The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis

Here is a paper called, "Neptune is a Star"

http://vixra.org/abs/1706.0002

Here is a paper called, "Uranus is a Star"

http://vixra.org/pdf/1706.0194v1.pdf

Creating different sized Earths in Stellar Metamorphosis, the TRAPPIST-1 System

http://vixra.org/pdf/1706.0365v1.pdf

The black box is where the TRAPPIST-1 objects are located. Some can be much older than others. They did not all form around the red dwarf they currently orbit, that is clearly a much younger star according to stellar metamorphosis.

No.

The True Theory is that all Planets are formed from Pea Soup.

You have an unproved and poorly written hypothesis.
 
I am confused, that paper does not say that Neptune size planets can't form. And they then have an explanation for the distribution of planets in our system. Which is different from other systems.

I don't see the relevance. Tweaking a model or modifying a model is not refuting a model.

They don't say it, you have to read between the lines.

They say that pebble accretion explains the dichotomy between Earth sized objects and the large cores of the "gas and ice giants".

They never mention that a well known issue of planet formation is how to clump the pebbles together into 1 km sized objects.

Straight from wikipedia:

The formation of planetesimals is the biggest unsolved problem in the nebular disk model. How 1 cm sized particles coalesce into 1 km planetesimals is a mystery.

So in essence this paper shows that not only can they not form Neptune sized objects, but that they can't form anything at all. This paper is literally all fluff.

The dogma went off into pebble accretion theory without addressing the fact that they can't even clump pebbles together. This is what they are doing now, they are solving mysteries with miracles.

The explanation in stellar metamorphosis is easy. The star is the location for accretion. It collects material and deposits it in the center, and while the star evolves it differentiates the core regions and loses mass at a faster rate than it accretes material. Eventually the thick atmosphere dissipates and exposes the newly formed "planet". Depending on the rate of mass loss in reference to hotter hosts and a list of other reasons will determine the eventual size of the rocky body in the center that is formed. I have outlined that in the new TRAPPIST-1 paper here:

http://vixra.org/pdf/1706.0365v1.pdf

Different stages of this process are observed in the solar system, as well as the thousands of exoplanets observed in the sky. They are all evolving stars. It also solves the mystery of planet formation, the planet formation process happens INSIDE a star. They are all giant planet ovens, which form the layered pearl in their centers like oysters over many billions of years. You are literally standing on the pearl of an ancient dead star. (still hot internally as well, as even after 4.5 billion years there is still lots of heat left over from earlier stages of evolution, the crust formation trapped the magma).

Neptune sized objects are easily explained, as well as the difference in masses between the objects, as well as how to clump 1 cm sized particles into 1 km sized objects all the way to something the size of the Earth.

Not only that, but a more advanced way to explain how the Moon formed and what it is has become available. It is a more advanced capture theory in light of GTSM.

http://vixra.org/pdf/1706.0398v1.pdf

Anyways, I have a lot more work to do developing this superior replacement paradigm to the outdated solar evolution/planet formation models and other theories. It will take lots of work, but I think I can do it.
 
They don't say it, you have to read between the lines.

They say that pebble accretion explains the dichotomy between Earth sized objects and the large cores of the "gas and ice giants".

They never mention that a well known issue of planet formation is how to clump the pebbles together into 1 km sized objects.

Straight from wikipedia:

The formation of planetesimals is the biggest unsolved problem in the nebular disk model. How 1 cm sized particles coalesce into 1 km planetesimals is a mystery.

So in essence this paper shows that not only can they not form Neptune sized objects, but that they can't form anything at all. This paper is literally all fluff.

The dogma went off into pebble accretion theory without addressing the fact that they can't even clump pebbles together. This is what they are doing now, they are solving mysteries with miracles.


Neptune sized objects are easily explained, as well as the difference in masses between the objects, as well as how to clump 1 cm sized particles into 1 km sized objects all the way to something the size of the Earth.

You know what "mystery" means. I'm not sure you do. What it does not mean is a process can't happen as you've stated. Do you have any experimental evidence whatsoever pebbles can't clump? Absolutely you do not. Your beliefs are the stuff of fluff.
 
They don't say it, you have to read between the lines.
You mean make stuff up? I am confused.
They say that pebble accretion explains the dichotomy between Earth sized objects and the large cores of the "gas and ice giants".

They never mention that a well known issue of planet formation is how to clump the pebbles together into 1 km sized objects.

Straight from wikipedia:

The formation of planetesimals is the biggest unsolved problem in the nebular disk model. How 1 cm sized particles coalesce into 1 km planetesimals is a mystery.
I don't think the word mystery means 'can't', now does it?
So in essence this paper shows that not only can they not form Neptune sized objects, but that they can't form anything at all. This paper is literally all fluff.
Wheer did it say that?
The dogma went off into pebble accretion theory without addressing the fact that they can't even clump pebbles together. This is what they are doing now, they are solving mysteries with miracles.
And you are engaging is speculation and hyperbole, unknown does not equal can't.
 
It's pseudoscience 101; anything science hasn't completely explained yet is therefore impossible. Pseudoscience 102, of course, is that anything science has completely explained is not actually properly explained, but there's a worldwide conspiracy of scientists covering up that fact.

Dave
 
That's what confuses me about this forum. The ideas I present are not only mine. Two other people before me have drawn this understanding up before I did.

Alexander Oparin:

http://www.valencia.edu/orilife/textos/The%20Origin%20of%20Life.pdf

Anthony Abruzzo:

http://gsjournal.net/Science-Journals/Research%20Papers-Astrophysics/Download/1160

Jeffrey, we already addressed the Oparin paper; it contradicts your ideas, not to mention that he was a biologist and wrote the paper in 1924. You're ignoring close to 100 years of progress using instruments unimagined back then.

RC soundly refuted the second paper; I'll just note that the publisher, Open Science Journal, looks to me like a vanity publisher. They claim "fast publishing" and thorough peer review, which tend to be mutually exclusive. I suspect the most important criterion for acceptance of a paper is a willingness to fork over 200 bucks. RC if you can give me a resource for good science journal rankings, I'll dig deeper.
 
jeffreyw: Cannot understand that a "Solar System" paper is about the Solar System

They say that pebble accretion explains the dichotomy between Earth sized objects and the large cores of the "gas and ice giants".
The great dichotomy of the Solar System: small terrestrial embryos and massive giant planet cores is about the Solar System :jaw-dropp.
21 June 2017 jeffreyw: Cannot understand that a "The great dichotomy of the Solar System" paper is about the Solar System.

If we find another system with the same dichotomy then the solution in this paper may apply.

The great dichotomy of the Solar System: small terrestrial embryos and massive giant planet cores
The basic structure of the solar system is set by the presence of low-mass terrestrial planets in its inner part and giant planets in its outer part. This is the result of the formation of a system of multiple embryos with approximately the mass of Mars in the inner disk and of a few multi-Earth-mass cores in the outer disk, within the lifetime of the gaseous component of the protoplanetary disk. What was the origin of this dichotomy in the mass distribution of embryos/cores? We show in this paper that the classic processes of runaway and oligarchic growth from a disk of planetesimals cannot explain this dichotomy, even if the original surface density of solids increased at the snowline. Instead, the accretion of drifting pebbles by embryos and cores can explain the dichotomy, provided that some assumptions hold true. We propose that the mass-flow of pebbles is two-times lower and the characteristic size of the pebbles is approximately ten times smaller within the snowline than beyond the snowline (respectively at heliocentric distance r<r ice and r>r ice , where r ice is the snowline heliocentric distance), due to ice sublimation and the splitting of icy pebbles into a collection of chondrule-size silicate grains. In this case, objects of original sub-lunar mass would grow at drastically different rates in the two regions of the disk. Within the snowline these bodies would reach approximately the mass of Mars while beyond the snowline they would grow to ∼20 Earth masses. The results may change quantitatively with changes to the assumed parameters, but the establishment of a clear dichotomy in the mass distribution of protoplanets appears robust, provided that there is enough turbulence in the disk to prevent the sedimentation of the silicate grains into a very thin layer.
 
jeffreyw: 2 lies about the great dichotomy of the Solar System paper

So in essence this paper shows that not only can they not form Neptune sized objects, but that they can't form anything at all.
21 June 2017 jeffreyw: 2 lies about the great dichotomy of the Solar System paper
The paper is not about the formation of planetesimals.
The paper solves the problem it addresses - the size of "Neptune sized objects" (gas giants) and Earth sized objects.
 
jeffreyw: Quote mining Wikipedia's article on the nebula hypothesis

Straight from wikipedia:

The formation of planetesimals is the biggest unsolved problem in the nebular disk model. How 1 cm sized particles coalesce into 1 km planetesimals is a mystery.
21 June 2017 jeffreyw: Quote mining Wikipedia's article on the nebula hypothesis.
Nebular hypothesis
The formation of planetesimals is the biggest unsolved problem in the nebular disk model. How 1 cm sized particles coalesce into 1 km planetesimals is a mystery. This mechanism appears to be the key to the question as to why some stars have planets, while others have nothing around them, not even dust belts.[23]
The citation is Planetesimal Formation by Gravitational Instability which in 2002 described a mechanism by which planetesimals can form :eek:.
The paper has been cited at least 147 times and judging by the titles the mystery is more what are the conditions for planetesimals to form given that the mechanism is fairly well established, e.g. gravitational instabilities + gas drag.

In his deluded world, every star should have a random assortment of planets. This (as in the sentence he does not quote) is not the real world or even the Solar System!
 
Last edited:
RC if you can give me a resource for good science journal rankings, I'll dig deeper.
I usually look for the impact factor of a journal.
But given the obviously bad nature of the paper, General Science Journal is dubious. This is confirmed by the current "papers" looking like a list of cranks. There are only single authors, multiple submissions by an author, anti special relativity, gibberish about Hubble's law, etc. No sign of any review - editor or peer! It is basically a forum with PDF uploads.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: His delusions and lies are now applied to the Moon

Not only that, but a more advanced way to explain how the Moon formed and what it is has become available.
21 June 2017 jeffreyw: His delusions and lies are now applied to the Moon!

The 1 page PDF starts "Abstract: The moon is a dead star vastly older than the Earth. Explanation is provided"
The age of the Moon has been measured, e.g. by dating Moon rocks, and is about 4.51 billion years. The age of the Earth is 4.54 billion years. The Moon is younger than the Earth :jaw-dropp!

The lies include "the Earth about 10 billion years old, and the Moon about 22+ billion years old" (see above). The latter lie exposes abysmal ignorance- the age of the universe is 13.8 billion years :eye-poppi!
21 June 2017 jeffreyw: Abysmal ignorance - the age of the universe is 13.8 billion years so nothing is older than 13.8 billion years.
It took 380,000 years for the universe to cool down enough for H and He and Li (not any heavier) atoms to form. Three or 4 hundred million years for the first galaxies to form. Some more hundred million years for enough stars and supernova to form heavier element, e.g. the silicon and iron which are a large part of bodies like the Earth and Moon. Thus no planets or moons existed before about 12.7 billion years ago.

A delusion of "Earth’s gravity was also much, much stronger".
A delusion of "Earth’s radioactive material being spilled onto the Moon".
 
Jeffrey, we already addressed the Oparin paper; it contradicts your ideas, not to mention that he was a biologist and wrote the paper in 1924. You're ignoring close to 100 years of progress using instruments unimagined back then.

RC soundly refuted the second paper; I'll just note that the publisher, Open Science Journal, looks to me like a vanity publisher. They claim "fast publishing" and thorough peer review, which tend to be mutually exclusive. I suspect the most important criterion for acceptance of a paper is a willingness to fork over 200 bucks. RC if you can give me a resource for good science journal rankings, I'll dig deeper.

Interesting. If it contradicts my ideas then only Anthony and I get priority for the discovery that stellar evolution is planet formation.

It was strange though, I had expected people to read Oparin's paper when he mentions that stars become planets. I guess they just want to spout of stuff without researching what I'm saying. Its all good. It really doesn't matter what Oparin said anyways, I've been developing the theory well beyond his original couple of sentences.

That's what you people do not understand. It already is the replacement paradigm to both big bang and nebular hypothesis (and all their variants). You can keep the outdated paradigm that was invented before a complete statistical analysis of other star systems was made, I don't mind. I just think people should know its old news, like the phlogiston theory of heat.

For those who are new to this thread the theories main postulate which the ridiculers fail to mention is that:

1. The old, outdated paradigm has "planets" as by-products of star formation.

2. The new, updated paradigm has "planets" as by-products of star evolution.


It is very, very easy to understand. More people are starting to see the change, I'm guessing over the next 10 years I will receive much more correspondence to the theory that is in favor of this. So far I have only received a few words of encouragement from outsiders who understand basic physics and chemistry. I expect to keep this thread alive long enough to see the progression of these facts, in light of the ridiculers who are on this forum.
 
Last edited:
Interesting. If it contradicts my ideas then only Anthony and I get priority for the discovery that stellar evolution is planet formation.

It was strange though, I had expected people to read Oparin's paper when he mentions that stars become planets. I guess they just want to spout of stuff without researching what I'm saying. Its all good. It really doesn't matter what Oparin said anyways, I've been developing the theory well beyond his original couple of sentences.

That's what you people do not understand. It already is the replacement paradigm to both big bang and nebular hypothesis (and all their variants). You can keep the outdated paradigm that was invented before a complete statistical analysis of other star systems was made, I don't mind. I just think people should know its old news, like the phlogiston theory of heat.

For those who are new to this thread the theories main postulate which the ridiculers fail to mention is that:

1. The old, outdated paradigm has "planets" as by-products of star formation.

2. The new, updated paradigm has "planets" as by-products of star evolution.


It is very, very easy to understand. More people are starting to see the change, I'm guessing over the next 10 years I will receive much more correspondence to the theory that is in favor of this. So far I have only received a few words of encouragement from outsiders who understand basic physics and chemistry. I expect to keep this thread alive long enough to see the progression of these facts, in light of the ridiculers who are on this forum.

No.

Planets are formed from congealed cooled pea soup.
 
No.

Planets are formed from congealed cooled pea soup.
Wow. That theory has every bit as much evidence backing it up as the OP! Now you need to do youtube videos for peer review. Who is more a peer than yourself?
 
I usually look for the impact factor of a journal.
But given the obviously bad nature of the paper, General Science Journal is dubious. This is confirmed by the current "papers" looking like a list of cranks. There are only single authors, multiple submissions by an author, anti special relativity, gibberish about Hubble's law, etc. No sign of any review - editor or peer! It is basically a forum with PDF uploads.

Good enough, thanks!
 
Last edited:
Wow. That theory has every bit as much evidence backing it up as the OP! Now you need to do youtube videos for peer review. Who is more a peer than yourself?

I'm unsure on videos. But it's been tempting.

However! You can easily do this yourself! Get a can (or a few cans) of pea soup, and cook them on your stove at the highest setting for several hours.

At first, you'll notice that your soup is bubbly, and hot This is a primordial planet. Turn down the heat. As time passes, you'll see that a 'skin' forms on your soup. This is the new planetary crust. The goopy hot goodness will be sealed in! Turn off the stove. Let sit for a few days. The soup will congeal on the pan, and start to grow fuzz! You have a living 'planet'!

Of course, this is all as a small scale, but it PROVES that planets are formed by pea soup!
 
I'm unsure on videos. But it's been tempting.

However! You can easily do this yourself! Get a can (or a few cans) of pea soup, and cook them on your stove at the highest setting for several hours.

At first, you'll notice that your soup is bubbly, and hot This is a primordial planet. Turn down the heat. As time passes, you'll see that a 'skin' forms on your soup. This is the new planetary crust. The goopy hot goodness will be sealed in! Turn off the stove. Let sit for a few days. The soup will congeal on the pan, and start to grow fuzz! You have a living 'planet'!

Of course, this is all as a small scale, but it PROVES that planets are formed by pea soup!
No need for videos now, you peer reviewed yourself beyond all doubt.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom