Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
??what "we" do believe in is hidden pockets of ice and gas!

Ask Tusenfem, is the "dirty snowball" a valid model still?
 
It is really very sad to see an electric comet woo believer reduced to having to rely upon electrostatic levitation (which will not work with these grain sizes), after all the promises and predictions of a certain David Talbott. Pathetic. N'est-ce pas?
 
??what "we" do believe in is hidden pockets of ice and gas!

Ask Tusenfem, is the "dirty snowball" a valid model still?

Sorry? Ask the fraudster Thornhill if his electric comet woo is still valid. Yes? Please present the evidence if you think it is.
 
Let me just leave this here, for the hard of thinking; guess what? Ice was ejected from Tempel 1 by the impact of a copper projectile. Yes? Ice was seen being entrained by CO2 jets at Hartley 2. There are some very pretty photos of such, if one cares to seek them out. Ice has been seen numerous times at 67P. Including subsurface after a landslide.
Bizarrely, some cretins would have you believe that all this ice is make believe, and we must head off into the world of woo to understand what is going on!
Errrrr, no. That garbage is long over. They lost. End of story. Bon Soir.
 
Sol88: Another lie in a question to derail from his comet delusions

Ask Tusenfem, is the "dirty snowball" a valid model still?
Continued "hidden pockets of ice and gas" idiocy followed by
15 November 2017 Sol88: Another lie in a question to derail from his comet delusions.

Nothing in the last 60 years has shown that comets are not made of ices and dust. Thus the "dirty snowball" model of comets made of ices and dust is still valid. What has changed is that we have expanded the model to cover a wider range of ices to dust ratios because that is what we have observed. This does not include Sol88 and his cult delusion of no ices at all or comets are rocks (the least of their delusions about comets).
 
Thank you Tusenfem.

We are on the same page!

When can we read your tail excursion paper?

I doubt we are on the same page, because I still have no idea what "complex plasmas" are, and you apparently are not going to define that.

The tail excursion was submitted three weeks ago.
 
Continued "hidden pockets of ice and gas" idiocy followed by
15 November 2017 Sol88: Another lie in a question to derail from his comet delusions.

Nothing in the last 60 years has shown that comets are not made of ices and dust. Thus the "dirty snowball" model of comets made of ices and dust is still valid. What has changed is that we have expanded the model to cover a wider range of ices to dust ratios because that is what we have observed. This does not include Sol88 and his cult delusion of no ices at all or comets are rocks (the least of their delusions about comets).

Reality Check, please contact Samuel P. D. Birch,1‹ Y. Tang,2 A. G. Hayes,1,2 R. L. Kirk,3 D. Bodewits,4 H. Campins,5 Y. Fernandez,5 R. de Freitas Bart,2 N. W. Kutsop,2 H. Sierks,6
J. M. Soderblom,7 S. W. Squyres1,2 and J-B. Vincent6,8
and tell them they are incorrect.

The surface of 67P/C-G is generally broken into rough and smooth terrains (e.g. Auger et al. 2015; La Forgia et al. 2015; Giacomini et al. 2016; Pajola et al. 2016b). The rough terrain is predominantly exposed bedrock, while the smooth terrain repre- sents disaggregated, transported remnants of formerly consolidated bedrock (Sierks et al. 2015).
Geomorphology of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Bedrock is not fluffy dustyiceysomething with, what 75% porosity.

Seems you’ve got it wrong again.
 
Last edited:
I doubt we are on the same page, because I still have no idea what "complex plasmas" are, and you apparently are not going to define that.

The tail excursion was submitted three weeks ago.

May we have a link, please?

Does the plasma around the comet contain dust?

Tip

What is Complex Plasma?

Plasma, the fourth state of matter, is consisted of neutrals, ions (positively charged) and electrons (negatively charged). The neutrals and the ions are relatively bigger and heavier. So they tend to be less mobile. On the other hand, the electrons are relatively smaller and lighter. So they tend to be highly mobile. If we introduce dust particles (directly or chemically with the use of reactive gases) into plasma, the electrons will interact and charge up the dust particle. The dust will then levitate above a confinement electrode due to the balance of electric force and gravitational force. This is the story of the making of complex plasma.

Different people use different names for complex plasma, such as dusty plasma, plasma crystals, colloidal crystals, fine particle plasma, coulomb crystal, etc.
Because the dust particle are highly negatively charged, their presence will dramatically change the properties of the plasma. So complex plasma give us a unique opportunity to study strongly coupled system.

Moreover, unlike classical plasma system where we consider the charge to be constant on each particle, the charge of the dust particles in complex plasma system varies with time and position. And so complex plasma opens up an unexplored and facinating field in plasma physics.

Knock yourself out champ!
 
Last edited:
Let me just leave this here, for the hard of thinking; guess what? Ice was ejected from Tempel 1 by the impact of a copper projectile. Yes? Ice was seen being entrained by CO2 jets at Hartley 2. There are some very pretty photos of such, if one cares to seek them out. Ice has been seen numerous times at 67P. Including subsurface after a landslide.
Bizarrely, some cretins would have you believe that all this ice is make believe, and we must head off into the world of woo to understand what is going on!
Errrrr, no. That garbage is long over. They lost. End of story. Bon Soir.

Ha ha ha...ice :blush:
 
Why are we still talking about this nonsense? For most sane people, 2+ years at the comet, with a whole suite of instruments, and nary a sign of any of the electric woo predicted by David Talbott, would be enough to end the discussion of this scientifically impossible woo. I guess it's a demonstration of how strong faith can be in some people.
 
And, if I remember correctly, Sol has still yet to give us a mechanism for this outburst. So what are we even discussing?
 
Ha ha ha...ice

Yep, ice.

snowstorm_strip.jpg


f-rosetta-a-20170323.jpg


Plenty of ice, and too many papers to list. They've all been linked before, anyway. Yet still not the tiniest indication of any electric woo.
 
Cheese Shop.

It's important to keep the thread churning, while people reply there is life in the place and it justifies his position.

Standard CT tactic, see any 9/11 or Apollo Hoax thread.
 
And, if I remember correctly, Sol has still yet to give us a mechanism for this outburst. So what are we even discussing?


What we are discussing is "jets" on a cometary surface and the failure of sublimation to produce ANY of the observed effects on a comet nucleus, in particular this "jet" Rosetta finds comet plume powered from below

Acceleration of ions and nano dust at a comet in the solar wind

lH.GunellaI.MannbcC.Simon WedlunddE.KalliodM.AlhodH.NilssoneJ.De KeyseraF.DhoogheaR.Maggioloa

Keep up champ :eek:

No "PRESSURISED GAS" needed!
 
Last edited:
Dust charging and transport on airless planetary bodies

Our dust experiments showed that the size distributions of lofted dust particles are much broader than the sizes of individual particles (38–45μm in diameter) (Figure S2b), covering small residues down to 7μm (limited by the image resolution) to large aggregates up to 140μm in diameter (~3 times larger than the individual particles). The lofting of aggregates is likely attributed to the enhanced charge collection due to the porous structures formed by the interparticle cohesion, according to our patched charge model. This is also another indication that the cohesive force has a large variation for irregular-shaped particles as described in the previous section. Large aggregates formed by small particles due to strong interparticle cohesion can have weak cohesion with their neighboring particles, leading to the lofting of the large aggregates rather than the individual particles. Similar processes may be responsible for the Rosetta detection of fluffy dust particles released from the surface of Comet 67P at its relatively low activity level [Schulz et al., 2015]. Ourlaboratory observations also showedthesmootheneddustysurfacesasaconsequenceofdustmobilization (Figure S2c). This process may lead to the formation of dust ponds on asteroid Eros [Robinson et al., 2001] and on Comet 67P [Thomas et al., 2015] and unexpectedly smooth surface of Saturn’s icy moon Atlas [Hirata and Miyamoto, 2012].

Sublimation? Gas drag?
 
I doubt we are on the same page, because I still have no idea what "complex plasmas" are, and you apparently are not going to define that.

The tail excursion was submitted three weeks ago.

But not accepted yet? :confused:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom