Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is one of the insane delusions from the Thunderbolts cult - that magnetic fields cannot be frozen into plasma and thus magnetic reconnection (seen in labs all of the time) does not exist.

As I've noted several times on this forum you can demonstrate magnetic reconnection with some typical business card type refrigerator magnets.


ETA:
Heck, just the turning of a compass needle from the Earth's magnetic field to that of a bar magnet brought near requires the needle's magnetic field to reconnect from the Earth's magnetic field to that of the bar magnet. The energy stored in the magnetic fields as they compress and stretch is released in the reconnection as the motion of the needle.
 
Last edited:
Particularly when the paper says...

Heck, who cares what the papers actually say just take a word, phrase, line or whatever from all or any number and just cobble them into a claim of support for whatever you want.
This bedrock idiocy first popped up in this part of the 8-year old thread back on 22 August 2017 with the stupidity of highlighting "Layered bedrock" from Geomorphology of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko.
tusenfem humorously showed how dumb the post was in No, probably more like (the Flintstones)

Now we get the same stupidity with the same paper and "consolidated bedrock".
 
I think the one thing tusenfem and I can agree on is, the tail excursion will be the most interesting part of the mission in data returned. ;)

And that the tail excursion was not under taken when the comet was more active. :(

Going to make a whole lot of sense on what’s going on up in front! :)
 
@ The Man

Thank you for engaging me a little on this subject with out just having a spamming convulsions.

Short answer is, I've not got the maths skill to any of that but
No, local differences in distribution of ions and electrons (local charge distributions) don't violate quasi neutrality. That's specifically what the "quasi" means. However, the comet carrying a significant charge explicitly violates the neutrality part, quasi or otherwise. Also simple ionization, photo or otherwise, doesn't change ion to electron ratios. Where local distribution variations become stronger or larger ambi-polar fields are generated opposing those variations

Yeah, unless there "powered" in a complete electrical circuit! These beasts are current carrying double layers!

Your above assertion will be kinda of a moot point once we know what's going on down the tail!
 
Short answer is, I've not got the maths skill to any of that but

The answer of every EC/ES/UE acolyte.
Yeah, unless there "powered" in a complete electrical circuit! These beasts are current carrying double layers!

Not, if you think that the ambi-polar electric field is supposed to be your "double layer".
 
I think the one thing tusenfem and I can agree on is, the tail excursion will be the most interesting part of the mission in data returned. ;)

And that the tail excursion was not under taken when the comet was more active. :(

Going to make a whole lot of sense on what’s going on up in front! :)

Do these sentences belong together, or what?
Do they have any combined meaning?
 
@ The Man

Thank you for engaging me a little on this subject with out just having a spamming convulsions.

No problem, I like spam and never convulse while chewing it up.

Short answer is, I've not got the maths skill to any of that but

What math skills are needed?

At 4 quarters per dollar, then having 8 quarters gives you 8 / 4=2 dollars

At -1.6 × 10-19 Coulombs per electron, then having -3.2 × 10-19 Coulomb of charge gives you -3.2 × 10-19 / -1.6 × 10-19 = 2 excess electrons.

The problem ain't "the maths skill" it is simply that EC musings generally never consider the charges they require. Yet still want to consider them and require them to be sufficient to EDM rock. At least in my experience whenever a quantification of charge is actually attempted in EU/EC speculations it is generally sufficient to blow the object apart often at relativistic speeds. So EDM and lightning like discharges don't even enter the picture.



Yeah, unless there "powered" in a complete electrical circuit! These beasts are current carrying double layers!

Your above assertion will be kinda of a moot point once we know what's going on down the tail!

Short and same response is: A "complete electrical circuit" as portrayed by the EC crowd, going between the sun and the comet, clearly is not a local charge distribution in regard to the quasi-neutrality of plasma, like an ambi-polar electric field. Again EC, as well as EU remain moot points until, at the very least, it can establish the quantitative scope of the charges it so vehemently requires yet so lackadaisically simply ignores.
 
Last edited:
@ The Man
Short answer is, I've not got the maths skill to any of that but

Yes, well that much is a prerequisite of being an EU follower. Anybody equipped with the necessary maths, and relevant science skills/ knowledge, wouldn't touch it with a barge pole.
It is how Thornhill is able to con his acolytes into believing that the solar wind creates the observed H2O (or OH; not sure what he's saying). Firstly, you would do the maths based on the solar wind flux, to see if there are enough H+ and O- ions to create the observed outgassing. The answer to that is no. And you'd ditch it right there.
Even if you didn't, you'd realise that for long periods the SW is not getting near the comet.
And, if that wasn't enough, you'd look at the energetics of H+ at ~400 km/s, and see what the chances are of it combining with anything. Pretty much no chance.
If none of those are enough to convince you that Thornie is talking twaddle, then you are his perfect acolyte. No maths, and little scientific knowledge that you are likely to bring to bear against him. And the con goes on.
 
Sol88: No math skills but can lie again about double layers, etc.

Short answer is, I've not got the maths skill to any of that but
Not short - over 8 years and thousands of posts with ignorance of basic math, physics and even English!
Over 2 years and counting of fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.
The parroting of the Thunderbolt cult ignorance, delusions and lies in this thread alone (continuation of a thread that is now 8 years of delusions from Sol88)
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.

The last link includes the clear English of Wal Thornhill lying thru his teeth about the Thunderbolts cult having confirmed comet predictions.

29 November 2017 Sol88: No math skills (still does not know that 0.6 g/cc is not 3.0 g/cc after over 8 years) but can lie again about double layers, etc.
Double layers are not expected at comets (46 abstracts out of 13.4 million for 'comet double layer', several irrelevant, at ADS) except at the deluded Thunderbolts cult.
Double layers have never been detected at any comet.

29 November 2017 Sol88: Added the stupidity of Birkeland currents in comet tails to his comet delusions.
28 November 2017 Sol88: His massively deluded point 14 from a post full of delusions is quoted. points out that a magnetic field is required as in the only detected Birkeland currents around the Earth. and comets have no magnetic field.
In addition Birkeland currents by themselves are invisible - we had to put a spacecraft inside them to detect them. Standard plasma physics is that there are several mechanisms that produce visible filamentary structures. I have not seen Birkeland currents mentioned as one of these. In any case what we will get is his cult act of imagining that pointing at a twisty, filamentary thing = Birkeland currents.
 
Last edited:
No problem, I like spam and never convulse while chewing it up.



What math skills are needed?

At 4 quarters per dollar, then having 8 quarters gives you 8 / 4=2 dollars

At -1.6 × 10-19 Coulombs per electron, then having -3.2 × 10-19 Coulomb of charge gives you -3.2 × 10-19 / -1.6 × 10-19 = 2 excess electrons.

The problem ain't "the maths skill" it is simply that EC musings generally never consider the charges they require. Yet still want to consider them and require them to be sufficient to EDM rock. At least in my experience whenever a quantification of charge is actually attempted in EU/EC speculations it is generally sufficient to blow the object apart often at relativistic speeds. So EDM and lightning like discharges don't even enter the picture.





Short and same response is: A "complete electrical circuit" as portrayed b] yet so lackadaisically simply ignores.


Doesn’t always blow them apart, although we have observed it, say Comet 332P.

Why would you think it would blow them apart often at relativistic speeds?

So even your feeble attempt at “have’n a go” shows the nucleus to be a different potential than the solar wind! :D
 
Perhaps you could paint us a picture using your mathmagicary to show the electric circuit between the 67p and the sun (solar wind)?

Or because they may be a little frightening for a ‘mainstreamer’, how about just the circuits we observe at 67P!

Should be fun with you two electrons!
 
Sol88: A couple of delusions - an electric circuit between the 67p and the sun...

Perhaps you could paint us a picture using your mathmagicary to show the electric circuit between the 67p and the sun (solar wind)?
29 November 2017 Sol88: A couple of delusions - that there is "a electric circuit between the 67p and the sun (solar wind)" and that people who know about his over 8 years of persisting with ignorance, delusions and lies will waste time answering this delusion.
 
Doesn’t always blow them apart, although we have observed it, say Comet 332P.

What amount of excess electrons "Doesn’t always blow them apart"? If you're not really sure of the amount of excess electrons you expect or require then you're are not really sure such an amount wouldn't have blown them apart.

Why would you think it would blow them apart often at relativistic speeds?

Electrodynamic forces are what bind molecules together and binds electrons in the atoms. Sufficient electrostatic forces (like too many excess electrons around) can overcome those binding forces, thus ripping or blowing the object apart. The higher the disparity between those binding and dismembering forces results in higher energy and speed of the flying apart remnants. Again it comes down to how many excess electrons the EC notions require.

EDM works similarly, in part thermally by heat from the current flow reducing the effect of inter-molecular binding forces and in part by the electrical field forces separating charges. The latter tends to dominate the former as the spark time (time of current flow through the object) is reduced.

That the factors are already required to be sufficient to separate parts of the object for the EC notions to just be somewhat internally consistent already demonstrates the requirement of the notions to blow at least parts of the object apart at perhaps various speeds. So that that object gets blow apart (at least in part) at whatever speed is a central tenet of EC assertions. Again it is simply the extent of the blowing apart and the resulting speed of the shrapnel that is dependent on the charges involved in the EC claims.

Why would you think it wouldn't happen particularly when you're not really sure how many excess electrons the EC notions require for such a comet?


Don't forget the purported circuit goes from the sun to or through the comet while EDM machines use very small gaps. To obtain just the same field strengths at such larger distances the charges involved would also have to be increased proportionally to the square of the distance. Again quite possibly putting them beyond the ability of the materials (or any material) to sustain.

So even your feeble attempt at “have’n a go” shows the nucleus to be a different potential than the solar wind! :D

What “have’n a go” are you referring to? Again no one can be “have’n a go” at any of the EC/EU stuff (particularly the proponents) without at least the quantitative scope of the charges expected to be involved.

Two rocks on the ground can have different potentials in relation to each other. It still doesn't mean that they are suddenly going to EDM bits off each other.

Again what does EC propose to be the number excess electrons on such a comet, as that would at least give you the expected charge and the magnitude of the surrounding electrical field.

Short and same response is: A "complete electrical circuit" as portrayed b] yet so lackadaisically simply ignores.

I don't know what that is suppose to be but it certainly ain't what I posted.
 
Thank you detailing how the dust is removed from the rock(comet nucleus)!
 
Sol88: Lies about comets being rocks and a post being about dust

Thank you detailing how the dust is removed from the rock(comet nucleus)!
29 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about comets being rocks and a post being about how dust is removed from the comet nucleus.
The Man's post is mostly about the scarcity of numbers in EC. No dust is mentioned.

This is electrical discharge machining which the Thunderbolts cult are deluded about, e.g. because EDM needs a dielectric medium to create the discharge while plasma (solar wind + coma) conducts! Working sinker EDM machines have dielectric fluid between an electrode and workpiece.

19 August 2009: The EC assumption of EDM machining does not produce jets.
20 August 2009: EDM in the EC idea needs a dielectric material which does not exist :eek:!
20 August 2009: No EDM sparks are seen in images of comet nuclei
20 August 2009: No EDM hot spots are seen in thermal maps of Tempel 1
31 August 2009: Voltage potentials are many orders of magnitude too small (for electrical discharges as in lightning and maybe EDM)
 
Last edited:
Perhaps you could paint us a picture using your mathmagicary to show the electric circuit between the 67p and the sun (solar wind)?

Or because they may be a little frightening for a ‘mainstreamer’, how about just the circuits we observe at 67P!

Should be fun with you two electrons!

Circuit diagrams "show" or paint pictures of electric circuits. Mathematics relay the relationships between quantitative values. The former is inherently less dynamic, showing generally fixed relations of predominantly stable components. Hence the lack of need for explicit and varying dynamic relations being laid out in the symbology. The later, mathematics, is more versatile and better suited to representing dynamic systems, even catastrophic and chaotic system.

Heck, given that just free space has electromagnetic properties, just to draw a circuit diagram of empty space you would have to draw little capacitors and inductors going every which way possible and it would just end up a big black splotch on the paper. So best to represent those characteristic as values with mathematical relationships.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vacuum_permittivity

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vacuum_permeability

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impedance_of_free_space


If it is just mainstream graphical representations of the dynamics of comets like 67p you are interested in, I'm sure they are easy to find.



https://www.google.com/search?q=gra...sAQIMA&biw=1280&bih=893#imgrc=8VUJL3QgOIm10M:
 
Thank you detailing how the dust is removed from the rock(comet nucleus)!


Nope, as the dust that was not removed is still dust already. No need to EDM dust even in EC prognostications as the particles are already generally separated from each other. That's what makes it dust in the first place, removed or not. Again enough charge and the whole thing just becomes dust.
 
Last edited:
Electrodynamic forces are what bind molecules together and binds electrons in the atoms. Sufficient electrostatic forces (like too many excess electrons around) can overcome those binding forces, thus ripping or blowing the object apart. The higher the disparity between those binding and dismembering forces results in higher energy and speed of the flying apart remnants. Again it comes down to how many excess electrons the EC notions require.

EDM works similarly, in part thermally by heat from the current flow reducing the effect of inter-molecular binding forces and in part by the electrical field forces separating charges. The latter tends to dominate the former as the spark time (time of current flow through the object) is reduced.

That the factors are already required to be sufficient to separate parts of the object for the EC notions to just be somewhat internally consistent already demonstrates the requirement of the notions to blow at least parts of the object apart at perhaps various speeds. So that that object gets blow apart (at least in part) at whatever speed is a central tenet of EC assertions. Again it is simply the extent of the blowing apart and the resulting speed of the shrapnel that is dependent on the charges involved in the EC claims.

Why would you think it wouldn't happen particularly when you're not really sure how many excess electrons the EC notions require for such a comet?

Sufficient electrostatic forces (like too many excess electrons around) as you state, will turn rock to DUST!

A sufficient strong electric field will do this, as observed! :) These electric fields are fractal, all the way down to the ones acting on the bonds that hold molecules together and electrons in the atoms!

Very basic science, no?


Why is so hard to understand??? I really can't fathom it. all the the "stuff" needed is there!

You could keep coming at me with the mathamagics but even the mainstream are deluded on what math to apply!

but what I do understand is history!

Lets take draped magnetic fields for example, why would the mainstream use this concept when the dude that proposed it said it was WRONG?

But mainstream use it anyway, why?

When you fully understand what's going on here you can see why!

And current carrying double layers, nested concentric field aligned currents (Birkeland Currents) and there associated effects are the DEATH knell to "Draped Magnetic Fields" and "Magnetic Reconnection".

I predict this will be the case once Tusenfems tail paper is released. As alluded to by Ip, W-H. & Mendis, D. A. (1976) The generation of magnetic fields and electric currents in cometary plasma tails

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science...1910357690110X!

and here we are, again!
 
@Tusenfem

Your the PLASMA expert here, is this a fair call?

current carrying double layers, nested concentric field aligned currents (Birkeland Currents) cannot exists along with "frozen in field lines", "Draped Magnetic Fields" and "Magnetic Reconnection".

H.Alfven says no, what do you say Tusenfem?
 
Its fascinating to see how Sol88 keeps harping on on (totally misunderstood) forces that play an insignificant part in comets, yet keeps ignoring the fact that if those forces were as significant as the EU / EC fantasy world claims, not a single spacecraft would have made it to orbit around earth, let alone to any comet.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom