The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
I can guess who drew up that diagram with the wrong information. Speaking of incorrect photoshopped creations. who can forget Knox's shoeprint being found on the paper in Filomena's room? :D

Can I be forgiven for getting some satisfaction (ok....a good laugh) when Vixen provides the links that actually disprove her own claims?

Considering her snarky, holier than thou attitude, to have so much wrong in one post is worthy of a good chuckle. I felt like saying OK, I've read the testimony and it proves you were wrong... now what? She's the gift that keeps giving.
 
Considering her snarky, holier than thou attitude, to have so much wrong in one post is worthy of a good chuckle. I felt like saying OK, I've read the testimony and it proves you were wrong... now what? She's the gift that keeps giving.

Don't expect an admission that she was wrong and Sollecito's fingerprints were not on the inside of the bedroom door. I wonder if President Peña Nieto and the Boy Scouts called her to tell her how right she was.:D
 
How hard can it be to provide a quote? Until you do your point remains an assertion.

The quote is:

"There is a low possibility (less than 5%) that a DNA profile will be observed 24 h after the contact that led to the transfer." (p.78)

Ergon comments:

"From the DNA report Stefanoni did not test the exterior door handle. I think her reasons would be fairly obvious. Knowing that others had tried to open the door just prior to breaking the door down, any sample gotten from the door handle would have been necessarily mixed (and probably hopelessly mixed with several or more possible DNA profiles).

Dr. Stefanoni took samples of the interior door handle because it had traces of Meredith’s blood and because it would be a relatively “uncontaminated” surface (the interior door handle could have been used by the murderer- hence blood trace- and possibly not be mixed with other DNA, other than Meredith’s).

From the fingerprint report, it looks like the door was powdered, but tough to tell if the handle was powdered as well. If it wasn’t powdered, the same reasoning might have applied- knowledge that others had tried the door handle would have made it an unlikely site for undisturbed fingerprints.

Gill’s claim is silly. There is no way tertiary transfer happened via latex gloves, dirty or not. The likelihood of Sollecito’s DNA transferring from handle to glove, and then from glove to bra clasp at some later time, with nothing else being contaminated with Sollecito’s DNA in between, is just dumb."

and

"Note % of alleles and peak height RFU transferred under light and heavy pressure to gloves then ask why Gill thinks Sollecito's very strong sample is a likely example of "cross transfer" is more relevant to the argument.

He also calls the sample "Trace DNA" (1.2, p.1) "Trace-DNA samples may be defined as any sample which falls below recommended threshholds at any stage of the analysis". RS strong sample does NOT fall below any recommended thresholds so the tertiary transfer argument falls flat.

All clear now?
 
Since when is calling someone an astrologer an ad hominem?

For the umpteenth time, provide a cite to a forensic-DNA expert which confirms Stefanoni's work.

Dr Stefanoni is an employee of the Rome Scientific Police (forensics). She is not an academic putting out research papers for peer review.

Her objective scientific biological findings were accepted by the courts, and the panel of 'judges' making up the jury confirmed BARD the pair were guilty as charged after having seen and heard all of the evidence put before them.

Marasca-Bruno of the Supreme Court invented a reason for an annulment based on Peter Gill's lies about tertiary transfer, and assistance in helping the defence pervert justice without ever taking the witness stand and being cross-exaimed by all parties, - unlike Stefanoni - and threw out the knife and bra clasp evidence only, despite the data being perfectly scientifically sound.

There is zero doubt the trial courts came to the correct verdict, based on the evidence. Only a simpleton can fail to understand why the pair lied so many times and have no alibi.
 
Last edited:
Whether Gill said this or not is irrelevant as evidence has been posted that DNA transfer is detectable beyond 24 hours. Logically there is no reason for a time limit on transfer. If DNA is detectably present it is transferrable (by definition as it has to transfer from the site on to the swab to be detectable).

ETA let us consider transfer as proposed by Vixen
Transfer 1 DNA from Kercher on Knox
Transfer 2 (secondary) DNA of Kercher from Knox's hands on to basin (along with Knox's DNA a primary transfer).
Transfer 3 (tertiary) DNA of Kercher from the basin onto the swab (along with Knox's DNA a secondary transfer).

If we consider the Luminol positive prints that were DNA positive.

Transfer 1 Kercher's DNA onto floor.
Transfer 2 Kerchers DNA from floor onto Knox's feet
Transfer 3 Kercher's DNA from from Knox's feet to floor
Transfer 4 Kercher's DNA from floor (some six weeks after the murder) to swab.

Now if we are to believe Vixen a quaternary transfer of DNA six weeks later is impossible so we can only conclude that the forensic police must have made up the results.


Thank goodness sophistry is not an acceptable form of argument in a law court.
 
The quote is:



Ergon comments:

"From the DNA report Stefanoni did not test the exterior door handle. I think her reasons would be fairly obvious. Knowing that others had tried to open the door just prior to breaking the door down, any sample gotten from the door handle would have been necessarily mixed (and probably hopelessly mixed with several or more possible DNA profiles).

Dr. Stefanoni took samples of the interior door handle because it had traces of Meredith’s blood and because it would be a relatively “uncontaminated” surface (the interior door handle could have been used by the murderer- hence blood trace- and possibly not be mixed with other DNA, other than Meredith’s).

From the fingerprint report, it looks like the door was powdered, but tough to tell if the handle was powdered as well. If it wasn’t powdered, the same reasoning might have applied- knowledge that others had tried the door handle would have made it an unlikely site for undisturbed fingerprints.

Gill’s claim is silly. There is no way tertiary transfer happened via latex gloves, dirty or not. The likelihood of Sollecito’s DNA transferring from handle to glove, and then from glove to bra clasp at some later time, with nothing else being contaminated with Sollecito’s DNA in between, is just dumb."

and

"Note % of alleles and peak height RFU transferred under light and heavy pressure to gloves then ask why Gill thinks Sollecito's very strong sample is a likely example of "cross transfer" is more relevant to the argument.

He also calls the sample "Trace DNA" (1.2, p.1) "Trace-DNA samples may be defined as any sample which falls below recommended threshholds at any stage of the analysis". RS strong sample does NOT fall below any recommended thresholds so the tertiary transfer argument falls flat.
All clear now?

Unfortunately this Ergon obviously does not understand of which he/she is writing.

Trace DNA is DNA that is not associated with a source. So the DNA from blood stains or semen is not trace. DNA from the bra hook is trace because there is no knowing if the source is blood, saliva, touch etc. Trace DNA may or mayn't be LCN but they are entirely unrelated concepts.

Steffanoni herself says that the quantity of DNA attributable to Sollecito cannot be known because it is part of a mix of DNA. But this Ergon obviously knows more than Steffanoni. Steffanoni points out the dominant contributor was the victim - Kercher, but Ergon obviously knows better. Steffanoni says that the ratio of Kercher's DNA to Sollecito's DNA is about 6:1, but Ergon being an expert knows better. So according to Steffanoni who did the testing 1/7 of the total DNA was attributable to Sollecito, Steffanoni said that the total DNA of the mix was about 1ng (1000pg) so Sollecito's contribution is less than 200pg (within the definition of LCN DNA) but Ergon can just assert this is not true, because Ergon just knows the answer without having to show the working.

The thing is for any lurkers you do not have to believe me. The electropherograms are on line you can measure the peak height of Kercher's DNA and Sollecito's DNA yourself. You can see that Sollecito is a minor contributor. You can do the simple maths yourself.
 
Dr Stefanoni is an employee of the Rome Scientific Police (forensics). She is not an academic putting out research papers for peer review.

Her objective scientific biological findings were accepted by the courts, and the panel of 'judges' making up the jury confirmed BARD the pair were guilty as charged after having seen and heard all of the evidence put before them.

Marasca-Bruno of the Supreme Court invented a reason for an annulment based on Peter Gill's lies about tertiary transfer, and assistance in helping the defence pervert justice without ever taking the witness stand and being cross-exaimed by all parties, - unlike Stefanoni - and threw out the knife and bra clasp evidence only, despite the data being perfectly scientifically sound.

There is zero doubt the trial courts came to the correct verdict, based on the evidence. Only a simpleton can fail to understand why the pair lied so many times and have no alibi.

The numerous falsehoods told by Vixen have been pointed out by myself and others and Vixen has the cheek to attack people for lying. PGP are completely shameless in their hypocrisy.
 
Since Raffaele never had any reason to step foot in Meredith's room in the one or two times he visited the cottage, and since he never admitted to ever doing so, and since his fingerprints were found on the inside of her door after the murder, I have no choice but to become a 100% born again guilter. It is now me and Vixen vs the world.

My only regret is that the prosecution did not make this damning evidence the front centerpiece of their case, and instead went with blood negative DNA negative blurry stains, and tales of floating turds. He got away with it :mad:

Heheh. Before you and I go riding off together Marlon Brando-style on a Harley-Davidson into the sunset, you should bear in mind, these are fingerprint fragments and as accurately identified by Agatino Giunta, fingerprint expert, as that of Raffaele Sollecito.

As a fragment, it could be there were not enough points of matches up to the legal requirement (IIRC 18 or so matching points). Rather like DNA has to match on at least 10 alleles for an ID to be legally permissable.
 
Last edited:
What does it say at the top of the fingerprint map?
"DIREZIONE CENTRALE ANTICRIMINE SERVIZIO POLIZIA SCIENTIFICA UACV"
so it should be clear "who/what the original source for the diagrams are". ;)

Well, it looks like whoever made that "fingerprint map" mislabeled the prints on the inside of Meredith Kercher's bedroom door. This is from the final fingerprint report made by the Direzione centrale anticrimine della polizia di Stato (page 6):


Long story short: prints Fr.73 and Fr.83 are mislabled in the map as Fr.72 :(


I cannot see that you are correct. According to murderofmeredithkercher.com, Fingerprint no. 72 IS on the door to Meredith Kercher's room.
 

Attachments

  • rs fingerprint on door.jpg
    rs fingerprint on door.jpg
    92 KB · Views: 6
The quote is:



Ergon comments:



and



Unfortunately this Ergon obviously does not understand of which he/she is writing.

Trace DNA is DNA that is not associated with a source. So the DNA from blood stains or semen is not trace. DNA from the bra hook is trace because there is no knowing if the source is blood, saliva, touch etc. Trace DNA may or mayn't be LCN but they are entirely unrelated concepts.

Steffanoni herself says that the quantity of DNA attributable to Sollecito cannot be known because it is part of a mix of DNA. But this Ergon obviously knows more than Steffanoni. Steffanoni points out the dominant contributor was the victim - Kercher, but Ergon obviously knows better. Steffanoni says that the ratio of Kercher's DNA to Sollecito's DNA is about 6:1, but Ergon being an expert knows better. So according to Steffanoni who did the testing 1/7 of the total DNA was attributable to Sollecito, Steffanoni said that the total DNA of the mix was about 1ng (1000pg) so Sollecito's contribution is less than 200pg (within the definition of LCN DNA) but Ergon can just assert this is not true, because Ergon just knows the answer without having to show the working.

The thing is for any lurkers you do not have to believe me. The electropherograms are on line you can measure the peak height of Kercher's DNA and Sollecito's DNA yourself. You can see that Sollecito is a minor contributor. You can do the simple maths yourself.


You are wrong, as there is no requirement to know the source of the DNA.

Just because the wearer/owner of the clothing contributes a higher level of the DNA found, does not cancel out Raffaele Sollecito's strong profile - not a trace - with high RFU's and a full deck of 18 matching alleles.

Prof Novelli a leading Italian geneticist and professor, calculated the probability of it not being Raff's as > 3 billion to one against.
 
I cannot see that you are correct. According to murderofmeredithkercher.com, Fingerprint no. 72 IS on the door to Meredith Kercher's room.


As you very well know (and as any lurker deserves to know), the fake wiki "murderofmeredithkercher.com" is notoriously biassed against Knox/Sollecito in its interpretation of evidence. And that bias is evident in this instance. Your "source" is biassed and incorrect. The print was found on the corridor-side face of the door.

In fact, it's laughably obvious that this is that case, with reference to the scientific police's own illustration. The location of the print on that illustration is clearly shown on the corridor-side face of the door.

Do you not think, Vixen, that if Sollecito's print really had been found on the Kercher-room face of that door, this would have formed a significant - and very vocal - part of the prosecution argument in court? After all, Sollecito never claimed to have been inside Kercher's room prior to the murder, and he provably never entered Kercher's room at any point after the door was broken down and her body was discovered. So therefore, by definition, any discovery of his fingerprint on the Kercher-room face of the door would have been a very clear pointer to his presence inside Kercher's room at some point in time between the evening of her murder and the moment when the door was broken down at around 1pm on 2nd November. And, in turn, this would have been a very strong pointer to Sollecito's involvement in the murder itself or its direct aftermath.

So perhaps, Vixen, you could present that part of the prosecution argument (to the Massei, Hellmann, Nencini or Supreme courts - your choice) where they clearly reference Sollecito's fingerprint on the Kercher-room face of that door, and everything that would imply.

Many thanks in advance for your presentation of that evidence.
 
You are wrong, as there is no requirement to know the source of the DNA.

Just because the wearer/owner of the clothing contributes a higher level of the DNA found, does not cancel out Raffaele Sollecito's strong profile - not a trace - with high RFU's and a full deck of 18 matching alleles.

Prof Novelli a leading Italian geneticist and professor, calculated the probability of it not being Raff's as > 3 billion to one against.



Unfortunately you do not understand of which you are writing either, Vixen.

The point here - and it's a point which Planigale explained very clearly and at some length in the post to which you responded - is nothing to do with the identification of that (low template amount of) DNA as Sollecito's. Rather, the point is ENTIRELY about the provenance and transference of that DNA.

And to illustrate this point further - and more vividly still - perhaps you'd like to explain just how the DNA of at least two other male contributors came to be discovered on that tiny bra clasp hook, Vixen? That DNA belonged to specific individuals. Did those individuals touch Kercher's bra clasp hook, Vixen?



(I'll tell you the truth of the matter to help you along if you like: the truth is that this tiny metal hook on the bra clasp was fatally compromised by a combination of it being swept up in a pile of debris on Kercher's floor - and thus placed into direct contact with plenty of other debris, some of which could easily have originate from outside Kercher's room - and its horribly inept handling by the Stefanoni-led forensics "expert" when they "discovered" and collected it in mid-December 2007 - when they inexplicably passed it among themselves with visibly dirty gloves.

That's how the low-template amounts of DNA from two as-yet-unidentified males came to get onto the tiny metal hook of the bra clasp; and that's how the low-template amount of Sollecito's DNA came to get onto the tiny metal hook of the bra clasp.

And that's before we even get to Stefanoni's unfit-for-purpose laboratory, with a shocking lack of understanding/adherence to the critical protocols and processes required for examining low-template DNA, and the consequent wide-open possibility for laboratory contamination.....)
 
I cannot see that you are correct. According to murderofmeredithkercher.com, Fingerprint no. 72 IS on the door to Meredith Kercher's room.

Yes, Fr. 72 IS on the inner side of Meredith's door. But Fr. 72 remains an unidentified print. Raffaele's prints (Fr. 68 and Fr. 70) are on the outer side of Meredith's door. This is confirmed both with the print diagram and in Giunta's court testimony. I laid this all out for you, including Giunta's testimony, in a previous post but apparently you didn't understand it.

"According to TMoMK" ? Are you kidding? You yourself suggested reading Giunta's testimony. So why now are you pointing to the fake wiki to support your claim? How about you post the portion of Giunta's testimony that supports your claim or just admit you've got this wrong and move on. It's this incessant need of yours to continue to argue something, even in the face of overwhelming, indisputable evidence to the contrary, that destroys your credibility.

Oh, and btw, we're still waiting for evidence of Amanda washing Meredith's blood from her hands and of Amanda being at the cottage at the time of the murder. We're being patient but it HAS been almost 10 years since the murder... shouldn't this evidence be readily available? Just sayin...
 
Unfortunately you do not understand of which you are writing either, Vixen.

The point here - and it's a point which Planigale explained very clearly and at some length in the post to which you responded - is nothing to do with the identification of that (low template amount of) DNA as Sollecito's. Rather, the point is ENTIRELY about the provenance and transference of that DNA.

And to illustrate this point further - and more vividly still - perhaps you'd like to explain just how the DNA of at least two other male contributors came to be discovered on that tiny bra clasp hook, Vixen? That DNA belonged to specific individuals. Did those individuals touch Kercher's bra clasp hook, Vixen?



(I'll tell you the truth of the matter to help you along if you like: the truth is that this tiny metal hook on the bra clasp was fatally compromised by a combination of it being swept up in a pile of debris on Kercher's floor - and thus placed into direct contact with plenty of other debris, some of which could easily have originate from outside Kercher's room - and its horribly inept handling by the Stefanoni-led forensics "expert" when they "discovered" and collected it in mid-December 2007 - when they inexplicably passed it among themselves with visibly dirty gloves.

That's how the low-template amounts of DNA from two as-yet-unidentified males came to get onto the tiny metal hook of the bra clasp; and that's how the low-template amount of Sollecito's DNA came to get onto the tiny metal hook of the bra clasp.
And that's before we even get to Stefanoni's unfit-for-purpose laboratory, with a shocking lack of understanding/adherence to the critical protocols and processes required for examining low-template DNA, and the consequent wide-open possibility for laboratory contamination.....)

Note that it's not even necessary to claim this is definitively how his DNA got there, only that it's a very reasonable possibility and that means this evidence does not rise above BARD.

What further proves this DNA to be non-primary transfer is that it is 1/6th that of Meredith's own DNA. If Raffaele has been involved in the attack and deposited his DNA at that time it would be reasonable to assume he would have been perspiring heavily when he touched the hook and that would have left significant DNA. In fact, his DNA should have become the dominant DNA on the hook. Then there's the whole "how did he get his DNA on the hook (which is NOT exposed when the bra is being worn) without getting his DNA elsewhere on the bra.

You gotta love Vixen's diversionary tactic of tossing out the "> 3 billion to one" line as if that was the least bit relevant. This is not about who's DNA it is but how that DNA got there. Being absolutely certain it's Raffaele's means nothing if it's shown it likely got there via secondary or tertiary transfer.
 
LondonJohn said:
As you very well know (and as any lurker deserves to know), the fake wiki "murderofmeredithkercher.com" is notoriously biassed against Knox/Sollecito in its interpretation of evidence. And that bias is evident in this instance. Your "source" is biassed and incorrect. The print was found on the corridor-side face of the door.
Welshman said:
The numerous falsehoods told by Vixen have been pointed out by myself and others and Vixen has the cheek to attack people for lying. PGP are completely shameless in their hypocrisy.
Planigale said:
Unfortunately this Ergon obviously does not understand of which he/she is writing.

Trace DNA is DNA that is not associated with a source. So the DNA from blood stains or semen is not trace. DNA from the bra hook is trace because there is no knowing if the source is blood, saliva, touch etc. Trace DNA may or mayn't be LCN but they are entirely unrelated concepts.

Steffanoni herself says that the quantity of DNA attributable to Sollecito cannot be known because it is part of a mix of DNA. But this Ergon obviously knows more than Steffanoni.
Vixen said:
You are wrong, as there is no requirement to know the source of the DNA.
Vixen, lurkers here might not have read when you say that it is possible to know the origin of trace DNA. Yes, I know that your argument in the highlighted text is a little different, but you make other arguments which require you to know the origin of trace DNA.

It's bound to come around sooner or later - you continually repeat that the last court, the one which acquitted the pair found as factual that Knox had rubbed Meredith's blood from her hands.

That was Sept 2015. Yet when one tracks back to the 2010 Massei report, the one written to justify the first (wrongful-)conviction, one finds a few curious things.

- Stefanoni herself confirmed that forensically speaking, one could not determine the origin of the trace DNA from Amanda mixed with Meredith's blood, found in the very bathroom they'd shared for weeks.

- Massei himself on behalf of the court accepts that there are no forensics, per se, to support a contention that Amanda's DNA came from skin cells

- this is even before considering that on other matters in that very same report, Massei rejects the significance of another's potential DNA being found because "DNA cannot be date-stamped".

- Massei himself claims that it had to have been Amanda's skin cells rubbed off in the action of cleaning blood from herself, only because that notion fits the other surmises he makes. That is the sum-total of his judicial reasoning.

- No one, much less Massei, has then explained how that blood got on to Knox in the first place, given that there are no forensics, and specifically blood-forensics, of Knox in the murder-room itself. (Unlike Rudy Guede who has his fingerprints in Merediths blood in the murder room!)

- In 2015, the Marasca-Bruno panel in acquitting the pair said of this that even if it were true, then Amanda would have had to have picked up this blood in another part of the house and at a time after the murder.​
There's cake. There's eating it. You can't have both. It's more than that there is no requirement to know the origin of trace-DNA, it's that when you repeat ad naseam that it is proven that Knox rubbed the victim's blood from her hands, you are claiming that it becomes mandatory to know the origin of trace-DNA.

And why are we arguing this anyway? This is the bathroom that Kercher and Knox shared for weeks. When Rudy Guede entered the bathroom after murdering the victim, the former of which he readily admits he did, he spread Meredith's blood to surfaces rich with both Amanda's and Meredith's pre-existing DNA.

Unless you're now going to argue that DNA can, indeed, be date-stamped.

BTW - Massei in 2010 got around this by saying that Knox had claimed that the bathroom had been cleaned. Really? Did Knox say she'd cleaned it to the molecular, DNA-free level? This is the girl who was criticised for not being able to clean a toilet - so much so, that the 2nd prosecutor, Crini in Florence, said that the unclean toilet was the motive for murder!!!! (That's how weird this case got.)

Lurkers here might want to delve into this for themselves; this has been the guilt PR-campaign ever since the police leaked stuff to the tabloids.
 
Last edited:
The quote is:

There is a low possibility (less than 5%) that a DNA profile will be observed 24 h after the contact that led to the transfer." (p.78)
Ergon comments:



and



All clear now?

Apparently you failed to understand in my previous post that this is NOT a quote from GILL. It is from his book where he is discussing and quoting previously published literature. It is taken out of that context and fails to provide what else was said in that literature or what Gill says about it. Since Ergon fails to mention any of this, it is apparent he has taken this from the Amazon "Look inside" result and paraphrased it. That search result is this:

page 78...published scientific literature - There is a very low probability (less than 5%) that a DNA profile will be observed 24 h after the contact that led to the transfer.

Compare that to what Ergon said:

Try reading Peter Gill's "Misleading DNA Evidence" where he contradicts himself on the case by saying chances of getting a reportable profile via passive transfer is "very low" >24 hrs after last contact (p76-77)

Notice that Ergon puts his own words into his quote that do not exist in the original: via passive transfer. Nowhere do those words appear in the quote from Gill's book.

Ergon is not a forensics expert yet he seems to think he knows more than actual forensic scientists including one of, if not the, most respected forensic experts in the world.
Edited by jsfisher: 
...<snip>... Edited for compliance with Rule 12 of the Membership Agreement.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ergon said:
Try reading Peter Gill's "Misleading DNA Evidence" where he contradicts himself on the case by saying chances of getting a reportable profile via passive transfer is "very low" >24 hrs after last contact (p76-77)
Notice that Ergon puts his own words into his quote that do not exist in the original: via passive transfer. Nowhere do those words appear in the quote from Gill's book.

Ergon is not a forensics expert yet he seems to think he knows more than actual forensic scientists including one of, if not the, most respected forensic experts in the world.
Edited by jsfisher: 
...<snip>... Moderated content redacted.

This is the reason why people should stop reading the fake-Wiki.

TMoMK wiki was started by a shadowy "Edward McCall" so that the pro-guilt side would have a short and snappy information source online. It has made great strides in publishing original documents, even if it remains unknown how they'd acquired them. Fact is - they have them.

But Ergon is now the effective caretaker of the fake-Wiki. It is not user editable, and the vast majority of entries are done by a single author - and most have as their last "edit" as being done before even the 2014 Florence reconviction.

I used to turn to it to find out what was what on that side of the fence. Yet the authors of the articles there are far, far, far too prone to add phrases like "via passive transfer" just to help out the reader in understanding the guilt-side of things(!!)

I have no idea if it is still there, but I gave up when one of their articles offered as proof that Vecchiotti must be corrupt, because Francesco Maresca (the Kercher's lawyer) saw Vecchiotti going to lunch once with a defence lawyer. (Apparently is it corrupt for an independent, forensic-DNA expert to brief the defence on what they have found!!!!)

So why would anyone be surprised when Vixen cites the fake-Wiki as proving that Raffaele's fingerprint had been found on the inside of Meredith's door!? (Even if the forensics do not support that!)

The fake-Wiki is not making a case, it is fabricating a case. As demonstrated by the last few posts on this thread.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Note that it's not even necessary to claim this is definitively how his DNA got there, only that it's a very reasonable possibility and that means this evidence does not rise above BARD.

Correct me if I am wrong, but each piece of evidence, in and of itself, is not to be judged using BARD. It's just the overall, assembled case that the prosecution constructs that must meet that threshhold.

Most evidence is either evident or it isn't. It's either Raffaele's fingerprint on the interior of Meredith's door or it isn't.

With other kinds of evidence - like Rudy claiming that he'd been in the cottage with Meredith's consent, that there's an "innocent" explanation for his DNA being inside her, and his claim that he witnessed a fight between Knox and Kercher over rent money - you either believe it or you don't.

None of those two things are measured by BARD. Just the overall case assembled by the prosecution.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom