Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
I, unfortunately for you Fred Burfle...


Please write my nick correctly Sol. If you have difficulty, (you seem to struggle with grammar and spelling) it’s right there by my avatar.

You are smart enough to realize the bulk porosity of 87 per cent (Fornasier et al. 2015), is a dirtysnowball model KILLER! How in the real world can you measure, even using Doppler shifts in the RSI, the density of a comet when the Philea probe returned results that falsify that assumption!


There’s been such a torrent of wrongness from you recently, Sol, it’s difficult to correct it all! Most is just the same old debunked crap and obfuscation so I’ll just refer interested lurkers to RC's links.

But let’s look at your statement above. Please tell us in your own words what you think the definition of bulk porosity is. Then please explain why you think this means comets are rocks. I look forward to your reply.
 
Last edited:
Reality check has stated that H.Laakso is wrong, these structures violate reality checks Debye length criteria and can not exist.

As usual you cannot read, that is not what RC said. He said that the size of the cometopause is much much larger than the typical size of a double layer.

As Harri Laakso never claims that there is a double layer, it is only you who claims this, the only one lying is you.

Last day at work, I have finished my papers and abstracts not yet my press release, after coffee I might just read through Harri's paper again.
 
As usual you cannot read, that is not what RC said. He said that the size of the cometopause is much much larger than the typical size of a double layer.

As Harri Laakso never claims that there is a double layer, it is only you who claims this, the only one lying is you.

Last day at work, I have finished my papers and abstracts not yet my press release, after coffee I might just read through Harri's paper again.

Great, would be much appreciated!


All asked is what a plasma physicist might just call these structures Harri describes.

Have they got a name? Just so I don’t keep calling them “double layers”.
 
Great, would be much appreciated!


All asked is what a plasma physicist might just call these structures Harri describes.

Have they got a name? Just so I don’t keep calling them “double layers”.


Just to clarify, i’m mean multiply double layers at varying distances from the nucleus! :thumbsup:
 
I wonder if reality check might be able to indulge me with the seemingly contradictory findings of Debye length and the findings of flying thru the tail of comet Comet Hyakutake at 3.5 odd au!

Keen?
 
Last edited:
Just to clarify, i’m mean multiply double layers at varying distances from the nucleus! :thumbsup:

My god, you are doing a George W. Bush.
By saying double layer often enough I guess you hope that we will be convinced that you are right.
 
Okay, I read through Harri Laakso's paper, and my goodness, now I know again why I have not looked at that paper for the last 7 years or so. Lot's is decribed but he could have taken the effort to put some lines in his plots to guide the reader. But anywhooo ...

I was actually right, he is mainly discussing AC fields or as he calls is fluctuations of the DC electric field Ey (there is only one component of the electric field that is measured with the APV-V instrument). However, there are some statements (3 actually) about "real" DC electric fields and potential drops, on which I will concentrate. For everything else I invite you to try and read the paper yourself.

But first he discusses the APV-L measurements with the two Langmuir probes, and there he immediately states in subsection "dc Electric Fields" of Section 3:

Laakso said:
The electric field component measured y the double probe antenna is almost parallel to the y axis in CSE (see Figure 1). However, the measured dc electric field differs considerably from vxBz. Since such high electric fields cannot be supported in the vicinity of comets , there must be a serious offset in the dc electric
field observations. The origin of the offset is partially photoemission from the spacecraft structure: the spacecraft body is 4-5 m and the solar panels only 1.5 m from the double probe antenna.

So, one can only use the Langmuir probes to study densities and waves. And why is the vxBz important? That is namely the convective electric field of the solar wind, which appears in the spacecraft frame of reference.

Then the APV-V antenna data is discussed, and we skip to Section 5 Cometopause, where Laakso observes (in Plate 4) that (and pay attention to the last sentence):

Laakso said:
Plate 4 also displays the dc electric field Ey and its fluctuations δy, where the latter is filtered in the same way as in Figur6e. Upstream of the CP, amplified dc electric field oscillations are observed near 6 mHz, whereas after the CP crossing the strongest mode appears at ~11 mHz (~13 mHz for Vega 2). At the CP the
dc electric field increases continuously by 10-20 mV/m until it begins to rapidly change its direction (from outward to inward) at the inner boundary of the CP. This value corresponds to a potential drop of 50-100 kV. It is not clear whether such a large value is true or not.

Measuring DC electric fields in a plasma is notoriously difficult on space missions. Here the two probes were 1.5 meter long booms at the end of the solar panel.

Where does the DC field come from? This is probably needed to slow down the solar wind:

Laakso said:
The rapid change of the dc electric field is associated with a change in the flow speed of plasmas in the reference frame of the spacecraft: within the CP, the spacecraft speed exceeds the flow speed of plasmas while outside the CP the situation is distinctly the opposite.

Indeed, a bit further this is said:

Laakso said:
This continuously increasin Ey on Vega1 is partially a consequence of the ongoing deceleration of plasma flow in the cometary plasma region, which is followed by two plateaus, in the middle of which is placed a current layer crossed at 0709 UT. The interpretation of the plateau could be, for instance, a region of constant flow velocity.

Than later in the paper we get the information that from Vega 2 tells us that:

Laakso said:
he thickness of the CP is ~10,000 km. It has a positively charged outer surface and a negatively charged inner surface.

However, no evidence in the data is shown that this is actually the case. One should at least then show the electron and ion densities along the crossing of this region.

Which leads us the the conclusion section, where things are suddenly stated with a bit more determination than in the paper proper:

Laakso said:
The cometopause is observed inbound at 160,000 km with a thickness of 10,000 km. It has a positively charged outer surface and a negatively charged inner surface with a potential drop of 50-100 kV. A current layer, with a thickness of 22,000 km and the electric current flowing from dawn to dusk, is located on Vega 1 outside the cometopause at a distance of 8,000 km. The current layer contains the solar wind plasma flow that is not properly able to penetrate the cometopause but is diverted to move a long the cometopause.

I did not mention the 135 kV potential drop on page 7751, but also there it is stated in the text that It is not evident whether such a large potential drop is possible, since spurious signals may be intensified at the current layer.

So, in all I think we can trust the oscillations of the electric field, as there you just subtract the background DC field, but the enormous potential drops of kVs are in my opinion (and in the text also Laakso's) dubious.
 
Cheers tusenfem for taking the time to go thru Harri’s paper, I appreciate you must be very busy.

I also keenly awaite your Tail excersion paper at 67P


Righto, so we can at least sorta agree there is something there, somesorta plasma structure or boundary, with a least some degree of potential difference between those layers?

So, without having to revisit the above paper again, what do plasma physicist call these structures?
 
Last edited:
Please write my nick correctly Sol. If you have difficulty, (you seem to struggle with grammar and spelling) it’s right there by my avatar.




There’s been such a torrent of wrongness from you recently, Sol, it’s difficult to correct it all! Most is just the same old debunked crap and obfuscation so I’ll just refer interested lurkers to RC's links.

But let’s look at your statement above. Please tell us in your own words what you think the definition of bulk porosity is. Then please explain why you think this means comets are rocks. I look forward to your reply.


Sorry there champ, bloody autocorrect :boggled:

definition of bulk porosity density?

In the case off 67P. A homogenous nucleus, with the surface representative of the interior. I believe CONCERT told us that? MUPUS-PEN tapped on the surface. OSIRIS-NAC has been taking biggest mob of pictures and GIADA has been feeling different parts of the nucleus.
 
Originally Posted by Laakso
The electric field component measured y the double probe antenna is almost parallel to the y axis in CSE (see Figure 1). However, the measured dc electric field differs considerably from vxBz. Since such high electric fields cannot be supported in the vicinity of comets , there must be a serious offset in the dc electric
field observations. The origin of the offset is partially photoemission from the spacecraft structure: the spacecraft body is 4-5 m and the solar panels only 1.5 m from the double probe antenna.

Are you able to elaborate a little on the above bolded rather curious statement?

So i’m also hearing and understanding it is notoriously difficult to measure electric fields in space?
 
Originally Posted by Laakso
The thickness of the CP is ~10,000 km. It has a positively charged outer surface and a negatively charged inner surface.

However, no evidence in the data is shown that this is actually the case. One should at least then show the electron and ion densities along the crossing of this region.

Would this data be available? Or any similar data on the Rosetta mission?
 
definition of bulk porosity density?

Don’t play games, Sol, your quote referred to porosity, and you know it. From the post in question:

I, unfortunately for you Fred Burfle, do understand that. What you have is a HUGE problem with your density guess.
<snip>
You are smart enough to realize the bulk porosity of 87 per cent (Fornasier et al. 2015), is a dirtysnowball model KILLER!

Please answer my question, Sol. What is the definition of porosity and how does a measured 87% porosity for a comet support your claim that comets are made of rock?

In the case off 67P. A homogenous nucleus, with the surface representative of the interior. I believe CONCERT told us that? MUPUS-PEN tapped on the surface. OSIRIS-NAC has been taking biggest mob of pictures and GIADA has been feeling different parts of the nucleus.

Please knock off the obfuscation and address my question.
 
Don’t play games, Sol, your quote referred to porosity, and you know it. From the post in question:



Please answer my question, Sol. What is the definition of porosity and how does a measured 87% porosity for a comet support your claim that comets are made of rock?



Please knock off the obfuscation and address my question.


You’d like me to describe “nothing”? 87% “empty space?

EC says rock all the way thru! Mainstream have “nothing’! 87% in fact. :boggled::blush:
 
You’d like me to describe “nothing”? 87% “empty space?

It’s clear Sol's unwilling or unable to give a straight answer, but he lets slip in this latest bit of shuck and jive that he knows 87% porosity (the figure in his citation!) means 87% void space in the comet nucleus. So much for solid rock.

EC says rock all the way thru! Mainstream have “nothing’! 87% in fact. :boggled::blush:

Here we see, once again, that no amount of evidence can keep a woo-monger from jamming their fingers in their ears and yelling “La La La La!”.
 
Are you able to elaborate a little on the above bolded rather curious statement?

Well the comet is surrounded by plasma and plasma does not like very large, large-scale DC electric fields. This should be known even to you.

sol88 said:
Would this data be available? Or any similar data on the Rosetta mission?

As stated already so often, all data are archived on ESA's Planetary Science Archive and on NASA's Planetary Data System.
 
I also keenly awaite your Tail excersion paper at 67P

It is at the production office, so should come out maybe in January.
However, there is ONLY magnetic field data in my paper.

Righto, so we can at least sorta agree there is something there, somesorta plasma structure or boundary, with a least some degree of potential difference between those layers?

So, without having to revisit the above paper again, what do plasma physicist call these structures?

Welll there are all kinds of boundaries, bow shock, cometopause, collisionopause, cavity boundary ...

Whether or not there is a potential drop across them is rather unclear, because the values that Laakso presents, he obviously does not really believe himself.
 
It is at the production office, so should come out maybe in January.
However, there is ONLY magnetic field data in my paper.



Welll there are all kinds of boundaries, bow shock, cometopause, collisionopause, cavity boundary ...

Whether or not there is a potential drop across them is rather unclear, because the values that Laakso presents, he obviously does not really believe himself.



Thanks tusenfem!

I'd have to go away a sit in my cave for awhile and ponder your answer.

But I may call them whatever I feel like it at the time?

Outer positively charged outer surface with an inner negativity charged surface with an disputed amount of potential drop across the + to -, maybe called a bow shock, cometopause, collisionopause, cavity boundary?

Merry xmas 'ol mate! :)
 
Thanks tusenfem!

I'd have to go away a sit in my cave for awhile and ponder your answer.

But I may call them whatever I feel like it at the time?

Outer positively charged outer surface with an inner negativity charged surface with an disputed amount of potential drop across the + to -, maybe called a bow shock, cometopause, collisionopause, cavity boundary?

Merry xmas 'ol mate! :)

Wait, "may"? So there is some non-zero probability that you won't just "call them whatever" you "feel like it at the time?". Do please let us know when that happens.

Happy Cobraticus (for the snake handlers out there).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom