Merged Teen Encouraged Friend to Commit Suicide, Convicted of Manslaughter

No. Not fair enough. While people do use threats of suicide to manipulate, there are also those who think they're serious -until they realize they're not. Apparently that happened to the boy at the center of this topic: he changed his mind when faced with the very real specter of dying. Sometimes, that is the ONLY thing that works to prevent someone from going through with the act.

(sigh)

I agree what this woman did was terrible, and she deserved to be prosecuted and punished. In fact, I think she deserves to spend time in prison. Clearly, she wasn't trying to help, but she almost did help despite her intentions.

If she had been a real friend to him, she gained the perfect opportunity to tell him to go home and call for some professional help. But now, the next person who really is trying to help, and finds themselves in that same place may face prosecution because of her actions. That's worrisome.
It's not in any way worrisome. Playing amateur reverse psychology with someone threatening suicide, who then commits suicide, should absolutely be criminalized. There's a reason psychologists, psychiatrists, and even social workers spend a lot of time in school and then doing on-the-job training before they're turned loose to practice independently.
 
Words are actions, actions have consequences, some will be unknowable beforehand some are at least knowable or are by a "reasonable" person. Many countries and states make helping someone commit suicide a crime, even if you don't pull the trigger so to speak, I see this somewhat similar. The intent was to have someone commit suicide.
 
This is actually a very interesting case. The judge stayed the sentence until the appeals at the state level occur. He was wise enough to realize he may be overturned on appeal. He doesn't want her to serve time and then be overturned, because you cannot undo prison time. So she really isn't doing any time... just yet.

He stated he was not going to stay the execution of the sentence until all appeals occur, because the end of his sentence is 2022 and appeals at the federal level may still be occurring.
 
This is actually a very interesting case. The judge stayed the sentence until the appeals at the state level occur. He was wise enough to realize he may be overturned on appeal. He doesn't want her to serve time and then be overturned, because you cannot undo prison time. So she really isn't doing any time... just yet.

He stated he was not going to stay the execution of the sentence until all appeals occur, because the end of his sentence is 2022 and appeals at the federal level may still be occurring.
Jail is a ridiculous sanction in this case, Amanda Knox agrees.
What on earth will jail time do?
I despair of ever modernising crime and punishment.
This woman is crushed by the process and understanding of existential finality, leave her alone, let her meditate, DO NOT DRUG HER UP YOU TERRIBLE MEDICATING MORONS.
 
Jail is a ridiculous sanction in this case, Amanda Knox agrees.
What on earth will jail time do?
I despair of ever modernising crime and punishment.
This woman is crushed by the process and understanding of existential finality, leave her alone, let her meditate, DO NOT DRUG HER UP YOU TERRIBLE MEDICATING MORONS.

Amanda Knox is twisted. The fact that she strongly identifies with Carter and not the victim's devastated family tells you all you need to know about her 'quirkiness'.

A friend of mine from a few years back had a son who committed suicide aged early teens from jumping off a building (before I knew her). This woman was the most broken saddest individual I ever met. She carried her grief around with her like a millstone. She gave out poems of her son in crowded streets and brought out books about him. Her writing was great, full of black humour. However, she suffered the most terrible depression you can imagine.

How anyone can demand we be 'compassion' to the instigator - here Michelle Carter - with a dismissive hand wave of the victim, is way off beam.

The judge did show 'compassion'. He gave Carter 2.5 years, when she could have got up to twenty years.

The 'compassion' correctly comes in sentencing and not in judging whether or not Carter is guilty as charged. They are two separate issues.
 
Here's the verdict which includes Juvenile Court Judge Lawrence Moniz explaining what led him to find her guilty:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A4i6bGFfQ9E

The ACLU has spoken out regarding the verdict, saying it imperils free speech. I'm expecting Carter to appeal her verdict. In the meantime she's free on bail until her sentencing hearing on August 3. I'm not sure why that is though since she was found guilty.

It's been reported that Carter has suffered from anorexia, cutting and childhood depression.

http://www.masslive.com/news/index.ssf/2017/06/michelle_carter_trial_controve_1.html

IMO she's a mess psychologically and needs to be removed from the community until she can be properly assessed and treated.
Every so often ACLU does something that makes me not like them for a good while. This is the latest of those. They apparently they do not realize this is the perfect other example of the 'do not cry "Fire!!!" ' in a crowded theater (unless there really is one) early example of what free speech DID NOT cover!!!!!
 
Last edited:
A debate has arisen as to whether sending texts encouraging another to suicide is a crime. Whilst Massachussetts (the Carter jurisdiction) does not have a specific law and like most, rolls it under 'involuntary manslaughter', other states have the following laws:

Arkansas – A person who “purposely causes or aids another person to commit suicide” is guilty of manslaughter.

Connecticut – Someone who “causes a suicide by force, duress or deception” is guilty of murder. Someone who “intentionally causes or aids another person, other than by force, duress or deception, to commit suicide” is guilty of manslaughter.

Florida – Deliberately assisting in someone’s self-murder (as it’s called there) is manslaughter, a second-degree felony. Interestingly, commercially exploiting self-murder is a third-degree felony.

Illinois – Inducing another to commit suicide has various penalties depending on the circumstances ranging from a Class A misdemeanor to a Class 2, 3 or 4 felony. Notably, in Illinois, coercing and controlling another person into committing suicide through “psychological pressure” alone is enough to trigger criminal conduct. (Michelle Carter would have been in a lot of trouble in Illinois.)

New Hampshire – Causing or aiding a suicide by purposefully aiding or soliciting another person to commit suicide is a Class B felony if the defendant’s conduct causes death; otherwise, it is a misdemeanor.

New York – New York has separate statutes which make it illegal to promote a suicide attempt or to “intentionally cause[] or aid[] another person to commit suicide.” The first is a Class E felony, the second is punishable as an attempt to commit murder, and the third is punishable as manslaughter, a Class C felony.
http://lawnewz.com/high-profile/if-youre-furious-about-michelle-carters-sentence-do-this/

This quells the idea that there is anything legally egregious in Carter being charged, tried and sentenced for applying psychological pressure on her boyfriend to kill himself.
 
A debate has arisen as to whether sending texts encouraging another to suicide is a crime. Whilst Massachussetts (the Carter jurisdiction) does not have a specific law and like most, rolls it under 'involuntary manslaughter', other states have the following laws:

http://lawnewz.com/high-profile/if-youre-furious-about-michelle-carters-sentence-do-this/

This quells the idea that there is anything legally egregious in Carter being charged, tried and sentenced for applying psychological pressure on her boyfriend to kill himself.


Possibly some conflation here. A law can exist and still be egregious.

For example. I don't think it would be too hard to compile another similar list of laws and penalties for possession of ridiculously small amounts of a recreational herb that most rational people would concede were egregious.
 
Possibly some conflation here. A law can exist and still be egregious.

For example. I don't think it would be too hard to compile another similar list of laws and penalties for possession of ridiculously small amounts of a recreational herb that most rational people would concede were egregious.

There is a big difference between disagreeing with the law and claiming it is 'unlawful' as Amanda Knox did in her LA Times diatribe.

In the case of pot smoking, these days, whilst illegal, you are unlikely to be charged except after several cautions.

However, were you to be charged, it would not be 'unlawful'.
 
Supreme Court won't take up appeal of Michelle Carter's conviction for role in boyfriend's suicide

Washington (CNN) The Supreme Court said on Monday that it would not take up the case of Michelle Carter, a woman serving a 15-month sentence for her part in her boyfriend's death by suicide.

Carter had asked the justices to take up her case, arguing that her conviction three years ago for involuntary manslaughter -- based on her words alone -- violated her First Amendment rights.

Carter was found guilty in 2017 of involuntary manslaughter in the death of 18-year-old Conrad Roy III, who killed himself in his car in Fairhaven, Massachusetts, in 2014. After his death, investigators discovered Roy had texted Carter as he contemplated and attempted suicide, and that she'd encouraged him to do it when he had doubts.

CNN: https://www.cnn.com/2020/01/13/politics/supreme-court-michelle-carter-boyfriend-suicide/index.html
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom