The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis

Archer understands GTSM, which is the replacement of establishment's nonsense. That by itself makes up for any woo he may apparently promote. Besides, your boy Newton tried to decipher the fn Bible.

See that's the difference between your musings and science. Perhaps having some good ideas doesn't 'make up' for the bad ones nor even make those bad ones any less bad. Just as simply having some bad ideas doesn't detract from the ones that do work. Each idea is assessed on it's own merits (self consistency) and how well it comports with the other workable ideas and evidence (general consistency). Bad ideas are generally self-inconsistent and/or generally inconsistent. While other ideas might help with the latter, the only idea that can help with the former is just general inconsistency. Which is a bad idea, like any self-inconsistent idea, as it simply refutes itself.


Oh, and unless you directly oppose simple Newtonian mechanics then Newton is equally as much "your boy" as well.


Doing great science doesn't mean you never have really bad ideas. In fact, in order to do great science really bad ideas are a necessity at times, because they give something to compare progress with. I can compare GTSM to the dead on arrival nebular hypothesis and explain the exoplanets with it, which the nebular hypothesis couldn't explain.

Nope, bad ideas are just bad and really bad ideas are, well, just really bad. Excusing them as a "necessity" or even inevitable doesn't make them any less bad or really bad . Just as perceived progress on a bad idea is still, well, bad and if you think you can only measure your progress against bad ideas you really do need to get some better ideas.


I'm sort of glad the dogma is engaged in pseudoscience, it gives me more room to breathe and develop theory.

Evidently even that purported "room" is still insufficient. Again, perhaps you simply need better ideas or just less "really bad" ones?
 
Doing great science doesn't mean you never have really bad ideas. In fact, in order to do great science really bad ideas are a necessity at times, because they give something to compare progress with.
Someday, perhaps, you will come to understand that really bad ideas are not, by themselves, great science.
 
Its all good dude.
That someone is gullible enough to fall for insanely ignorant delusions and lies is never good.

On the other hand Daniel Archer cannot understand that he posted normally in this forum so falling for delusions and lies is not that surprising :p! More probably he did not understand that he had to post a certain number of times before spamming us with the crank web site he and you ignorantly use.
 
jeffreyw: Yet another totally deluded PDF with electric universe insanity this time

Oh BTW I wrote up a new paper on some differences between EU, GTSM and the dogma.
21 November 2017 jeffreyw: Yet another totally deluded PDF with electric universe insanity this time.
 
jeffreyw: An abysmally ignorant and deluded post

Archer understands GTSM, which is the replacement of establishment's nonsense. ...
Daniel Archer stating GTSM ignorance, delusions and lies does not make GTSM ignorance, delusions and lies any better.
People understand and support the flat earth model, which is the replacement of establishment's spherical Earth model. Only the ignorant and deluded believe the that Earth is flat.
People understand and support the geocentric model, which is the replacement of establishment's heliocentric model. Only the ignorant and deluded believe the that Earth is at the center of the Solar System.
etc. etc.

Ask Daniel Archer to participate here and present real evidence (not made up images or what he thinks are in images) for GTSM.

21 November 2017 jeffreyw: A total delusion of doing any science at all.
Doing any science starts off with understanding the real world that we live in, e.g. that it is physically impossible for a planet to be a old star or the complete stupidity of stellar systems forming by collecting random objects.

21 November 2017 jeffreyw: A lie of "dead on arrival nebular hypothesis".

21 November 2017 jeffreyw: A lie that his ignorant delusions "explain the exoplanets with it, which the nebular hypothesis couldn't explain".

21 November 2017 jeffreyw: A total delusion of "dogma is engaged in pseudoscience".
 
Last edited:
Someday, perhaps, you will come to understand that really bad ideas are not, by themselves, great science.

D. Archer is helping me concerning the classification of stars that are so evolved that they no longer emit light in the visible spectrum.

http://vixra.org/pdf/1712.0460v1.pdf

From what I see Corot-7b can be classified as an ocean world/pre-Earth. Too bad the measurements are poor. We have a theory now that predicts its composition.

Do you have a theory that predicts the composition of Corot-7b? If not then this thread isn't for you, that is unless you just want to slander and make stuff up about me as does "Reality Check".
 
Last edited:
Nuttery repeated remains nuttery.

Interesting.

If this theory is correct, then does that mean the people who claim it is nonsense are the "nutters"?

In fact, should we go the extra mile and say the people who comment on this thread, repeating over and over again that it is "nuttery", are exceedingly "nuts"?

Doesn't say much for "Reality Check" does it?
 
Last edited:
All Reality Check is doing is attempting to get you to answer questions. If your theory is so solid, you should have no problem answering. You chose to ignore and continue posting unsupported nonsense. The ball is in your court to support your claims.
 
D. Archer is helping me concerning the classification of stars that are so evolved that they no longer emit light in the visible spectrum.

http://vixra.org/pdf/1712.0460v1.pdf


For those who don’t want to add more hits to a woo page, the “classifications” in the table are unsupported, as usual.

From what I see Corot-7b can be classified as an ocean world/pre-Earth. Too bad the measurements are poor. We have a theory now that predicts its composition.


From what I see, Corot-7b can be classified as an uncommonly large Wedgewood teapot. I have just as much evidence for my classification as you do for yours.

Do you have a theory that predicts the composition of Corot-7b? If not then this thread isn't for you, that is unless you just want to slander and make stuff up about me as does "Reality Check".


Anyone may post in this thread, whether they have a theory or not. You don’t have a theory and you posted, didn’t you? And I’d cool it with accusing other members of slander, that path leads to the (mods') Dark Side.
 
Last edited:
From what I see Corot-7b can be classified as an ocean world/pre-Earth. Too bad the measurements are poor. We have a theory now that predicts its composition.


Yes we do have a theory predicting the composition of Corot-7b

Yours and Fred's

I think you are both wrong and that Corot-7b is much hotter than a Wedgewood teapot.

Surface temperature can be predicted based on the size and brightness of the star and how far away the planet is.

Both Corot-7b and Gliese 1214b would be predicted to too hot for liquid water, Corot-7b
would likely have a molten rock surface.

No ocean world for Corot-7b
 
Yes we do have a theory predicting the composition of Corot-7b

Yours and Fred's

I think you are both wrong and that Corot-7b is much hotter than a Wedgewood teapot.


Gee, bob, thanks for setting me straight on that! :rolleyes:

And it’s ferd, by the way.
 
Gee, bob, thanks for setting me straight on that! :rolleyes:

And it’s ferd, by the way.

Sorry Ferd, you know I wasn't setting you straight. Jeffrey is serious and you were being facetious.

You are closer than Jeffrey with the Wedgewood teapot at least in regards to temperature.
 
Sorry Ferd, you know I wasn't setting you straight. Jeffrey is serious and you were being facetious.

You are closer than Jeffrey with the Wedgewood teapot at least in regards to temperature.


Apologies if I misread your post, it read like an equivalence between my and jeffrey's “claims”. A smiley might have been helpful.
 
jeffreyw: An ignorant crank is helping another ignorant crank

D. Archer ...".
22 December 2017 jeffreyw: An ignorant crank is helping another ignorant crank to dig themselves deeper into a pit of ignorance and delusion.

This is Corot-7b
COROT-7b has a maximum surface temperature between 1800 and 2600 °C (3300 to 4700 degrees Fahrenheit).[17] Due to the high temperature, it may be covered in lava.[2] The composition and density of the planet, though weakly constrained, make COROT-7b a probably rocky planet, like Earth. It could belong to a class of planets that are thought to contain up to 40% water (in the form of ice and/or vapor) in addition to rock.[17] However, the fact that it formed so close to its parent star may mean that it is depleted of volatiles.[18]
And these idiots think that COROT-7b is an "ocean world/pre-Earth" :jaw-dropp!
 
jeffreyw: Lies about the "nutters" - they are the "planets are old stars" people

Interesting.
22 December 2017 jeffreyw: Lies about the "nutters" - they are the people stupid enough to think that planets are old stars which can never be correct.
Physical facts that have been stated many times:
  • Stars are 100,000's of times heavier than planets.
  • Stars keep the majority of their mass throughout their lifetime.
  • Stars are a different composition from planets.
  • Earth and other planets are younger than the Sun.
  • And what makes your ideas actually insane - Earth and other planets are much younger than the universe :eek:!
 
Last edited:
Yes we do have a theory predicting the composition of Corot-7b

Yours and Fred's

I think you are both wrong and that Corot-7b is much hotter than a Wedgewood teapot.

Surface temperature can be predicted based on the size and brightness of the star and how far away the planet is.

Both Corot-7b and Gliese 1214b would be predicted to too hot for liquid water, Corot-7b
would likely have a molten rock surface.

No ocean world for Corot-7b

There are two major possibilities.

1. Corot-7b formed where it is located.

2. Corot-7b formed somewhere else and was adopted by Corot-7.

Taking Corot-7b as being formed near or at its current location would of course lead it depleted of volatiles, as no light elements would collect there. So if it formed where or near where it currently orbits, of course it would be a lava world. A very strange lava at that, one that does not include oxygen, hydrogen, nitrogen, etc.

Did Corot-7b form near or at its current orbit? If it did not, then volatiles could easily be present in huge amounts and the thick atmosphere would allow for the surface to be quite cool internally, given thick oceans of water are present.

I think the latter is correct because of their ages in stellar metamorphosis. The stars that have lost a very, very large percentage of their mass are vastly older than the hot, big, bright ones. So that means that corot-7 absolutely adopted Corot-7b.

I wrote up a short paper outlining the issue of stellar age delineation.

http://vixra.org/pdf/1607.0532v1.pdf

It basically means the more massive, youngest, brightest objects adopt the move evolved, less massive, less energetic ones, and that objects can orbit each other which differ in ages by billions of years. We even see this in our solar system as all the rocky bodies are vastly older than the Sun, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune.
 
Problem is, knowing how old something is, we don't know how old the earth is, we only know how old the oldest rocks on the earth are.

Interesting paper, it rivals Jack's Shining paper.

You are dating things by your stellar metamorphosis theory, so your reasoning is rather circular, like orbits of things that formed when a gas cloud condenses, orbits would be much more elongated if things were captured.
 
Problem is, knowing how old something is, we don't know how old the earth is, we only know how old the oldest rocks on the earth are.

Interesting paper, it rivals Jack's Shining paper.

You are dating things by your stellar metamorphosis theory, so your reasoning is rather circular, like orbits of things that formed when a gas cloud condenses, orbits would be much more elongated if things were captured.

Well I have a method for figuring out how old a dead/highly evolved star is, problem is that it uses the variable of how slow iron collects onto the interior of the star and forms the core.

Here is a short paper I wrote explaining that given the thickness of an iron core, we can determine how long it took the star to get to at least that age. So it sets a lower limit.

http://vixra.org/pdf/1707.0407v1.pdf

This of course is a relative age dating technique (not absolute in terms of radiometric dating), but can be useful as it means Mercury and the Earth took about the same time to form their iron cores (because they are about the same size) but since Mercury no longer has a magnetic field either like Earth, which signals internal fluid motion, it is probably vastly older. Not only that, but it clearly has been through an extremely tortured past, so chances are that object had been orbiting a large number of previous hosts at much closer distances before it was adopted by the current system.

I would seriously consider the Earth to at least be about 10 billion years old, and Mercury to be about 65 billion.

This all seems circular, but it isn't really. The young hot star is born, it expands greatly, then gravitationally collapses, cools, loses mass and dies. The orbits between objects change on the basis of how much mass is lost by the host, and if there are any interrupting objects that can allow for the exchange of angular momentum between objects. Basically it is not "cosmology", it should be chaos-olgy. It is more random than ordered. Of course this ruins the perfection mentality of astronomers. Which is quite strange because Pi isn't a neat number either...

Not only that but elongated orbits are already observed. The eccentricities of a huge volume of "exoplanets" (evolving stars) is coming to light, and many of them are above an eccentricity of .5
 
Well I have a method for figuring out how old a dead/highly evolved star is, problem is that it uses the variable of how slow iron collects onto the interior of the star and forms the core.

Here is a short paper I wrote explaining that given the thickness of an iron core, we can determine how long it took the star to get to at least that age. So it sets a lower limit.

http://vixra.org/pdf/1707.0407v1.pdf

This of course is a relative age dating technique (not absolute in terms of radiometric dating), but can be useful as it means Mercury and the Earth took about the same time to form their iron cores (because they are about the same size) but since Mercury no longer has a magnetic field either like Earth, which signals internal fluid motion, it is probably vastly older. Not only that, but it clearly has been through an extremely tortured past, so chances are that object had been orbiting a large number of previous hosts at much closer distances before it was adopted by the current system.

I would seriously consider the Earth to at least be about 10 billion years old, and Mercury to be about 65 billion.

Mercury's iron core is much smaller than Earth's because Mercury is so much smaller than Earth, and the Sun has more iron than any body in the solar system, so that totally torpedoes your dating system.

You should go to wikepedia

"Despite its small size and slow 59-day-long rotation, Mercury has a significant, and apparently global, magnetic field."

Mercury still has a molten core.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom