Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

As I have said I don't deny Einstein became mainstream. I just don't accept that that is how became successful.

Why can't Einstein using a more holistic approach than others of the time be considered non-mainstream?

Again, a revolutionary new chef isn't using food that others haven't. Like molecular gastronomy. But that doesn't mean it isn't outside the mainstream.

Because, no matter how much YOU want it to be so, Einstein was not doing anything outside of the purview of what you call mainstream.

And he did not do so because the scientific method, which you seem to abhor, is the method that actually delivers reproducible, testable, results.

If Einstein had never lived we still would work with the theories he discovered as many others were on the same path. He just was quickest.
 
Why not? Again, I recommend the book The Hunt for Vulcan: . . . And How Albert Einstein Destroyed a Planet, Discovered Relativity, and Deciphered the Universe assuming, of course, you want to actually learn the specifics of how Einstein's career progressed as opposed to propping up a convenient mythology about him.

If Einstein was such an "outsider" why did his Special Relativity paper early in his career earn him a University job, which in turn ensured he got plenty of attention, assistance, and review as he progressed towards General relativity? The mythology of Einstein as an outsider simply is not supportable if you take an even cursory look at his career.

Because at that time science wasn't big business like it is now. But the school system was still the same. Education has always been incredibly traditional and designed for the masses not geniuses who truly think outside of the box.

I also think physics was incredibly desperate for new ideas at the time because of stagnation. To me this Mills saga indicates we are reaching that point of desperation again finally. Starting to at least.
 
I also think physics was incredibly desperate for new ideas at the time because of stagnation. To me this Mills saga indicates we are reaching that point of desperation again finally. Starting to at least.

I'm curious; you've admitted you don't have the maths skills to judge physics arguments, yet you claim that you can see signs of desperation because of stagnation?

What exactly are you seeing?
 
Because at that time science wasn't big business like it is now. But the school system was still the same. Education has always been incredibly traditional and designed for the masses not geniuses who truly think outside of the box.



I also think physics was incredibly desperate for new ideas at the time because of stagnation. To me this Mills saga indicates we are reaching that point of desperation again finally. Starting to at least.


But physics was NOT stagnant at the time Einstein was working. Quite the opposite. Physicists were often frustrated by the delays in their testing caused by WWI, WWII and other political upheavals. A LOT was changing.

Please, check out the book I linked to. It's available as an audio book, dead tree and ebook. A firmer grounding in the history of the time period will help you make informed arguments.
 
I'm curious; you've admitted you don't have the maths skills to judge physics arguments, yet you claim that you can see signs of desperation because of stagnation?

What exactly are you seeing?

I don't think you need math skills to see that theoretical physicists are flailing around in the dark. Plus I witnessed high level scientist discuss these things and the scientists against the mainstream view weren't some crackpots and showed how many others think something is horribly wrong with theoretical physics.

Plus the fact we don't even know what makes up 90 percent of the known universe.. there's that. ;)
 
But physics was NOT stagnant at the time Einstein was working. Quite the opposite. Physicists were often frustrated by the delays in their testing caused by WWI, WWII and other political upheavals. A LOT was changing.

Please, check out the book I linked to. It's available as an audio book, dead tree and ebook. A firmer grounding in the history of the time period will help you make informed arguments.

I'll check it out when I can. Thanks. What makes this book more accurate than the info others are promoting about Einstein?
 
Plus the fact we don't even know what makes up 90 percent of the known universe.. there's that. ;)

Mainstream science discovered that. And mainstream science is investigating it. And mainstream science will probably be what solves the problem.
 
Mainstream science discovered that. And mainstream science is investigating it. And mainstream science will probably be what solves the problem.

And they discovered it relatively recently. There's been multiple implications that he thinks mainstream science is bad because it waits to develop an explanation rather than producing one via clairvoyance.
 
I'll check it out when I can. Thanks. What makes this book more accurate than the info others are promoting about Einstein?

To start it's a heavily researched book. While written for the mass market, it sticks to the verifiable facts. The author is an experienced science history writer who teaches the subject at MIT. The book itself has received praise for its accuracy, both in the science it describes and in the biographical data it presents.

Review: The Hunt for Vulcan

The Hunt for Vulcan by Thomas Levenson review - Newton, Einstein and the invisible planet


The same author also wrote Einstein in Berlin which focuses heavily upon one of the more critical periods in Einstein's career. While I haven't read that book myself, it also contains a good deal of heavily researched data on Einstein.

I recommend "The Hunt for Vulcan" not to try and overthrow your ideas or challenge your underlying beliefs, but to present you with data that is more accurate and more easily defended. The book tells the real-world story of an established theory, the belief in an entire planet, being overthrown by a subsequent theory. I would think that series of events would be of particular interest to someone who believed Mills is gearing up to cause a similar overthrow.
 
Split from this thread.
Posted By: jsfisher




Do you think cutting edge revolutionary science is done in the mainstream?

Look at Einstein.. was he mainstream? Who predicted Einstein would revolutionize theoretical physics? He was considered a failure from my understanding. This is a perfect example of how mainstream science is not cutting edge science.

You got it completely wrong! Einstein absolutely was a "mainstream" scientist and used "mainstream" science in his work. He was not an outsider. His proposals as to Relativity quickly gained serious interest, consideration, and exploration. As is true of all "mainstream" science, that does not mean that his theories went unchallenged: they were. A significant number of physicists began skeptical, but Einstein's theories were not simply discarded on that basis. They were tested. And every time a test result matched his predications, his theories gained more interest and more acceptance.

The idea that Einstein was a failure, or ignored, or laughed at, or had theories that did not originate from (and were extended by) accepted physics and math, is absolutely wrong. Sorry.
 
Last edited:
As I have said I don't deny Einstein became mainstream. I just don't accept that that is how became successful.

Why can't Einstein using a more holistic approach than others of the time be considered non-mainstream?
Again, a revolutionary new chef isn't using food that others haven't. Like molecular gastronomy. But that doesn't mean it isn't outside the mainstream.

Holistic? Perhaps you can explain how Einstein's approach was holistic? In many ways he simply explored the implications of what was already known. These implications were startlingly, but flowed out of very established physics.
 
Have you ever heard this quote from Einstein -

"I am well aware that I have no special talent; curiosity, obsession and stubborn endurance, combined with self-criticism have brought me to my ideas"

Those traits he talks about are autistic traits. Not exclusively of course. But people on the autism spectrum get obsessed with things. To a level that I don't think many people can. For good reason because it allows them to function in society properly. So this trait is a blessing and a curse for autistic people.

Also, it's not just an obsession about one thing.. but it's constant obsessions. I feel this is what allows people with autism disorders to do things others can't. But that's not the only reason i feel I have discovered the things I have. But explaining that is the problem.

Probably 98% of people with these traits are not within the autistic spectrum and it is silly to even bring this up. Much of Einstein's life indicates the opposite- he was a very socially adept person (even to the point of some unseemly enthusiasms in regard to sexual liaisons). I probably am autistic in many ways myself and I fully appreciate people who are even more so than I am, but there is no reason to bring this up here. Red herring.
 
As I have said I don't deny Einstein became mainstream. I just don't accept that that is how became successful.

Your lack of acceptance doesn't change that.

Why can't Einstein using a more holistic approach than others of the time be considered non-mainstream?

Because building on and utilizing the work of others, both previous and current, is mainstream science. Just look at the references in any scientific paper. Just getting published isn't enough you also need to be referenced in the published works of others. That's the mainstream of scientific success.

Again, a revolutionary new chef isn't using food that others haven't. Like molecular gastronomy. But that doesn't mean it isn't outside the mainstream.

Again using the same recipe, the scientific method, building on and utilizing the work of others, both previous and current, means it is that very mainstream menu.
 
I don't think you need math skills to see that theoretical physicists are flailing around in the dark. Plus I witnessed high level scientist discuss these things and the scientists against the mainstream view weren't some crackpots and showed how many others think something is horribly wrong with theoretical physics.[...]

I doubt you understood what they were discussing.
 
I don't think you need math skills to see that theoretical physicists are flailing around in the dark. Plus I witnessed high level scientist discuss these things and the scientists against the mainstream view weren't some crackpots and showed how many others think something is horribly wrong with theoretical physics.

Plus the fact we don't even know what makes up 90 percent of the known universe.. there's that. ;)

How do we know "we don't even know what makes up 90 percent of the known universe."?

I'll give you a hint, it starts with "mainstream".
 
Plus the fact we don't even know what makes up 90 percent of the known universe.. there's that. ;)

"Science knows it doesn't know everything; otherwise, it'd stop. But just because science doesn't know everything doesn't mean you can fill in the gaps with whatever fairy tale most appeals to you."

- Dara Ó Briain

And that is, in a nutshell, the mainstream view.

Dave
 
How do we know "we don't even know what makes up 90 percent of the known universe."?

I'll give you a hint, it starts with "mainstream".

We don't know. The entire model could be completely wrong and both the mainstream and Mills could be wrong.
 
I doubt you understood what they were discussing.

I didn't say I did understand it all. But I could see there was obviously a real debate there. And when you factor in the fact that mainstream science doesn't know what makes up 90% of the known universe it doesn't give much reason for faith in the mainstream view. And the fact that mainstream theoretical physics is incredibly stagnant and continues to not lead to any major new discoveries or confirmation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom