Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

This doesn't make sense though because everyone is arguing from ignorance on some level
If someone displays ignorance of a topic such as dark energy then they are ignorant of the topic :eye-poppi.
If someone continues to display ignorance of a topic after being directed to a source on that topic then the options are bad:
  • Not able to click on a link that includes what they asked for, e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_energy
  • Cannot understand the contents of the source.
    An honest person would then acknowledge that and ask a follow-up question.
  • Is in total denial and so ignore or deny the information.
  • Or are trolling by asking questions and ignoring the replies.
 
If someone displays ignorance of a topic such as dark energy then they are ignorant of the topic :eye-poppi.
If someone continues to display ignorance of a topic after being directed to a source on that topic then the options are bad:
  • Not able to click on a link that includes what they asked for, e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_energy
  • Cannot understand the contents of the source.
    An honest person would then acknowledge that and ask a follow-up question.
  • Is in total denial and so ignore or deny the information.
  • Or are trolling by asking questions and ignoring the replies.

I think you are suffering from Dunning-Kruger here. You aren't aware of what my argument is. I was asking questions anyway.. and somehow that turned into me making claims.
 
I guess I will try once more, although getting quite boring.

No assumptions, no authority fallacies, no assertions without evidence.


Barring that you will simply be criticized for making bad posts. Me too. If I do it I will be criticised too. Everyone here is subject to this dynamic.


This is one massive strawman because I haven't made any claims.. I have mainly asked questions related to how I perceive things.
 
What purpose does it serve to nitpick and attack any perceived minute error in a conversation other than to derail it?
The purpose is to document a case of
  • moving the goalposts or ignorance of what you have posted over the last couple of days (no Solvay conference).
  • trying to actually detail a thread that is not about the Solvay conference.
  • indulging in hyperbole.
    Stating facts is not an attack.
    1. You did not mention the conference before that post.
    2. There are many Solvay conferences.
 
The purpose is to document a case of
  • moving the goalposts or ignorance of what you have posted over the last couple of days (no Solvay conference).
  • trying to actually detail a thread that is not about the Solvay conference.
  • indulging in hyperbole.
    Stating facts is not an attack.
    1. You did not mention the conference before that post.
    2. There are many Solvay conferences.

Your comments are too vague.. you seem to be preaching to the choir. As usual.

You are taking my comments too literally. That's a lawyerly argument. When I said "I was talking about" I meant I was thinking about. It wasn't moving the goal post. It was simply making my argument more clear. Again, these actions are similar to that of someone with NPD - a controlling personality disorder. Paranoia is one of the key components.
 
Last edited:
I think you are suffering from Dunning-Kruger here. You aren't aware of what my argument is. I was asking questions anyway.. and somehow that turned into me making claims.

What do you call it when the very claim that someone is suffering from Dunning-Kruger is itself an instance of Dunning-Kruger about what Dunning and Kruger actually demonstrated? Douglas Hofstadter would make hay with that concept.
 
What purpose does it serve to nitpick and attack any perceived minute error in a conversation other than to derail it?
One view of science is that it is systematic pedantry.

"Nitpicking"? "Perceived minute error"? To some extent, that's like beauty isn't it, in the eye of the beholder?

To me, like so many of your posts (as has been noted by several others), this has an "all or nothing" character, an apparent attempt to wildly generalize and even misconstrue ...
 
Considering every past era was shown to be completely in the dark we should assume the same about this era...
Only correct for someone "completely in the dark" about the history of science, SkepticalTheorist :jaw-dropp!
If we look at the documented history of science from the Babylonians onward we see eras of glimmers of light growing until we have the explosion of light that is the modern scientific era.
 
What do you call it when the very claim that someone is suffering from Dunning-Kruger is itself an instance of Dunning-Kruger about what Dunning and Kruger actually demonstrated? Douglas Hofstadter would make hay with that concept.

You think you and others here don't suffer from Dunning-Kruger... I see skeptics here are experts at everything.. including skepticism and they probably have that completely wrong.


I have stated I am not an expert..does that sound like someone with Dunning Kruger?

I have studied Mills work and related information for almost a decade - full time. Yet people here assume they know more than me and most haven't researched Mills at all.. so again who is more likely to be displaying D-K?

Who told me to shut up?
 
Have you learned anything from anyone you deem to be "not a skeptic"?
Begging the question somewhat?

Myself, I do not deem other ISF members "skeptic", "not a skeptic", or anything in between.

However, I have certainly learned a lot from many of those who have proposed or defended non-mainstream ideas, here in the SMMT section.
 
One view of science is that it is systematic pedantry.

"Nitpicking"? "Perceived minute error"? To some extent, that's like beauty isn't it, in the eye of the beholder?

To me, like so many of your posts (as has been noted by several others), this has an "all or nothing" character, an apparent attempt to wildly generalize and even misconstrue ...

That doesn't mean criticism can't be excessive and misapplied.
 
This is one massive strawman because I haven't made any claims.. I have mainly asked questions related to how I perceive things.
(my bold)

Exaggerate somewhat?

For example, from post #24 of this thread, "the problem is that the scientific literate are brainwashed". Is that a claim, or not?
 
(my bold)

Exaggerate somewhat?

For example, from post #24 of this thread, "the problem is that the scientific literate are brainwashed". Is that a claim, or not?

It's an opinion. You could be lawerly and ignore that it is an opinion and nitpick it to death because of the wording. But then you turn a discussion into a hellish court debate.
 
You think you and others here don't suffer from Dunning-Kruger... I see skeptics here are experts at everything.. including skepticism and they probably have that completely wrong.
You clearly don't understand what Dunning and Kruger demonstrated. Individuals here have genuine expertise in few subjects each, and together have expertise in a wide range of subjects. That's just a fact

I have stated I am not an expert..does that sound like someone with Dunning Kruger?
it's not what you say about yourself but the evidence of your posts
I have studied Mills work and related information for almost a decade - full time. Yet people here assume they know more than me and most haven't researched Mills at all.. so again who is more likely to be displaying D-K?
And yet your posts are entirely content free regarding Mills and every other topic under the sun. In your 7,539 posts you have said zero, zilch, nothing. On the evidence of this thread, I know infinitely more about Mills history and his claims including the mighty tome than you do.
 
Last edited:
And yet your posts are entirely content free regarding Mills and every other topic under the sun. In your 7,539 posts you have said zero, zilch, nothing. On the evidence of this thread, I know infinitely more about Mills history and his claims including the mighty tome than you do.

Content free according to whom Mr. D-K?

On the evidence of this thread, I know infinitely more about Mills history and his claims including the mighty tome than you do.

You have been suckered into the Outlook maze and don't even know you have D-Ked yourself.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom