The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis

It has some flaws I'll admit. I really have to nail the Goldich Dissolution Series, during water world stages of stellar evolution. I've been neglecting that. Oh and Marklund convection, that's essentially completely ignored in the literature. Its wild how two processes that are central to stellar evolution are ignored.


Nope, not "completely ignored in the literature."


http://www.gly.uga.edu/railsback/Fundamentals/8150Goldich&BondStreng06LS.pdf

https://www.google.com/search?q=Gol...hUBxCYKHZjbDToQ9QEIMTAC#imgrc=NJKOxd41lofz5M:

https://books.google.com/books?id=2...=onepage&q=Goldich Dissolution Series&f=false


https://books.google.com/books?id=w...g6MAU#v=onepage&q=Marklund convection&f=false

https://books.google.com/books?id=_...gyMAM#v=onepage&q=Marklund convection&f=false


The ignorance remains simply yours.
 
None of them did in this theory, the "solar system" is a system of independent objects. They are all in different stages to their own evolution, and were adopted by the Sun.

As well, the objects that orbit the intermediate aged stars, Jupiter and Saturn, were also adopted by Jupiter and Saturn. So in essence we live in a multiple star system, star system.

A facet to the worldview that is being replaced is that it is assumed the solar system is a singular body. It is not. It is composed of thousands of separate bodies.

Astronomers have an outdated worldview, that has been outdated since the 1920's. The Great Debate is centered on why this is the case. It was assumed that the observed disk nebulas in the sky were forming solar systems. When Hubble found out they were entire galaxies, some people forgot to change their worldview.

If the disks are actual galaxies, with billions of stars, and not forming solar systems, then why did they keep the idea that the solar system was formed from a disk? Habit. Literature. Repetition. Not only that, but it was accepted that the Earth and the Sun were around the same age. They're not anywhere near the same age. Not only that, but they didn't even form from the same cloud.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/earth-has-water-older-than-the-sun/

Their problem is with isotopic abundances. They don't match. If the Earth formed from the same material as the Sun, they would match. They don't though. There's a higher concentration of O-16 in the Sun than on Earth.

That is overviewed in this paper:

http://vixra.org/pdf/1707.0205v1.pdf

I also miss-spelled isotopic. Ha. I have it as isotropic.

You also missed that your example does not work.

The article your reference actually asserts the deuterium abundance as a hold over form the nebular cloud. That's deuterium mind you, making heavy water. A result of heavy hydrogen not heavy oxygen.
 
You also missed that your example does not work.

The article your reference actually asserts the deuterium abundance as a hold over form the nebular cloud. That's deuterium mind you, making heavy water. A result of heavy hydrogen not heavy oxygen.

https://genesismission.jpl.nasa.gov/gm2/news/features/isotopes.htm

It is oxygen abundances too. Heavy hydrogen and heavy oxygen. The ratios are off, which means the Earth and the Sun did not form from the same cloud.

This is predicted by stellar metamorphosis, as Earth is the remains of a star vastly older than the Sun.
 

You're not realizing what is happening here. I am explaining the differentiation process of the internal regions of a star as it differentiates itself internally, by applying the Goldich Dissolution Series to star evolution.

It is ignored in the literature in the sense that no astrophysics books, in all the universities on the Earth mention it. It is 100% ignored in 100% of the literature except my own.

Which brings us directly back to square one. We are dealing with the realization that geophysics IS astrophysics. Stars cool, die and evolve, differentiating their interiors becoming "planets". They were never mutually exclusive. Geology is the study of the Earth, and since Earth is an ancient star, the study of the Earth is astrophysical. The worldview of Earth being independent of the galaxy is an outdated one, it is only one of hundreds of billions. It is not special by any means, simply because we live here. I mean, it may be special to us, but there are hundreds of billions of them in all different stages of evolution, so its just another fish in the ocean.

It is especially wild because they say that planet formation cannot be witnessed, and if it can its in a disk. Which is horrendously outdated. The difference is that the differentiation process is internal, so that means we can only view the external properties and then infer and reverse engineer based on the Earth's and other much older star's characteristics.

Those little dots in the night sky aren't light bulbs, they are new, big, hot planets.
snip.JPG


The theory is very, very large, and it needs lots more work done. Unfortunately it also makes many people upset because their worldview is being challenged. So the nasty behavior is expected really.
 
Last edited:
You think there are rocks on the Sun?

No, the star cools, dies and differentiates itself while losing mass over many billions of years, becoming a "planet". This means planet formation is stellar evolution. Or stated differently, stars have never been mutually exclusive objects of planets. They are the same objects, only in different stages to their evolution. The really old stars that have combined their elements into molecules (rocks) are called "planets". The really young, hot planets are still called "stars", and are mostly at the highest enthalpy, which is called plasma.

The really young stars like the Sun do not have rocks. They become differentiated worlds with giant iron/nickel cores with rocky layers as they evolve.

The problem for new folks that come here is this: Astronomers assumed the hot, big planets were something else. They called them "stars" because of the fact that they appear different.

So appearances have deceived them.

The truth is that young planets are really big, hot and bright.

They have separated the most massive, populous celestial objects in space into two distinct categories. When in fact, the categories were ad hoc.

Stars as we know them are simply hot, young planets, and planets as we know them are simply cool, old, highly evolved stars. They are conceptually the same objects.

If we want to see what young planets look like, all we have to do is look up on a clear dark night... or if you have welder's glasses you can see one during the day, given it is a cloudless afternoon.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: A delsuiuon the Sun and Earth did not form from the same cloud

https://genesismission.jpl.nasa.gov/gm2/news/features/isotopes.htm

It is oxygen abundances too. Heavy hydrogen and heavy oxygen. The ratios are off, which means the Earth and the Sun did not form from the same cloud.

This is predicted by stellar metamorphosis, as Earth is the remains of a star vastly older than the Sun.
What Are Isotopes, and Why Should We Care?
Followed by:
6 October 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that different isotope abundances between the Sun and Earth means that did not they form from the same cloud.
He links to the Genesis project where
And Genesis scientists are hard at work determining the isotopic composition of the Sun to help solve the puzzle of how the planets began to form out of a cloud of gas and dust
The entire Solar System formed from the same cloud because it is physically impossible for the Sun to have collected the planets especially with asteroids and other objects after formation as we observe them.

6 October 2017 jeffreyw: A lie that his delusions predict anything, including isotope abundances.
 
jeffreyw: A inane delusion about weathering on the Earth's surface

You're not realizing what is happening here.
We do know what is happing here. You are digging deeper into a pit of ignorant delusions that high school science students know are wrong and stating complete delusions about irrelevant science.
6 October 2017 jeffreyw: A inane and abysmally ignorant delusion that weathering on the Earth's surface applies to the interiors of stars.

5 October 2017 jeffreyw: Idiocy that the Goldich dissolution series has something to do with his deluded stellar evolution.

6 October 2017 jeffreyw: The delusion that astronomers are so stupid that they think that the interior of stars are the surface of the Earth!
Astrophysics ignores geology because stars are balls of plasma, not balls of rock :eye-poppi.
Astrophysics specifically ignores the Goldich dissolution series because stars are not balls of rock surrounded by atmospheres with chemical weathering :jaw-dropp!
Next we will have the delusion that astrophysics it wrong because it ignores the equally irrelevant human immune system!

6 October 2017 jeffreyw: The ignorant delusion that "geophysics IS astrophysics" from stars becoming planets stupidity.

6 October 2017 jeffreyw: A lie abut the Earth being an ancient star (it is a planet younger than the Sun).

6 October 2017 jeffreyw: A fantasy of a "worldview of Earth being independent of the galaxy".
Earth being a special place was discarded abut 400 years ago (Copernicus, etc.). That has been a fundamental postulate in science for centuries.

6 October 2017 jeffreyw: A lie that planet formation cannot be observed when we have observed it!
The truth is that planet formation does not happen on timescales that we can observe it from starts to finish in a single system. We have observed the stages of planet formation in systems with different ages from new stars pushing gas away from them to new planets clearing their orbits.

6 October 2017 jeffreyw: A "horrendously outdated" lie when the models of planet formation are up to date.

6 October 2017 jeffreyw: Still thinks an idiotic and lying cartoon is valid scientific evidence.

6 October 2017 jeffreyw: Thinks people pointing out that he has obviously ignorant, wrong and deluded ideas makes it "nasty".
We are not upset by yet another Internet crank spouting ignorant and deluded fantasies. Plenty of these ignorant people have popped up here. There is even a wiki listing then and here you are: Jeffrey Wolynski
Jeffrey J. Wolynski (born 1984) is an obscure, scarcely known physics crank. Despite his exaggerated claims, he's virtually unknown to mainstream physics, and the only people who take him seriously are other wannabe physicists, conspiracy theorists, UFO nuts, Nibiru believers, Electric Universe, and aetherometry proponents.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: Repeats ignorant delusions about stars.

6 October 2017 jeffreyw: Repeats ignorant delusions about stars including being ignorant about his delusions :eye-poppi!
He cannot understand that his delusion means that stars do not have rock and so geology is irrelevant until they become "planets" with rocks and geology! Thus it is idiotic to apply the physics of the chemical weathering of the surfaces of balls of rock to balls to plasma (stars).

6 October 2017 jeffreyw: Abysmal ignorance of plasma which is a not label for "highest enthalpy".
Plasma is a gas that has a physically significant proportion of ions.

6 October 2017 jeffreyw: 2 lies that young planets are "really big, hot and bright".
Planets have a single size whether young or old, e.g. the Earth has been the same size for 4.6 billion years.
Planets only reflect light so their brightness depends mainly on their distance from their star.

6 October 2017 jeffreyw: The usual lie that astronomers assume.
6 October 2017 jeffreyw: The idiocy that stars only "appear" different from planets - they are physically different, e.g. emit their own light.

6 October 2017 jeffreyw: A "They have separated the most massive, populous celestial objects in space into two distinct categories" lie.
Stars are the most massive (hundreds of thousands of time more massive than planets), populous celestial objects in space. They are separated into dozens of spectral types.
Planets are the light, may be slightly more populous than stars (Like the Caltech group, other teams of astronomers have estimated that there is roughly one planet per star) celestial objects in space. As for population: moons outnumber planets, asteroids outnumber planets, trillions of Oort cloud objects outnumber planets :eye-poppi!

6 October 2017 jeffreyw: An abysmally ignorant lie that the difference between planets and stars is adhoc.
This is a planet. This is a star. They have definitions based on their physical properties, e.g. stars have fusion, planets do not.
 
https://genesismission.jpl.nasa.gov/gm2/news/features/isotopes.htm

It is oxygen abundances too. Heavy hydrogen and heavy oxygen. The ratios are off, which means the Earth and the Sun did not form from the same cloud.

Nope, it doesn't. The very article you cited asserted that. Citing articles that actuality oppose your fundamental claims is either lazy, ignorant or both.


This is predicted by stellar metamorphosis, as Earth is the remains of a star vastly older than the Sun.

Again, your own example doesn't even support what you claim '"is predicted by stellar metamorphosis" changes in abundance ratios according to weight.
 
You're not realizing what is happening here. I am explaining the differentiation process of the internal regions of a star as it differentiates itself internally, by applying the Goldich Dissolution Series to star evolution.
.

Nope, it,s just that "You,re not realizing what is happening here", your own cited article and your own example don't support your claims.

It is ignored in the literature in the sense that no astrophysics books, in all the universities on the Earth mention it. It is 100% ignored in 100% of the literature except my own.

As noted above even you ignore your own "literature". By all means please let us know when you can get your own citations and examples to agree with your own "literature".

Which brings us directly back to square one. We are dealing with the realization that geophysics IS astrophysics. Stars cool, die and evolve, differentiating their interiors becoming "planets". They were never mutually exclusive. Geology is the study of the Earth, and since Earth is an ancient star, the study of the Earth is astrophysical. The worldview of Earth being independent of the galaxy is an outdated one, it is only one of hundreds of billions. It is not special by any means, simply because we live here. I mean, it may be special to us, but there are hundreds of billions of them in all different stages of evolution, so its just another fish in the ocean.

It is especially wild because they say that planet formation cannot be witnessed, and if it can its in a disk. Which is horrendously outdated. The difference is that the differentiation process is internal, so that means we can only view the external properties and then infer and reverse engineer based on the Earth's and other much older star's characteristics.

Those little dots in the night sky aren't light bulbs, they are new, big, hot planets. [qimg]https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-Fa-snj_YZxc/WMGzhbALqBI/AAAAAAAAAYg/ks__VdicI0M1UWM1bCJz_jCehk_fv6_DwCLcB/s1600/snip.JPG[/qimg]

The theory is very, very large, and it needs lots more work done. Unfortunately it also makes many people upset because their worldview is being challenged. So the nasty behavior is expected really.


Why you expect yourself to be nasty or upset is of little concern. However, if you can't even be bothered to apply your own claims to your own citations and examples such that they fundamentally agree with rather than refute those claims. Then both "The theory", your own understanding of it and how you go about actually applying it, needs some serious work. That work relating to your understanding of it and how you go about actually applying it unfortunately, is work you must primarily do. People here are certainly willing and trying to help but it still remains up to you to accept and actually apply such help. Heck, as far as I'm concerned you can be as upset or nasty as you are able or please, if you just accept and actually apply the help being given.
 
Edited by Agatha: 
Do not discuss your ignore list. Doing so is a breach or rule 0, rule 11 and rule 12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yes, arguing and pointing out flaws is how science works. But then, you are not doing science.
You are preaching, and noone is good like preachers at ignoring actual well written opposition. Hence your liberal use of the ignore feature. Pretty soon everyone you see in this thread will agree with you, and they will all be called Jeffryw.
 
Edited by Agatha: 
Do not discuss your ignore list. Doing so is a breach or rule 0, rule 11 and rule 12.


Asserting (evidently) expanded deliberate ignorance won't help you with the "lots more work" that you at least don't entirely ignore.

Bemoaning how people won't help you while (again evidently) ignoring those who do try to help you, apparently simply because you don't like the implications of that help, indicates it is primarily you who just won't help you.
 
Asserting (evidently) expanded deliberate ignorance won't help you with the "lots more work" that you at least don't entirely ignore.

Bemoaning how people won't help you while (again evidently) ignoring those who do try to help you, apparently simply because you don't like the implications of that help, indicates it is primarily you who just won't help you.
Quoted for truth, and for the benefit of those wilfully ignoring it.
 
In JW's universe, are there any old stars (planets) with young stars orbiting them. Say an Earth being orbited by the sun? If not, how do these old stars know to find a young star and slip into the ecliptic?
 
In JW's universe, stellar systems are sets of randomly collected objects (so the Solar System does not exist :eek:!) so some of them would be a planet orbited by a star. However that is the same as a star orbited by a planet - just a swap of reference frames.
The "slip into the ecliptic" magic is one real world fact that makes his idea into a delusion.
Add his delusion that rocky planets are older than gas giants and we have these random collected planets also magically sorting by age.
Add asteroids (and a delusion that they must be trillions of years old?), and they also magically slide between Mars and Jupiter.
Add Kuiper Belt objects (and a delusion that they must be tens of trillions of years old?).
Add Oort Cloud objects!
And what about dust?
 
It has been over a month since JW last posted. I bet he's reviewing the whole thread and writing responses to all the questions asked of him and finally working out all the mathematics needed to support his ground star breaking theory.

Or he's just making videos in his car rehashing his bare assertions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom