The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis

jeffreyw: 203 items of ignorance and delusion since 15th January 2015 :eye-poppi

  1. 10 August 2017 jeffreyw: The fantasy that number of views means that his obviously ignorant and deluded PDFs are accepted as valid.
  2. 10 August 2017 jeffreyw: The delusion that this forum is not showing how obviously ignorant and deluded his idea is :eye-poppi!
  3. 10 August 2017 jeffreyw: A PDF about ages with the usual ignorance, lies and delusions.
  4. 10 August 2017 jeffreyw: The ignorance that only radiometric dating is used to date solar system objects.
  5. 10 August 2017 jeffreyw: A lie about meteorites "not evidenced to come from anywhere in the solar system".
  6. 10 August 2017 jeffreyw: A lie about astronomers "forcing" all the solar system objects to be the same age.
  7. 10 August 2017 jeffreyw: Paranoia on astronomers not challenging the mainstream because it would impact careers badly.
  8. 10 August 2017 jeffreyw: Insulting readers knowledge (people know that we have no samples from Mercury!).
  9. 10 August 2017 jeffreyw: More irrelevant paranoia about the LHC.
  10. 10 August 2017 jeffreyw: Ignorant fantasies and lies about Mars.
  11. 10 August 2017 jeffreyw: Abysmally ignorant delusion that Mars is at least 25 billon years old ( older than the universe!)
  12. 10 August 2017 jeffreyw: Many delusions about biology in a PDF
  13. 11 September 2017 jeffreyw: Ignorant fantasies about Mars which has several "giant mountains".
  14. 11 September 2017 jeffreyw: A "crust ossification" delusion form yet another ignorant and deluded PDF.
  15. 11 September 2017 jeffreyw: The repeated delusion that science is dogma with the Mars age lie
  16. 11 September 2017 jeffreyw: An ignorant delusion that the Sun and gas giants are "clearly much younger" than rocky planets.
  17. 11 September 2017 jeffreyw: Insults most academics when he is the one with "an impossible level of ignorance, attainable only by egos that are inflated to extreme proportions" as documented in this thread for everyone to read forever :eye-poppi!
 
jeffreyw: Martian water evaporation irrelevancy

Relative and Absolute Ages in Stellar Metamorphosis
A PDF that keeps on giving ignorant fantasies :p!
11 September 2017 jeffreyw: Martian water evaporation irrelevancy.
"There is no evidence of mountain building due to contraction of the crust caused by slow gravitational collapse, the majority of the water has evaporated".
That Mars used to have water and has little water now is nothing to do with delusions about the Martian crust. Water on Mars

11 September 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that Mercury is "in excess of 65 billion years old" because it has no atmosphere and has craters.

11 September 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that impact craters are "healed" by "interior fluid motion".
Impact craters are on the surface and not affected by "interior fluid motion".

11 September 2017 jeffreyw: A "paradigm of stellar metamorphosis is much more advances" lie - ignorant delusions are not more advanced that working science.

11 September 2017 jeffreyw: A "old, painfully outdated models that were taught in the 1950’s" lie because they are not the 2017 models.
 
"Crust ossification principle"?


Ossification as in...

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/ossification




?!?!?

Perhaps you should let someone else name your 'principles'.

I asked for help. Many, many times. Most people are too lazy or suffer from a deep sense of nihilism.

Words have many meanings. It does fit though. The crust becomes more rigid as it thickens, thus there will be no earthquakes on Venus/Mars.

Here is a paper that explains natural gas and oil are formed while life itself is forming. The two are nearly parallel events. This is a re-positioning of the events concerning oil and natural gas formation.

http://vixra.org/pdf/1709.0255v1.pdf

Natural gas and oil formed while life was beginning, they were not formed as a result of decomposing life, but as leftovers from the formation of life itself.
 
jeffreyw: Lies about and insults other posters in this thread

I asked for help. Many, many times. Most people are too lazy or suffer from a deep sense of nihilism.
21 September 2017 jeffreyw: Lies about and insults other posters in this thread.
You never asked for help. Other posters have pointed out real world facts about planes and stars to you that you are still ignoring and denying after almost 2 years :jaw-dropp!

Digging himself even deeper into a pit of ignorance and delusion:
21 September 2017 jeffreyw: An idiotic natural gas and oil PDF ignoring basic facts.
The physical evidence suggests that life on Earth has existed for at least 3.5 billion years. Natural gas and oil are only millions of years old.
Petroleum and natural gas are formed by the anaerobic decomposition of remains of organisms including phytoplankton and zooplankton that settled to the sea (or lake) bottom in large quantities under anoxic conditions, millions of years ago
As an example Foraminifera have an origin about 542 million years ago.

The real world needs vast populations of fairly large scale animals (zooplankton and algae) to have evolved and increased in numbers to be the starting point of the formation of petroleum.
The real world needs sediment laid down over geological scales to trap the animal remains.
The real world needs even more sediment laid down over millions of years to produce the high pressures and temperatures to turn the trapped animal remains into natural oil and gas.
 
I asked for help. Many, many times. Most people are too lazy or suffer from a deep sense of nihilism.

As people here have actually tried to help, the laziness, suffering and nihilism must be yours.

Words have many meanings. It does fit though. The crust becomes more rigid as it thickens, thus there will be no earthquakes on Venus/Mars.

Words having meanings, that fit, other than what you intend was the point. Hence, perhaps you should let someone else name your 'principles'.


Mars may still be seismically active we just don't have the equipment on it to tell.


https://www.space.com/418-marsquakes-red-planet-rumble.html

While Venus doesn't appear to be or perhaps even have been tectonicly active. It may still be geologically active.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geology_of_Venus


Here is a paper that explains natural gas and oil are formed while life itself is forming. The two are nearly parallel events. This is a re-positioning of the events concerning oil and natural gas formation.

http://vixra.org/pdf/1709.0255v1.pdf

Natural gas and oil formed while life was beginning, they were not formed as a result of decomposing life, but as leftovers from the formation of life itself.

Nope, the linked citation simply claims not "explains", as you also simply, well, claimed.


This, tough basic, explains and not just claims.

http://www.sjvgeology.org/oil/oil.html

You will note the lack of strawman claims, made up percentages and assertions of biologists experimenting "with the first lifeforms if they wanted".

Heck, even though basic it still explains the oil, gas coal differences by kerogen type.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerogen

Hope that helps.
 
jeffreyw: His hydrocarbons PDF is deluded from the first 2 words in the abstract

Had some spare time so read this insane tirade full of ignorance and delusions.
22 September 2017 jeffreyw: His hydrocarbons PDF is deluded from the first 2 words in the abstract: "Establishment dogma"
That is the start of the PDF insanity: "Establishment dogma has a false worldview, which compounds into hundreds of false smaller theories, models and guesses.".

22 September 2017 jeffreyw: The abstract ends with a lie of "Explanation is provided" since no explanation is provided.
The repeated delusion of dogma and the delusion that his cartoons represent the real world are presented.

22 September 2017 jeffreyw: A lie of "The dogma fully accepts the false notion of life somehow being independent of the natural world".
Biology and the study of the origin of life is part of the natural sciences which look at the natural world.
Abiogenesis uses the natural state of the early Earth to predict mechanisms to form life.

22 September 2017 jeffreyw: Abysmal ignorance about hydrocarbons leads to the delusion that petroleum and life have the same hydrocarbons so petroleum must have existed before life!
Hydrocarbons are compounds of hydrogen and carbon. Petroleum "consists of hydrocarbons of various molecular weights and other organic compounds".

There are many theories of abiogenesis, none of which start with hydrocarbons. The usual route is to start with inorganic compounds and have processes to turn then into amino acids (H, N, O and C) - see the classic if outdated Miller–Urey experiment.

22 September 2017 jeffreyw: An ignorant statement that natural gas is just methane.
Natural gas
Natural gas is a naturally occurring hydrocarbon gas mixture consisting primarily of methane, but commonly including varying amounts of other higher alkanes, and sometimes a small percentage of carbon dioxide, nitrogen, hydrogen sulfide, or helium.[2]

22 September 2017 jeffreyw: A lie that natural gas is found on Jupiter, Saturn, Neptune and Uranus.
Methane is found in the atmospheres of Jupiter, Saturn, Neptune and Uranus.

22 September 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that "seemingly abiogenic atmospheres such as Jupiter" contain methane from life.
Methane does not need life to be generated. Extraterrestrial methane
Methane has been detected or is believed to exist on all planets of the solar system and most of the larger moons. With the possible exception of Mars, it is believed to have come from abiotic processes.
Methane is also found in space: List of interstellar and circumstellar molecules
It is probable that some methane on Earth is abiotic, e.g. ABIOTIC METHANE ON EARTH

22 September 2017 jeffreyw: A lie of "is found deep in the interior crust".
Petroleum is found in the top of the Earth's outer crust. Petroleum has used for thousands of years with no drilling because it seeps onto the surface of the Earth. Drilling for oil is considered to have started in 1859 with the first drilled (not dug) well (Drake Well)

22 September 2017 jeffreyw: The dumb suggestion that anyone can confuse coal for petroleum.

22 September 2017 jeffreyw: The stupidity of life evolving in the atmospheres of stars where the temperature destroys complex molecules.

22 September 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion of "bacterial blooms that appear on evolved stars".
Evolved stars are white dwarfs, neutron stars and black holes.
 
Last edited:
So Jeffery,
If the sun is an average star, where does all the iron go when it transitions into a planet?

Most of the iron is lost due to CME's, flaring, photoevaporation, etc.

The iron (and nickel/heavy elements such as osmium/palladium/lead/uranium etc.) that doesn't escape sinks to the center, forming the core.

All evolved/dead stars have iron/nickel cores sparsed with heavier elements that are stable at higher temperatures (are refractory).

What this means is that at one point, Mercury was the same "solid" size as the Earth, as its iron/nickel core is comparable. Since the vast majority of its solid material has been stripped away, this means it was orbiting other host stars at extremely close distance. This is evidenced by many hundreds of close in exoplanets found.

Of course this answers immediately why Mercury's core is so big as compared to its overall mass. Unfortunately mainstream has to abandon their protoplanetary disk/nebular hypothesis as well as their assumption that Earth and Mercury and all the objects in the solar system are the same age. They're not.

Mercury is a dead star. Here is one of my very early papers... its the first time I think I use trillions of years. http://gsjournal.net/Science-Journals/Essays-Astrophysics/Download/4575 It is dated January 11, 2012, a full 4 months after I made the discovery.

Mercury is easily many tens of billions of years old. If not hundreds of billions... then you again, have to battle with the big bang creationists, because nothing in the universe is older than 13.7 billion years old.

They've conjectured themselves a big dead end. With careerism so prevalent, I wouldn't expect any insider to change their tune, this change will have to happen in the public sphere while letting the old guard die out. It should take a few decades, but once people wake up, that will be that.

Anyways, here is a video overviewing the mobility, volume and gravity principles of stellar metamorphosis.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pz-7oq2_HOo
 
Last edited:
hello Jefferyw,
So that is a lot of iron to have been ejected by CMEs or any other events.

If Mars is predominantly elements much lighter that iron, why would iron have left the star over the lighter elements?

Are you sure CMEs don't eject hydrogen?
 
hello Jefferyw,
So that is a lot of iron to have been ejected by CMEs or any other events.

If Mars is predominantly elements much lighter that iron, why would iron have left the star over the lighter elements?

Are you sure CMEs don't eject hydrogen?

All elements are ejected by stars that are in the Sun's stages of evolution.

Mars is differentiated like the Earth. It has a large iron/nickel core and a mantle. Its crust is a lot thicker as well, due to it cooling off and solidifying very deeply. Given its atmosphere has mostly depleted and its magnetic field has all but vanished, we can predict using stellar metamorphosis that it is a dead world, probably much, much older than the Earth. Not only that, but we can even determine how old Mars is by measuring the moment of inertia, which can be used to determine the size of its iron/nickel core. Given an iron core deposition rate of 8,200 years per meter depth, it took at least 14.76 billion years to form, completely tanking the big bang idea of the universe only being 13.7 billion years old.

The paper is here:

http://vixra.org/pdf/1707.0407v1.pdf

The majority of a star's early evolution involve it losing hydrogen/helium at much larger amounts than heavier elements.

The pattern is that the older you get, the higher the ratio of heavy elements are present as opposed to lighter ones. With the Sun being mostly hydrogen and helium, and the Earth being rock forming elements such as iron/nickel/silicon/sulfur/oxygen/carbon, etc, it is deduced that the Earth is way, way older than the Sun, which is a direct contradiction to the mainstream as well, in which the Earth formed with the same material as the Sun. Of course, it is strange that they still accept that the Earth formed from the Sun's material as the isotopic abundances are different. There is a rule of thumb with that as well, both are referenced below.

"The Principle of Diminishing Solar Abundances or The Solar Abundance Principle of Stellar Evolution".

http://vixra.org/pdf/1603.0422v1.pdf

"As stars evolve into rocky differentiated worlds, the ratio of lighter elements to heavy elements diminishes considerably."

The isotopic abundance paper to determine the ages of stars is also listed below:

http://vixra.org/pdf/1707.0205v1.pdf

It makes a firm prediction of the isotopic abundances concerning Juno's measurements of the Sun.

The O-16 abundances of Jupiter as opposed to O-17 and O-18 should be between 99.757% and 99.92%. Which are the Earth's and the Sun's oxygen isotopic abundances comparatively, but be slightly skewed towards the Sun because it is much younger than the Earth and closer to the Sun in age.
 
All elements are ejected by stars that are in the Sun's stages of evolution.

Mars is differentiated like the Earth. It has a large iron/nickel core and a mantle. Its crust is a lot thicker as well, due to it cooling off and solidifying very deeply. Given its atmosphere has mostly depleted and its magnetic field has all but vanished, we can predict using stellar metamorphosis that it is a dead world, probably much, much older than the Earth. Not only that, but we can even determine how old Mars is by measuring the moment of inertia, which can be used to determine the size of its iron/nickel core. Given an iron core deposition rate of 8,200 years per meter depth, it took at least 14.76 billion years to form, completely tanking the big bang idea of the universe only being 13.7 billion years old.

The paper is here:

http://vixra.org/pdf/1707.0407v1.pdf

The majority of a star's early evolution involve it losing hydrogen/helium at much larger amounts than heavier elements.

The pattern is that the older you get, the higher the ratio of heavy elements are present as opposed to lighter ones. With the Sun being mostly hydrogen and helium, and the Earth being rock forming elements such as iron/nickel/silicon/sulfur/oxygen/carbon, etc, it is deduced that the Earth is way, way older than the Sun, which is a direct contradiction to the mainstream as well, in which the Earth formed with the same material as the Sun. Of course, it is strange that they still accept that the Earth formed from the Sun's material as the isotopic abundances are different. There is a rule of thumb with that as well, both are referenced below.

"The Principle of Diminishing Solar Abundances or The Solar Abundance Principle of Stellar Evolution".

http://vixra.org/pdf/1603.0422v1.pdf

"As stars evolve into rocky differentiated worlds, the ratio of lighter elements to heavy elements diminishes considerably."

The isotopic abundance paper to determine the ages of stars is also listed below:

http://vixra.org/pdf/1707.0205v1.pdf

It makes a firm prediction of the isotopic abundances concerning Juno's measurements of the Sun.

The O-16 abundances of Jupiter as opposed to O-17 and O-18 should be between 99.757% and 99.92%. Which are the Earth's and the Sun's oxygen isotopic abundances comparatively, but be slightly skewed towards the Sun because it is much younger than the Earth and closer to the Sun in age.


Nope, using your example the ratio of 16O to 17O and 18O in the sun would be 99.92% to .04% to .04% respectively. While the terrestrial abundance of those are 99.757% to .038% to .205% respectively. So while the ratio of 16O to 18O would have changed considerably (about 1/5th or a factor of 5) the ratio of 16O to 17O would have changed hardly at all (less than 5% or a factor of .05). Your example doesn't work, you would get significantly different, by a couple of orders of magnitude, values for just the age of the Earth in comparisons to the sun.


As I don't think you just pulled the 99.92% and 99.757% (for 16O) out of your arse you should cite in your "paper" where you got those values from. A standard even grade school research papers are held to.

Myself, I got the terrestrial abundance values here...

http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.705.8807&rep=rep1&type=pdf

And here is a reference for the solar wind values.

http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/97JA02245/pdf



You will note table 1 where solar wind and solar energetic particle 16O to 18O ratios vary from well below terrestrial to well above. With some broad error ranges.
 
jeffreyw: Ignorant fantasies about stars

Most of the iron is lost due to CME's, flaring, photoevaporation, etc. ...
2 October 2017 jeffreyw: Ignorant fantasies about stars, e.g. CME's, flaring, photoevaporation, etc. do not get rid of 99.99% of a star or just iron :eye-poppi!

A main sequence star such as the Sun has a fairly uniform composition. We know this from astrophysics and because we can probe the Sun's internal structure using helioseismology.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: Ignorant delusion that stars have iron cores.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: Ignorant fantasy that "evolved/dead stars" have heavy element cores.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: Ignorant delusion that Mercury has had most of its solid matter magically stripped away.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: Ignorant delusionthat Mercury was orbiting other host stars.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: A lie that the size of the core of Mercury is explained by his delusions.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: A lie that delusions will make the mainstream abandon anything when the mainstream does not know about the delusions!

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: A lie that all the objects in the Solar System are assumed to have the same age.
We have measurements of the ages of objects in the Solar System having the same age.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: A lie that the objects in the Solar System have different ages when he has no measurements.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: The complete idiocy that any object in the universe has ages of trillions of years.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: The complete idiocy that Mercury is older than the universe.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: The stupidity of "big bang creationists" when there is enormous evidence for the Big Bang.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: The stupidity of "careerism" when there is enormous evidence for the Big Bang.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: Cites a crank YouTube video with ignorant delusions about planets being old stars, etc.
 
jeffreyw: Delusions about Mars crust and atmosphere, etc.

All elements are ejected by stars that are in the Sun's stages of evolution....
More fantasies and lies.
2 October 2017 jeffreyw: Delusions about the crust, atmosphere magnetic field, age, etc. of Mars.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: A lie that the age of Mars can be found from its moment of inertia.
Moment of inertia is not related to age. For planets, the moment of inertia factor "characterizes the radial distribution of mass inside a planet or satellite" and is constant.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: The idiocy that Mars is older than the universe.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: The persistent delusion that planets are old stars.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: A lie about the formation of the Earth which was not from the Sun!
The Solar System formed from a cloud of gases and some dust. When the Sun ignited it blew away most of the gases as we see in newly formed stars today. Anyone with even high school science knows that the composition of the Sun and Earth has to be different.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: A lie that an deluded PDF makes predictions.
The PDF has the idiocy of drawing a lying cartoon based on the ignorant delusion that planets are old stars.

2 October 2017 jeffreyw: The ignorant delusion that Jupiter is much younger than the Earth.
 
Last edited:
Given an iron core deposition rate of 8,200 years per meter depth, it took at least 14.76 billion years to form, completely tanking the big bang idea of the universe only being 13.7 billion years old.

So you are saying that Mars did not form in the solar system, I forgot.
 
And here is a reference for the solar wind values.

http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/97JA02245/pdf
The abstract makes the range of the ratio and match to terrestrial values explicit:
Abstract. Measurements of the 160 and 180 distribution functions in the solar wind at low to average solar wind speeds from the MASS instrument on the Wind spacecraft are reported The 16O/18O density ratio is 450 +/- 130, a value consistent with terrestrial, solar photospheric, solar energetic particle, and galactic cosmic ray 16O/18O isotopic ratios. This study constitutes the first reported spacecraft measurement of the isotope 180 in the core solar wind and may represent the best determination of the solar 16O/18O density ratio to date.
 
So you are saying that Mars did not form in the solar system, I forgot.

None of them did in this theory, the "solar system" is a system of independent objects. They are all in different stages to their own evolution, and were adopted by the Sun.

As well, the objects that orbit the intermediate aged stars, Jupiter and Saturn, were also adopted by Jupiter and Saturn. So in essence we live in a multiple star system, star system.

A facet to the worldview that is being replaced is that it is assumed the solar system is a singular body. It is not. It is composed of thousands of separate bodies.

Astronomers have an outdated worldview, that has been outdated since the 1920's. The Great Debate is centered on why this is the case. It was assumed that the observed disk nebulas in the sky were forming solar systems. When Hubble found out they were entire galaxies, some people forgot to change their worldview.

If the disks are actual galaxies, with billions of stars, and not forming solar systems, then why did they keep the idea that the solar system was formed from a disk? Habit. Literature. Repetition. Not only that, but it was accepted that the Earth and the Sun were around the same age. They're not anywhere near the same age. Not only that, but they didn't even form from the same cloud.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/earth-has-water-older-than-the-sun/

Their problem is with isotopic abundances. They don't match. If the Earth formed from the same material as the Sun, they would match. They don't though. There's a higher concentration of O-16 in the Sun than on Earth.

That is overviewed in this paper:

http://vixra.org/pdf/1707.0205v1.pdf

I also miss-spelled isotopic. Ha. I have it as isotropic.
 
Or maybe your "theory" is flawed?

It has some flaws I'll admit. I really have to nail the Goldich Dissolution Series, during water world stages of stellar evolution. I've been neglecting that. Oh and Marklund convection, that's essentially completely ignored in the literature. Its wild how two processes that are central to stellar evolution are ignored.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: The delusion that the Solar System is made up of independent objects

None of them did in this theory, the "solar system" is a system of independent objects.
Starts with the "solar system" delusion that there is not a set of objects (system) around the Sun (Sol) wgich we call the Solar System :p
5 October 2017 jeffreyw: The delusion that the Solar System is made up of independent objects.
Children know that the Solar System is made up of related objects. All of the planets orbit in about the same plane. All of the planets orbit in the same directions. There is a distinction between the inner rocky planets and the outer gas planets. There is the asteroid belt. There is the Kuiper belt. There is the Oort cloud.

5 October 2017 jeffreyw: The persistent and ignorant delusion that planets and moons are old stars.

5 October 2017 jeffreyw: A lie that his delusions are replacing anything.

5 October 2017 jeffreyw: A double lie that the Solar System is "assumed" to be a "singular body".
There is evidence on the origin and structure of the Solar System which is and has always been many bodies.

5 October 2017 jeffreyw: Insults astronomers who have an modern, up to date worldview.

5 October 2017 jeffreyw: Lies about the Great Debate in the 1920's.
The Great Debate on 26 April 1920 was whether spiral nebulae were inside the Milky way or outside the Milky Way. Spiral nebula were never considered to be "forming solar systems". They were and still are collections of stars.

5 October 2017 jeffreyw: Repeats the "spiral nebulae" are solar systems lie.

5 October 2017 jeffreyw: "Habit. Literature. Repetition" idiocy.

5 October 2017 jeffreyw: A lie that the ages of the Sun and Earth are accepted when they are measured.

5 October 2017 jeffreyw: Lies about a Scientific American article on the age of water on Earth.
This is not his lie of a comparison between the composition of the Earth and Sun.
Earth Has Water Older Than the Sun
By reconstructing conditions in the disk of gas and dust in which the Solar System formed, scientists have concluded that the Earth and other planets must have inherited much of their water from the cloud of gas from which the Sun was born 4.6 billion years ago, instead of forming later. The authors say that such interstellar water would also be included in the formation of most other stellar systems, and perhaps of other Earth-like planets.

The dense interstellar clouds of gas and dust where stars form contain abundant water, in the form of ice. When a star first lights up, it heats up the cloud around it and floods it with radiation, vaporizing the ice and breaking up some of the water molecules into oxygen and hydrogen.

Until now, researchers were unsure how much of the 'old' water would be spared in this process.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: Idiocy that the Goldich dissolution series is relevant

It has some flaws I'll admit. ...
5 October 2017 jeffreyw: Idiocy that the Goldich dissolution series has something to do with his deluded stellar evolution.
Goldich dissolution series
The Goldich dissolution series is a way of predicting the relative stability or weathering rate of various minerals on the Earth's surface. S. S. Goldich came up with the series in 1938[1] after studying soil profiles. He found that minerals that form at higher temperatures and pressures are less stable on the surface than minerals that form at lower temperatures and pressures.[2] This pattern follows the same pattern of the Bowen's reaction series, with the minerals that are first to crystallize also the first the undergo chemical weathering.
This is geology specific to the Earth perhaps with applications to planets with atmospheres (and thus weathering) once we have samples to establish the series.

5 October 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that Marklund convection is central to his deluded stellar evolution.
Marklund convection is a very minor proposed process in plasma filaments. Stars are not plasma filaments :jaw-dropp!
35 abstracts reported by ADS show how very minor the convection is. About half of these are co-authored by Marklund. None of these are for the body of stars (the closest is solar flares). I can see no actual measurements of Marklund convection.

My conclusion: A credible, minor and irrelevant possible phenomena in plasma filaments.

5 October 2017 jeffreyw: Delusion of "water worlds" when there are no such things.
This may be a delusion that gas giants that look blue are covered in water.

4 October 2017 jeffreyw: Delusion of "water world stages of stellar evolution" when stars never form planets.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom