does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

It could be. CA gov systems are notoriously fickle. It's working for me right now, though.

You can try this direct link too: http://rct.doj.ca.gov/Verification/Web/Details.aspx?result=709340f7-dcd4-40f7-87e8-c7433916c73d

Search function working for me, too, now. T'was temporary.

Very interesting - in five of the last six years they filed after the max. extended due date (Nov 15), and the last received filing (11/21/2016) did not have the required Form 990 attached :D Although I have by now seen that form. It contains an obvious error concerning Richard Gage's salary :D

So their status currently is "DELINQUENT" :thumbsup:


Haha and in the Founding Documents (Part VIII) they answer the question "Do you attempt to influence legislation?" with "No" :eek:
 
Benthamitemetric = a lawyer with zero training in heat transfer but lots in bombast who had his head handed to him after crowing that the ARUP report validated NIST before being shown Nordenson's little problem.

Oystein = a self trained bombastic sort and occasional cheerleader for more advanced bombastic types.

I think any rational person can see why I don't answer you two here in your bombastic little piranha tank. I would debate either one of you one-on-one on the 911 free forum.

A lawyer with zero training in heat... sees you don't have evidence and your claims remain a failed fantasy.

A self-trained bombastic sort - who sees your CD claims are a lie.

And you, with nothing in the real world to debate. How do you debate a fantasy.

Tony, post your proof... wait, you can't, you got no evidence. Who did 9/11 in your fantasy? Same guys who did OKC and JFK?
 
Yeah, that one's been amusing me for a while. Tony seems to need the floor girder below the initial failure to maintain enough strength to arrest the impact even when it's hotter than the girder that failed first.

Dave

The 12th floor girder between columns 44 and 79 is not hotter than the one on the 13th floor when the failure is alleged to have happened.

This is just flailing around saying whatever you want, because you can't show an analysis that shows what you are saying.
 
Sounds like piranha-Bethamitemetric and piranha-Oystein have taken painful bites out of mute TS’s rear.

Some of the piranhas here double as whackadoodles that say whatever they want regardless of accuracy. If you want to call that a bite go ahead. That would then make the first sentence apply to you too.
 
Last edited:
T
This is just flailing around saying whatever you want, because you can't show an analysis that shows what you are saying.


It is more accurate to say that you can't show evidence that explosives were used to bring down WTC 7. While we have overwhelming fire and impact damage evidence, there's absolutely no evidence supporting CD.
 
Some of the piranhas here double as whackadoodles that say whatever they want regardless of accuracy. If you want to call that a bite go ahead. That would then make the first sentence apply to you too.

Tony we both know you have no evidence and no understanding of fires.

And according to your understanding of fires I burned to a crisp again today!
 
The 12th floor girder between columns 44 and 79 is not hotter than the one on the 13th floor when the failure is alleged to have happened.

This is just flailing around saying whatever you want, because you can't show an analysis that shows what you are saying.
sure. You can produce a cogent CD scenario which is utterly bereft of the necessary C4 fairies, right?

Oops. I forgot. TS has me on ignore because I had the chutzpah to actually be demonstrably an engineer.

Sorry Tony.
 
The reason I don't put you on ignore is it is hard to believe you actually take yourself seriously. Your rants could be taken as sarcasm, and I think deep down you are probably a nice guy as that seeps through the rant on occassion.

I'm thinking your failure to put him on ignore (and say so) is because of the repercussions of doing so.
 
So instead of evidence, we are treated to insults?

I can see why the new investigation is proceeding at such a glacial pace...

Well, we know from experience that when Tony goes into insult mode its because he's got nuthin' and he knows it.
 
It is more accurate to say that you can't show evidence that explosives were used to bring down WTC 7. While we have overwhelming fire and impact damage evidence, there's absolutely no evidence supporting CD.
An even more accurate statement would be that Tony doesn't have any analysis he can share, or is willing to share.
This is possibly because engineers scare the stuffing out him. But that is just speculation on my part.
 
Some of the piranhas here double as whackadoodles that say whatever they want regardless of accuracy. If you want to call that a bite go ahead. That would then make the first sentence apply to you too.

If you can't support your positions with reason, then just resort to lame throwaway insults? You are dodging my last post in a rather sad way.

Come on, Tony. You are claiming that you modeled the girder connections sufficiently to prove that two consecutive floors could not have collapsed under any reasonable set of fire conditions. But it's one thing to claim it and another to actually have done it.

As we've already established, your model is an overly-simplistic representation of a single girder connection at a single temperature. It includes no other structural elements and, as far as I can tell, does not at all account for any damage that could have reasonably occurred to that connection because it seems like you didn't even run a simulation at the heightened temperature but instead used back-of-the-envelope guesstimates as to the effect of the increase in temperature on the connection.

Without even looking at such a model in detail we know it is lacking. How do we know? Because, as you know, ARUP, WAI and NIST all found that the girder connections in question could completely fail in reasonable fire scenarios without sustaining any impact from a falling floor above. That's how the first floor falls in any model, after all. You take issue with NIST's failure model so I'm happy to table it, even though I don't agree with your criticism in context, but you have never so much as even raised a critique of ARUP's or WAI's (and WAI not only established its own failure scenarios, but it also replicated ARUP's!).

Given that multiple fulsome, finite element model analyses have demonstrated that, under reasonable fire scenarios, the girder connections could completely fail even without sustaining impact damage from above, your overly-simplistic model that you claim demonstrates they could never fail even after sustaining impact damage is obviously wrong. It could be wrong because of how it omits all of the other structural elements in the floor. It could be wrong because it doesn't actually model girder behavior during heating and thus omits damage that occurs to the girder connections from said heating (the same heating that ARUP demonstrates could completely fail such connections). It could be wrong because you set the parameters incorrectly. It could be wrong because it doesn't even exist and its "conclusion" is just a lie you are telling in an attempt to reach a conclusion that is out of your grasp. It could be wrong for any number of reasons. But we know it is wrong. If one floor can fail from fire alone, then clearly another floor can fail from fires of similar severity plus the impact of the floor above it. And we can know this without even pointing out that WAI also specifically undertook additional modeling to prove it true in reasonable fire scenarios in WTC7.

Do you want to add to your inability to address the fundamental error you and Korol made re heating an inability to address the clear limits of your floor collapse propagation model? Or do you want to correct the record?
 
Last edited:
Some of the piranhas here double as whackadoodles that say whatever they want regardless of accuracy. If you want to call that a bite go ahead. That would then make the first sentence apply to you too.
the realcddeal has spoken - support for the NIST reports? Where is the support for the "real" cd deal? You showed up with fantasy, and have never presented evidence.

Why are you spreading the lie of CD? Where do the 19 terrorists fit in your fantasy CD thing? 19 terrorists figured out 9/11 over 15 years ago - are the better engineers than you are? What is stopping you from seeing CD is nonsense? What does NIST have to do with your CD fantasy?

Why can't you start your debate, and stop the weak attacks on the wackadoodle piranhas? Why? because you have BS for facts, and nonsense for evidence.

These and other simple questions will never be answered, as we await the next CNN edition with the realcddeal spewing BS on national TV, trying to spread "fake news".
 
Originally Posted by Ziggi

Pay attention, "dude" and dont change the subject again...I asked u
...so if not gibberish, why did u repeat info about nist choice of mid level fuel load and try to create some sort of controversy

..referring to this
Dude, I think you need to seriously check your sources. What was the fire load NIST used to estimate the fires on the floors it believed to be collapse initiating? It was 32kg


This goes over your head? U gonna evade answering again?
Last time I checked, the point was that you cannot defend Korol's clearly erroneous paper. The discussion about it has now gone on for over three weeks and no one has offered any theoretical or experimental bases for his flawed methodologies. Yes, I realize you want to go into a stupid tangent about fuel loading, and, yes, I almost gave you the benefit of the doubt and went down that path with you, but I quickly realized there is nothing about Korol's fuel load modeling that saves his paper from the errors I pointed out, and so I don't care. All you can do is whine that's all gibberish to you. I don't know whether that's true or whether you're lying to dodge the point. I'd believe either, actually.

The last time u checked obviously involves some other dimension. It is also obvious that u avoid answering for that bs because you dont know what the hell u were thinking...u were reduced to babbling gibberish. OK, moving on. There plenty of other bs to rub your nose in.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11670356&postcount=1518

Originally Posted by benthamitemetric View Post
... And you are comically misreading the '93 Cardington Study compartmental fire if you think that those fires burned for anywhere near 3 hours (or were a "double fuel fire"). Check your eyes and reading comprehension if you want to have an adult conversation or just go back to scamming people.
Originally Posted by Ziggi
- U cite F47 which cuts out at 170 min...10 min short of 3 hours
- F47 caption for graph says Test 4...Table 2 p17 says fuel load for that is 40kg...which is double the 20kg/meter2 industry std office fire load.

So talking about comical lack of reading comprehension, u have been ranting and raving about a report even though u did not understand the MOST BASIC data.
 
Last edited:
The last time u checked obviously involves some other dimension. It is also obvious that u avoid answering for that bs because you dont know what the hell u were thinking...u were reduced to babbling gibberish. OK, moving on. There plenty of other bs to rub your nose in.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11670356&postcount=1518




So talking about comical lack of reading comprehension, u have been rant and raving about a report even though u did not understand the MOST BASIC data.

Got me on one point--I meant that there weren't 3 hours of heating, not that there weren't three hours of fire! My bad! Of course, it's not a point that in any way matters when evaluating Korol's clearly erroneous methodologies. Any defense for the omission pre-heating or the arbitrary shortening of direct heating? It's been about three weeks since Tony and I started discussing the Korol paper in earnest. He's moved on because he knows its wrong. You, of course, remain slow to catch on. Keep bringing it up, though. I always enjoy an opportunity to remind you and Tony how you can't defend it.
 
It's hilarious watching Tony get angry because "laymen" here are embarrassing him so badly.

I can understand though, 15 years of failure must be very frustrating!
 
You know you just quoted benthamitemetric saying "I don't think there is any evidence that Tony receives any substantial financial benefits from his role in AE911Truth", , right?

haha, shhhhhhhhhh, I was hoping to get at least one or two more good exchanges from him before i pointed that out...
 
Last edited:
It's hilarious watching Tony get angry because "laymen" here are embarrassing him so badly.

I can understand though, 15 years of failure must be very frustrating!

To be fair, I think Tony's only been on the wrong track for 8-9 years or so. He's close to his epiphany, though. He now knows he's been fundamentally mistaken about the steel temperatures in WTC7. All he needs to do now is realize that two consecutive floors could have collapsed, and he's already out of excuses as to why they couldn't have.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom