Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

That doesn't mean the current scientific method can't be improved. It's very naive to think perfection would be reached when science is so young.
And you are the one and only person who can say, with specificity, just how it should be improved (for avoidance of doubt, that's a question)?
 
Like what?

Something that can't be easily explained in a brief paper or even a book. Something that requires people to a lot of digging and research on their own and isn't easily spelled out. Something that requires going against common beliefs.

Rather an over-generalization, no?

How many times have you called your fellow skeptics on over-generalizations?

I've asked you this before, but don't recall getting a straight answer: in your view of the core aspects of science, what role does objectivity play? Independent verifiability?

Could you elaborate here?
 
I thought it was obvious that my view was that the system is corrupt and misguided. The scientific process isn't the problem.

I think you got this idea because others conflated skepticism with the scientific process. When I referred to skeptics it was the skeptics on messageboards etc. Not the concept of skepticism. I consider myself skeptical. I consider conspiracy theorists more skeptical than "skeptics" on these boards.

There is very little point to correcting your blanket, broad, and patently incorrect mis-statements, as has been done time after time here in this thread, only to have you reply- well I didn't mean that, I only meet this... Ultimately it often comes down to "Well I am only saying science is wrong... where it is wrong." Of course- who would even argue against that?

For example I could reply that the science is surprisingly incorrupt compared to most human endeavors, but then you would reply that you meant it was incorrupt where... it was incorrupt. Yes, of course there is corruption in science- it is performed by humans after all. But I think there is relatively little corruption in science compared to other areas of society, there are active efforts to reduce even this, and ultimately the self checking aspects of science counteract corruption. The real question for this thread is if the corruption that does exist is why your favorite ideas have not been accepted by "established" science. Sorry, corruption is not the barrier.

And it is you who have presented the "skeptics" on this board as representatives of the "problems" with the scientific "establishment." Don't now try to say that you are a great fan of the scientific establishment and only are disturbed by the skeptics here. That is clearly not what you have been arguing for multiple pages.
 
Last edited:
I think the biggest issue now is corruption. How can that be stopped? I think it can be stopped by people like skeptics groups learning to realize when they have been manipulated.
May I ask, have you ever been manipulated? How did you conclude that it had happened? What did you do to avoid it happening again?

More than anything else, though, what has this got to do with science?
 
That's not the point though.. the point is it can be improved. How has it improved over time?
Better understanding of experimental "errors", more robust grasp of what "statistics" is, greater attention to mathematical foundations, recognition of the need for objectivity, peer-review, ... it's a pretty long list ... :)
 
I was referring to the skeptics on this board not in their entirety... I consider myself skeptical. I don't think the scientific process is at fault. It's how it is being implemented and a kind of paranoia rampant within. I think there is a reason for this paranoia.
And yet, for all your hundreds of posts, remarkably few seem to contain any meat!

Lots of vague generalities, essentially meaningless one-liners, but nothing concrete or specific ... and certainly nothing actionable ... but maybe I missed some?
 
That's not the point though.. the point is it can be improved. How has it improved over time?


What are your credentials for making recommendations to improve the discipline of science? I don't see any.

The fact the you have to ask how science has improved over time tells me you know absolutely nothing about it.
 
I thought it was obvious that my view was that the system is corrupt and misguided. The scientific process isn't the problem.

I think you got this idea because others conflated skepticism with the scientific process. When I referred to skeptics it was the skeptics on messageboards etc. Not the concept of skepticism. I consider myself skeptical. I consider conspiracy theorists more skeptical than "skeptics" on these boards.
Good to see that you are, after how many hundred posts? making this clear!
 
That just happens to maybe be the biggest mystery in science - how gravity works.
That is not how science works. There is no ultimate truth saying how anything works. There is a process of refining our understanding of how things work. At each step there is no overall mystery - just puzzling aspects.
There was 400 years of gravity is an inverse square force between masses (Newtonian gravity). The theory matched observations. Then we noticed that the orbit of Mercury was not matched by the theory.
Since 1915 gravity has been a consequence of the curvature of spacetime. Many more observations are matched by the theory. Scientists are trying to break GR by looking at more extreme observations in the expectation that this will give insights into a quantum theory of gravity.
 
That model hasn't been shown to be false as our gravity model has.
:jaw-dropp :jaw-dropp

Wow! I mean, just wow!

ST, by your own admission, in the other thread, you do not understand GR, nor most of astrophysics (yes, I'm extending what you actually said; if you do, in fact, think that you understand GR, the spectroscopy that astronomers use, how the Hubble Space Telescope works, etc, etc, by all means please say so!).

Yet here you are, proclaiming as if you're a leading expert, that you know all about the IMF, stellar evolution models, and vast amounts of extra-galactic astronomy and astrophysics besides!!

But fine, I'll bite: please compare and contrast the experimental and observational evidence which GR is consistent with (and that which it is not) vs the theoretical models of the stellar composition of galaxies beyond the Local Group.
 
What did I misconstrue?

<snip>
Really?!?

"I love how skeptics are experts on everything ... "

ALL skeptics? On EVERYTHING? Or one ISF member, re one narrow topic, (shall I go on?)

And, FWIW, you make it extraordinarily easy for people to misunderstand (and so possibly misconstrue) what you write. May I suggest greater clarity, a lot more specificity, and concentrating on trying to convey your key points in a way your intended audience (ISF members reading your posts) will fully appreciate?
 
Science isn't supposed to work that way. That is why it is corrupted.

When i say science I am talking about the scientific community. Scientific institutions.
Does that include Mills? The authors of vixra papers? Big pharma research labs? Research hospitals, including cancer centers? The Plank consortium? The Gaia consortium? The extended LIGO team?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom