on the beams. Beams cut via thermitic cutter charges prior to collapse could have been hidden in plain sight, right out in the open.
FACT remains Ziggi, that there IS ample evidence that columns were cut by thermitic lances AFTER the towers collapsed.


You have a conjecture, a fiction, a fantasy with absolutely nothing other than "could'a been, you don't know" to go on. That IS called an "Argument from Ignorance" logical fallacy, akin to a Creationist's "God of the Gaps" fallacy.
You must have missed post 1204

Anything to say, Ziggi?
You are asking that NIST, FEMA etc. have operated on the assumption that your logical fallacy was something other than unsupported conjecture and politics driven fiction.
 
Last edited:
Ziggi, you can try to answer these easy, straight questions, too. I think they are relevant in the context of the OP and the thread topic - a proposed debate of a WTC7 collapse initiation hypothesis, where it would be fair to point out that no alternative or better hypothesis exists, as you surely know.


[2] There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Ziggi, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!


[3]Ziggi, more than 15 years after 9/11, and after you have spent so many years reviewing all of the evidence, what is, in your opinion today, the most likely ultimate cause of the WTC7 collapse?
(Remember, a straight and honest answer could easily be a single word, or a brief sentence )
 
Thread Title: does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me
U are still trying to dodge that..but are u now ready to address what I said?

Speaking of dodging:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?

AND

There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Ziggi, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!


Ziggi, more than 15 years after 9/11, and after you have spent so many years reviewing all of the evidence, what is, in your opinion today, the most likely ultimate cause of the WTC7 collapse?
(Remember, a straight and honest answer could easily be a single word, or a brief sentence )
 
At this point I think we can safely rule out any answers to any direct questions presented to Tony

...or Ziggi
 
Last edited:
You are the one who initially made the unsupported claim that Dave Thomas uses science to back his arguments on the building collapses, not me. You need to support your claim first before any further discussion can be had.

Please provide just one instance where you think Dave Thomas has used science to support his contentions on how the WTC buildings collapsed.

While we are waiting for that perhaps we could pass the time by you providing just one instance where you used science to support yours contentions on how the WTC buildings collapsed.
 
While we are waiting for that perhaps we could pass the time by you providing just one instance where you used science to support yours contentions on how the WTC buildings collapsed.
I think that's pretty rich coming from a guy (Tony) who can't even put his loads and boundary conditions on a simple beam free body diagram, don't you?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom