does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

These reports, as you are aware do not concur. I presume that when you say "there's another report" you are referring to ARUP?

If you are hanging your hat on the WAI report, then you should clearly state that so that we can accept NIST's hypothesis as invalid before moving on. These are engineering reports, and collectively do not present you with an a la carte menu that you can mix and match from.

So you are hanging your hat on the WAI report or not ?

You asked for reports that conclude that fire brought down the buildings.
On that point THEY ALL concur. It is only on the least relevant detail, the initial failure, the detail that is most difficult to nail down with certainty, that they differ.
THEY ALL concur that multiple floor failures led to column instability which in turn led to a progression of failures eventually involving the entire structure.
 
The last few pages here highlight the reality that there are no legitimate engineering analyses that can show WTC 7 collapsed due to fire. The three reports we have that make that claim require impossible situations and actually refute one another.

The ARUP analysis shows the NIST alleged walk-off of girder A2001 to the west was impossible, the Weidlinger report shows both NIST's and ARUP's alleged floor cascades were impossible and I had independently verified this before even seeing the Weidlinger report. Finally, the Weidlinger report needs to claim extreme steel temperatures not contained in either of the two earlier reports and which are not substantiated publicly.

It is clear from the last several pages here that those who still insist on believing that WTC 7 collapsed due to fire cannot provide a plausible hypothesis for their claim and are reduced to babbling things like "there were fires in the building and we know it distorts steel". It is also clear why none of these individuals will debate the issue in a one-on-one situation. They simply can't and know they will suffer the same ignominious fate as tfk.
This post indicates the abject failure of Tony Szamboti to recognize that all the reports on WTC 7 conclude that fire damage initiated the progressive collapse. HE completely and deliberately ignores that fact that the detail of initiation is the most difficult aspect of collapse to nail down. He completely ignores that fact that all these reports demonstrate that multiple floor failures cause column instability which in turn lead to a progression of failures that eventually bring down the entire structure.
 
.............. It is also clear why none of these individuals will debate the issue in a one-on-one situation. They simply can't and know they will suffer the same ignominious fate as tfk.


[1] as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make? If you debated every single ISF 9/11 debunker poster, and "won" every time, EXACTLY how would this further the cause of AE911T to garner a new investigation?


[2] There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!
 
[1] as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make? If you debated every single ISF 9/11 debunker poster, and "won" every time, EXACTLY how would this further the cause of AE911T to garner a new investigation?


[2] There exists no testable CD hypothesis for WTC7. <- Tony, is that correct? If you disagree, then please provide the URL to the site that hold this hypothesis, so we can test it!



There is one way Jay, but no one knows it but me so I guess that makes me guilty of the crime, for all of Tony's engineering (wile E. Coyote ) super genius he hasn't figured it out yet.
 
We only have evidence of fire. We don't have evidence of sooper seekret ninjas planned in the 90s by Guliani to demolish an empty fire gutted building.

Reality vs. Fantasy: In the Real World, Reality is the way to go.
 
Last edited:
I forgot to add that several posters here have agreed to a debate. Tony has thus far rejected, or ignored, their offers.

I know, debating Tony is like debating a two year old, on Cookie being bad for them.

Tony couldn't come up with a workable solution to demolish an out house, for penguins, with thermite at the south pole!
 
Tony's constant claims that insulation could have been used to shield charges is not only false it is insulting to anyone who understands the use of thermite or explosives!

It also raises the question of where you place these insulated charges to protect them from debris, knowing that they have to cause a collapse, yet they have to be kept safely away from potential impact areas.

The plan involves the building being set on fire as a result (or seeming so) of such damage as is caused by the collapse of the towers, so the plan needs the towers to collapse, and needs to know how much damage that will do to 7. There must be enough damage to justify there being fires severe enough that they could plausibly destroy it, but if the damage was that severe maybe you just let the fires destroy it anyway. On the other hand, the damage might easily be so great that the building is destroyed outright, in which case why rig it at all? In either case, motive is left dangling. Why's it imperative to demolish one more anonymous office block that's figuratively and literally in the shadow of two world famous buildings?

It would have been fascinating to be a fly on the wall at the planning meeting where anonymous malevolent forces discussed their motives and the incredible engineering challenge presented by faking 9/11.
 
We only have evidence of fire. We don't have evidence of sooper seekret ninjas planned in the 90s by GulianI to demolish an empty fire gutted building.

Reality vs. Fantasy: In the Real World, Reality is the way to go.

You don't need anything else, fire works just fine, as Dr Greening pointed out here long ago a smart CD, would work with and augment the fires, nothing more.

So why all these over complicated idiot theories that would never work?
 
It also raises the question of where you place these insulated charges to protect them from debris, knowing that they have to cause a collapse, yet they have to be kept safely away from potential impact areas.

The plan involves the building being set on fire as a result (or seeming so) of such damage as is caused by the collapse of the towers, so the plan needs the towers to collapse, and needs to know how much damage that will do to 7. There must be enough damage to justify there being fires severe enough that they could plausibly destroy it, but if the damage was that severe maybe you just let the fires destroy it anyway. On the other hand, the damage might easily be so great that the building is destroyed outright, in which case why rig it at all? In either case, motive is left dangling. Why's it imperative to demolish one more anonymous office block that's figuratively and literally in the shadow of two world famous buildings?

It would have been fascinating to be a fly on the wall at the planning meeting where anonymous malevolent forces discussed their motives and the incredible engineering challenge presented by faking 9/11.

All you have to do is augment the fires, one device in the right place shielded by heavy structure, would be enough all three building studies confirm that, then let fires do the work for you, no one is the wiser.

Remember I never said it would be done, but Tony and the other Truthers propose the most complicated and dumbest theories possible!
 
Last edited:
... Remember I never said it would be done, but Tony and the other Truthers propose the most complicated and dumbest theories possible!

They ought to be careful about that. If they come up with three CD theories and then other people disagree with some detail of each, then it can't be CD. That's how it works, right? Like a three strikes thing?
 
Everytime u post something I catch u lying and evading, and your response every time is changing the subject again and lying more...and now it is time to stop allowing u changing the subject again...and backtrack instead, starting from newest to oldest until I got a straight answer to everything u have avoided so far...and since u think repeating your claims about Tony endlessly is so cool I might do the same if u dont deliver.

Now, your latest post is full of gibberish to divert attention from your claim in the post before that:


I told u that U are reduced to babbling gobbledygook...can u refute that? What did u think u were refuting? I told u nist went 50% over 20 to 30, about mid point between the 20 and 40. OK it 32 not 30 but that detail does not really change anything or refute anything i said ..so if not gibberish, why did u repeat info about nist choice of mid level fuel load and try to create some sort of controversy?

You are claiming Korol's erroneous choices to (1) exclude from his analysis all pre-heating (which NIST estimated, for example, would account for nearly 400 C f temperature increases in certain locations on moderately involved floors) and (2) shorten the direct heating phase by up to 66% were justified because he increased the assumed fuel load on the floors in question by 25% (from 32kg/m3 to 40kg/m3) . So show us how that is theoretically sound, Ziggi. How much pre-heating and direct heating ought to be excluded from a fire model for every 1kg/m3 of fuel added?

I've shown how erroneous Korol's methodology is re pre-heating and direct heating. If you want to claim his adjustment to fuel load somehow saves him from those errors, then actually explain how.
 
Last edited:
All you have to do is augment the fires, one device in the right place shielded by heavy structure, would be enough all three building studies confirm that, then let fires do the work for you, no one is the wiser.

Remember I never said it would be done, but Tony and the other Truthers propose the most complicated and dumbest theories possible!

My favorite is how they presuppose all of these extremely complicated, multi-week black-ops missions to install explosives all while presuming the explosives were installed to destroy documents in the building (something that isn't even guaranteed by destroying the building).

If they had access to the building for all of these covert ops, why not just take and destroy the documents directly?

SO DUMB.
 
Another possibility for how charges could have been placed in WTC 7 is with a cover story. It is well known that in the late 1990's mayor Rudy Giuliani insisted on putting his newly created Office of Emergency Management headquarters on the 23rd floor of WTC 7 and the contractor for the 13 million dollar project had access to the entire building for backup power and life systems.

The same can be said of the Twin Towers with the ACE elevator upgrade which was occurring in the eight months prior to Sept. 11, 2001.

Tony, Tony, Tony. Guess who had access to all of the WTC7 building modification records? It was the plaintiffs in the Aegis Insurance case, a collection of US and foreign insurers and reinsurers who were taking billions in loses due to the collapse of the building. As you know, they hired some of the worlds foremost tall building and fire science experts to examine those building records, and those experts even retained the world's foremost forensic engineering firm (ARUP) to assist them. Did these people, with every motivation to do so and the expertise to do so, unearth evidence of your fantasy scenario of explosives being installed during renovations for the emergency management headquarters?
No, and they concluded that the building modifications played no role in the fire induced collapse.
 
Okay then. We will sort this out thus. I will ask you once again, in light of our exchange since...
"Did Bailey make any amendments to his original evidence to the court that you are aware of?"

Since the above has already been answered I wonder if we could just cease this pointless derail and get back to it? I seem to recall there is the unanswered question of you having any evidence to support your assertion that ARUP tested NIST's heating scenario.

Do you or do you not have such evidence?

A simple yes or no will do.
 
Another possibility for how charges could have been placed in WTC 7 is with a cover story. It is well known that in the late 1990's mayor Rudy Giuliani insisted on putting his newly created Office of Emergency Management headquarters on the 23rd floor of WTC 7 and the contractor for the 13 million dollar project had access to the entire building for backup power and life systems.

The same can be said of the Twin Towers with the ACE elevator upgrade which was occurring in the eight months prior to Sept. 11, 2001.

Tell me Tony, just how far would you get in a court case with such a fictional, long game (supposedly 11 years long) "could'a been"?

Are you accusing Rudy Guliani of being 'in-on-it"?

When will you move beyond "could'a" fictions, and get into actual evidence?

Then there are the, on topic of the thread, questions in post 1563 above. These have been put forth nigh on a dozen times now. Surely you have seen them.
 
Last edited:
The last few pages here highlight the reality that there are no legitimate engineering analyses that can show WTC 7 collapsed due to fire.


I will once again, invite you to address the list that I have posted for you here.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11665527&postcount=1294


If you continue to evade addressing my list, it will further highlight your CD claim as baseless, which explains your failure to address my list. You have been placed high on a pedestal and I'm am waiting for you to respond.

.
 
Last edited:
Your claim that there are no real world examples of something done covertly to a large building over time is refuted by the secret repair of the Citicorp building in 1978. The repair was done at night over a three month period without public knowledge and would never have even been publicly known without those who managed it choosing to make it known in the late 1990's.


Are you being funny?! The Citicorp building was not rigged covertly with CD explosives. You have just underlined what I have known all along, and that is, you have no clue what it takes to demolish a steel-framed building with CD explosives.


Additionally, planting charges on core columns, via the elevator shafts, which allow access to them, is not observable.


False! There is no way a large occupied steel-framed building can be properly rigged for demolition implosion covertly. You have to access and rig a large portion of a steel-framed building for demolition, which would have taken months of preparation even before the first explosives are placed.

Simply detonating explosives in a steel-framed building without extensive and proper preparations to the steel structure of a building won't work because the blast waves will simply flow around steel columns and the result will be what you saw after WTC 1 was bombed in 1993. Did WTC 1 collapse after its bombing in 1993? No! Did WTC 1 and WTC 2 immediately collapse after those buildings were struck by B-767s? No! Did WTC 7 immediately collapse after it was struck by debris from WTC 1? No!

The more you post, the more it becomes clear that you are not knowledgeable enough to debate the collapse of WTC 7.
 
Last edited:
The last few pages here highlight the reality that there are no legitimate engineering analyses... .

Nope, the last few pages highlight there are gullible people in 9/11 truth, gullible followers who have no clue what a legitimate engineering analyses is. The pages show 9/11 truth cherry picks from studies which say fire did it, to make weak attacks on other studies which say fire did it.

9/11 truth fooling those who can't do science, those who fail to use critical thinking skills, and those with no idea what evidence is. Got any evidence for CD? No.

Planting silent explosives in the elevator shafts? From the top of the elevator? Tony, you got a fantasy of CD, no evidence.
 
Last edited:
Another possibility for how charges could have been placed in WTC 7 is with a cover story.

It is well known that in the late 1990's mayor Rudy Giuliani insisted on putting his newly created Office of Emergency Management headquarters on the 23rd floor of WTC 7 and the contractor for the 13 million dollar project had access to the entire building for backup power and life systems.

The same can be said of the Twin Towers with the ACE elevator upgrade which was occurring in the eight months prior to Sept. 11, 2001.


In that case, explain the lack of CD explosions during impacts and as fires raged out of control in addition to the lack of CD explosive hardware at ground zero.

Just to let you know that upgrading elevators and structural pre-weakening are two different things.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom