does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Tony's FEA requires bolt sheer on the girder without damage to the seat, or girder edge,

If ductile deformation failure occurs the the seat, and girder edge, as well as the stiffener can be damaged and the girder will walk off, as in NISTs model.

The other models also point to fire induced collapses.

The temperatures of the fire could have easily reached 1400C in air for sustained periods.

Thank you - this is more to the point. This still means that there can be no failure to the west, so invalidating NIST's hypothesis which is impossible. Refreshing to get that out the way in a debate such as this. Are you saying that the girder sags and fails to the north, in the cooling phase?


As for the other models, which ones specifically are you referring to? I have studied them and there is no viable failure mechanism there in any of them that can possibly occur in the heating phase.

Is it fair then to say that we are now considering a failure in the cooling phase of the analysis, presumably ARUP's ?

ETA, could you point me to the reference for that temperature please?
 
Tony's FEA requires bolt sheer on the girder without damage to the seat, or girder edge,

If ductile deformation failure occurs the the seat, and girder edge, as well as the stiffener can be damaged and the girder will walk off, as in NISTs model.

The other models also point to fire induced collapses.

The temperatures of the fire could have easily reached 1400C in air for sustained periods.
Tony's FEA is garbage. He doesn't actually have anything, other than possibly a local model (L-FEM). Nothing that defines anything other than a very specific area for a very specific, unspecified, condition.
 
Tony's FEA is garbage. He doesn't actually have anything, other than possibly a local model (L-FEM). Nothing that defines anything other than a very specific area for a very specific, unspecified, condition.

I know I was just being nice, seeing he is so kicked down by himself.
 
If you should find a plausible CD theory please do the same.

There is no need for me or anyone else to prove that controlled demolition with explosives has the ability to do this to the structure. Your position requires you to prove the viability of a fire induced progressive collapse, which is unprecedented, unlike controlled demolition.
 
There is no need for me or anyone else to prove that controlled demolition with explosives has the ability to do this to the structure. Your position requires you to prove the viability of a fire induced progressive collapse, which is unprecedented, unlike controlled demolition.
It is not unprecedented, it is why steel has insulation so people can get out before it fails. But make up BS, don't use reason, use BS.

Why is steel insulated? You can't prove CD, there is no evidence, it was fire. There is evidence for fire, and steel fails in fire. You studied nothing. What caused your collapse? Fire did it, what did your fantasy version of 9/11?
 
Thank you - this is more to the point. This still means that there can be no failure to the west, so invalidating NIST's hypothesis which is impossible. Refreshing to get that out the way in a debate such as this. Are you saying that the girder sags and fails to the north, in the cooling phase?


As for the other models, which ones specifically are you referring to? I have studied them and there is no viable failure mechanism there in any of them that can possibly occur in the heating phase.

Is it fair then to say that we are now considering a failure in the cooling phase of the analysis, presumably ARUP's ?

ETA, could you point me to the reference for that temperature please?

NIST's 1998 study into stack effect fires, soot can undergo catalitic combustion on hot surfaces at up to 1400C in air.

Soot being pure carbon.

Until you can Quantify the oxidation rates, fluidic flows, and actions of Catalytic heating you can not determine that failure by fire is not the most probable cause.
 
There is no need for me or anyone else to prove that controlled demolition with explosives has the ability to do this to the structure. Your position requires you to prove the viability of a fire induced progressive collapse, which is unprecedented, unlike controlled demolition.

Not, in fact, true, as collapse of steel structures due to fire is known to occur. And yours requires you to prove the viability of preparation of a building for demolition using explosives (please, please don't start talking about thermite, because we all know that's an absurd fantasy) either while the building was fully occupied and without the knowledge of its occupants, or in a period of a few hours while the building was on fire. These are the suggestions which are truly unprecedented.

If you have some hypothesis as to how WTC7 could have been prepared for demolition without the knowledge of its occupants, please share it. It's been boring around here lately and we could all do with a hearty guffaw or two.

Dave
 
There is no need for me or anyone else to prove that controlled demolition with explosives has the ability to do this to the structure. Your position requires you to prove the viability of a fire induced progressive collapse, which is unprecedented, unlike controlled demolition.
No. Absent a plausible alternative it becomes the default explanation. The evidence for fire is undeniable.

Do you have a plausible alternative?
 
Last edited:
NIST's 1998 study into stack effect fires, soot can undergo catalitic combustion on hot surfaces at up to 1400C in air.

Soot being pure carbon.

Until you can Quantify the oxidation rates, fluidic flows, and actions of Catalytic heating you can not determine that failure by fire is not the most probable cause.

1400C is not sustainable enough to be conducted to the steel. What temperature do you suppose the elements at column 79 could get to? I would assert that even ARUP's were on the high side, and they were nothing like 1400C. I think we should be specific about steel temperatures here, and not conflate those with gas temperatures, however fleeting.
 
There is no need for me or anyone else to prove that controlled demolition with explosives has the ability to do this to the structure. Your position requires you to prove the viability of a fire induced progressive collapse, which is unprecedented, unlike controlled demolition.

Not correct you must prove CD in a fire environment with no hypersonic explosive waves.

You must prove you have devices and technology that will accomplish the task, in one of the worst structural fires in history, and leave no observable trace evidence of the devices usage.

You must also prove access and opertunity to preform said CD.
 
No. Absent a plausible alternative it becomes the default explanation. The evidence for fire is undeniable.

Do you have a plausible alternative?

Fire Vs CD. One has proven ability to bring down such a structure, and one doesn't. I await your fire based plausible hypothesis. Fire would be unprecedented, as I am sure you are aware, controlled demolition would not.

Please let's deal with the viability issue of fire, and then discuss the potential CD.
 
You simply don't know much about heat transfer. I am sure you never had a course in it and everything is not instinctive. Discussing it on a forum like this with all of the noise and barbs from anonymous posters isn't the way to have a legitimate debate. I can do that with you on the 911 free forum in a one-on-one debate.

Just like nothing about this forum prevented you from writing this sorry post, nothing about this forum prevents you from substantively responding re Korol's clearly erroneous paper. In fact, as the record shows, you already responded to me dozens of times on this forum, but those responses only laid bare your ignorance of the subject matter and willingness to lie and make things up to try to win an argument. Now, suddenly, some magical force is preventing you from continuing to respond? You know what that force is, Tony? It's reality coupled with a bit of shame because you know you are dead wrong.
 
Fire Vs CD. One has proven ability to bring down such a structure, and one doesn't. I await your fire based plausible hypothesis. Fire would be unprecedented, as I am sure you are aware, controlled demolition would not.

Please let's deal with the viability issue of fire, and then discuss the potential CD.
Why wouldn't you want to discuss your CD hypothesis first? You seem to think there is reason to believe there is one.
 
1400C is not sustainable enough to be conducted to the steel. What temperature do you suppose the elements at column 79 could get to? I would assert that even ARUP's were on the high side, and they were nothing like 1400C. I think we should be specific about steel temperatures here, and not conflate those with gas temperatures, however fleeting.

With the carbon at 1200-1350C which is easy and simple to achieve, about 840-920C in steel temperature.
That is after conduction of heat though the insulating layer.

I conclude this based on dirrect tests with simple surface induced catalytic combustion in a stack effect, no forced ventilation only the stack effect.
 
Why wouldn't you want to discuss your CD hypothesis first? You seem to think there is reason to believe there is one.

Well as far as you and I are concerned, the reason that I believe there is one is your apparent inability to present a viable fire based hypothesis.
If you have such a hypothesis you would have presented it by now surely.
 
Fire Vs CD. One has proven ability to bring down such a structure, and one doesn't. I await your fire based plausible hypothesis. Fire would be unprecedented, as I am sure you are aware, controlled demolition would not.

Please let's deal with the viability issue of fire, and then discuss the potential CD.
Fire was the cause, no one denies this except paranoid conspiracy theorists who fail to back up their claims. 9/11 truth present nothing to do with engineering and fire science. You present less.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom