The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis

Well speaking of ignoring the laws of nature. Establishment dogma states that stars remain hot and bright for their entire lives, contradicting the conservation of energy.

Nope, by all means please, show specifically and explicitly how stellar fusion and stellar evolution contradict conservation of energy.


To them, a dead star is extremely energetic (white dwarfs). Yet, in this theory dead stars have lost their energy due to radiating it all away. Actual dead stars are objects that look like Mercury. They are the ancient dead cores of long dead stars, and the 100% guaranteed do NOT radiate strongly in the visible light spectrum.

Not only that but they also ignore the conservation of mass, the most fundamental physical law in nature. To them, stars remain massive their whole lives, regardless if they are directly observed to be losing mass as they cool and die. This means evolved stars should be much less massive than young ones.

Nope "remain massive" is not the same as 'remain as massive'. By your own assertions stars "are directly observed to be losing mass" so they get less massive than the were before. How massive a star is when it is older depends on how massive it was when it was younger not how massive some other younger star may currently be. Heck, I'm currently older and more massive than any of my nephews.


These two basic laws, conservation of mass and conservation of energy are ignored. This means 100% of all accepted peer reviewed theories of stellar evolution are false.

The fact is that they have labeled older stars as "planets" and have gotten away with it for a very long time. They have been wrong in their assumptions, so naturally all the logic that is based on those assumptions is also false.

It is very easy to see their blind spot.

Just look for evolutionary models of Uranus, Neptune, Earth, Saturn, Jupiter, etc. They do not exist. You would think objects that have mass and radiate in EM frequencies outside of the visible spectrum would have models to predict their future radiative output, but nope. Not a single paper exists in any scientific journal that predicts the evolutionary sequence of those objects.

Not only that but no models exist either predicting the strength of their magnetic field output as they evolve. Why is this? It is because everything is under the paradigm of all the objects are related to the Sun. Yet, they are NOT related to the Sun. They are all independent structures. They are all stars in varying stages of evolution and are all vastly OLDER than the Sun.

This is of course outlined in the theory in a series of papers that is growing more rapidly with all the "exoplanet" data that is rolling in. They are just looking at evolved/evolving/dead stars. That is what an exoplanet is! So here we are.

Nope, 2 sec of trying turns up a paper on models for "The Evolution and Internal Structure of Jupiter and Saturn with Compositional Gradients".

https://arxiv.org/abs/1606.01558

You don't seem to be even trying. Even just with your own assertion let alone the other nonsense you'd like to ascribe to others.
 
Last edited:
Nope, by all means please, show specifically and explicitly how stellar fusion and stellar evolution contradict conservation of energy.




Nope "remain massive" is not the same as 'remain as massive'. By your own assertions stars "are directly observed to be losing mass" so they get less massive than the were before. How massive a star is when it is older depends on how massive it was when it was younger not how massive some other younger star may currently be. Heck, I'm currently older and more massive than any of my nephews.




Nope, 2 sec of trying turns up a paper on models for "The Evolution and Internal Structure of Jupiter and Saturn with Compositional Gradients".

https://arxiv.org/abs/1606.01558

You don't seem to be even trying. Even just with your own assertion let alone the other nonsense you'd like to ascribe to others.

The paper quotes "evolutionary history", not future evolution, meaning they are saying the same thing with different words.

Their definition of "evolutionary history" is "formation".

Clearly you are not trying. Psychological projection is what I think its called. Ascribing to me attributes the claimant possesses.

To further clarify, there is a zero on the time scale. Zero is where we currently are. This paper only is looking at the (-) part of the "evolution", I'm concerned with the positive side, the future evolution. If they were concerned about that, then it would have been mentioned. It is not mentioned. Just cutting and pasting the article into MS word finds that they don't even use the word "future" even. There is a reason for that. They have no prediction for Jupiter's or Saturn's future evolutionary path. This means their modelling and paper does not address the issue which you are ascribing.
 
Last edited:
Well speaking of ignoring the laws of nature. Establishment dogma states that stars remain hot and bright for their entire lives, contradicting the conservation of energy.

To them, a dead star is extremely energetic (white dwarfs). Yet, in this theory dead stars have lost their energy due to radiating it all away. Actual dead stars are objects that look like Mercury. They are the ancient dead cores of long dead stars, and the 100% guaranteed do NOT radiate strongly in the visible light spectrum.

Not only that but they also ignore the conservation of mass, the most fundamental physical law in nature. To them, stars remain massive their whole lives, regardless if they are directly observed to be losing mass as they cool and die. This means evolved stars should be much less massive than young ones.

These two basic laws, conservation of mass and conservation of energy are ignored. This means 100% of all accepted peer reviewed theories of stellar evolution are false.

The fact is that they have labeled older stars as "planets" and have gotten away with it for a very long time. They have been wrong in their assumptions, so naturally all the logic that is based on those assumptions is also false.

It is very easy to see their blind spot.

Just look for evolutionary models of Uranus, Neptune, Earth, Saturn, Jupiter, etc. They do not exist. You would think objects that have mass and radiate in EM frequencies outside of the visible spectrum would have models to predict their future radiative output, but nope. Not a single paper exists in any scientific journal that predicts the evolutionary sequence of those objects.

Not only that but no models exist either predicting the strength of their magnetic field output as they evolve. Why is this? It is because everything is under the paradigm of all the objects are related to the Sun. Yet, they are NOT related to the Sun. They are all independent structures. They are all stars in varying stages of evolution and are all vastly OLDER than the Sun.

This is of course outlined in the theory in a series of papers that is growing more rapidly with all the "exoplanet" data that is rolling in. They are just looking at evolved/evolving/dead stars. That is what an exoplanet is! So here we are.
Wow.

Not a single claim is remotely true.

Do you really believe this baloney?
 
The paper quotes "evolutionary history", not future evolution, meaning they are saying the same thing with different words.

Effective models work both ways both historical and future evolution form any individual perspective. To the model itself however, all data produced is historical. Meaning only up to how far the evolution of model has been run.


Their definition of "evolutionary history" is "formation".

Nope, read the paper...

Our findings suggest that the initial configuration has an important role in determining the long-term planetary evolution (see also paper I). If the primordial internal structure is hot, the planet is expected to retain heat even after 109 years of evolution.

So explicitly not just "formation". Do please try harder.

Clearly you are not trying. Psychological projection is what I think its called. Ascribing to me attributes the claimant possesses.

Armchair Psychology? Again, Do please try harder. Projecting simply projection is still just projection that ain't even trying.


To further clarify, there is a zero on the time scale. Zero is where we currently are. This paper only is looking at the (-) part of the "evolution", I'm concerned with the positive side, the future evolution. If they were concerned about that, then it would have been mentioned. It is not mentioned. Just cutting and pasting the article into MS word finds that they don't even use the word "future" even. There is a reason for that. They have no prediction for Jupiter's or Saturn's future evolutionary path. This means their modelling and paper does not address the issue which you are ascribing.

Ah, so just a specific word search and not actually reading the paper, you indeed aren't even trying. Even just in the abstract...

We conclude that the internal structure is directly linked to the formation and evolution history of the planet. These alternative internal structures of Jupiter and Saturn should be considered when interpreting the upcoming Juno and Cassini data.

See, "upcoming" that means, you know, "saying the same thing with different words" as "future". Please, do try harder.

In spite of your assertions and evident lack of effort the paper explicitly asserts, even just in the abstract, the potential applicability of the models to "future" events and data.


To further clarify, that positive side, the future evolution you are looking for would still be the "evolutionary history" of some model up to and beyond that time. The model itself has to be run to at least that time regardless of whether you consider that time to be your "future" or your "history". Data produced by any time dependent model is always just the "evolutionary history" of that model, specifically how far it has been run.
 
jeffreyw: Delusion and ignorance about stars and conservation of energy

Establishment dogma states that stars remain hot and bright for their entire lives, contradicting the conservation of energy.
24 May 2017 jeffreyw: Delusion and ignorance about stars and conservation of energy.
A delusion of "establishment dogma".

Stars conserve energy. The energy they generate comes from fusion. This is the conversion of mass to energy (E=mc2).

Stars actually get brighter and hotter during their lifetime due to the laws of physics and observations :eye-poppi!
Why the Sun Will Become Hotter and Brighter from a beginners guide to the stars.
 
jeffreyw: Lie about data being ignored + fantasies about Kepler data

They are ignored.
24 May 2017 jeffreyw: Lie about data being ignored + fantasies about Kepler data.
The Kepler mission data is continuously analyzed for exoplanets. There is even a citizen "Zooniverse project" looking at the data.

A prediction from the exoplanets that have been detected that there are millions of them in the Milky Way does not mean that the data from Kepler has millions of observations of exoplanets :eye-poppi.

The Kepler mission is monitoring 145,000 main sequence stars, not every star in the Milky Way.

The Kepler mission looks for exoplanets that cross the disk of their star causing it to change brightness. It detects exoplanets in orbits with a plane allowing this. Other exoplanets cannot be detected, e.g. one orbiting so that we cannot see it crossing the star (the orbital plane is perpendicular to us).
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: A lie that conservation of energy and mass is ignored in astronomy

...These two basic laws, conservation of mass and conservation of energy are ignored.
24 May 2017 jeffreyw: A lie that conservation of energy and mass is ignored in astronomy.
Astronomers have a postgraduate education and thus know and apply these laws.
Conservation of mass is one reason why a star being 100,000 times more massive than a planet makes his "planet = old star" assertion into a delusion.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: Massive ignorance of planetary science which has models of planets

Just look for evolutionary models of Uranus, Neptune, Earth, Saturn, Jupiter, etc. They do not exist.
24 May 2017 jeffreyw: Massive ignorance of planetary science which has models of planets!
The history (not really his delusion of "evolution") of planets is a fundamental part of planetary science.

The future radiative output of planets are so simple that it is basic textbook physics. Take a rocky sphere at a given temperature. Let it radiate. Have a student work out its future temperature and radiative output.

What is real science is real planets which orbit stars, e.g. the Earth. The balance between radiative output and sunlight input is part of the complex modeling of the Earth's climate.
 
jeffreyw: More "evolve" delusion + ignorance of planetary science + hypocrisy

Not only that but no models exist either predicting the strength of their magnetic field output as they evolve.
24 May 2017 jeffreyw: More "evolve" delusion + ignorance of planetary science + hypocrisy.
The hypocrisy is that his ignorant fantasies have no such predictions or even scientific model and so he is accusing himself of being wrong :eek:!

There are models of the magnetic fields of the planets, especially Earth, that predict the strength of the magnetic fields. A minutes Google and: A deep dynamo generating Mercury’s magnetic field
The model explains the observed structure and strength of Mercury’s surface magnetic field and makes predictions that are testable with space missions both presently flying and planned.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: Knows that the measured age of the Earth matches the Sun and lies about it

...They are all stars in varying stages of evolution and are all vastly OLDER than the Sun..
24 May 2017 jeffreyw: Knows that the measured age of the Earth matches the Sun and lies about it :jaw-dropp!
This is the Earth (formed about 4.54 billion years ago) and Sun (formed approximately 4.6 billion years ago) - ages that he has been told a few times.

Ditto for the measured ages of other objects in the Solar System. We have Moon rocks that are not older than the Sun! We have meteorites that are not older than the Sun!
 
PAH's in Stellar Metamorphosis

http://vixra.org/pdf/1705.0464v1.pdf

Abstract:

The vast majority of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH)’s are formed in intermediate stages of a star’s evolution. This is in line with the astrochemical principle of stellar metamorphosis. Stars in intermediate stages of evolution are outlined in a graph and are comprised of M, L, Y and T type brown dwarfs all the way to ocean world stages of stellar evolution. PAH’s are mostly formed in Pop 2 stars according to the General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis.
 
http://vixra.org/pdf/1705.0464v1.pdf

Abstract:

The vast majority of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH)’s are formed in intermediate stages of a star’s evolution. This is in line with the astrochemical principle of stellar metamorphosis. Stars in intermediate stages of evolution are outlined in a graph and are comprised of M, L, Y and T type brown dwarfs all the way to ocean world stages of stellar evolution. PAH’s are mostly formed in Pop 2 stars according to the General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis.

From the linked 'paper' (just page being more descriptive).


In stellar metamorphosis theory we can use physics and chemistry to determine where, why and how PAH’s form in the largest abundances in all galaxies

By all means please show exactly and specifically how you "can use physics and chemistry to determine where, why and how PAH’s form" "In stellar metamorphosis theory". Because you certainly didn't do anything of the sort in that single page link (nor the other single page link linked in that link).


ETA:
Heck "page" isn't even descriptive of those links as one is just a paragraph (other than the "abstract") with your fantasy chart and the other is just a couple, well, paragraphs that hardly take up half the page. Do please try harder.
 
Last edited:
It looks like it's about way past time to put this tomfoolery into the general skepticism and the paranormal forum.
 
jeffreyw: An ignorant and deluded abstract about stars and hydrocarbons

Abstract:
A crank PDF on a PDF upload site and
31 May 2017 jeffreyw: An ignorant and deluded abstract about stars and hydrocarbons

Stars have temperatures of 1000's of degrees. No complex molecules exist on stars.
 
Neptune is a Star (new paper)

In stellar metamorphosis Neptune is also a star. It is a very late stage star. Of course the nebular hypothesis predicted that Neptunes would be rare, but they are not rare, they are very common.

They sit right in the middle of the chart. They have a while to go before they become Earth-like, but are well on their way. There are billions of them in the galaxy.

Not only that, but Neptune is not related to the Sun. It is mostly a completely independent structure, except for the lower impact the Sun has on it from its position in the solar system.

I wrote a paper on the predicted abundances of Neptunes here, according to stellar metamorphosis theory:

http://vixra.org/pdf/1706.0002v1.pdf

Proof that the nebular hypothesis is already busted, as it failed to predict the abundances of Neptune sized objects (it failed in dozens of ways actually, this is just one).

http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2011/02/110222-planets-formation-theory-busted-earth-science-space/

The nebular hypothesis theory has struck out. What is really cool is that the article above was written early in 2011. Later in 2011 I found out Earth is an ancient star, so its cool. The transition of failed theory to good theory happened within a timeframe of a few months, if you count Geoffrey Marcy's account of the failure of accepted theory to bridge to stellar metamorphosis.
 
In stellar metamorphosis Neptune is also a star. It is a very late stage star. Of course the nebular hypothesis predicted that Neptunes would be rare, but they are not rare, they are very common.

They sit right in the middle of the chart. They have a while to go before they become Earth-like, but are well on their way. There are billions of them in the galaxy.

Not only that, but Neptune is not related to the Sun. It is mostly a completely independent structure, except for the lower impact the Sun has on it from its position in the solar system.

I wrote a paper on the predicted abundances of Neptunes here, according to stellar metamorphosis theory:

http://vixra.org/pdf/1706.0002v1.pdf

Proof that the nebular hypothesis is already busted, as it failed to predict the abundances of Neptune sized objects (it failed in dozens of ways actually, this is just one).

http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2011/02/110222-planets-formation-theory-busted-earth-science-space/

The nebular hypothesis theory has struck out. What is really cool is that the article above was written early in 2011. Later in 2011 I found out Earth is an ancient star, so its cool. The transition of failed theory to good theory happened within a timeframe of a few months, if you count Geoffrey Marcy's account of the failure of accepted theory to bridge to stellar metamorphosis.

No.
 
jeffreyw: The delusion that Neptune is a star and lies about the nebular hypothesis

In stellar metamorphosis Neptune is also a star.
6 June 2017 jeffreyw: The delusion that Neptune is a star and lies about the nebular hypothesis, etc.

The nebular hypothesis predicts that Neptune exists like all of the objects in the Solar System. There is a problem about which formation mechanism forms gas giants. Before 2000 there was an issue that Neptune and Uranus should not exist because there would not be enough mass to form them far from the Sun. Then it was realized that they could have formed closer to the Sun and migrated outwards resulting in the 2009 Nice model.

The 2011 National Geographic article is an opinion from one astronomer 6 years ago. Geoffrey Marcy states that the nebular hypothesis works for the solar system with nearly circular orbits that are in the same plane and in the same direction. The detected exoplanets though:
  • "In reality, though, only about one in three of the known exoplanets has a circular or near-circular orbit."
  • "However, about one in three exoplanets' orbits are "misaligned." Some orbit in the opposite directions as their stars' rotations, and others are tilted out of the ecliptic, like weather satellites crossing over Earth's Poles rather than the Equator"
The question that he does not address is whether the techniques to detect exoplanets could give a biased sample, e.g. hot Jupiters imply a disrupted system where the planet has migrated inward.
Then we get to Neptune-like planets where only gas drag should make them rare but his opinion is that they are too common for that to be the only mechanism in place. He suggests gravitational slingshots from other planets which happens to be the primary mechanism in the Nice model.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom