Some of the piranhas here double as whackadoodles that say whatever they want regardless of accuracy. If you want to call that a bite go ahead. That would then make the first sentence apply to you too.
If you can't support your positions with reason, then just resort to lame throwaway insults? You are dodging
my last post in a rather sad way.
Come on, Tony. You are claiming that you modeled the girder connections sufficiently to prove that two consecutive floors could not have collapsed under any reasonable set of fire conditions. But it's one thing to claim it and another to actually have done it.
As we've already established, your model is
an overly-simplistic representation of a single girder connection at a single temperature. It includes no other structural elements and, as far as I can tell, does not at all account for any damage that could have reasonably occurred to that connection because it seems like you didn't even run a simulation at the heightened temperature but instead used back-of-the-envelope guesstimates as to the effect of the increase in temperature on the connection.
Without even looking at such a model in detail we know it is lacking. How do we know? Because, as you know, ARUP, WAI and NIST all found that the girder connections in question could
completely fail in reasonable fire scenarios without sustaining any impact from a falling floor above. That's how the first floor falls in any model, after all. You take issue with NIST's failure model so I'm happy to table it, even though I don't agree with your criticism in context, but you have never so much as even raised a critique of ARUP's or WAI's (and WAI not only established its own failure scenarios, but it also replicated ARUP's!).
Given that multiple fulsome, finite element model analyses have demonstrated that, under reasonable fire scenarios, the girder connections could completely fail even without sustaining impact damage from above, your overly-simplistic model that you claim demonstrates they could never fail even after sustaining impact damage is obviously wrong. It could be wrong because of how it omits all of the other structural elements in the floor. It could be wrong because it doesn't actually model girder behavior during heating and thus omits damage that occurs to the girder connections from said heating (the same heating that ARUP demonstrates could completely fail such connections). It could be wrong because you set the parameters incorrectly. It could be wrong because it doesn't even exist and its "conclusion" is just a lie you are telling in an attempt to reach a conclusion that is out of your grasp. It could be wrong for any number of reasons. But we know it is wrong. If one floor can fail from fire alone, then clearly another floor can fail from fires of similar severity
plus the impact of the floor above it. And we can know this without even pointing out that
WAI also specifically undertook additional modeling to prove it true in reasonable fire scenarios in WTC7.
Do you want to add to
your inability to address the fundamental error you and Korol made re heating an inability to address the clear limits of your floor collapse propagation model? Or do you want to correct the record?