Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Great so given such considerations the addition of gas drag can be sufficient to lift and separate the particles.

So you knew this was BS...




when you posted it or you found out later?

Gas drag in this instance is in the same basket as gravity.


Did you not happen to notice the dust is charged?

Would you not wonder all the whats's and hows that goes along with charged dust in a dusty plasma in a plasma stream?
 
Last edited:
And :confused:you've got a bit a paper somewheres says you're a smart cookie?

We could ask more questions, no?

You are not asking questions, you are giving a list of random quotes about dust, possibly charged.
This is your modus operandi, you throw in stuff and you want us to explain it to you, so that you can misinterpret it all into validation of a non-existing electric comet idea.
So, yes, you can ask all the questions you want, but that's not what you are doing, you are making "claims".
 
Gas drag in this instance is in the same basket as gravity.

Technically they would be opposing baskets as gravity would oppose the effects of gas drag.

Did you not happen to notice the dust is charged?

Yep, I noticed and even specifically remarked on some of the effects of such charging. Heck, I did that even in what you just quoted.

Would you not wonder all the whats's and hows that goes along with charged dust in a dusty plasma in a plasma stream?

Again, I noted some of those "whats's and hows" specifically relating to the cohesion forces noted in the paper you cited before.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: An insult that tusenfem has "a bit a paper somewhere"

And :confused:you've got a bit a paper somewheres says you're a smart cookie?
11 October 2017 Sol88: An insult that tusenfem has "a bit a paper somewhere" saying that he is a smart cookie.
tusenfem is a smart cookie because there is evidence in this thread that Sol88 has read that tusenfem has written at least 1 scientific paper (thus the insult). In addition, tusenfem has given Sol88 clear explanations of the physics of comets.

No one needs to be smart to know that Sol88 is blindly parroting ignorant comet delusions from his totally deluded cult. All one needs is the ability to read numbers and read science! After 8 years, Sol88 has still in denial of basic arithmetic, i.e. that 0.6 g/cc (average comet density) is not 3.0 g/cc (average asteroid density).
 
Sol88: Irrelevant idiocy about gas drag + gravity etc.

Gas drag in this instance is in the same basket as gravity. ...
11 October 2017 Sol88: Irrelevant idiocy about gas drag + gravity + dust + dusty plasma + a plasma stream.

That idiocy shows:
11 October 2017 Sol88: Abysmal ignorance about his comet delusions which have nothing to do with this post.
No totally insane delusion that comets are rocks blasted from the Earth by electrical discharges when other planets wandered by including recently.
No abysmally ignorant delusion that comet jets are electrical discharges between the comet nucleus and the Sun.
 

how does this fit with the "dirtysnowball" dust and ice model? :rolleyes:

Specifically the "jets".

it's pretty bloody obvious that the well consolidated material on a comet is in fact rock with no surface ice!

and in fact this is the direction REAL scientist are taking, which leaves the no working model!

Which model are the REAL scientist now working from Tusenfem?
 
Sol88: Usual inane attempt to derail form his comet delusions

16 October 2017 Sol88: Usual inane attempt to derail from his comet delusions.

16 October 2017 Sol88: Repeats 8 years of the insanely ignorant delusion that comets are rock.

16 October 2017 Sol88: A lie about any scientists believing in his comet delusions.

16 October 2017 Sol88: The idiocy from the last months that the descriptive name of a model is the model itself.
 
Last edited:
Conclusions We performed simple simulation of Philae on 67P/Churyumov Gerasimenko using generic parameters for the comet composition that would have to be re.ned using the results of the ongoing experiments to accurately model the environment of Philae. Nonetheless, our purpose was to investigate the effect of the electrostatic charging of the dust grains on their interaction with Philae. We showed that even if the dominant dust production mechanism is the ejection of neutral dust caused by the sublimation of volatile material in the soil, the subsequent charging of the dust increased the dust collection by about an order of magnitude. This is an important effect that should be taken into account to interpret Philae's dust measurements.

So what happen the dust after it is charged?

is the sublimation of "ice" the primary driver?
 
Sol88: Usual inane attempt to derail from his comet delusions

16 October 2017 Sol88: Usual inane attempt to derail from his comet delusions with a random quote and highlight

For others:
The paper from 2015 about comets made of ices and dust models mechanisms for the ejection of dust from the surface of an ices and dust nucleus specifically for the environment around the Philae lander and collecting on the Philae lander.
  • Neutral dust blown off the surface onto Philae by the sublimation of volatile material in the soil.
  • Electrostatically charged dust (not Sol88's comet delusions) blown off the surface onto Philae by the charge between the grains and the surface which is at least partially caused by Philae.
This is dust traveling from the soil to the to the various surfaces of Philae, e.g. its solar panels.
Simulation of the electrostatic charging of Philae on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko and of its interaction with the dusts.
ROSETTA's probe Philae landed on a dust covered soil. This dust may be ejected from the ground through many mechanisms (other than spacecraft landing) : micro-meteorite impacts, electrostatic charging and soil outgassing. In any cases, the dust grains charge electrostatically in the ambient plasma and this charge impacts the dust interaction with the spacecraft, which is itself differentially charged due to its partial exposure to the solar UV light. Using the DUST addition to the Spacecraft-Plasma Interaction Software (SPIS) routinely used to compute the charge state of the spacecraft surfaces, we simulate the electrostatic charging of Philae as well as its dust environment. SPIS-DUST allows one to compute the electrostatic charging of the dust grains on the ground and in the plasma, and to model their ejection and their recollection by the probe. We simulated one cometary day of the Philae environment at different distances from the sun to observe the variation of the dust collection with Philae's local time.
 
Last edited:
This article popped up a few days ago, and is somewhat related to recent discussions:

Rosetta finds comet plume powered from below
http://www.esa.int/Our_Activities/Space_Science/Rosetta/Rosetta_finds_comet_plume_powered_from_below

Last year, a fountain of dust was spotted streaming from Rosetta’s comet, prompting the question: how was it powered? Scientists now suggest the outburst was driven from inside the comet, perhaps released from ancient gas vents or pockets of hidden ice.
<snip>
Alongside a steep increase in the number of dust particles flowing from the comet, Rosetta also detected tiny grains of water-ice.

There is free access paper describing the event:

Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03
Agarwal, J. et al
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/arti...idence-of-sub-surface-energy-storage-in-comet

So, they are essentially saying the same as Skorov, in a paper mentioned upthread, that freely sublimating ice from the surface cannot have shifted so much dust into the coma, and there has to be something else powering the outburst. This mechanism has always been seen as a likelihood at comets, but obviously isn't the only one.
 
That dust jet image is now an APOD: A Dust Jet from the Surface of Comet 67P (Astronomy Picture of the Day for 2017 November 6)

ETA: The ESA blog links to the 1 July 2015 article Comet sinkholes generate jets
A number of the dust jets emerging from Rosetta’s comet can be traced back to active pits that were likely formed by a sudden collapse of the surface. These ‘sinkholes’ are providing a glimpse at the chaotic and diverse interior of the comet.

Rosetta has been monitoring Comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko’s activity for over a year, watching how its halo of dust and gas grows as the comet moves closer to the Sun along its orbit.

From a distance of a few hundred kilometres, Rosetta observes an intricate pattern of the dust jets emitted from the nucleus as they stream out into space. But now, thanks to high-resolution images from the OSIRIS camera from distances of just 10–30 km from the comet centre last year, at least some of these dust jets can be traced back to specific locations on the surface, the first time this has ever been seen.
That gives at least 3 physically credible mechanisms to blast dust from comet nuclei.
  1. Pressurized gas bubbles venting via existing vents.
  2. Exposure of stores of ice.
  3. Collapsing surface layers forming sinkholes releasing volatiles and exposing ices (a combination of the above 2 mechanisms).
 
Last edited:
For information on the presentations of the current Rosetta SWT meeting follow @Philae_MUPUS on twitter.
 
For information on the presentations of the current Rosetta SWT meeting follow @Philae_MUPUS on twitter.

Thanks, Tus. I did follow it. Very interesting. Wish I could have been there. To hear about all the electric woo! What didn't happen. Hey ho.
 
This article popped up a few days ago, and is somewhat related to recent discussions:

Rosetta finds comet plume powered from below
http://www.esa.int/Our_Activities/Space_Science/Rosetta/Rosetta_finds_comet_plume_powered_from_below



There is free access paper describing the event:

Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03
Agarwal, J. et al
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/arti...idence-of-sub-surface-energy-storage-in-comet

So, they are essentially saying the same as Skorov, in a paper mentioned upthread, that freely sublimating ice from the surface cannot have shifted so much dust into the coma, and there has to be something else powering the outburst. This mechanism has always been seen as a likelihood at comets, but obviously isn't the only one.

“Curiouser and curiouser!” :D
 
This article popped up a few days ago, and is somewhat related to recent discussions:

Rosetta finds comet plume powered from below
http://www.esa.int/Our_Activities/Space_Science/Rosetta/Rosetta_finds_comet_plume_powered_from_below



There is free access paper describing the event:

Evidence of sub-surface energy storage in comet 67P from the outburst of 2016 July 03
Agarwal, J. et al
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/arti...idence-of-sub-surface-energy-storage-in-comet

So, they are essentially saying the same as Skorov, in a paper mentioned upthread, that freely sublimating ice from the surface cannot have shifted so much dust into the coma, and there has to be something else powering the outburst. This mechanism has always been seen as a likelihood at comets, but obviously isn't the only one.

Ahhh I see the problem! :rolleyes:

have the authors of the above paper talked to the authors of these papers?

No mention of charge, plasma, electrostatic just SUBLIMATION :jaw-dropp ho hum

Shakes head, again.

Dusty Plasma, people, look it up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom