Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Electrical activity and dust lifting on Earth, Mars, and beyond
Renno, N. O. & Kok, J. F.
https://s3.amazonaws.com/academia.e...e=Electrical_Activity_and_Dust_Lifting_on.pdf

Is irrelevant. How are you lifting dust on a comet, when there is a diamagnetic cavity in place? For the umpteenth time. Any chance of actually answering this? Or are you just gouing to carry on wasting our time with links to papers that are irrelevant to the discussion?

ETA:
If this is possible at asteroids, which nobody is doubting, due to their lack of a coma, then comets should look like asteroids. And asteroids should have a dusty environment, just like comets. They don't.
 
Last edited:
Diamagnetic cavity :o

You're just so sure, jd116. :confused:

Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system

4. Conclusion In summary, the population of small bodies in our solar system today, including both minor planets and classical comets, is far less well-delineated into distinct groups of objects than the classical paradigm might have led one to believe in the past. These objects instead appear to occupy a continuum spanning the full range of observational, physical and dynamical properties classically attributed solely either to asteroids or comets. We now know of currently actively sublimating main-belt objects that could have originated either in the asteroid belt or in the outer solar system, and objects displaying comet-like activity that may have no volatile ice content whatsoever. We have found objects composed of inner-asteroid-belt-like material on long-period comet-like orbits, and active objects on comet-like orbits that may in fact originate from the asteroid belt. We also now recognize that dormant comets may be found in both comet-like and un-comet-like orbits. The population of continuum objects is extraordinarily diverse, with each type of object holding the potential for revealing exciting new insights about our solar system due to their unique sets of overlapping comet- and asteroid-like properties. Given this complexity and the growing interest in addressing the many questions that it has raised thus far, it is likely that many more interesting findings await us in this rapidly developing field in the coming years.

And you are saying, jd116, there can be no electric fields inside the comets diamagnetic cavity?

Is this the case, Tusenfem?

How are the neutrals being ionised then or more pressing how are they being released via "subsurface energy"?
 
Last edited:
And away we go again. Rinse and repeat. Ad nauseam. And still zero attempt to explain how any of that is lifting dust when there is a diamagnetic cavity in place. There is nothing electrical going on in that cavity, otherwise it wouldn't be called 'diamagnetic' would it? So, for the umpteenth time, explain what is lofting dust, and how it could form within that cavity.

The charged dust is within the coma. Due to processes in the coma. There are no electric fields within a diamagnetic cavity. There are no currents within a diamagnetic cavity. There is no charge separation within a diamagnetic cavity. There are no suprathermal electrons within a diamagnetic cavity. There are no spikes in the magnetic field within a diamagnetic cavity. By definition. There are no double layers, as you have been repeatedly told. The dust is lofted by gas, and may or may not be collimated. The surface is not bedrock hard, as has been repeatedly pointed out to you.
Frankly, you are just wasting everybody's time with your inane claims, when it has been repeatedly explained to you, with links to the relevant science, that your claims are wrong. Demonstrably and without any doubt.
If you want to carry on your religious belief in this particularly idiotic, unscientific and evidence-free woo, then fine. I just wish you'd take your nonsense somewhere else, and leave the good people of this forum alone, and save them from having to continually correct your idiotic claims.

Are you also saying the processes of electrostatics mentioned in the paper is bunkem?
 
Electrical activity and dust lifting on Earth, Mars, and beyond
Renno, N. O. & Kok, J. F.
https://s3.amazonaws.com/academia.e...e=Electrical_Activity_and_Dust_Lifting_on.pdf

Is irrelevant. snip...

Or are you just gouing to carry on wasting our time with links to papers that are irrelevant to the discussion?

ETA:
If this is possible at asteroids, which nobody is doubting, due to their lack of a coma, then comets should look like asteroids. And asteroids should have a dusty environment, just like comets. They don't.

It is relevant, me 'ol mate! :)

Just because you choose not to see the obvious, doesn't mean everyone.

It's basically cutting edge, as confirmed by Reality Check. :)
 
Are you also saying the processes of electrostatics mentioned in the paper is bunkem?

No. I'm saying that you are not understanding the paper, nor are you understanding the cometary environment as it is when there is a diamagnetic cavity in place. That is, the solar wind electrons, needed for large voltage gradients in craters, and between the night and day sides, are not reaching the nucleus. Therefore the process as described is irrelevant at a comet when it is highly active.
 
No. I'm saying that you are not understanding the paper, nor are you understanding the cometary environment as it is when there is a diamagnetic cavity in place. That is, the solar wind electrons, needed for large voltage gradients in craters, and between the night and day sides, are not reaching the nucleus. Therefore the process as described is irrelevant at a comet when it is highly active.

Not what the latest papers say, jd116!
 
Lest we forget here, we are talking about a sudden, explosive emission of so much dust that it is optically thick, from a very small area. I have seen absolutely nothing presented that would explain this behaviour electrostatically. It is nonsense. And the authors of those papers would tell Sol the very same.
We have seen other sudden dust enhancements, and they are accompanied by gas increases. There is absolutely no reason to suppose that all such sudden enhancements are not due to gas release. It is a pointless discussion.
 
Charged dust: and so what? Electrical activity and dust lifting on Earth, Mars, and beyond
Nilton O. Renno1,2,* and Jasper F. Kok1,2

yes, so what, because you just gather a lot a terms and then "we" just have to make sense of your ramblings.
It is the trick of just writing incomprehensive post in order to get one of the "experts" to make sense of it for you and work out any possible details or models.

electric fields (locally very strong): care to elaborate what "very" strong means here, and where this "locally" is? = Same Paper

And exactly what does that quote have to do with comet 67P?
Next to that, looking at the paper by Renno and Kok, this quote of yours does not exist, heck, the paper only has 6 figures.
You found an upload of a preprint of this paper, and not the published one in Space Science Reviews, which does not have the text you quoted anymore.


More later from your paper Tusenfem, Current in Cometary Comae

oh yippie I can't wait
 
Last edited:
Lest we forget here, we are talking about a sudden, explosive emission of so much dust that it is optically thick, from a very small area. I have seen absolutely nothing presented that would explain this behaviour electrostatically. It is nonsense. And the authors of those papers would tell Sol the very same.
We have seen other sudden dust enhancements, and they are accompanied by gas increases. There is absolutely no reason to suppose that all such sudden enhancements are not due to gas release. It is a pointless discussion.

Interestingly, the plasmaphysical processes of the Argawal outburst are being studied as we speak (well okay, type).
 
Here is an interesting article on 'electric asteroids'! Yikes!!!
https://sservi.nasa.gov/articles/ne...to-the-invisible-world-of-electric-asteroids/

However, it isn't quite the sort of thing that Thornhill et al would hope for from the headline alone.

The paper which describes the model is here:

Grid-free 2D plasma simulations of the complex interaction between the solar wind and small, near-Earth asteroids
Zimmerman, N. I. et al.
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20150011018.pdf

To create the necessary electric fields, the model has to incorporate both photoemission and the plasma interaction from the solar wind. Of course, this plasma interaction is not going to happen at a comet with a diamagnetic cavity in place, as the solar wind is getting nowhere near the nucleus.
So, all jolly interesting, and shows that electric effects in space are not ignored by the likes of NASA. It should be noted, however, that we have had a few close up looks at asteroids, and there is no discernible dust coma. Take a look at the Hayabusa images from asteroid Itokawa, for instance. So, if dust levitation is happening, then it is only minor. And this mechanism certainly cannot be responsible for explosive outbursts at comets, even when the solar wind is reaching the surface.
 
Sol88: States ignorance of diamagnetic cavities and an irrelevant paper

Diamagnetic cavity....
23 November 2017 Sol88: States ignorance of diamagnetic cavities and an irrelevant to his comet delusions paper.

Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system is not his insane comets delusion that include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; etc. etc.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: An idiotic electrostatics paper question to derail from his comet delusions

Are you also saying the processes of electrostatics mentioned in the paper is bunkem?
23 November 2017 Sol88: An idiotic electrostatics paper question to derail from ihs comet delusions.
The electrostatics paper is about comets made of ices and dust :eye-poppi.
 
Sol88: A lie that a (or any!) mainstream paper is relevant to his comet delusions

It is relevant, me 'ol mate!
23 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that a (or any!) mainstream paper is relevant to his comet delusions.
23 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that I have confirmed that this review paper is relevant to his comet delusions or "cutting edge".

To show how obvious the lies are
  1. The paper is from 2008.
  2. The paper is a review of existing theoretical and observational evidence.
  3. The word comet appears 1 time in a section title and comets are ignored in the section.
  4. He has cited least 1 also irrelevant but recent paper on electrostatic lifting of dust on comet 67P.
Electrical activity and dust lifting on Earth, Mars, and beyond
We review electrical activity in blowing sand and dusty phenomena on Earth, Mars, the Moon, and asteroids. On Earth and Mars, blowing sand and dusty phenomena such as dust devils and dust storms are important geological processes and the primary sources of atmospheric dust. Large electric fields have been measured in terrestrial dusty phenomena and are predicted to occur on Mars. We review the charging mechanisms that produce these electric fields and discuss the implications of electrical activity to dust lifting and atmospheric chemistry. In addition, we review theoretical ideas about electric discharges on Mars. Finally, we discuss the evidence that electrostatics is responsible for dust transport on the Moon and asteroids.
 
Last edited:
Here is an interesting article on 'electric asteroids'! Yikes!!!
https://sservi.nasa.gov/articles/ne...to-the-invisible-world-of-electric-asteroids/

However, it isn't quite the sort of thing that Thornhill et al would hope for from the headline alone.

The paper which describes the model is here:

Grid-free 2D plasma simulations of the complex interaction between the solar wind and small, near-Earth asteroids
Zimmerman, N. I. et al.
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20150011018.pdf

To create the necessary electric fields, the model has to incorporate both photoemission and the plasma interaction from the solar wind. Of course, this plasma interaction is not going to happen at a comet with a diamagnetic cavity in place, as the solar wind is getting nowhere near the nucleus.
So, all jolly interesting, and shows that electric effects in space are not ignored by the likes of NASA. It should be noted, however, that we have had a few close up looks at asteroids, and there is no discernible dust coma. Take a look at the Hayabusa images from asteroid Itokawa, for instance. So, if dust levitation is happening, then it is only minor. And this mechanism certainly cannot be responsible for explosive outbursts at comets, even when the solar wind is reaching the surface.

Whoo boy!

Evidence is laid out in front of you and you CHOOSE to ignore it! :rolleyes:

ya lesser crested Drongo!

Like you say..."
"Goes without saying that nothing electrical happened." [Jonesdavid116] "
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom