The Man
Unbanned zombie poster
Archer understands GTSM, which is the replacement of establishment's nonsense. That by itself makes up for any woo he may apparently promote. Besides, your boy Newton tried to decipher the fn Bible.
See that's the difference between your musings and science. Perhaps having some good ideas doesn't 'make up' for the bad ones nor even make those bad ones any less bad. Just as simply having some bad ideas doesn't detract from the ones that do work. Each idea is assessed on it's own merits (self consistency) and how well it comports with the other workable ideas and evidence (general consistency). Bad ideas are generally self-inconsistent and/or generally inconsistent. While other ideas might help with the latter, the only idea that can help with the former is just general inconsistency. Which is a bad idea, like any self-inconsistent idea, as it simply refutes itself.
Oh, and unless you directly oppose simple Newtonian mechanics then Newton is equally as much "your boy" as well.
Doing great science doesn't mean you never have really bad ideas. In fact, in order to do great science really bad ideas are a necessity at times, because they give something to compare progress with. I can compare GTSM to the dead on arrival nebular hypothesis and explain the exoplanets with it, which the nebular hypothesis couldn't explain.
Nope, bad ideas are just bad and really bad ideas are, well, just really bad. Excusing them as a "necessity" or even inevitable doesn't make them any less bad or really bad . Just as perceived progress on a bad idea is still, well, bad and if you think you can only measure your progress against bad ideas you really do need to get some better ideas.
I'm sort of glad the dogma is engaged in pseudoscience, it gives me more room to breathe and develop theory.
Evidently even that purported "room" is still insufficient. Again, perhaps you simply need better ideas or just less "really bad" ones?
!