Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sufficient electrostatic forces (like too many excess electrons around) as you state, will turn rock to DUST!

Exactly, again perhaps blow a whole object to bits if one considers or requires such powerful forces. So in the EC EDM conjectures it is those forces that produce dust from rock. That ain't removing it as even in EDM machining you need some other way to remove such extracted material form the local environment. Certainly some of the extracted material is given sufficient energy to move further away from the local environment but of course also some ain't. So produced dust builds up in the local environment and thus on the EC rock nucleus. Simply producing dust just gives you more dust around including on the object.


A sufficient strong electric field will do this, as observed! :) These electric fields are fractal, all the way down to the ones acting on the bonds that hold molecules together and electrons in the atoms!

Very basic science, no?

No, electric and magnetic fields vary with distance proportional to 1 over the distance squared. In near field if I recall it is just 1/ distance. So no such fields can not be the same at all scales. A requirement of a fractal.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractal



Why is so hard to understand??? I really can't fathom it. all the the "stuff" needed is there!

That the assertion is simply and fundamentally wrong is not in anyway "hard to understand" nor your inability to "fathom" such.

You could keep coming at me with the mathamagics but even the mainstream are deluded on what math to apply!

You asked for painted picture and I gave you some.

but what I do understand is history!

Given the demonstrable lack of understand you asserted above, such an exclamation is hardly compelling.

Lets take draped magnetic fields for example, why would the mainstream use this concept when the dude that proposed it said it was WRONG?

But mainstream use it anyway, why?

Given your asserted "dude" "proposed it" and "said it was WRONG". That too lacks any veracity. As contradictions are by definition simple false. Also simply proposing something doesn't imbue you with ownership of its validity.


When you fully understand what's going on here you can see why!

And current carrying double layers, nested concentric field aligned currents (Birkeland Currents) and there associated effects are the DEATH knell to "Draped Magnetic Fields" and "Magnetic Reconnection".

I predict this will be the case once Tusenfems tail paper is released. As alluded to by Ip, W-H. & Mendis, D. A. (1976) The generation of magnetic fields and electric currents in cometary plasma tails

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science...1910357690110X!

and here we are, again!

Not again, still. EC and EU are just baseless speculation without quantitative values to apply.
 
I doubt Hannes Alfvén said that, the combination of the words is at random, just some terms that you happen to know. And the combination does not even make any sense at all!

As I recall what Hannes Alfvén said was basically that "frozen in field lines" tended to be overused or applied improperly in MHD. If I recall correctly, from other discussions on this forum on the subject, resistive magnetohydrodynamics tends to work better in that regard.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetohydrodynamics

I'm off for a bit.
 
The primary distinction between comet and asteroid surfaces is that electrical
arcing and “electrostatic cleaning” of the comet nucleus will leave little or no
dust or debris on the surface during the active phase
, even if a shallow layer
of dust may be attracted back to the nucleus electrostatically as the comet
becomes dormant in its retreat to more remote regions.

From T & T's poster. Whoops.
 
... We have a magnetic reconnection thread containing another Thunderbolts cult member absolutely denying even physics textbooks. This is the 'Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)' thread where I quote Somov's textbook section on MR in vacuum. He could not even understand that there were 2 sections with the titles:
  • 4.4.2 Reconnection in vacuum
  • 4.4.3 Reconnection in plasma
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section II has most of the text of 4.4.2 Reconnection in vacuum.
And ... looks like he's still arguing about it at cult HQ .. (and still using abusive language)!
 
You are saying, you are unsure or truly do not understand?

The point is CCDLs and FACs have nothing do with nested draping, frozen in magnetic fields and Magnetic reconnection!

You see, Sol, I am starting to doubt seriously whether English is your actual first language. The "questions" and "statements" that you are giving are so obscure, full of grammatical errors, that one has no idea what you are trying to say. And no, on the physics side I am not unsure and I understand plenty, but again, as your writing is so horrible, it is hard to find out what you want to claim. That is where my comment But what exactly "CCDLs" and "FACs" have to do with nested draping and frozen in and MRx is something I don't understand. comes from.

Let us revisit what you wrote:

current carrying double layers, nested concentric field aligned currents (Birkeland Currents) cannot exists along with "frozen in field lines", "Draped Magnetic Fields" and "Magnetic Reconnection"

First of all, the "cannot exists" [sic] does not make any sense at all. For example, draped fields and field aligned currents can easily exist together, there is nothing that says the cannot, not even Alfvén. On the other hand, frozen in fields and magnetic reconnection indeed, cannot exist together, as soon as you enter the ion diffusion region, where the ions decouple from the magnetic field, but the field is still frozen in the electron fluid. When you then enter the electron diffusion region, there in no frozen in field anymore.

If CCDLs and NESTED FIELD ALIGEND CURENTS and all there UNIQUE properties are around in the tail region, as they MUST be if

H. Madanian1
And

Jan Deca,1,2,* Andrey Divin,3,4 Pierre Henri,5 Anders Eriksson,4 Stefano Markidis,6 Vyacheslav Olshevsky,7 and Mihály Horányi1,2

Along with

HARRI LAAKSO
To Have any leg to stand on, then the detection of these entities validates Alfvens little sook, no?


"nested field aligned currents" do not appear in Hadi's, Jan's or Harri's paper. Heck, "field aligned" does not even appear!
Deca does not discuss the tail (he uses tailward once)
Madanian does not discuss the tail (he uses tail disconnection event once)
Laakso discussses in two sentences the electron density in the tail of Giacobini-Zinner.

There is no reason at all, why viable plasma processes cannot happen anywhere around a comet. But why on Earth (or rather in space) "finding these entities" will "validate Alfvén's little sook". (FWIW "sook" in Australian slang means A crybaby, a complainer, a whinger; a shy or timid person, a wimp; a coward.)

I did not know Alfvén had a "sook", would you like to name him? And what exactly will be "validated".

Now the question is, for you Sol, what exactly are these "all there UNIQUE properties and why as they MUST be if Madanian, Deca, Laakso (well there you went again with just randomly writing stuff without actually looking at whether you really put a question there or only word salad.

MRx in the magnetic and electric fields and the plasma....ahhhh! Makes more sense, electric fields and the charge carriers!

and what exactly is that supposed to mean?
 
Oh .. and Mozina seems to like criticizing professional mathematicians so much .. how about an update on his progress in acquiring some math skills of his own?

Well, as it turns out, I can report that he recently went on a massive rampage trying to convince all at another forum that his logic (on LIGO's sigma calculations) was flawless .. (never mind that it led to the stupendously tumultuous conclusion that 1=0.5! :dig: )
:jaw-dropp:
 
Gosh, didn't realise Mozina was still pushing his stuff after all these years!
 
I wonder if any of the EU loons can identify this extract of a paper. written in 2010?:



So, come on, EU loons, who wrote that? First one to get it right gets a lollipop!

P.S. Alfven was dead, so it wasn't him.

If anybody was wondering about this somewhat OT digression, the answer can be found in:

The Earth’s Magnetosphere as a Key to the Plasma Universe
Fälthammar, C-G.
http://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:484042/FULLTEXT01.pdf

So, it appears that the former student of Alfven disagrees with his former colleague, co-author and friend.
 
...and what exactly is that supposed to mean?
What Sol88 wrote hints at drinking the Thunderbolts Kool-Aid about magnetic reconnection especially from the retired electrical engineer Donald E. Scott. According to them, MRx has nothing to do with magnetic fields so it has to be "electric fields and the charge carriers". This is related to their lie about astronomers believing that there are no electric currents in space.
 
30 November 2017 Sol88:
<snip>
We have a magnetic reconnection thread containing another Thunderbolts cult member absolutely denying even physics textbooks. This is the 'Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)' thread where I quote Somov's textbook section on MR in vacuum. He could not even understand that there were 2 sections with the titles:
  • 4.4.2 Reconnection in vacuum
  • 4.4.3 Reconnection in plasma
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section II has most of the text of 4.4.2 Reconnection in vacuum.
<snip>
I don’t know whether to thank you or curse you, RC!

I found that thread quite riveting, couldn’t tear myself away from it, for well over 10 hours!!

Yes, it’s OT; but just when I thought the discussion couldn’t possibly turn any more surreal or bizarre, it did! A vacuum becomes a plasma when there are two current carrying wires are in it ... and even when they are not (in it) ... whodathunkit :D
 
... Yes, it’s OT; but just when I thought the discussion couldn’t possibly turn any more surreal or bizarre, it did! A vacuum becomes a plasma when there are two current carrying wires are in it ... and even when they are not (in it) ... whodathunkit :D
If I recall correctly, this miracle was considered justified because Somov's textbook was entitled: 'Plasma Astrophysics' therefore the term 'Vacuum' 'must' be taken as being within the context of there being ubiquitous, double-layer forming, reconnecting plasma in an astrophysical environment! :boggled:
(Ie: yet another example of that Mozina 'logic' I mentioned previously ..)
PS Apologies for the OT-ness of this slight diversion from the other EU mythology ...
 
Last edited:
30 November 2017 Sol88:
<snip>
We have a magnetic reconnection thread containing another Thunderbolts cult member absolutely denying even physics textbooks. This is the 'Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)' thread where I quote Somov's textbook section on MR in vacuum. He could not even understand that there were 2 sections with the titles:
  • 4.4.2 Reconnection in vacuum
  • 4.4.3 Reconnection in plasma
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section II has most of the text of 4.4.2 Reconnection in vacuum.
<snip>
I don’t know whether to thank you or curse you, RC!

I found that thread quite riveting, couldn’t tear myself away from it, for well over 10 hours!!
Consider yourself lucky. I participated in that thread for months.

The thread became so repetitive that I created a web page quoting three weeks of Mozina's responses to my own five-part derivation of magnetic reconnection directly from Maxwell's equations. Someone who wants to read just a sampling of that thread's madness could start there.
 
Consider yourself lucky. I participated in that thread for months.

The thread became so repetitive that I created a web page quoting three weeks of Mozina's responses to my own five-part derivation of magnetic reconnection directly from Maxwell's equations. Someone who wants to read just a sampling of that thread's madness could start there.

Indeed, that is a worthy source of information re MRx. As is the link to TT's various anti-EU posts. I have it bookmarked. And have done for some time. Many thanks to WDC and TT for the info and real science.
Amazing what one can learn by following real science, as opposed to the idiotic woo proposed by the likes of Thornhill, Talbott, Scott, Mozina, et al.

P.S. the Sun has a solid iron surface! I kid you not. Lol.
 
P.S. the Sun has a solid iron surface! I kid you not. Lol.
To be more exact but enormously more LOL :D.
Iron mountain ranges on the surface of the Sun (based on images of light from > 160,000 K solar flares thousands of kilometers above the photosphere).
A delusion about the Sun having layers sorted by atomic mass with one being an iron layer.
A delusion of a neutron star at the center of the Sun.
Mozina borrowed the last 2 from a totally ignorant about solar physics nuclear physics professor Olivier Manuel after Mozina contributed the iron mountain ranges delusion to a couple of 2006 papers.
 
I don’t know whether to thank you or curse you, RC!

I found that thread quite riveting, couldn’t tear myself away from it, for well over 10 hours!!

Yes, it’s OT; but just when I thought the discussion couldn’t possibly turn any more surreal or bizarre, it did! A vacuum becomes a plasma when there are two current carrying wires are in it ... and even when they are not (in it) ... whodathunkit :D

@JT;
Yes, it is instructive to go over some of these old threads. I, personally, have rummaged back through years worth of EU nonsense on BAUT/ Cosmoquest. Some of them feature a certain 'Nereid' as a mod and/or poster! Nothing has changed. No models, nothing quantitative, same old nonsense. I expect, were we to come back in ten years, we would be confronted by the same nonsense. All Youtube, no trousers. To coin a phrase.
 
To be more exact but enormously more LOL :D.
Iron mountain ranges on the surface of the Sun (based on images of light from > 160,000 K solar flares thousands of kilometers above the photosphere).
A delusion about the Sun having layers sorted by atomic mass with one being an iron layer.
A delusion of a neutron star at the center of the Sun.
Mozina borrowed the last 2 from a totally ignorant about solar physics nuclear physics professor Olivier Manuel after Mozina contributed the iron mountain ranges delusion to a couple of 2006 papers.

Oh please, RC! Do not remind me of that running difference image thread! Ye Gods! There is only so much hilarity I can take in one night! I have read that thread from start to finish, and it is hilarious. Yourself and Gee Mack explained it perfectly. Any eejit could have understood it. Not Mozina, though; lol. This is what happens when non-scientists try to do science. Never ends well. Always amusing, though.
 
If anybody was wondering about this somewhat OT digression, the answer can be found in:

The Earth’s Magnetosphere as a Key to the Plasma Universe
Fälthammar, C-G.
http://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:484042/FULLTEXT01.pdf

So, it appears that the former student of Alfven disagrees with his former colleague, co-author and friend.

Good find jd116!

Not quite a full digression but one that holds a critical role for the ELECTRIC COMET. So it is still on the table.

If Tusenfems interpretation of the data from the tail excursion is more along the lines of what Don Scott was describing in Birkeland current model, then would Alvfens warning be just a little more pertinent?

Especially in the surface, coma and tail interactions? Something some where of currents closing thru the coma? Nested concentric field aligned currents, double layers, ELECTRIC field CONNECTIONS and the resulting magnetic field topology rearrangements...


We can not use MHD. :boggled:

And I hear the maths gets quite complicated, tusnfem?
 
Last edited:
And it still has a connection to the jets, gas, dust and ice on the surface of the layered bedrock of the nucleus!

It’s also going to make it very problematic for the “Dirtysnowball” model to explain the feature that may be observed when a probe (Rosetta) flys radially away from the centre of the tail. I think you call that perpendicular to the z direction?

I think all the other probes flew more or less parallel to z?
 
Last edited:
A lie about Fälthammar's paper being about his comet delusions

Good find jd116!...
1 December 2017 Sol88: A lie about Fälthammar's paper being about his comet delusions.

1 December 2017 Sol88: A lie about magnetic reconnection holding a critical role in his comet delusions.

1 December 2017 Sol88: A lie of tusenfem's "interpretation" having anything to do with Birkeland currents or the deluded Don Scott.

1 December 2017 Sol88: A lie that we cannot use MHD.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; etc. etc.

No magnetic field from the comet nucleus. Randomish magnetic fields in the coma and tail plasma but Birkeland currents have never been seen outside of Earth's strong & structured magnetic field. ETA: Interaction between the coma and solar wind forms a magnetosphere around the nucleus but once again no detected Birkeland currents despite having the Rosetta spacecraft in that magnetosphere.
 
Last edited:
A lie that Fälthammar's paper on the Earth has a connection to comet nuclei

And it still has a connection to the jets, gas, dust and ice on the surface of the layered bedrock of the nucleus!
1 December 2017 Sol88: A lie that Fälthammar's paper on the Earth has a connection to comet nuclei.
If anybody was wondering about this somewhat OT digression, the answer can be found in:

The Earth’s Magnetosphere as a Key to the Plasma Universe
Fälthammar, C-G.
http://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:484042/FULLTEXT01.pdf

So, it appears that the former student of Alfven disagrees with his former colleague, co-author and friend.
This is a conference paper from 2010 on The Earth’s Magnetosphere and comet nuclei have no magnetosphere :jaw-dropp!
1 December 2017 Sol88: An ignorant statement about the Rosetta probe which was crashed into 67P!
Impact on the comet's surface occurred 14.5 hours after its descent manoeuvre

1 December 2017 Sol88: A delusion that any probe into a comet tail will support his comet delusions, e.g. impossible Birkeland currents.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; etc. etc.

ETA: There is ignorance about comets in his post, of course :eye-poppi!
A probe has passed through a comet tail
The Ulysses spacecraft made an unexpected pass through the tail of the comet C/2006 P1 (Comet McNaught), on February 3, 2007.[7] Evidence of the encounter was published in the October 1, 2007 issue of the Astrophysical Journal.[8]
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom