I am confused, that paper does not say that Neptune size planets can't form. And they then have an explanation for the distribution of planets in our system. Which is different from other systems.
I don't see the relevance. Tweaking a model or modifying a model is not refuting a model.
They don't say it, you have to read between the lines.
They say that pebble accretion explains the dichotomy between Earth sized objects and the large cores of the "gas and ice giants".
They never mention that a well known issue of planet formation is how to clump the pebbles together into 1 km sized objects.
Straight from wikipedia:
The formation of planetesimals is the biggest unsolved problem in the nebular disk model. How 1 cm sized particles coalesce into 1 km planetesimals is a mystery.
So in essence this paper shows that not only can they not form Neptune sized objects, but that they can't form anything at all. This paper is literally all fluff.
The dogma went off into pebble accretion theory without addressing the fact that they can't even clump pebbles together. This is what they are doing now, they are solving mysteries with miracles.
The explanation in stellar metamorphosis is easy. The star is the location for accretion. It collects material and deposits it in the center, and while the star evolves it differentiates the core regions and loses mass at a faster rate than it accretes material. Eventually the thick atmosphere dissipates and exposes the newly formed "planet". Depending on the rate of mass loss in reference to hotter hosts and a list of other reasons will determine the eventual size of the rocky body in the center that is formed. I have outlined that in the new TRAPPIST-1 paper here:
http://vixra.org/pdf/1706.0365v1.pdf
Different stages of this process are observed in the solar system, as well as the thousands of exoplanets observed in the sky. They are all evolving stars. It also solves the mystery of planet formation, the planet formation process happens INSIDE a star. They are all giant planet ovens, which form the layered pearl in their centers like oysters over many billions of years. You are literally standing on the pearl of an ancient dead star. (still hot internally as well, as even after 4.5 billion years there is still lots of heat left over from earlier stages of evolution, the crust formation trapped the magma).
Neptune sized objects are easily explained, as well as the difference in masses between the objects, as well as how to clump 1 cm sized particles into 1 km sized objects all the way to something the size of the Earth.
Not only that, but a more advanced way to explain how the Moon formed and what it is has become available. It is a more advanced capture theory in light of GTSM.
http://vixra.org/pdf/1706.0398v1.pdf
Anyways, I have a lot more work to do developing this superior replacement paradigm to the outdated solar evolution/planet formation models and other theories. It will take lots of work, but I think I can do it.