The Man
Unbanned zombie poster
I'm not sure that this has got anything to do with the 'electric comet theory' any more. Given the predictions on this site by David Talbott, and the pdf poster he co-wrote with Thornhill. it is blindingly obvious that that has failed to eventuate. No electric discharges, no EDM (lol), no rock, plenty of ice, etc.
He appears now (insofar as I can follow his twisted logic) to be claiming that electrostatic charging is responsible for dust jets! This despite the fact that said jets are associated with an increase of gas. Such as:
Comet's firework display ahead of perihelion
http://sci.esa.int/rosetta/56325-comets-firework-display-ahead-of-perihelion/
And:
The 2016 Feb 19 outburst of comet 67P/CG: an ESA Rosetta multi-instrument study
Grun, E. et al.
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/462/Suppl_1/S220/2633359
Then there seems to be some stuff about double layers and CIV. I have no idea where this is meant to be going. It just seems to be distraction tactics, as one would expect from a woo believer whose beliefs have been well and truly debunked by real science and observation.
Exactly, the introduction of a neutral gas into the plasma would seem to be at odds with the EC portrayal of the jets as electrostatic discharges or the result of EDM. Again it seems just an attempt to find anything stated as electrodynamic in nature in relation to comets regardless of if it directly opposes basic EC assertions.
ETA:
As tusenfem alludes to up thread I don't recommend trying to read much actual meaning into Sol88's mainstream paper spamming. As I've seen many times from crank science supporters It's often beneficial for others to try to find the, tenuous if any, connections between their mainstream citations and the alternate notion's assertions for them. If Sol88 can't make clear how this directly supports EC assertions then the indications from the quoted citation and those EC assertions are that they are in direct opposition.
Last edited:
