The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
After months' of asking, maybe Vixen could also provide one, just one forensic-DNA expert who supports Stefanoni's police-DNA-work....
..... work which was accepted in the 2009 trial (which convicted the pair) and work which was trashed in the 2011, second-trial after the appointment of independent forensic-DNA experts. (Note: Stefanoni's work has been trashed by every forensic-DNA expert since, as well as ordinary DNA experts.)

So there are issues piling up for Vixen. No wonder she'd rather talk about some author's parents being "stoned hippies". Divert, divert, divert.

As I keep saying, Dr Stefanoni is a member of staff not a research fellow writing up papers for peer review.Please be realistic.

No one has said Stefanoni was not a member of the police staff. What this has to do with Bill's question is....nothing.


Evade, evade, evade....

Why would anybody do a research paper appraising a member of staff. Is it not normal to research already published works and add to the body?

Once again, you are twisting things. No surprise there. Bill did not ask about any papers but about her police DNA work. And as he correctly stated, the records of that work are available for review by others. Which is exactly what was done.

Keep on dancing...

It is also noted that, once again, you fail to acknowledge you were wrong about what Burleigh said much less what I said.
 
No, she did not say that. What she did say was, 'I never saw them take drugs' [paraphrase].

In other words, they were stoned out of their boxes.

Man I hate your behavior.

Now I grant you that just because children never witnessed their parents taking drugs doesn’t mean the parents didn't. However it doesn't mean they did either. And given that Nina who KNEW her parents believed that they didn't how do you a person who doesnt know her parents at all justify coming to the opposite conclusion?

This behavior is DESPICABLE. Or didn't you learn in school that you need to be informed before you make conclusions?
 
Oh, sweet Jesus. This is a classic example of why you have the reputation for twisting and contorting things. Notice I said "misinformation" which it clearly was as it was the Daily Mail and not the Times. Nowhere did I suggest you lied.

In fact, I even clarified that I didn't think you were lying when I later wrote:



No one has forgotten, however, that you have still failed to provide any link to the alleged article by Follain in the Sunday Times where he talked to people about Knox's "wild behavior" as you claimed. You have done the usual song and dance of doing everything you can to avoid producing said link...one which you claimed you have done many times before. As is obvious, if such an article existed you would produce it. Therefore, it is extremely probable that no such article exists. Why can't you just admit you made a mistake like an adult?

Now that it's clear you were wrong about question #1, how about dealing with the other two:


2. I said that "there can only be one newspaper report and one witness."

3. I called you any "childish names".

Can you spell out your reason for wanting me to pay subs to the TIMES to dig out this article yet again instead of doing a simple search on ISF/

By claiming I was 'making it up' (=calling me a liar) you implied the DAILY MAIL was the only proper source.
 
I see you agree that it was the "most stupid" opinion ever rendered, or a willful attempt at......


No. It is misconceived to imagine anyone would do a scientific thesis on Stefanoni, or Mignini or Massei or any person.

If I were a research fellow, I would set out to look at forensic procedures, not personalities.
 
Man I hate your behavior.

Now I grant you that just because children never witnessed their parents taking drugs doesn’t mean the parents didn't. However it doesn't mean they did either. And given that Nina who KNEW her parents believed that they didn't how do you a person who doesnt know her parents at all justify coming to the opposite conclusion?

This behavior is DESPICABLE. Or didn't you learn in school that you need to be informed before you make conclusions?


Come off your high horse. Being at Haight-Astbury at the height of the Summer of Love was the ultimate status symbol.

Why else do you think Nina Burleigh wrote an article bragging about it. Saying you were there but never inhaled just isn't going to be believed.
 
No. It is misconceived to imagine anyone would do a scientific thesis on Stefanoni, or Mignini or Massei or any person.

If I were a research fellow, I would set out to look at forensic procedures, not personalities.

Who on earth has been talking personalities? You either have serious reading comprehension issues or are willfully goalpost shifting. Is there any point in talking to you?

For those who wish to talk seriously about this, here is a link to Dr. Peter Gill, the father of LCN DNA testing, trashing Stefanoni's work. What Gill thinks of her personality is of primary interest to Vixen and Vixen alone.

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1872497316300333
 
Who on earth has been talking personalities? You either have serious reading comprehension issues or are willfully goalpost shifting. Is there any point in talking to you?

For those who wish to talk seriously about this, here is a link to Dr. Peter Gill, the father of LCN DNA testing, trashing Stefanoni's work. What Gill thinks of her personality is of primary interest to Vixen and Vixen alone.

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1872497316300333

Peter Gill based his work on Conti & Vecchiotti who were heavily criticised by Chieffi, as Hellmann failed to state a reason as to why he hired them at all, when Novelli and co were equally if not more so expert and called them 'intellectually dishonest'. They also had the Carabinieri watching them.


Gill has no first hand access to Stefanoni's labs, reports and samples.

It's unethical to base results on someone else's experiment when you were not there and had no part in it.
 
Peter Gill based his work on Conti & Vecchiotti who were heavily criticised by Chieffi, as Hellmann failed to state a reason as to why he hired them at all, when Novelli and co were equally if not more so expert and called them 'intellectually dishonest'. They also had the Carabinieri watching them.


Gill has no first hand access to Stefanoni's labs, reports and samples.

It's unethical to base results on someone else's experiment when you were not there and had no part in it.

I note no cites at all to any of the ridiculous claims made in this post. But you have dodged the claim you'd made that the issue was personalities.

- Chieffi did not criticize C&V. Chieffi wrote that Hellmann had erred by allowing C&V to make the de facto judicial decision about the testing of Sample 36I. You don't even know the reasons why Chieffi annulled the Hellmann acquittals.

- Hellmann, in fact, did state the reason. You just don't agree with it.

- "Novelli and c." did not call them "intellectually dishonest."

- I have also heard reports that the Carabinieri had been sent to harass C&V with threats of arrest - and given that those threats were never carried out proves that they were meant to intimidate.

- Gill had first hand access to everything that Stefanoni had submitted to the court. Indeed, Gill is able to completely trash Judge Nencini's own misunderstanding of DNA forensics, and showed that Nencini had completely misunderstood even what Stefanoni had submitted:​
The police scientist stated that she ran a negative amplification control concurrently with sample “B” that had very low background noise7. This finding was interpreted as evidence that the item was not contaminated in the Nencini sentencing report and this was a critical reason why the defendants were found guilty. The same error was also made in relation to the bra-clasp.

From the Nencini report

“Surely, because it was a low copy number, the sample taken from the knife’s blade and identified by letter ‘B’ could not produce findings of certain attribution; nevertheless, this Court finds that the interpretation of the test is correct for the reasons highlighted above, because it is a trace that bears the presence of only one contributor, which make a test error less probable; also, the positive and negative checks established that there was no contamination of the item.”​
“In conclusion, we must declare that with respect to Item No. 36 (the knife, the alleged murder weapon) and Item No. 165-B (the closure hook of the bra worn by Meredith KERCHER the night she was killed), no contamination or pollution has been proven or could be concretely possible. This assertion is also confirmed by the negative and positive controls (to be further discussed below) conducted by Dr. Patrizia Stefanoni and part of the trial record, which show that there was no contamination of said evidentiary items.”​

However, this was also a serious error of interpretation. The negative control is simply a blank or empty tube run concurrently with the samples in the laboratory beginning at the extraction stage of the analytical process. Consequently, it can only be used as a control for potential reagent contamination. It cannot be used to discount possible contamination, either at the crime scene or in the examination room.

As for "It's unethical to base results on someone else's experiment when you were not there and had no part in it," that is complete stupidity and shows a remarkably willful misunderstanding of this case.
 
Link to this alleged article? I've been unable to find any such article. Not that you'd make this up.:rolleyes:
QUOTE]


Can you spell out your reason for wanting me to pay subs to the TIMES to dig out this article yet again instead of doing a simple search on ISF/

By claiming I was 'making it up' (=calling me a liar) you implied the DAILY MAIL was the only proper source.

Can you spell out your reason for wanting me to pay subs to the Times to dig out this alleged article when you are the one claiming it exists? As for doing a simple search on ISF/, why don't you do it for the exact reason I just stated? Why should I spend who knows how long trying to find something that may...or may not...exist? I know this is difficult for you to understand, but it is not up to me to prove your claim. But this the usual game you play: make a claim, fail to provide proof, and when asked to do so, put the onus on the other person to prove your claim.

Prosecutor: We have proof that the defendant is guilty.

Judge: Please present this proof.

Prosecutor: Your Honor, just search through the court files and you'll find it. Or are you calling me a liar?

I never implied the Daily Mail was the only proper source. I said straight out that Malone's article was in the DM and not the Sunday Times. You claimed Follain wrote a piece in the S Times where he, after interviewing Knox's friends, described her "wild behavior". As I said, I think you confused the article by Follain (that was provided by Bill, IIRC) with the Malone DM article.

As for calling you a liar, I did not. I asked for a link as I could not find (nor could anyone else) this alleged article. As for your "making it up", I'm going on past history where you have provably made things up. They've been listed many times before. Would you like that list provided again?

Now, stop this song and dance routine. If you could provide that article, if only to prove us all wrong and you right, you would. There is absolutely not a single logical reason you would not. You know it. We know it. Anyone reading this knows it.
 
Come off your high horse. Being at Haight-Astbury at the height of the Summer of Love was the ultimate status symbol.

Why else do you think Nina Burleigh wrote an article bragging about it. Saying you were there but never inhaled just isn't going to be believed.

Please, for the love of God, stop wildly speculating on her motives, her thoughts, her beliefs, and everything else just because she thinks Knox is innocent. You keep proving her point over and over again.
 
Link to this alleged article? I've been unable to find any such article. Not that you'd make this up.:rolleyes:
QUOTE]




Can you spell out your reason for wanting me to pay subs to the Times to dig out this alleged article when you are the one claiming it exists? As for doing a simple search on ISF/, why don't you do it for the exact reason I just stated? Why should I spend who knows how long trying to find something that may...or may not...exist? I know this is difficult for you to understand, but it is not up to me to prove your claim. But this the usual game you play: make a claim, fail to provide proof, and when asked to do so, put the onus on the other person to prove your claim.

Prosecutor: We have proof that the defendant is guilty.

Judge: Please present this proof.

Prosecutor: Your Honor, just search through the court files and you'll find it. Or are you calling me a liar?

I never implied the Daily Mail was the only proper source. I said straight out that Malone's article was in the DM and not the Sunday Times. You claimed Follain wrote a piece in the S Times where he, after interviewing Knox's friends, described her "wild behavior". As I said, I think you confused the article by Follain (that was provided by Bill, IIRC) with the Malone DM article.

As for calling you a liar, I did not. I asked for a link as I could not find (nor could anyone else) this alleged article. As for your "making it up", I'm going on past history where you have provably made things up. They've been listed many times before. Would you like that list provided again?

Now, stop this song and dance routine. If you could provide that article, if only to prove us all wrong and you right, you would. There is absolutely not a single logical reason you would not. You know it. We know it. Anyone reading this knows it.


No, I am not going to spend my time digging out articles just for the sake of your getting me to dance to your tune, when you confirmed you are not the slightest bit interested in the article anyway.
 
No, I am not going to spend my time digging out articles just for the sake of your getting me to dance to your tune, when you confirmed you are not the slightest bit interested in the article anyway.

Which is just another way of saying there is no such article. And no, I don't think you intentionally lied about it. I think you made a mistake and just cannot admit it. How Trumpensian.

Now, how about addressing the remaining questions that:

2. I said that "there can only be one newspaper report and one witness."

3. I called you any "childish names".
 
Last edited:
Which is just another way of saying there is no such article. And no, I don't think you intentionally lied about it. I think you made a mistake and just cannot admit it. How Trumpensian.

Now, how about addressing the remaining questions that:

2. I said that "there can only be one newspaper report and one witness."

3. I called you any "childish names".

Please refer to my previous answer.

"The road to Hell is paved with good intentions".
 
Come off your high horse. Being at Haight-Astbury at the height of the Summer of Love was the ultimate status symbol.

Why else do you think Nina Burleigh wrote an article bragging about it. Saying you were there but never inhaled just isn't going to be believed.

BULL. You DON'T KNOW and suggesting that you do is DESPICABLE. I know people who went to Woodstock and didn't take drugs as well. I've been to Haight Asbury many times. It's just a neighborhood with a few bars, music and clothing stores and head shops. It really wasn't much different in 1969.

I have lived around drugs with siblings that even sold them. I'm next to the youngest of 9 children. Everyone of them smoked pot and most would do any drug put in front of them. And I Have NEVER smoked pot or any other non-prescription drugs. NEVER..NOT ONCE.

This is your problem. You judge based on your preconceived ideas. Oh, they went to Haight Asbury in 1969, they must be hippie stoners. Amanda had sex...she must have killed her roommate.
 
Unsurprisingly, NvdL has yet another AK book out. This one published just two weeks after the last one. I can only imagine the hours of intense and thorough research spent in front of the computer googling the internet. Long nights of cutting and pasting. Early morning risings, fueled by strong coffee, to fit in all that had to be done in order to put out such a credible and well-researched piece of professional journalism. Also unsurprising is the review. And I do mean review. No "s". But I'm sure more of the same NvdL fan reviewers...all 3 or 4 of them...will by dropping by to give it their thumbs up. For a laugh, go have a look at the description of the book, etc. Just be sure to visit the WC first because you might just piss yourself laughing. Oh..almost forgot; it's called FOXY KNOXY FIGHTS BACK: Second Trial and Acquittal.
 
Last edited:
Will you please return to discussing the trials of Ms Knox and Signor Sollecito. At the same time, will you all please remember to be civil and polite.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Agatha
 
There really is nothing to discuss unless we go back to playing whack a mole with the falsehoods that the PGP routinely post as if they were actually true.

Which is what I hate about this forum.
 
There really is nothing to discuss unless we go back to playing whack a mole with the falsehoods that the PGP routinely post as if they were actually true.

Which is what I hate about this forum.

I moderately disagree. Examining the prosecution and trial history of this case is a virtual roadmap of and classic account of a wrongful prosecution where people actually did jail-time. For Raffaele that was exclusively preventative detention, and for Knox a combination of time for the calunnia conviction, plus preventative detention for the annulled murder stuff.

There's also the issue of people like Nick van der Leek. There are those who remain to cut-and-paste "books" to basically regurgitate the failed Mignini prosecution, as if there has been merit to it to begin with.
 
I moderately disagree. Examining the prosecution and trial history of this case is a virtual roadmap of and classic account of a wrongful prosecution where people actually did jail-time. For Raffaele that was exclusively preventative detention, and for Knox a combination of time for the calunnia conviction, plus preventative detention for the annulled murder stuff.

There's also the issue of people like Nick van der Leek. There are those who remain to cut-and-paste "books" to basically regurgitate the failed Mignini prosecution, as if there has been merit to it to begin with.

I would urge everybody to read Nick van der Leek and Lisa Wilson's books for a cutting insight into this crime.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom