Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm not sure that this has got anything to do with the 'electric comet theory' any more. Given the predictions on this site by David Talbott, and the pdf poster he co-wrote with Thornhill. it is blindingly obvious that that has failed to eventuate. No electric discharges, no EDM (lol), no rock, plenty of ice, etc.
He appears now (insofar as I can follow his twisted logic) to be claiming that electrostatic charging is responsible for dust jets! This despite the fact that said jets are associated with an increase of gas. Such as:

Comet's firework display ahead of perihelion
http://sci.esa.int/rosetta/56325-comets-firework-display-ahead-of-perihelion/

And:

The 2016 Feb 19 outburst of comet 67P/CG: an ESA Rosetta multi-instrument study
Grun, E. et al.
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/462/Suppl_1/S220/2633359

Then there seems to be some stuff about double layers and CIV. I have no idea where this is meant to be going. It just seems to be distraction tactics, as one would expect from a woo believer whose beliefs have been well and truly debunked by real science and observation.

Exactly, the introduction of a neutral gas into the plasma would seem to be at odds with the EC portrayal of the jets as electrostatic discharges or the result of EDM. Again it seems just an attempt to find anything stated as electrodynamic in nature in relation to comets regardless of if it directly opposes basic EC assertions.

ETA:

As tusenfem alludes to up thread I don't recommend trying to read much actual meaning into Sol88's mainstream paper spamming. As I've seen many times from crank science supporters It's often beneficial for others to try to find the, tenuous if any, connections between their mainstream citations and the alternate notion's assertions for them. If Sol88 can't make clear how this directly supports EC assertions then the indications from the quoted citation and those EC assertions are that they are in direct opposition.
 
Last edited:
Sol88. Have you considered joining the Cosmoquest Forum and starting a thread over there in the Q&A section?
It is for asking questions on astronomy and cosmology. You will get a number of very well informed answers.
Be aware though it is for asking questions and receiving mainstream answers, not advocating your own theories but it will get you answers to your mainstream questions and help you understand the papers you quote.

https://forum.cosmoquest.org/forumdisplay.php?8-Space-Astronomy-Questions-and-Answers

That would be unlikely! See the status of the first poster in this thread:
https://forum.cosmoquest.org/showthread.php?41761-Electric-Comets
 
Last edited:
Nothing in that quote is the least bit relevant to what I said. The neutrals will head out. A small number will be ionised before they reach the pile up boundary. The lifetime against photoionisation for H2O is of the order of 106 seconds. The molecules are travelling at ~ 600 m/s. To reach the boundary at, say, 200 km would take ~ 300 s. Any ions and electrons formed within the cavity are not subject to a magnetic field. There is no reason for them to go wandering off to dark parts of the nucleus. Spherical symmetry is assumed in many models to make them easier to compute. It just means in those models (Haser model?) that the comet is modelled as being a sphere. The speed of the sublimating gases means that gravitational pull can be ignored. The gas will still head up and out.


Ummm....yes it is!

2.4NoteonliteratureThedustyicemodelhasbeenfrequentlyadoptedinstudiesofcometaryactivityandevolution,thoughnumericaltreatmentvariesgreatlywithdifferentworks.ReferencescanbefoundinSmoluchowski(1981),Weissman&Kieffer(1981),Froeschle,Klinger&Rickman(1983),K¨uhrt(1984),K¨uhrt(1999),amongnumerousothers.Itisconclusivethatexposureofwatericeovercometarynucleiislimited(Filacchioneetal.2016).Theeffectofthisdustman-tleonheattransportandgasdiffusionthroughthenucleusaswellastheconditionsofdustactivityhasbeenstudiedingreatde-tail.
:mad::mad::mad:

Bloody apple :mad: have to wait till I’m home

Not enough ‘gas’
Too much dust
Gas can’t remove dust
Model used in diamagnetic gas production rate flawed
The dust is charged at the nucleus already
Suns infrared can’t penetrate
No surface ice
Dust is colimated
 
2.4NoteonliteratureThedustyicemodelhasbeenfrequent lyadoptedinstudiesofcometaryactivityandevolution,t houghnumericaltreatmentvariesgreatlywithdifferentw orks.ReferencescanbefoundinSmoluchowski(1981),Weis sman&Kieffer(1981),Froeschle,Klinger&Rickman(1983) ,K¨uhrt(1984),K¨uhrt(1999),amongnumerousothers.Iti sconclusivethatexposureofwatericeovercometarynucle iislimited(Filacchioneetal.2016).Theeffectofthisdu stman-tleonheattransportandgasdiffusionthroughthenucleus aswellastheconditionsofdustactivityhasbeenstudiedi ngreatde-tail.


Dafuq is that? Judas Priest. Please make a point. You are wasting everybodies time. It is complete sh*te. What on Earth are you on about?
Stop wasting everybody's time with your idiotic woo.
 
Last edited:
At the moment just a hastily written "list" of points that need clarifying.
I will add links to the relevant paper when I've finished fishing!



1. Comet appears hard(Mupus) Thermal and mechanical properties of the near-surface layers of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko and Rocky (Osiris) (Bedrock) Geomorphology of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

2. Not enough ‘gas' from sublimation, comet too weakly outgassing to form any sorta mechanical/physical barrier.

3. Comet would form a langmiur sheath anyhow.

4. Too much dust for "ice" to release gas

5. Gas can’t remove dust "explosive" dust releases with no 'gas' increase.

6. No chambers or nozzles found

7. Model used in diamagnetic gas production rate flawed, nucleus does not evenly radially expand it's "atmosphere".

8. The dust is charged at the nucleus already

9. Suns infra-red can’t penetrate dusty surface, sublimation of pathetic amount of surface ice hard to detecte.

10. Dust is charged, filamentary, fine structured and collimated.

11. Nested draping, "frozen in" magnetic field and magnetic reconnection wrong.
I sincerely hope that the increased interest in the study of double layers -- which is fatal to this pseudoscience -- will change the situation. Whenever we find a double layer (we hammer a nail into the coffin of the "merging" pseudo-science. H. Alfven

12. Constant electric field in side diamganetic cavity "spikes", zero/low magnetic field because constant electric field in DMC "spiky" nature of cavity probe flew through because not true cavity. analogues to a parallel plate capacitor.

13. Cold calm electrons down to on the nucleus.

14. Plasma tail will show a nested Birkeland current structures,(concentric cylindrical current sheet surfaces) This will be evident in the the pitch angle of the helical total magnetic field B vector encircling a field aligned current changing continuously with increasing radial distance r from the central axis of the current. As Don Scotts described in the model D E Scott has presented http://www.ptep-online.com/2015/PP-41-13.PDF this was also found in the ULYSSESS ION TAIL OF COMET McNAUGHT data.

15. New papers on the plasma physics around a weakly charged comet are only just starting in earnest, late 2017

16. Diocotron instability incorrectly called Kelvin-Helmholtz instability

Electric comet still has legs
"dirtysnowyiceball" digs itself s a deep/er hole
 
Last edited:
Sorry but to keep continuity for me at least i'll keep adding to the above list.

It may pop up now and again, and again.....
 
15. New papers on the plasma physics around a weakly charged comet are only just starting in earnest, late 2017 Interaction of the solar wind with comets: a Rosetta perspective

There are further interesting and exciting observations made by the Rosetta Plasma Consortium [51] in the innermost interaction region of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko. For example, multiple entries into a magnetic cavity have been observed in the interaction region [ 52]. However, their distance to the nucleus deviates significantly from those theoretically expected, which has caused an ongoing interesting scientific discussion. Other interesting observations on November 25, 2017 concern electrically charged nanograins in the inner coma, indicating a possible connection between dust at the surface of the nucleus and the comet’s plasma environment [ 53]. Aeolian ripples (figure 20 ) on the surface of the nucleus of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko [ 54]maybe another hint of a pronounced impact of the plasma environment on the nucleus morphology. The ripples observed exhibit a wavelength of about 10 m, which is comparable to the wavelength of ion acoustic waves in that environment [ 55]. Such ‘plasmaeolian’ structures would demonstrate the importance of a deeper understanding of the cometary plasma environment, if the conjectured relation can be confirmed.

For you jd116.
 
Last edited:
17. Current carrying double layer being called anything but their correct name, same with FAC's. They are indeed Birkeland currents.

and despite whet Tusenfem says and mainstreams stubbornness to acknowledge them, double layers play a very important role.

DLs not only separate plasmas or regions of plasma with quite different characteristics [12], they are found within a wide variety of plasmas from discharge tubes to the Birkeland currents supplying Earth’s aurora (see [11]), and most likely plasmas in interstellar and intergalactic space. They are especially common within current-carrying plasmas, where they form current-carrying DLs. Compared to the sizes of the plasmas that contain them, DLs are very thin, typically ten Debye lengths, ranging from a few millimetres for lab plasmas to thousands of kilometres for astrophysical plasmas. (A Debye length in plasma physics is the distance over which charge separation can occur. In space plasmas, where the electron density is relatively low, the Debye length is correspondingly large.) Ions and electrons that enter the double layer are accelerated, decelerated, or reflected by the electric field. A double layer is said to be relativistic if the potential drop is so large that the total gain in energy of the particles is larger than the rest mass energy of the electron or the ion. The rest mass energy of the electron is 511 keV and that of proton is 938 MeV, and those of other ions even larger.

Of special interest for applications to astrophysics is the acceleration of charged particles traversing the DL by the net potential difference across the DL. A detailed treatment of the DL is given by Peratt, who devoted a long chapter to it in his book [2].
Dr. Mae-Wan Ho
 
1. Comet appears hard(Mupus)

Already addressed. Not rock, for the millionth time.

Shear modulus scales with velocity squared, so when taking into account the formal uncertainties arising from the arrival time inversion, the shear modulus may easily be as large as 10 MPa. This is still low compared to solid rock or monocrystalline ice, but is compatible with highly porous materials.

Constraints for the subsurface structure at the Abydos site on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko resulting from CASSE listening to the MUPUS insertion phase
Knapmeyer, M. et al.
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016AGUFM.P42A..04K

2. Not enough ‘gas' from sublimation, comet too weakly outgassing to form any sorta mechanical/physical barrier.

Complete dross. No references to back it up. The comet quite obviously has a barrier, as the spacecraft flew through it multiple times. And was also seen at Halley.

3. Comet would form a langmiur sheath anyhow.

Rubbish. Why? References? More dross.

4. Too much dust for "ice" to release gas

Rubbish. Why? References? More dross.

5. Gas can’t remove dust "explosive" dust releases with no 'gas' increase.

Nonsense. ALICE didn't detect gas. As it has previously failed to do when gas has been detected by other instruments. Dumb argument.

6. No chambers or nozzles found

Err, because they would be subsurface. Plenty of circular features (including the one in the Agarwal paper) that could easily be vents.

7. Model used in diamagnetic gas production rate flawed, nucleus does not evenly radially expand it's "atmosphere".

Complete nonsense. You don't even understand what you are talking about here. The gas is directly measured. The diamagnetic cavity is seen. End of story. For instance:

Spatially resolved evolution of the local H2O production rates of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko from the MIRO instrument on Rosetta.
Marshall, D. W. et al
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/pdf/forth/aa30502-17.pdf

8. The dust is charged at the nucleus already

Hardly at all when there is a diamagnetic cavity. Won't do anything. We already know that dust outbursts have been accompanied by an increase in gas.

9. Suns infra-red can’t penetrate dusty surface, sublimation of pathetic amount of surface ice hard to detecte.

Huh? We see the gas from the sublimation! Where else is it coming from? We see the ice at the surface. Therefore the solar heating is quite obviously reaching the ice.

10. Dust is charged, filamentary, fine structured and collimated.

The dust gets charged once it is in the coma. And then it is only nanograins. It is not all collimated. If the gas is released in a collimated manner, then so is the dust. And we know that collimated releases are associated with an increase in gas. As I've already posted.

Comet's firework display ahead of perihelion
http://sci.esa.int/rosetta/56325-comets-firework-display-ahead-of-perihelion/

11. Nested draping, "frozen in" magnetic field and magnetic reconnection wrong.

Lol. And then quotes Alfven, who came up with the nested draping scenario! And he was wrong about MRx. As observed. And the frozen-in concept is also more applicable than he realised.

12. Constant electric field in side diamganetic cavity "spikes", zero/low magnetic field because constant electric field in DMC "spiky" nature of cavity probe flew through because not true cavity. analogues to a parallel plate capacitor.

Complete gibberish. Have a look at the Halley data. I'll leave Tusenfem to deal more thoroughly with that particular waste of pixels.

13. Cold calm electrons down to on the nucleus.
Really? And? More pixels wasted.


14. Plasma tail will show a nested Birkeland current structures,(concentric cylindrical current sheet surfaces) This will be evident in the the pitch angle of the helical total magnetic field B vector encircling a field aligned current changing continuously with increasing radial distance r from the central axis of the current. As Don Scotts described in the model D E Scott has presented http://www.ptep-online.com/2015/PP-41-13.PDF this was also found in the ULYSSESS ION TAIL OF COMET McNAUGHT data.

No Birkeland currents seen. Quotes a Don Scott paper, in which he embarasses himself by equating a planetary nebula with a z-pinch!

15. New papers on the plasma physics around a weakly charged comet are only just starting in earnest, late 2017

There have been plenty of papers on a weakly OUTGASSING comet. And on a highly active comet. The comet is not charged.


16. Diocotron instability incorrectly called Kelvin-Helmholtz instability

Wrong. This is a quasi-neutral plasma. Therefore it isn't a dicotron instability. As Tusenfem has already explained to you.


Electric comet still has legs
"dirtysnowyiceball" digs itself s a deep/er hole

Lol. The electric comet is long dead. There is not a jot of evidence to support it. And a whole load against it. Where is the rock? Where are the electric discharges? Where is the predicted EDM? It couldn't be deader.
 
Last edited:
17. Current carrying double layer being called anything but their correct name, same with FAC's. They are indeed Birkeland currents.

and despite whet Tusenfem says and mainstreams stubbornness to acknowledge them, double layers play a very important role.

Dr. Mae-Wan Ho

Laughable. Tries to back up the EU nonsense by quoting a crank!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mae-Wan_Ho

Ho has been criticized for embracing pseudoscience

Yup, that'll make people sit up and take notice. Not.
 
15. New papers on the plasma physics around a weakly charged comet are only just starting in earnest, late 2017 Interaction of the solar wind with comets: a Rosetta perspective



For you jd116.

So, the nature of the diamagnetic cavity was not totally as predicted. Wow! Considering that we had only encountered one at a comet before (not counting artificial comets), this is not all that surprising. EU said nothing about the cavity. Indeed, the idiot Thornhill was telling his intellectually challenged followers that the solar wind was creating the water! Even though it isn't reaching the nucleus for some time, as we'd known since 1986.
As for your electrically charged nanograins; you should have read the paper that was referenced in the one that you quote mined:

The lower energy particles came from roughly the direction of the comet; the higher-energy particles came from approximately the solar direction. These particles are interpreted as clusters of molecules, most likely water, which we refer to as nanograins because their inferred diameters are less than 100 nm.

Observation of charged nanograins at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
Burch, J. L. et al.
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/2015GL065177/full
 
Sol88: Lies about double layers yet again

yup, double layers...:D
27 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about double layers yet again with a paper on the 67P diamagnetic cavity .

27 November 2017 Sol88: Stupid question to derail from his comet delusions.
If there is one diamagnetic cavity then 2 detections of it will find it in abut the same place :eye-poppi
 
Sol88: A lie that ionization has "everything" to do with his cult comet delusions

Ionization has EVERYTHING to do with the ELECTRIC COMET.
27 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that ionization has "everything" to do with his cult comet delusions.
Those idiots at Thunderbolts have insane delusions about comets that do not involve ionization of the comet coma. For those who do not know how insane the electric comet is:
11 October 2017 Sol88: Abysmal ignorance about his comet delusions which have nothing to do with this post.
No totally insane delusion that comets are rocks blasted from the Earth by electrical discharges when other planets wandered by including recently.
No abysmally ignorant delusion that comet jets are electrical discharges between the comet nucleus and the Sun.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: The idiocy of the title of a paper about comets made of ices and dust

Houston we have a problem...
of multiple idiocy
27 November 2017 Sol88: The idiocy of the title of a paper about comets made of ices and dust.
Plasma waves confined to the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko by Gunell, H. et. al.

27 November 2017 Sol88: The idiocy that a diamagnetic cavity is empty (not magnetic field does not mean no plasma!)

27 November 2017 Sol88: The repeated idiocy that a diamagnetic cavity is anything to do with his comet delusions.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: A lie and delusion about a double layer

But the diamagnetic cavity is after the double layer, sonwhats stopping the solar wind? Diamagnetic cavity or electric double layer?
27 November 2017 Sol88: A lie and delusion about a double layer and a stupid diamagnetic cavity question.
He been told many times that it is the comet coma that stops the solar wind from reaching the surface of the comet nucleus.
 
Sol88: A lie about his irrelevant delusion of a coma double layer

Interesting, ay! So they COULD be there. :D
27 November 2017 Sol88: A lie about his irrelevant delusion of a coma double layer.
The 1976 paper included the possibility and never detected double layers in comet tails.
 
Sol88: Idiotic, irrelevant citation of a paper on the diamagnetic cavity of Comet 67P

27 November 2017 Sol88: Idiotic and irrelevant citation of a paper on the diamagnetic cavity of Comet 67P (made of ices and dust!)
The idiocy includes that he probably picked this paper because of "Electric Field" in the title.

27 November 2017 Sol88: Stupid promise to derail from his comet delusions by returning to a previous derail.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Lies about a paper being a problem for the mainstream of ices and dust comets

The above paper introduces some new problems for the mainstream!
27 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about a MSc thesis being a problem for the mainstream of comets made of ices and dust.
The author, Birgitte Madsen, stated the obvious that has probably been known since the 1950's. Ices sublimate. This creates gas. The rate of outgassing Q is important!

27 November 2017 Sol88: Idiocy of highlighting the paper describing sublimating ices :eye-poppi!
RPC-LAP Electric Field Signatures at the Diamagnetic Cavity of Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
2.2 Generation of cometary boundaries When illuminated by the Sun, energy from the solar radiation causes sublimation of ice from the comet surface. The amount of sublimated ice per time unit is described by the cometary outgassing rate Q, on which the activity level of a comet and the extent of the comet -solar wind interaction region depend on. It is, therefore, highly relevant to estimate Q when doing in-situ observations of the cometary environment. By assuming spherical symmetry and negligible gravitational pull on the cometary neutrals, the observed neutral number density nn at a distance r from the comet nucleus is related to the outgassing rate Q by ...
An estimate for Q is calculated ("Rearranging Eq. (2.22) provides an estimate of the outgassing rate as seen by a spacecraft in the vicinity of a comet")
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Yet another pathetic attempt to derail from his comet delusions

You may be able to fill the lurkers in here a bit Tusenfem.
The lurkers understand that this is:
27 November 2017 Sol88: Yet another pathetic attempt to derail from his comet delusions with an irrelevant question.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom